LGBT people have gained more legal recognition in recent years, but LGBT rights remain a central issue in Indiana politics. Stephanie Wang/IndyStar
Jackie and Lisa Phillips-Stackman hold their daughter, Lola, at their Indianapolis home, Friday, Dec. 4, 2015. The couple are filing a lawsuit against the state to try to get Indiana to recognize both same-sex parents on their children's birth certificates.(Photo: Michelle Pemberton/The Star)Buy Photo
In oral arguments Monday, a panel of three judges for the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals examined whetherIndiana discriminates by not recognizing two married women both as parents on their children's birth certificates without having to adopt.
Judge Diane S. Sykesdrew distinctions betweenbiological parentage and parental rights, and which of the two should be represented on birth certificates.
"You can't overcome biology," Sykes said. "If the state defines parenthood by virtue of biology, no argument under the Equal Protection Clause or the substantive due process clause can overcome that."
"Your Honor, with all due respect, we maintain that parenthood is no longer defined by biology," said Karen Celestino-Horseman, the attorney for eight same-sex couples who brought the lawsuit against the state for only allowing only a mother and a father to be named on birth certificates.
"That's a policy argument to take to the legislature," Sykes responded.
The state of Indiana is appealing a ruling by a district judgewho sidedwith the same-sex couplesand ordered the state to recognize both women as parents on birth certificates of children who are conceived through a sperm donor.
"In our view, that order creates an inequality that did not exist before and undermines the rights of biological fathers and their children," said Indiana Solicitor General Thomas Fisher.
Read the back story: Same-sex couples sue state over birth certificates
More on politics: Tully: A few thoughts about the Mike Pence protests
Trump's education plan: DeVos: School choice should expand, but not from Washington D.C.
The couples' case argued that parental recognition should be a benefit conferred by the U.S. Supreme Court's marriage equality ruling in 2015, known as Obergefell v. Hodges.
Prior to the lawsuit, the spouse who was not the birth mother would have to adopt the child, even if her egg was used for the pregnancy. That was the case for Indianapolis couple Jackie and Lisa Phillips-Stackman, who are part of the lawsuit.
Not recognizing the non-birthmother, the lawsuit said, could make it more difficult for families to be covered by insurance policies, or for the parent to enroll her child in school.
The adoption process, which can be costly, amends the birth certificate to recognize adoptive parents. The original record, Fisher said, is still retained.
But the lawsuit contended that spouses should be recognized as a parent when the child is born because of her wedded status similar to how married opposite-sex couples are often treated, where the husband can be presumed to be the father.
"The statute creates a paternity presumption that just is impossible in a same-sex marriage situation," Sykes said, referring to the state statute on birth certificates that the couples are challenging.
"Your Honor," Celestino-Horseman said, "that's if one still presumes that parenthood is still defined"
Sykes interrupted: "It's not a parenthood statute. It's a paternity statute. Paternity presumption is impossible in a same-sex marriage situation. So we just don't have any kind of discrimination going on here at all."
Later, Sykes said that what the couples may be seeking is a redefinition of parenthood.
"Your Honor," Celestino-Horseman said, "parenthood"
Sykes interrupted again: " is biological or adopted. You want this third category."
As Celestino-Horseman cited relevant cases, Sykes delineated between marriage cases and parenthood cases.
In pregnancies using a sperm donor, opposite-sex couples can say the husband is the father of the child but that same presumption of parenthood doesn't extend to a wife in a same-sex couple who isn't the birth mother, the lawsuit argued.
The state of Indiana countered that opposite-sex couples aren't supposed to do that. The mother is supposed to state when the husband is not the father. But that's not what often happens in real life.
"That led me to think that your argument is that a state law becomes unconstitutional because people subject to the state law don't follow it," Judge Frank H. Easterbrook said, "which would be a very difficult position to take."
The debate, he said, would then be about how state law is supposed to operate not whether it discriminates.
Easterbrook asked how the couples' case would apply to two married men who have a child through artificial insemination.
Celestino-Horseman indicated the situation was more complicated because it would involve surrogacy.
"I don't want to be the one to tell you this, but Obergefell says there can't be any sex discrimination, and now you're saying there must be sex discrimination," Easterbrook said. "In a female-female marriage, the right answer is mother No. 1 and mother No. 2. In a male-male marriage, the right answer is surrogate mother, sperm donor, followed by adoption. In your view, doesn't there have to be identical treatment of the male-male marriage and the female-female marriage?"
News alerts delivered to your phone:Download IndyStar app for breaking news, sports.
Celestino-Horseman responded that wasn't part of the case.
"We can't ignorethe logical implications of your arguments. And you seem to want to," Easterbrook replied.
He added that the case aimed to require "a mis-recording of who the father is."
