On 27 April 2017, the Court of Justice of the European Union issued a judgement upon request of the Tribunal de Grande Instance of Perpignan (France) for a preliminary ruling under Article 267 TFEU, made by decision of 5 August 2015.
The request concerned the interpretation of Directive (EC) 2002/46 on the approximation of laws of the Member States relating to food supplements and Articles 28 and 30 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) on the free movement of goods.
The question arose in the context of a criminal proceeding brought against Noria Distribution SARL (Noria Distribution) for putting on sale or sold food supplements not authorised in France because they exceeded the maximum daily doses of vitamins and minerals which may be used for the manufacture of such food supplements, as set forth in the inter-ministerial order of 9 May 2006 on nutrients (Order).
Background of the case
Noria Distribution, a French company that markets food supplements in the European Union, is prosecuted in France for having sold food supplements containing vitamins and minerals in quantities exceeding the maximum daily doses provided in the Order. The Company does not substantially contest the violation of French Law, but it claims that the Order on which the criminal proceeding is based is not compatible with the European Law.
According to Article 5 of Decree No 2006/352 transposing Directive (EC) 2002/46 under French Law ("Decree"), vitamins and minerals can be used in the manufacture of food supplements only under the conditions set forth in an implementing inter-ministerial Order. The Order provides a positive list of vitamins and minerals that can be used in the manufacture of food supplements and establishes the maximum daily doses that must not be exceeded in the context of that use. It follows that food supplements with content of nutrients exceeding the limit set forth in the Decree, cannot be legally placed in the French market even though they are legally sold in other European Member States. Although the Decree provides a simplified "mutual recognition" procedure, this shall not apply to food supplements containing vitamins and minerals.
Question referred to the Court
The Tribunal de Grande Instance of Perpignan, unsure on the conformity of national legislation with Directive (EC) 2002/46, decided to stay the proceeding and refer to the Court a request for preliminary ruling. In particular, the referring Court inquires:
Findings of the Court
As to the first question, the Court of Justice of the European Union ("CJEU") observes that until the adoption by the European Commission of an act setting forth the maximum amount of vitamins and minerals to be used in foodstuffs, Member States remain competent to adopt the legislation concerning these amounts. However, in the exercise of that competence, they shall comply with the rules concerning the free movement of goods, as well as with principles laid down in Article 5(1) and (2) of Directive (EU) 2002/46, including the requirement for a risk assessment based on generally accepted scientific data.
According to the CJEU, the French Decree constitutes a measure having an effect equivalent to a quantitative restriction, since it prohibits the marketing of food supplements exceeding the maximum limits of nutrients even if they are lawfully manufactured or marketed in another Member State. According to the CJEU's case law, measures having equivalent effect to a quantitative restriction are justified when two requirements are fulfilled. First, national rules provide a procedure enabling economic operators to obtain the authorisation to market food supplements non-compliant with these limits and the procedure is: easily accessible; can be completed within a reasonable time; and, in case of refusal, the decision can be challenged before the courts. Secondly, the application to obtain the authorisation to market those food supplements may be refused by the competent national authorities only if those supplements pose a genuine risk to public health.
Since the French legislation forbids the marketing of food supplements whose content in nutrients exceeds the upper limits set by the legislation without providing a procedure of mutual recognition, the restriction does not seem justified under the European Law.
With reference to the second question, concerning the method used to set maximum amounts of vitamins, the CJEU affirms that it shall be based on a scientific risk assessment based on generally accepted scientific data and it must be carried out on a case-by-case basis. It follows that a method which consists of setting those amounts without taking into account all of these elements, is not compatible with rules on free movement of goods.
Finally, addressing the third question, the CJEU points out that by requiring that the assessment is based on generally accepted scientific data, Article 5(1) of Directive (EC) 2002/46 intends that the assessment shall be based on reliable scientific data, regardless of whether they are national or international. It follows that if recent and reliable international scientific data are available on the date on which the scientific assessment of risks is carried out, that assessment cannot be made without having regard to those data.
Comment
In the case at issue, the Court of Justice provides a new ruling on boundaries of national legislation which provides measures having an effect equivalent to a quantitative restriction to free circulation of goods. According to the Court, these measures are not generally forbidden provided that they are based substantively on a full risk assessment based on up-to-date science and, procedurally, on a system that allows a Member State to verify whether a genuine risk to public health actually exists.
