The proposition seemed tailor-made for one of the nations most diverse and liberal states. California officials asked voters to overturn a 24-year-old ban on affirmative action in education, employment and contracting.
The state political and cultural establishment worked as one to pass this ballot measure. The governor, a senator, members of Congress, university presidents and civil rights leaders called it a righting of old wrongs.
Women and people of color are still at a sharp disadvantage by almost every measure, The Los Angeles Times wrote in an editorial endorsement.
Yet on Election Day, the proposition failed by a wide margin, 57 percent to 43 percent, and Latino and Asian-American voters played a key role in defeating it. The outcome captured the gap between the vision laid out by the liberal establishment in California, which has long imagined the creation of a multiracial, multiethnic coalition that would embrace progressive causes, and the sentiments of many Black, Latino, Asian and Arab voters.
Variations of this puzzle could be found in surprising corners of the nation on Election Day, as slices of ethnic and racial constituencies peeled off and cut against Democratic expectations.
We should not think of demography as destiny, said Professor Omar Wasow, who studies politics and voting patterns at Princeton University. These groups are far more heterogeneous than a monolith and campaigns often end up building their own idiosyncratic coalition.
Asian-American Californians opposed the affirmative action measure in large numbers. A striking number of East and South Asian students have gained admission to elite state universities, and their families spoke to reporters of their fear that their children would suffer if merit in college selection was given less weight. That battle carried echoes of another that raged the past few years in New York City, where a white liberal mayors efforts to increase the number of Black and Latino students in selective high schools angered working- and middle-class South and East Asian families whose children have gained admission to the schools in large numbers.
Theres more texture to California blue politics than you might think, said Lanhee Chen, a fellow at the conservative Hoover Institution at Stanford University and policy director for Mitt Romneys 2012 presidential run. Identity politics only go so far. There is a sense on affirmative action that people resent being categorized by progressives.
Latinos, too, appear sharply divided. Prominent Latino nonprofit and civil rights organizations endorsed the affirmative action proposition even as all 14 of Californias majority-Latino counties voted it down.
Latinos make up more than half of San Bernardino Countys population, although significantly fewer turn out to vote. More residents there voted on the affirmative action proposition than for president, rejecting it by a margin of 28 percentage points. In rural Imperial County, in the southeastern corner of the state, 85 percent of the population is Latino. The voters there who gave Joseph R. Biden Jr. a nearly 27-point margin of victory went against the affirmative action measure by 16 percentage points.
The results suggest that Democrats may need to adjust their strategy as the complexities of class, generation and experience, and the competing desires of these demographic groups become clear. Since the dawn of the 21st century, it has become commonplace for party leaders to talk of a rising demographic tide that is destined to lift the Democrats to dominance. That liberal coalition is seen as resting on a bedrock of upper-middle-class white voters, alongside working- and middle-class Black, Latino and Asian voters.
In broad strokes, that narrative held. Black voters, along with a shift in the white suburban vote, played a pivotal role in delivering Georgia to the Democratic column (although so closely that a statewide audit is taking place). So, too, Black voters in Pittsburgh and Philadelphia voted overwhelmingly for Democrats as did well-to-do majority-white suburbs and gave Pennsylvania and therefore the national election to President-elect Biden.
In Arizona, Latino voters piled up large margins for Mr. Biden and tipped the state narrowly into the Democratic column for the first time since 1996. Representative Ruben Gallego, the Democratic congressman from Phoenix who is a former Marine and a Harvard graduate, noted that several decades of aggressive tactics by Republican governors and white sheriffs had stirred activism among the young Latinos who dominate politics there.
The Republicans caught Latino lightning in the bottle in Florida and South Texas, but not here, Mr. Gallego said. We are very politicized. Its just important that white liberals dont impose their thoughts and policies on us.
Aside from those successes, however, the election presented complications wrapped one inside another for Democrats. In Texas and Florida, in California and in Colorado (where New York Times exit polls found that roughly 40 percent of white voters and 38 percent of Latino voters cast ballots for President Trump), the assumption that people of color would vote as a liberal Democratic bloc often proved illusory.
John Judis is a liberal writer and scholar who in 2002 co-wrote The Emerging Democratic Majority, which became a seminal text for those who saw the Democratic Party as a political tide rising. He has since backed off that a touch.