"Your view seems to be that it is unconstitutional for Indiana to correctly record the parent," he said.
The Seventh Circuit is taking the case under advisement and may rule at a later date.
Call IndyStar reporter Stephanie Wang at (317) 444-6184. Follow her on Twitter: @stephaniewang.
Read or Share this story: http://indy.st/2rLLPSp
Link:
Judge to Indiana same-sex couples: 'You can't overcome biology' - Indianapolis Star
- Host change alters toxic cocktail - March 19th, 2011 [March 19th, 2011]
- Integrative Biology 131 - Lecture 01: Organization of Body - August 27th, 2011 [August 27th, 2011]
- Systems Biology Lecture 1 - August 27th, 2011 [August 27th, 2011]
- Biology 1B - Lecture 24: Phylogenetics - August 28th, 2011 [August 28th, 2011]
- Biology 1B - Lecture 28: Evolutionary Medicine - Published ! - August 28th, 2011 [August 28th, 2011]
- 1. Introduction to Human Behavioral Biology - August 29th, 2011 [August 29th, 2011]
- Bill Nye: 100 Greatest Discoveries : Biology (Discovery Channel) 3/3 - August 31st, 2011 [August 31st, 2011]
- Introduction to Biology - 1 - What is Biology? - August 31st, 2011 [August 31st, 2011]
- What is Biology? - September 3rd, 2011 [September 3rd, 2011]
- Biology 1B - Lecture 16: Population Genetics I: Mendel, Darw - September 3rd, 2011 [September 3rd, 2011]
- Bill Nye: 100 Greatest Discoveries : Biology (Discovery Channel) 2/3 - September 4th, 2011 [September 4th, 2011]
- Biology 1B - Lecture 3 - September 6th, 2011 [September 6th, 2011]
- Biology: Proteins: Amino Acids - September 8th, 2011 [September 8th, 2011]
- Girls Aloud - Biology - September 9th, 2011 [September 9th, 2011]
- Biology 1A - Lecture 3: Cell structure and organization -#1 - September 10th, 2011 [September 10th, 2011]
- Biology 1A - Lecture 2 - September 11th, 2011 [September 11th, 2011]
- Biology of Alzheimer's Disease and Other Dementias - September 11th, 2011 [September 11th, 2011]
- Bill Nye: 100 Greatest Discoveries : Biology (Discovery Channel) 1/3 - September 11th, 2011 [September 11th, 2011]
- What is Biology - Part 1: Lecture 1.1 - September 12th, 2011 [September 12th, 2011]
- Lec 1 | MIT 7.012 Introduction to Biology, Fall 2004 - September 15th, 2011 [September 15th, 2011]
- (Notes On) Biology - September 17th, 2011 [September 17th, 2011]
- Biology Introduction - September 18th, 2011 [September 18th, 2011]
- Biology 1B - Lecture 10: Paleoecology and Hominid Ecology - September 20th, 2011 [September 20th, 2011]
- Zen Biology Lesson for Enlightenment - September 20th, 2011 [September 20th, 2011]
- Biology: Mitosis: An Overview - September 23rd, 2011 [September 23rd, 2011]
- Synthetic Biology: Drew Endy - September 24th, 2011 [September 24th, 2011]
- ATP: Adenosine Triphosphate - September 26th, 2011 [September 26th, 2011]
- Biology 1B - Lecture 13: Conclusion - September 27th, 2011 [September 27th, 2011]
- Biology 1AL - Lecture 1 - September 30th, 2011 [September 30th, 2011]
- Biology 1A - Lecture 7: Cell membrane structure and transpor - October 1st, 2011 [October 1st, 2011]
- Biology 1AL - Lecture 4: Lab 5: Complementation I, Genetics - October 4th, 2011 [October 4th, 2011]
- Pilobolus: A performance merging dance and biology - October 4th, 2011 [October 4th, 2011]
- Molecular Biology's Central Dogma - October 4th, 2011 [October 4th, 2011]
- Biology 1A - Lecture 15: The Laws that Govern the Inheritanc - October 4th, 2011 [October 4th, 2011]
- Biology 1B - Lecture 1: Introduction to Ecology - October 4th, 2011 [October 4th, 2011]
- Girls Aloud - Biology Live At Wembley - October 4th, 2011 [October 4th, 2011]
- Lec 1 | MIT 7.014 Introductory Biology, Spring 2005 - October 7th, 2011 [October 7th, 2011]
- The New Biology - From Victim to Master of Your Health - October 7th, 2011 [October 7th, 2011]
- Synthetic Biology Explained - October 7th, 2011 [October 7th, 2011]
- Andrew Hessel - Introduction to Synthetic Biology - October 7th, 2011 [October 7th, 2011]
