The Trump Administration has published an interim final rule that will dramatically reduce the number of aliens who can apply for asylum in the United States.
The rule authorizes asylum officers in expedited removal proceedings and immigration judges in regular removal proceedings to conduct a threshold screening to determine whether an alien is barred by a Safe Third Country agreement from applying for asylum. Aliens who are barred will have to choose between applying for asylum in a Safe Third Country and going home (unless they have some other basis for lawful status in the United States).
Those would be the only choices: apply elsewhere or go home.
The United States currently has Safe Third Country agreements with El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, and Canada; the agreement with Canada, however, is subject to different rules.
The new rule applies prospectively to aliens who arrive at a United States port of entry or who enter or attempt to enter the United States between ports of entry on or after Nov. 19, 2019.
Immigration advocates may be successful in challenging this rule in the lower federal courts, but I expect the Supreme Court to find that it is a lawful exercise of statutory authority.
Safe Third Country agreements are not new
Safe Third Country agreements were created to make it possible for countries to share the responsibility of aiding asylum seekers. In 1991, the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugeesinvited such agreementsto foster international cooperation.
The United States desperately needs international assistance with asylum seekers. Its immigration courts have so many cases now that the American Bar Association says they are on the brink of collapse.
The immigration court backlog was542,411 casesin January 2017, when PresidentDonald TrumpDonald John TrumpGiuliani associate prepared to testify Nunes aides scrapped Ukraine trip to avoid alerting Schiff Democrats pledge sharp turn in US ties with Saudi Arabia Schumer praises former Navy chief after ouster MOREtook office, and it had increased to1,023,767 casesby the end of September 2019, with an average wait for a hearing of696 days.
The immigration courts only completed297,109 casesthrough September of fiscal 2019. At that rate, even if there were to be a freeze on immigration enforcement to prevent new cases from being added, it would take three-and-a-half years to clear the backlog.
El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras are not safe
Immigration advocates are certain to argue that the safe third countries are not safe. They are plagued by the crime and violence that caused people to seek asylum in the United States in the first place. El Salvadorhas the worlds highest intentional homicide rate. Honduras is fifth, and Guatemala is 16th.
But asylum law doesn't provide refuge from violent, crime-ridden countries. When asylum seekers from El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras fail to establish eligibility for asylum, they are returned to their countries, regardless of the danger that awaits them there.
The asylum provision, section 208(b)(1)(A) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, only authorizes asylum for an alien who has established that he is a "refugee" as that term is defined bysection 1101(a)(42)(A), which reads as follows:
(42) The term "refugee" means (A) any person who is outside any country of such person's nationality .... and who is unable or unwilling to return to ... that country because of persecution or a well-founded fear of persecution on account of race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion, ...
And the Safe Third Country provision, section 208(a)(2), just requires participating countries to be able to provide safety from persecution:
Paragraph (1) [the one that gives aliens the right to apply for asylum] shall not apply to an alien if the Attorney General determines that the alien may be removed, pursuant to a bilateral or multilateral agreement, to a country .... in which the alien's life or freedom would not be threatened on account of race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion, and where the alien would have access to a full and fair procedure for determining a claim to asylum .... (Emphasis supplied.)
No court has jurisdiction to review the validity of Safe Third Country agreements
Congress prohibited court review of determinations made under the Safe Third Country provision and the other two exceptions. Section 208(a)(3) states that:
No court shall have jurisdiction to review any determination of the Attorney General under paragraph (2)
I expect the Supreme Court to respect this limitation.
In the Travel Ban case, the immigration advocates argued that Trump had exceeded the authority Congress delegated to the President in section 212(f) of the INA. The Supreme Court rejected their arguments on the basis of the "plain language" of the section, finding that, "attempts to identify a conflict with other provisions in the INA, and their appeal to the statute's purposes and legislative history, fail to overcome the clear statutory language."
The same surely is true of the language in the judicial review limitation. Congressional intent could not be any clearer.
The only way immigration advocates will succeed with a challenge to the Safe Third Country rule is to persuade the Supreme Court that Congress violated the Constitution by authorizing the Executive Branch to determine when discretionary humanitarian relief from persecution should be granted, and that is extremely unlikely.