People of color is a term thats been adopted by the cultural left as a way of arguing that if these groups proportionately voted Democratic in the past, they will do so in the future, Mr. Judis said. I dont see how you can make the argument.
Viewing the Latino vote as monolithic fails, of course, to capture the often sharply varying politics and ethnicities of people hailing from nearly two dozen countries on two continents. The same is true when examining the behavior of Asian-American voters.
Philadelphia offers a snapshot: A record number of Latinos in the city, which is heavily Puerto Rican and Dominican, turned out and buoyed Mr. Biden. Yet exit polls also found that Latino voter support there for Mr. Trump leapt to 35 percent this year from 22 percent in 2016. In Milwaukee, an analysis by Urban Milwaukee reported an uptick in the Latino working-class vote for Mr. Trump, although a majority still favored Mr. Biden.
Along the Rio Grande in Texas, where some Mexican-American families, known as Tejanos, have roots that extend back four centuries, the vote margins shifted dramatically in 2020. Latino turnout soared, almost entirely to the benefit of Mr. Trump. Although Mr. Biden obtained more total votes in the four counties of the Rio Grande Valley than Hillary Clinton did in 2016, his margins of victory fell sharply.
The reasons offered for these results include poor field organizing by the Democratic Party, the cultural conservatism of some older Tejano families, and the fact that many in these often-dense counties find good-paying jobs with the Border Patrol.
Many voters, too, worried that Mr. Biden and the Democrats would impose a new coronavirus-driven shutdown, with dire consequences for the many thousands who own and labor for small businesses. Prof. Omar Valerio-Jimenez grew up in the Rio Grande Valley and teaches history at the University of Texas at San Antonio. Several of his old friends and cousins voted for Mr. Trump.
They faced this challenge: Do they continue to open our stores and restaurants and churches, which lets us pay our bills, he said, or do we quarantine and not have the money to pay our bills?
Muslim voters also confounded Democratic strategists with their support for Mr. Trump reaching 35 percent, according to The Associated Press. This, too, is a constituency difficult to pigeonhole, as it encompasses Africans, Arabs, South Asians and Europeans.
A sizable number of Muslims have experienced Donald Trump and to the surprise of Democrats they said, We want more of that, Shadi Hamid of the Brookings Institution said.
Analyzing vote shifts is a tricky business, particularly when trying to gauge why some Latino, Black or Arab voters moved from supporting a liberal Democratic candidate like Mrs. Clinton in 2016 to voting for a populist authoritarian Republican like Mr. Trump. Some analysts pointed to the appeal among male voters regardless of color or ethnicity of Mr. Trumps masculine persona. Others mentioned the performance of the national economy, which had hummed along until the plague arrived.
There were small, intriguing changes in the Black vote as well. The Timess exit polls in Georgia found that 16 percent of Black men voted for Mr. Trump. (Compared with 7 percent of Black women there.) And to chart the votes along the so-called Black Belt in Mississippi, which includes 10 counties along the Mississippi River, was to find that although Mr. Biden won handily, his margin in nearly every county was two to three percentage points smaller than Mrs. Clintons.
The unanswered question is whether the 2020 election will be a one-off, the voting patterns scrambled by an unusually polarizing president who attracted and repelled in near equal measure. If it signals something larger, political scientists noted, some Latino and Asian voters might begin to behave like white voters, who have cleaved along class lines, with more affluent residents in urban areas voting Democratic while a decided majority of rural and exurban residents support Republicans.
Then there is California, where the sands of change blow in varying directions. In 2018, Democrats swept the Orange County congressional seats. In 2020, the Republicans have rebounded and taken at least two of those seats.
The Republican candidate Michelle Steel, who is Korean-American, came out against the affirmative action proposition, a stance that proved popular with her Asian-American constituents, as well as many white voters. And on election night, Ms. Steel rode that support to a narrow win against the incumbent Democratic congressman, Harley Rouda.
This is the challenge for liberal Democrats, Professor Wasow said. In a diverse society, how do you enact politics that may advance racial equality without reinforcing racial divisions that are counterproductive and hurt you politically?