Addressing the first question, the Court confirms the findings of the Solgar decision (C-233/10), where it stated that maximum amounts of vitamins and minerals shall be based on generally accepted scientific data and on risk assessment, as generally required by Regulation (EC) 178/2002 for all measures concerning food safety.
Dealing with the procedural requirement, the Court clarifies the meaning of "mutual recognition procedure", that it shall not be intended as a procedure according to which Member States automatically recognize and authorize the import of any food supplements, but as a procedure that allows Member States to verify whether a genuine risk to public health exists. In the light of this, Member States are required to provide a procedure for repeating the assessment when importers are able to present new scientific evidence that could lead to a reconsideration of the original restriction.
This decision confirms that the lack of harmonization in sensitive matters such as food supplements still leads to the creation of barriers to free circulation of goods even though Regulation 764/2008/EC ("Mutual Recognition Regulation") has clarified the procedure which national authorities shall follow before they can restrict goods which are lawfully marketed in other Member States. This has been clearly pointed out by the EU Commission itself in the document "Upgrading the Single Market: more opportunities for people and business" where the Commission has highlighted that "National regulations and practices continue to create barriers ()While these problems occur in many industrial sectors, they are particularly present in the fields of construction, foodstuffs, food supplements and fertilisers. This translates into lost business opportunities, less competition and higher prices for consumers".
Even though the referring Court has not yet provided a decision on the case at issue, the ruling of the CJEU has led the Italian Ministry of Health to revise the maximum levels of vitamins (Vitamin D, Vitamin B12 and Vitamin K) allowed in food supplements, bringing legal levels in line with the European Food Safety Authority opinions and international safety data.
Visit link:
- Dietary Supplements - Food and Drug Administration - December 8th, 2016 [December 8th, 2016]
- Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition - December 8th, 2016 [December 8th, 2016]
- Easy Cooked Dog Food Recipe - Homemade Dog Food - December 30th, 2016 [December 30th, 2016]
- Supplements - iHerb.com - January 19th, 2017 [January 19th, 2017]
- Herbal supplements' illegal ingredients pose health risk, experts warn - The Guardian - February 7th, 2017 [February 7th, 2017]
- More People Are Getting Suspicious About Their Supplementsand for Good Reason - NewBeauty Magazine (blog) - February 7th, 2017 [February 7th, 2017]
- Taiwan fungus provides anti-skin cancer supplement potential, researchers report - NutraIngredients.com - February 7th, 2017 [February 7th, 2017]
- Vitamin What? This Food-Based Supplement Line Might Be the Nutritional Antidote You're Looking For - MarieClaire.com - February 7th, 2017 [February 7th, 2017]
- Despite AAP warning, health food stores endorsed sports supplements for teens - Healio - February 7th, 2017 [February 7th, 2017]
- Jellyfish Memory Supplement Prevagen Is a Hoax, FTC Says - NBCNews.com - February 7th, 2017 [February 7th, 2017]
- Experts reveal hidden dangers behind supplements - Science Daily - February 7th, 2017 [February 7th, 2017]
- Top dentist claims sugary foods and supplements bad for nursing home patients' teeth - Irish Mirror - February 7th, 2017 [February 7th, 2017]
- A Supplement Company Sued Over Research It Didn't Like And Lost - Consumerist - February 11th, 2017 [February 11th, 2017]
- Borderline products: Marketing food supplements in the UK following the glucosamine case - JD Supra (press release) - February 11th, 2017 [February 11th, 2017]