- Foldit: Biology for gamers - by Nature Video - October 7th, 2011 [October 7th, 2011]
- Bruce Lipton - Biology of Perception 1 of 7 - October 12th, 2011 [October 12th, 2011]
- Biology 1B - Lecture 15: Darwin and the Origin II - October 12th, 2011 [October 12th, 2011]
- Girls Aloud - Biology - Video - October 13th, 2011 [October 13th, 2011]
- Biology 1A - Lecture 14: How Somatic Cells - Mitosis - and G - Video - October 13th, 2011 [October 13th, 2011]
- Dna Molecular Biology Visualizations - Wrapping And Replicat - Video - October 13th, 2011 [October 13th, 2011]
- The Biology Song - Video - October 14th, 2011 [October 14th, 2011]
- What is Biology? - Video - October 14th, 2011 [October 14th, 2011]
- Lec 2 | MIT 7.014 Introductory Biology, Spring 2005 - Video - October 14th, 2011 [October 14th, 2011]
- Biology 1A - Lecture 19: Gene Expression II - RNA is transla - Video - October 15th, 2011 [October 15th, 2011]
- Biology 1B - Lecture 14: Darwin and the Origin of Species I - Video - October 15th, 2011 [October 15th, 2011]
- Biology 1A - Lecture 1 - Video - October 15th, 2011 [October 15th, 2011]
- Integrative Biology 131 - Lecture 18: Lymphatic System - Video - October 20th, 2011 [October 20th, 2011]
- biology - nuclear transfer (clone creating) - Video - October 20th, 2011 [October 20th, 2011]
- Introduction to Biology - Video - October 20th, 2011 [October 20th, 2011]
- Biology 1A - Lecture 1: Course introduction. Introduction to macromolecules. - Video - October 23rd, 2011 [October 23rd, 2011]
- Bruce Lipton - Biology of Perception 2 of 7 - Video - October 23rd, 2011 [October 23rd, 2011]
- Seinfeld - Marine Biologist - Video - October 27th, 2011 [October 27th, 2011]
- Biological Classification: Kingdoms - Video - October 28th, 2011 [October 28th, 2011]
- A Biologist's St. Patrick's Day Song - Video - October 28th, 2011 [October 28th, 2011]
- A Biologist's Mother's Day Song - Video - October 30th, 2011 [October 30th, 2011]
- Biology 1B - Lecture 28: Fungal diversity and reproduction - Video - November 2nd, 2011 [November 2nd, 2011]
- Learn Biology: Ecosystem Definition - November 5th, 2011 [November 5th, 2011]
- Learn Biology: Gregor Mendel Biography - Video - November 6th, 2011 [November 6th, 2011]
- TEDxCaltech - J. Craig Venter - Future Biology - Video - November 8th, 2011 [November 8th, 2011]
- Biology 1B - Lecture 31: Origin of land plants - bryophytes - Video - November 8th, 2011 [November 8th, 2011]
- Practical biology - The Thin Blue Line - Video - November 8th, 2011 [November 8th, 2011]
- Dr. Karin Remington on Computational Biology - Video - November 14th, 2011 [November 14th, 2011]
- Bully-Soundtrack Biology Class - Video - November 14th, 2011 [November 14th, 2011]
- From Chemtrails to Pseudo-Life- The Dark Agenda of Synthetic Biology. SLIDE SHOW - Video - November 14th, 2011 [November 14th, 2011]
- ROUTINE OF EXERCISES TO LOSE WEIGHT WITH THE BIOLOGICAL AND DOMESTIC GYMNASTICS OF LUIS MORI - Video - November 14th, 2011 [November 14th, 2011]
- Biology 1B - Lecture 7: Trophic Dynamics and Biogeography - Video - November 14th, 2011 [November 14th, 2011]
- Plant Tissue Arrangement in Organs (AP Biology) - Video - November 14th, 2011 [November 14th, 2011]
- BIOLOGICAL GYMNASTICS OF WEIGHT'S REDUCTION BY LUIS MORI-YEAR 2012 - Video - November 14th, 2011 [November 14th, 2011]
- From Chemtrails to Pseudo-Life: The Dark Agenda of Synthetic Biology (FULL LENGTH VIDEO) - Video - November 14th, 2011 [November 14th, 2011]
- Pre-AP Biology - Unit 5.12 - Translation.mp4 - Video - November 14th, 2011 [November 14th, 2011]
- Marine Biology Research @ Clark U - Video - November 14th, 2011 [November 14th, 2011]
- Major in a Minute: Biology - Video - November 17th, 2011 [November 17th, 2011]
- Bruce Lipton - Biology of Perception 3 of 7 - Video - November 17th, 2011 [November 17th, 2011]
- Biology: Carbohydrates: Monosaccharides - Video - November 17th, 2011 [November 17th, 2011]