Almost a year on, a legal fight to set the road map for how South Carolina deals with imperiled beach houses has stalled.
The challenges that have popped up in the case beg the question of whether the state can really be compelled to deal with vulnerable oceanfront properties as sea levels rise and storms intensify.
At the same time, recent trends in state policy have moved South Carolina's position from one of "retreat" gradually encouraging homeowners to move away from the shore to one of preservation, or doing everything possible to keep homes in place.
The legal case concerns five homes on Harbor Island, a gated retirement and vacation community at the eastern edge of Beaufort County. As parts of the island's beach have eroded, the houses are now routinely underwashed by the ocean and have largely been left derelict, with pieces of the structures falling into the sea.
The Harbor Island Owners Association is arguing that the people who own the homes should remove them. Two other homes on the beachfront have already been demolished and two have been relocated, said Don Woelke, the manager of the association.
"We know that with sea level rise and the fact that nearly every beach in South Carolina is eroding, were going to see more houses that are located on the active beach," said Amy Armstrong, the lead lawyer representing the association. "What we wanted to achieve is to get some precedent about what happens, whos responsible when this happens, and how."
The situation is relatively rare, though most beaches in South Carolina are gradually eroding. In other places, federally or locally funded renourishment programs suck sand off the ocean floor and spit it back onto the beach periodically; Harbor Island isn't eligible for public funds because it doesn't allow the general public access to its beach.
Beach renourishment, though, is a "mid-term solution to a long-term problem," said Paul Gayes, a professor of marine science and geology at Coastal Carolina University. It's also one that's likely to become increasingly costly over time, as continuous storms are forcing beach towns to renourish more and more often.
"The likelihood is playing out that logically, youre going to run into places that are not going to be able to sustain it," Gayes said.
And that makes the Harbor Island example a peek into the future, when many places beyond the small, private island are likely to face the same issues.
The Harbor Island suit was filed in November 2018. For the S.C. Environmental Law Project which isArmstrong's group, the suit was an opportunity to strengthen the public trust doctrine, the legal concept that the beach is open to the public, and that the state has an interest in protecting it.
Under that logic, the plaintiffs argued that South Carolina should be responsible for removing the houses. But since then, a judge has ruled that SCELP was not specific enough in simply naming the state; it needed to sue a specific agency or official.
The nonprofit Law Project then pivoted to another tactic: forcing the homeowners themselves to pull houses off the beach.
It's been a lengthy process, though Armstrong said it's not unreasonable to expect a suit like this to be litigated over years. Several motions still need to be heard and no trial date has been set yet.
The homeowners named in the suit have largely denied that they're liable for the house removal or asked to be dismissed, according to court records.
One couple, John and Judy Price, argued in filings that the Owners Association is actually responsible to protect the beach because it's a "common area," like other amenities on the island, and says state authorities recommended a renourishment project in 2017.
Chris Deters, an attorney for the Price family, said that rather than filing a suit, the owners' association should have invested in an engineering solution to stop the erosion. Deters said it might be more wise to make a concession and allow for more public access, in exchange for public renourishment funding.
"The (owners association) is tone deaf to the threat our current environmental pattern presents to the coastal community," Deters said.
The strongest response came in a filing by St. Helena attorney Bruce R. Hoffman, who is representing defendants Barbara and Patrick Shurtleff. Their filings argue that Armstrong herself has a conflict of interest and needs to be removed because she once spoke with Debra Hoffman, Bruce's wife, about potentially representing them in a different case related to sand-trapping groins built on Hunting Island.
The Hoffmans also own a beachfront home on Harbor Island, though they are not named defendants. Armstrong said the assertion she should be removed is a "sideshow," and that she never had an attorney-client relationship with the Hoffmans, and thus, no conflict in this case.
"We know the law in this area. Weve been successful," Armstrong said. "Of course they would like us to not be counsel."
But Hoffman maintained that by simply consulting with beachfront property owners, even for a different case, Armstrong gleaned confidential information that should disqualify her from suing them now.
"I'm just doing what I think is best for my client and my clients case," Hoffman said.
For the other 600-odd homeowners on Harbor Island, the legal drama doesn't change the fact that there are still houses in the beach falling into the water, piece by piece.
"There was no idea on how long it would actually take (when the case was first filed)," Woelke said. "This is a process, and we live with it, and we just wait."
The houses on Harbor Island aren't the only ones that have been overtaken by the sea. Beach communities in South Carolina have struggled with erosion and the impacts of strong storms for over a century.
Earlier this decade, abandoned cottages on and eroding section of nearby Hunting Island either fell into the ocean or were demolished. In that case, houses owned by the state park there were removed by public officials, but private homes were considered the responsibility of their owners, according to a 2013 report in the Beaufort Gazette.
The S.C. Department of Health and Environmental Control is responsible for telling the owners of vulnerable beach homes to remove them when they're on active beach, spokeswoman Laura Renwick said, but few situations across the state have reached that level in recent years.