- Liberal Journalist Mocks Republicans Trying to Help People ... - January 25th, 2022
- Youth wing of Australia's Liberal Party recognising the Republic of Artsakh and the Armenian, Assyrian, Greek Genocides Public Radio of Armenia -... - January 25th, 2022
- OPINION/LETTER: Liberal progressives and a focus on feelings - Yahoo News - January 25th, 2022
- MSNBC's Tiffany Cross urges liberals to 'pick up a weapon and get involved' in 'war' for democracy - Fox News - January 25th, 2022
- Liberal Boys and Girls Wrestling Teams Win at Atwood - KSCB News.net - January 25th, 2022
- Liberal leadership speculation a distraction, Trudeau should shut it down firmly, say Liberal MPs, political insiders, and pollsters - The Hill Times - January 25th, 2022
- Liberal media members heap praise on Biden following first solo press conference in months: 'Quite the change' - Fox News - January 25th, 2022
- Tiley's plan to ride out the Open storm - Daily Liberal - January 25th, 2022
- The liberal justices lies reveal the lefts addiction to virus fears - New York Post - January 11th, 2022
- B.C. Liberal party insists its vetting process will catch fraudulent memberships - Vancouver Sun - January 11th, 2022
- After Harry Reid's death, will the LDS Church ever see another liberal leader? - KUER 90.1 - January 11th, 2022
- Letter to the editor: Have suspicions of the liberal agenda? - The Winchester Star - January 11th, 2022
- The New York Times is a reminder: good liberals often oppose unions - The Guardian - January 11th, 2022
- Conservative, liberal female figures weigh in on VP Harris report that her race and gender affect headlines - Fox News - January 11th, 2022
- During 1992-2015 the question whether the PPP/C was practicing liberal democracy never arose - Stabroek News - January 11th, 2022
- Liberal fecklessness: The US is on a precipice and time is running out - Open Democracy - January 11th, 2022
- The liberal fantasy of the Capitol coup - UnHerd - January 11th, 2022
- US call for allies to lift game in Pacific - Daily Liberal - January 11th, 2022
- Ontario Liberal Leader Invites Health and Political Leaders to a Virtual Summit on the Escalating Hospital Crisis - Ontario Liberal Party - January 11th, 2022
- Manitoba Liberals say they won't field candidate in Thompson byelection - Thompson Citizen - January 11th, 2022
- Liberal dark money juggernaut raises $1.6 billion to flood left-wing groups with cash, tax forms reveal - Fox News - November 29th, 2021
- 8 times liberal media tried to ruin Thanksgiving, from ditching turkey to declaring genocide remains on menu - Fox News - November 29th, 2021
- Liberal MP crosses the floor to support independent bill for federal integrity commission - The Guardian - November 29th, 2021
- Liberals introduce bill to provide sick pay, ban intimidation of patients and health-care workers - CBC.ca - November 29th, 2021
- Is the honeymoon period over for liberal arts in Asia? - Times Higher Education (THE) - November 29th, 2021
- Liberal economists got the memo: Build Back Better couldn't possibly worsen inflation | TheHill - The Hill - November 29th, 2021
- John Ivison: Liberals so focused on carbon taxes, they missed the flood coming in the back door - National Post - November 29th, 2021
- A 20-year spike in inflation could put the bite on the Trudeau Liberals - CBC.ca - November 29th, 2021
- John Rawls and Liberalism's Selective Conscience - The Nation - November 29th, 2021
- Liberal Party members running as independents, community candidates in local elections - The Sydney Morning Herald - November 29th, 2021
- No need for overdevelopment: Labor, Liberal councillors united in opposition to apartment towers - The Sydney Morning Herald - November 29th, 2021
- Ana Pateman will run for council in the east ward - Daily Liberal - November 29th, 2021
- Toongi will be home to a new Critical Minerals Hub - Daily Liberal - November 29th, 2021
- Suspected Omicron case in Switzerland - Daily Liberal - November 29th, 2021
- What Exactly Is a 'Liberal'? | Merriam-Webster - April 5th, 2021
- liberalism | Definition, History, & Facts | Britannica - April 5th, 2021
- What is a liberal? What is a conservative? | Fox News - April 5th, 2021
- DePauw ranked No. 10 liberal arts school in the nation - DePauw University - April 5th, 2021
- Bringing in gender quotas in the Liberal party is not just right it's smart politics too - The Guardian - April 5th, 2021
- Former central bank governor to play prominent role at Liberal convention - The Globe and Mail - April 5th, 2021