- Consumers at risk from drug ingredients in herbal food supplements - The Pharmaceutical Journal - February 11th, 2017 [February 11th, 2017]
- Lawmakers propose cutting state food benefit program - New Mexico Political Report - February 13th, 2017 [February 13th, 2017]
- Dietary supplement could improve heart health - Medical Xpress - February 14th, 2017 [February 14th, 2017]
- Lafayette business accused of selling misbranded dietary ... - The Daily Advertiser - February 17th, 2017 [February 17th, 2017]
- Inside The Ultimate Fighter: Talent, check. Alcohol, check. Food ...? - Bloody Elbow - February 22nd, 2017 [February 22nd, 2017]
- ISU student-founded company offers unique nutritional supplements - Iowa State Daily - February 22nd, 2017 [February 22nd, 2017]
- Artefact - bespoke food supplements created by doctors and ... - PR Web (press release) - February 24th, 2017 [February 24th, 2017]
- Vitamins have unique job within the body - The Oshkosh Northwestern - February 24th, 2017 [February 24th, 2017]
- Safely Navigating the Supplement World - USA Hockey - February 24th, 2017 [February 24th, 2017]
- Ora Organic on 'Shark Tank': A Look Inside the Plant-Based Supplements - Heavy.com - February 25th, 2017 [February 25th, 2017]
- Masquelier's Grape Seed Extract as a Supplement for Vascular Health - Medical News Bulletin - February 25th, 2017 [February 25th, 2017]
- Gut bacteria determines the beneficial impacts of soy food on heart health - Pittsburgh Post-Gazette - February 28th, 2017 [February 28th, 2017]
- Cranberry Supplements: Not Bitter, Better - WholeFoods Magazine - February 28th, 2017 [February 28th, 2017]
- Stop Taking These 10 Vitamins and Supplements and Eat These Foods Instead - The Daily Meal - February 28th, 2017 [February 28th, 2017]
- What your family needs to know about IV vitamins - Deseret News - March 1st, 2017 [March 1st, 2017]
- Supplement Pitfalls Revealed by Experts - Anti Aging News - March 1st, 2017 [March 1st, 2017]
- CRN and ACI Partner for Dietary Supplements Conference - WholeFoods Magazine - March 1st, 2017 [March 1st, 2017]
- Food supplements - Food Safety - European Commission - March 1st, 2017 [March 1st, 2017]
- Stop Taking These 10 Vitamins and Supplements and Eat These Foods Instead - Huffington Post - March 2nd, 2017 [March 2nd, 2017]
- 'Amphetamine-like substance' in supplements among 2016 food alerts - Irish Times - March 2nd, 2017 [March 2nd, 2017]
- Amazon's private label Elements expands for first time in years with invite-only vitamins and supplements - TechCrunch - March 3rd, 2017 [March 3rd, 2017]
- Dog show win for Rumor is a win for food supplement company - Channel3000.com - WISC-TV3 - March 3rd, 2017 [March 3rd, 2017]
- Dog show win is a win for food supplement company - WSAW - March 4th, 2017 [March 4th, 2017]
- Supplemental living - Star2.com - March 6th, 2017 [March 6th, 2017]
- Real or Synthetic: The Truth Behind Whole-Food Supplements - March 6th, 2017 [March 6th, 2017]
- Amazon Launches Amazon Elements Supplements | Whole Foods ... - WholeFoods Magazine - March 8th, 2017 [March 8th, 2017]
- Supplements and prescriptions: a risky combination - KOLO - March 8th, 2017 [March 8th, 2017]
- A&H recalls several dietary supplements - KLTV.com - Tyler ... - KLTV - March 9th, 2017 [March 9th, 2017]
- Insurer denying Pasco teen with life-threatening food allergy - WTSP.com - March 9th, 2017 [March 9th, 2017]
- Sports, doping and supplements: Where do authorities, clubs and leagues stand? - NutraIngredients.com - March 9th, 2017 [March 9th, 2017]
- Kale is coming for everything you eat and then you - MarketWatch - March 11th, 2017 [March 11th, 2017]
- Know your supplements unregistered brands flood markets - DAWN.com - March 12th, 2017 [March 12th, 2017]
- How a Sports Dietitian Recommends Dietary Supplements - Nutritional Outlook - April 8th, 2017 [April 8th, 2017]