Meanwhile, more changes in state policy have flummoxed coastal policy experts, as a revision of the state's beach management laws deleted the word "retreat."
The change was part of the fallout after DHEC published new lines limiting beach development and rebuilding in late 2017; those lines, in some cases, barred property owners from rebuilding if their homes were damaged. They've since been revised.
While the changes might seem technical, Gayes said the alteration of state policy really means that South Carolina has taken the stance that it will not move beach houses where they are, regardless of rising sea levels.
Even with renourishment, he said, "At the end of the day, youre buying time."
- Puerto Peasco bets on heavy restrictions in bid to reactivate tourist economy - AZCentral - August 8th, 2020
- The Interisland Travel Quarantine Is Coming Back, Oahu Beaches And - Honolulu Civil Beat - August 8th, 2020
- Beaches Open At The Lake Of The Ozarks - krmsradio.com - August 8th, 2020
- Woman hospitalized with life-threatening injury after shooting near The Beaches - FirstCoastNews.com WTLV-WJXX - August 8th, 2020
- Several Cape Cod beaches temporarily closed following great white shark sightings - The Boston Globe - August 8th, 2020
- Oahu beaches, parks and team sports will be halted once more - Honolulu Star-Advertiser - August 8th, 2020
- Shark sightings in Wellfleet and Truro temporarily close beaches - The Boston Globe - August 8th, 2020
- Recreationists react to closures of city and state parks, beaches and campgrounds - Honolulu Star-Advertiser - August 8th, 2020
- At least 151 migrants land on Kent beaches - BBC News - August 8th, 2020
- Frigid waters to return to some area beaches - WOODTV.com - August 8th, 2020
- Whats That Building? The Modernist Bathhouses At Illinois Beach State Park - WBEZ - August 8th, 2020
- The 10 Best Beaches on the French Riviera - Fodor's Travel - August 8th, 2020
- Crouch: Recent southern counties outbreak linked to Myrtle Beach - West Virginia MetroNews - August 8th, 2020
- Does This Video Show an Octopus Walking on the Beach? - Snopes.com - August 8th, 2020
- Delaware beach guide: What you need to know for your Aug. 7-9 weekend beach trip - The News Journal - August 8th, 2020
- At least 26 migrants land on Kent beaches - BBC News - August 8th, 2020
- Galveston must keep its word on sudden beach closures - Galveston County Daily News - August 8th, 2020
- 10 of the UK's best seaside cafes and beach shacks - The Guardian - August 8th, 2020
- 17-year-old girl airlifted with life-threatening injuries following crash on North Landing Bridge in Virginia Beach - WAVY.com - August 8th, 2020
- Great White Sharks may be closer to the NJ beaches than you think - New Jersey 101.5 FM Radio - August 6th, 2020
- Shops closed, beaches deserted as Isaias nears the Carolinas - Fox 59 - August 6th, 2020
- We have a beautiful beach: Myrtle Beach officials remind vacationers of beach rules - ABC27 - August 6th, 2020
- A Trip To Virginia Beach Showed Why We Arent Beating This Virus - Forbes - August 6th, 2020
- Travel/Beach Restrictions: Heres what you need to know for RI, Mass. - WPRI.com - August 6th, 2020
- Isaias destroys outdoor venue at Long Beach Islands Surflight Theatre - WHYY - August 6th, 2020
- Boss Of The Beach TV Series Based On New York Magazine Article In Works By Darren Aronofsky & Searchlight TV - Deadline - August 6th, 2020
- A day in the life of the newly opened SF Bay trail at Albany Beach - Berkeleyside - August 6th, 2020
- Jersey Shore businesses dealt devastating blow as power wiped out on all of LBI - NJ.com - August 6th, 2020
- All of Long Beach Island Remains Without Power - TAPinto.net - August 6th, 2020
- Alki Beach and Don Armeni Boat Launch to be closed at night Thursdays through Sundays - Westside Seattle - August 6th, 2020
- Water restrictions removed at all state beaches other than Reid - NewsCenterMaine.com WCSH-WLBZ - August 3rd, 2020
- The best beaches in America are in Florida, according to Trip Advisor - I Love the Burg - August 3rd, 2020
- These 2 New England beaches just ranked among the best in the U.S. - Boston.com - August 3rd, 2020
- This Cape Cod beach was the only one in Massachusetts to land within Trip Advisors top 25 in US - MassLive.com - August 3rd, 2020
- Travel/Beach Restrictions: Heres what you need to know in RI, Mass. - WPRI.com - August 3rd, 2020
- Pensacola Beach-goers kept their eyes on the sky - WKRG News 5 - August 3rd, 2020
- Beach battle: Reduced access increases tension between tourists and Seacoast communities - Seacoastonline.com - August 3rd, 2020