- Georgia Governor: MLB Decision To Move All-Star Game Is Based On 'Fear And Lies' - NPR - April 5th, 2021
- Conservative vs Liberal - Difference and Comparison | Diffen - April 5th, 2021
- Why We Need The Liberal Arts To Achieve Stakeholder Capitalism - Chief Executive Group - April 5th, 2021
- Former bank governor Mark Carney among featured speakers at Liberal convention - Kamloops This Week - April 5th, 2021
- 82 unions and liberal groups urge Biden to go bigger on tax hikes and hold the wealthy accountable - Business Insider - April 5th, 2021
- Opposition shuts WE hearing as Liberals again refuse to let staffer testify - CTV News - April 5th, 2021
- Quotas for women would be fraught with problems in the NSW Liberal Party - Sydney Morning Herald - April 5th, 2021
- Conservative opinion columnist Rob Port to begin new livestream show with liberals - INFORUM - April 5th, 2021
- NSW Young Liberals turn to Tory selection process for women - Sydney Morning Herald - April 5th, 2021
- Liberal senator backs redeploying of superannuation early access scheme - Sydney Morning Herald - April 5th, 2021
- Here's why there's *no* chance of a liberal takeover of Washington - CNN - December 10th, 2020
- Conservatism and Liberalism: Two Books on the Great Divide - The Wall Street Journal - December 10th, 2020
- LETTER - The Liberal Democrats are an alternative - Daily Echo - December 10th, 2020
- White clicktivism: why are some Americans woke online but not in real life? - The Guardian - December 10th, 2020
- The Liberal Arts Institution and the Scaled Online Learning Platform Provider | Learning Innovation - Inside Higher Ed - December 10th, 2020
- The collective suicide of the liberal class: We will all pay the price for their cowardice - Salon - December 10th, 2020
- BC Liberals to adopt more aggressive tone, pundit predicts - Prince George Citizen - December 10th, 2020
- Our Political System Is Unfair. Liberals Need to Just Deal With It. - The New York Times - November 20th, 2020
- Neal Gabler with Catching the Wind: Edward Kennedy and the Liberal Hour, 1932-1975 (Virtual) - wgbh.org - November 20th, 2020
- Opposition defeats Liberals on motion to fight Chinese tactics - The Globe and Mail - November 20th, 2020
- Why is the liberal Left resorting to fake news too? - Evening Standard - November 20th, 2020
- India's mask of economic liberalism is off - The Hindu - November 20th, 2020
- Wisconsin issues recount order, paid for by Trump, in 2 liberal counties - pressherald.com - November 20th, 2020
- Gavin Newsom Is the Face of Privileged Liberal Hypocrisy - The Daily Beast - November 20th, 2020
- Reader letters, Thursday: Senate runoffs give chance to stand against liberals - Savannah Morning News - November 20th, 2020
- John Ivison: The Liberal MP Justin Trudeau couldn't control. Memoir reveals final, angry call with PM - National Post - November 20th, 2020
- The importance of how voters perceive the political orientation of colleges and universities (opinion) - Inside Higher Ed - October 19th, 2020
- Liberals, WE make disclosures as chance of confidence vote heats up on the Hill - CTV News - October 19th, 2020
- In B.C.s pandemic election, the Liberals and NDP have reversed roles - The Globe and Mail - October 19th, 2020
- What happened when Trump backers and Black Lives Matters protesters met in Liberal - The Journal at the Kansas Leadership Center - October 19th, 2020
- What The Babylon Bee Thinks Is So Funny About Liberals - The New York Times - October 19th, 2020
- After 20 years, the ACT election was the Liberals' to lose what went so wrong? - ABC News - October 19th, 2020
- Facebook, bias and the battle over conservative and liberal content on social media - East Idaho News - October 19th, 2020
- Feinstein slammed by liberals over Amy Coney Barrett hearing - Los Angeles Times - October 19th, 2020
- Theres a Word for Why We Wear Masks, and Liberals Should Say It - The New York Times - October 19th, 2020
- B.C. Conservative leader says B.C. Liberal leak of WorkSafeBC report shows party is worried - Kamloops This Week - October 19th, 2020
- The Encroachment of the Unsayable - The New York Times - October 19th, 2020
- COMMENTARY: The Liberals are being disingenuous in their push to end WE Charity investigations - Global News - October 19th, 2020
- Conservative Critiques Of Twitter Sound Very Left-Wing Liberal - Forbes - October 19th, 2020
- Non-profit aimed at feeding food insecure in Liberal expands - KoamNewsNow.com - October 19th, 2020