Nolan Rappaport was detailed to the House Judiciary Committee as an Executive Branch Immigration Law Expert for three years. He subsequently served as an immigration counsel for the Subcommittee on Immigration, Border Security and Claims for four years. Prior to working on the Judiciary Committee, he wrote decisions for the Board of Immigration Appeals for 20 years. Follow him on Twitter @NolanR1 or at https://nolanrappaport.blogspot.com
- Trump to seek nearly 8 percent cut in education spending - Politico - February 10th, 2020
- STAAR Surgical to Report Fourth Quarter and Fiscal Year Results on February 26, 2020 - BioSpace - February 10th, 2020
- Where the Democratic Candidates Stand on Medicare for All - The Fiscal Times - February 10th, 2020
- The IMF reports on the macroeconomic situation of the Gambia for the year 2019 - Freedom Newspaper - February 10th, 2020
- Year In Review: School Board Pushed to Gain Traction on School Equity - Loudoun Now - January 5th, 2020
- New rep's anti-Trump rant has GOP seeing red - The Union Leader - January 5th, 2020
- The Puerto Rican Flag's Evolving Colors Say a Lot About the Island's Relationship With Its Colonial Rulers - Mother Jones - January 5th, 2020
- Niinist calls for mutual respect, end to lies and half-truths in public debate - Helsinki Times - January 5th, 2020
- As the White House and the world reject refugees, here's how to help - Norfolk Daily News - January 5th, 2020
- 'Insulting' number of attacks on NHS staff end up in court - HeraldScotland - January 5th, 2020
- The gathering storm in disability services | Opinion - pennlive.com - January 5th, 2020
- Sense of belonging and trust key to progress: Economist - Telegraph India - January 5th, 2020
- 2020 look ahead: Politics and protectionism to dominate Indian economy - Nikkei Asian Review - January 5th, 2020
- Administration outlines public safety initiatives | Letters to the Editor - The Guam Daily Post - January 5th, 2020
- U.P. reps want to use state-owned aircraft to fly back-and-forth - Marquette Mining Journal - January 5th, 2020
- 'All about the money': How women travelling to Canada to give birth could strain the health-care system - CBC.ca - January 5th, 2020
- aLL: Making body positive, plus size fashion the new normal - India Retailing - January 5th, 2020
- The Review - Business Recorder - January 5th, 2020
- Tax Burden: How Tax Burden Affects Economic Freedom - November 25th, 2019
- Democrats Must Heed The Wisdom Of JFK - FITSNews - November 25th, 2019
- Edited Transcript of PSTG earnings conference call or presentation 21-Nov-19 10:00pm GMT - Yahoo Finance - November 25th, 2019
- Spartz to seek second term - Current in Carmel - November 25th, 2019
- Angelica Ross Has Had a Phenomenal YearAnd Shes Using It to Open Doors to Others - Observer - November 25th, 2019
- The Trump Administration Gutted the Staff Overseeing $1 Billion in Aid to Iraq. A Watchdog Is Raising Red Flags. - ProPublica - November 25th, 2019
- All but one Scottish university fails to record suicide rates, The Ferret reveals - The National - November 25th, 2019
- On the Proposed Budget for Fiscal Year 2020: Letter to the Finance Minister - Freedom Newspaper - November 25th, 2019
- Removing the burden of SOEs on our people - ft.lk - November 25th, 2019
- Anti-abortion group says 45 now-elected Conservative MPs would vote to restrict abortion access heres why pro-choice experts are concerned - Toronto... - November 25th, 2019
- Cooper: Teacher town hall should talk future, not rehash the past - Chattanooga Times Free Press - November 13th, 2019
- Factbox: Key Points of Spanish Pact for Leftist Government - The New York Times - November 13th, 2019
- Natural gas drilling credits eat up royalty revenue from extraction industry: report - Vancouver Sun - November 13th, 2019
- Letter to the Editor: An Appraisal of Macri - Americas Quarterly - November 13th, 2019
- The U.S. held over 69,000 migrant children in government custody in 2019 - Mashable - November 13th, 2019
- Greg Grandin and the End of the Myth (Review) - NACLA - November 13th, 2019