- Social butterfly Vera Pavelec, one of four pals testing positive after Huntington Beach party, dies of COVID - OCRegister - August 3rd, 2020
- Beach Boys holding on to Connecticut concert date - MassLive.com - August 3rd, 2020
- Maine beach named one of the best in the country - WMTW Portland - August 3rd, 2020
- Isaias expected to bring big surf to area beaches - WPRI.com - August 3rd, 2020
- North Beach Neighbors Band Together to Boost Restaurants' Business With Volunteer Deliveries - CBS San Francisco - August 3rd, 2020
- Various groups hold beach cleanups across the Coastal Bend area in the aftermath of Hurricane Hanna - KIIITV.com - August 3rd, 2020
- Long Island Beaches Reopen This Weekend After Days Of Shark Sightings - CBS New York - August 3rd, 2020
- Close encounter: mother and calf whales stun surfers at Sydney's Manly beach - The Guardian - August 3rd, 2020
- The latest on Delaware's beaches: Your weekend trip guide for the first weekend in August - The News Journal - July 30th, 2020
- Shark sightings off LI coastline close several beaches for swimming for third straight day: officials - WPIX 11 New York - July 30th, 2020
- Study: Water quality dipped at Dot beaches last year - Dorchester Reporter - July 30th, 2020
- These 2 New England beaches were just ranked in the top 25 in the US - The Boston Globe - July 30th, 2020
- $22 million SunRunner bus system approved to connect St. Petersburg with beaches - FOX 13 Tampa Bay - July 30th, 2020
- Honolulu looks to outlaw large tents at beaches and parks - KHON2 - July 30th, 2020
- BEAUTIES and the Beach - coastalbreezenews.com - July 30th, 2020
- JW Marriott Making a Difference on the Beach - coastalbreezenews.com - July 30th, 2020
- Going to the Delaware Beaches Soon? DC Says You'll Have to Quarantine When You Get Back - Washingtonian - July 30th, 2020
- The Best Beach Getaways in the U.S. - Cond Nast Traveler - July 30th, 2020
- 141 tickets issued for alcohol, other violations at Westerly beaches in past 10 days - The Westerly Sun - July 30th, 2020
- Itchy invaders: Sea lice reported at Dariens Weed Beach - Darien Times - July 30th, 2020
- FDNY battles fire in Midland Beach townhouses; 1 firefighter injured - SILive.com - July 30th, 2020
- The story behind Miami's Colored Beach - The Miami Times - July 29th, 2020
- Three Long Island Beaches Close After High Levels Of Bacteria Discovered - Daily Voice - July 29th, 2020
- Thailand's beach resorts have reopened to domestic tourists. Here's what guests can expect - CNN - July 29th, 2020
- Series of Shark Sightings Prompt Swimming Restrictions at Long Island Beaches - NBC New York - July 29th, 2020
- Long Island Beaches Cleared After Another Shark Sighting Off Jones Beach - Gothamist - July 29th, 2020
- Virginia Beach City Public Schools board to vote on school reopening plan - 13newsnow.com WVEC - July 29th, 2020
- Pools and beaches hit capacity during scorching heat - News 12 Westchester - July 27th, 2020
- Several Beaches Closed to Late Arrivals Amid Covid Concerns - East Hampton Star - July 27th, 2020
- 'Leave Only Footprints' campaign: Items left on beach subject to removal by Town of Kitty Hawk - The Coastland Times - The Coastland Times - July 27th, 2020
- Its really devastating us: Beach towns fear they wont survive a summer of COVID-19 - USA TODAY - July 27th, 2020
- Many head to local swimming holes, beaches as temperatures near 100 degrees - KPTV.com - July 27th, 2020
- Residents expected to pack public pools, beaches Monday as high heat moves in - WFSB - July 27th, 2020
- Scarborough Beach snack bar closed after positive COVID-19 test - The Westerly Sun - July 27th, 2020
- Long Beach police release videos in killing of liquor store clerk who tried to stop thief - KTLA Los Angeles - July 27th, 2020
- Weymouth man drowns off Merrimack River beach; foul play not suspected - Boston.com - July 27th, 2020
- For many in Connecticut, COVID-19 restrictions have made it harder to go to the beach this summer - theday.com - July 27th, 2020
- Nueces County beaches are closed to pedestrians, vehicles and will reopen Monday, July 27 - KIIITV.com - July 27th, 2020
- Hundreds gather in Huntington Beach to be baptized with cold dunk in the ocean - OCRegister - July 27th, 2020
- Sea Turtles Are Hatching On Escambia's Beaches. Their Odds Of Survival Are Not Good. - NorthEscambia.com - July 27th, 2020
- Jones, Orient Beach forced to turn away visitors early amid hot temps - New York Post - July 27th, 2020
- One More Thing To Worry About At The Beach: Water Quality - wgbh.org - July 27th, 2020
- These Are the Beaches Travelers Can't Wait to Return To - Reader's Digest - July 27th, 2020