- WWE News: Jinder Mahal talks about fast food, supplements and accusations of PED use - Sportskeeda - June 6th, 2017 [June 6th, 2017]
- Nutrigenetics, Weight Management, and Dietary Supplements - Nutritional Outlook - June 6th, 2017 [June 6th, 2017]
- FDA Budget Cuts and Increased User Fees Are Bad for America - Morning Consult - June 7th, 2017 [June 7th, 2017]
- All of those antioxidant supplements are a huge con - INSIDER - June 7th, 2017 [June 7th, 2017]
- Everything You Need to Know About Eating Activated Charcoal - Eater - June 7th, 2017 [June 7th, 2017]
- Botanical Supplements Market to Reach US$ 69 Bn by 2025 - Persistence Market Research - PR Newswire (press release) - June 8th, 2017 [June 8th, 2017]
- Placenta Pills: Growing trend among new moms - WTSP 10 News - June 8th, 2017 [June 8th, 2017]
- Probiotics Conferences | Europe | Asia | USA | Middle East ... - June 8th, 2017 [June 8th, 2017]
- 'I quit protein supplements for six weeks and put on muscle' - BBC News - June 13th, 2017 [June 13th, 2017]
- GUEST COLUMN: Should you take dietary supplements? - Wicked Local Easton - June 13th, 2017 [June 13th, 2017]
- UNPA launches PCQI training for dietary supplement companies - NutraIngredients-usa.com - June 14th, 2017 [June 14th, 2017]
- Vitamin Labels Are Wrong and Will Be for Years! - HuffPost - June 16th, 2017 [June 16th, 2017]
- Clarifying FDA and FTC Roles Could Strengthen Oversight and Enhance Consumer Awareness - Government Accountability Office - June 17th, 2017 [June 17th, 2017]
- Nutraceuticals could be about to become more expensive in India under GST drive - FoodNavigator-Asia.com - June 20th, 2017 [June 20th, 2017]
- Backpack meal supplements - Arkansas News - June 20th, 2017 [June 20th, 2017]
- Ghana news: Centre of Awareness clears air about food supplement ... - Graphic Online - June 20th, 2017 [June 20th, 2017]
- Backpack meal supplements - Newport Independent - June 20th, 2017 [June 20th, 2017]
- 'Normal' bowel movements vary from person to person - Reno Gazette Journal - June 20th, 2017 [June 20th, 2017]
- FDA urges caution about bodybuilding supplements - CT Post - June 20th, 2017 [June 20th, 2017]
- North America Dietary Supplements Market is expected to reach USD 68.22 billion by 2025 - PR Newswire (press release) - June 21st, 2017 [June 21st, 2017]
- Your vitamin D tests and supplements are probably a waste of money - Vox - June 21st, 2017 [June 21st, 2017]
- Alibaba Says Chinese Consumers Are Obsessed With Sneakers and Supplements - TheStreet.com - June 21st, 2017 [June 21st, 2017]
- North America Dietary Supplements Market 2014-2017 & 2025 - Market is Expected to Reach USD 68.22 Billion ... - PR Newswire (press release) - June 22nd, 2017 [June 22nd, 2017]
- Banned drugs in food supplement major challenge: FSSAI - The Statesman - June 22nd, 2017 [June 22nd, 2017]
- Scammers selling fake cures for Parkinson's and Alzheimer's are getting away with it - The Verge - June 22nd, 2017 [June 22nd, 2017]
- A Chinese vitamin MLM cult is replacing healthcare for poor Ugandans - Boing Boing - June 23rd, 2017 [June 23rd, 2017]
- Testosterone Wars - The Atlantic - June 23rd, 2017 [June 23rd, 2017]
- FSSAI committed to robust and unambiguous standards for food supplements - Catch News - June 23rd, 2017 [June 23rd, 2017]
- Clinical pharmacist Carrie Beth Smith discusses dietary supplements and their role in wellness - Southeast Missourian - June 26th, 2017 [June 26th, 2017]
- Protein supplements are considered food - Burlington Times News - June 26th, 2017 [June 26th, 2017]
- Supplements & Nutrition Packaging: Food & Pharma Demand for Advanced Packaging on the Rise - Edition Truth - June 26th, 2017 [June 26th, 2017]
- Methylsulfonylmethane (MSM) Market Is Expected To Reach Over US$ 10 Bn By 2023, Expanding At A CAGR Of 7 ... - Technorati - June 26th, 2017 [June 26th, 2017]
- Global Acerola Extract Market Size Is Expected To Reach Over US$ 15763.8 Mn By 2017 To 2025 - Technorati - June 26th, 2017 [June 26th, 2017]