- Lawmakers huddle to plot next steps on the budget - Politico - November 13th, 2019
- UW pushes for bill to fund project that finds and identifies missing soldiers - The Badger Herald - November 13th, 2019
- Betsy DeVos Might Outlast Them All - HuffPost - November 13th, 2019
- Catholics arrested with other faith groups protesting low cap for refugees - National Catholic Reporter - October 16th, 2019
- Keeping Sudan's Transition on Track - Sudan - ReliefWeb - October 16th, 2019
- Tax policy expert: Closing the tax gap can drive political change - EURACTIV - October 16th, 2019
- Fishing for equity in a regressive tax system - Real Change News - October 16th, 2019
- Andy Puzder: Here are the 7 most ridiculous economic proposals from the Dem debate - Fox Business - October 16th, 2019
- Kansas foster care instability led to surge in runaways, left children vulnerable to sex traffickers - The Ottawa Herald - October 16th, 2019
- What Unites the Right? - National Review - October 16th, 2019
- Andrew Yangs America Should Be Built On The Blockchain - Forbes - October 16th, 2019
- Kramberger: West Islanders have voting options on the fringe - Montreal Gazette - October 16th, 2019
- History is in the past: candidate | News - The Daily Courier - October 16th, 2019
- More than 1,000 Palestinians in Gaza have bone infections after being shot by Israeli forces - Mondoweiss - October 16th, 2019
- EDITORIAL COMMENT: Economy will rebound, lets be patient - Chronicle - October 16th, 2019
- Singapore Economy: Population, GDP, Inflation, Business ... - May 3rd, 2019
- What is meant by "fiscal freedom"? | eNotes - April 16th, 2019
- Fiscal year - Wikipedia - February 24th, 2019
- United Kingdom Economy: Population, GDP, Inflation ... - February 24th, 2019
- Freedom in the 50 States 2017-2018: California Fiscal ... - November 2nd, 2018
- Freedom in the 50 States 2017-2018: Indiana Fiscal Freedom ... - October 12th, 2018
- Freedom in the 50 States 2015-2016 | Overall Freedom ... - August 20th, 2018
- Fiscal Freedom - The Heritage Foundation - August 9th, 2018
- Freedom in the 50 States 2015-2016 | Fiscal Freedom | Cato ... - March 10th, 2018
- Fiscal Freedom - heritage.org - March 3rd, 2018
- Index of Economic Freedom - heritage.org - February 28th, 2018
- Freedom in the 50 States 2015-2016 | Pennsylvania Fiscal ... - February 6th, 2018
- September Will Be a Mess in Congress; Budget, Spending and Debt Fights Ahead - Indian Country Today Media Network - August 25th, 2017
- Austin Petersen: Why I became a Republican - Washington Examiner - August 25th, 2017
- Hood: Focus on long-term growth - Henderson Daily Dispatch - August 25th, 2017
- Focus on long-term growth - The Mountaineer (subscription) - August 24th, 2017
- Report: Brockton lawmaker is 'big winner' from legislative pay raise vote - Enterprise News - August 24th, 2017
- Watchdogs Raise Concerns Over Budget 'Earmarks' | 90.5 WESA - 90.5 WESA - August 24th, 2017
- City Hall staffers see $2.8M in raises through fiscal year 2017 - NY ... - New York Daily News - August 6th, 2017
- GOP leaders enlist Pence, Mulvaney to help with budget woes - Politico - July 14th, 2017
- Freedom Caucus Fires First Volley in New Debt Ceiling Battle | The ... - The Fiscal Times - July 14th, 2017
- The Health Care Security And Freedom Act Of 2017 - Investor's Business Daily - July 14th, 2017
- Trump's looming steel war, explained - The Week Magazine - July 14th, 2017
- US warship sails close to South China Sea island occupied by Beijing - Daily Sabah - July 3rd, 2017
- Commentary: Trump's cuts to education a threat to freedom ... - The Daily Herald - July 3rd, 2017
- GOP Senators join in call to nix August recess to work on looming issues - Fox News - July 3rd, 2017
- Independence Day and Fiscal Responsibility - Summit NJ News ... - TAPinto.net - July 2nd, 2017
- Moderate House Republicans warn of trouble for tax reform - CNBC - July 2nd, 2017
- Fiscal Freedom | Prometheism.net - Part 31 - June 30th, 2017
- Fiscal Freedom | Prometheism.net - Part 30 - June 30th, 2017
- GST will be India's 'economic freedom': Anil Ambani - Economic Times - June 30th, 2017