Last week, I spoke at a webinar organised by ICJ Kenya to mark the 10th anniversary of the Constitution. Our task was to respond to the question: Does the Constitution answer the land question?
Drawing on my book to be published this week, I argued that we must look beyond the text of the Constitution and subsequent land laws.
At first sight, Kenya has indeed addressed the land question in her Constitution. In Chapter Five (Land and Environment), it sets out in detail the principles that should govern land and its administration. That chapter is a signal achievement, giving form to what citizens told the Constitution of Kenya Review Commission they wanted: Equality of access to land as a critical productive resource, transparency in relation to acquisition and administration, and a system of land administration functions (such as registries) in close proximity to them.
But
All of this is to be admired in Chapter Five. How then to we explain why Kenyas land inequalities are greater now than they were at the inauguration of the Constitution, with the best land in the hands of a few powerful individuals?
The concentration of land in the hands of the wealthy and powerful has had enormous consequences for ordinary citizens. The forced taking of land has transferred capital to a privileged few, expanding the number of citizens with no resources for subsistence or petty commodity production. Forced to serve as a reservoir of cheap labour, their livelihoods are often dependent on precarious work in cities where their existence is dominated by insecurity.
The attainment of their social and economic rights which shaped the progressive 2010 Constitution is a distant hope. Poor accommodation, domestic and police violence, hunger and a lack of healthcare and access to water are the everyday reality.
Only a wider understanding of the land question beyond the text of the Constitution and other laws will enable us to understand why this so. Prof Yash Ghai has written that to understand the dynamics and functions of constitutionalism, we must pay attention to its social and economic bases. Students, teachers and scholars must go beyond the formal boundaries of the law.
HISTORY
One starting point is to deepen our knowledge of the historical meaning of land reform. In the late colonial period, land reform was a defensive strategy. It was only ever introduced to deal with Kenyans increasingly radical demands over land and their growing challenges to the racial priority given to white settlers and the consequent landlessness of so many.
This perspective allows us to see continuities: in the present day, land reform has also only been on the table as a defensive strategy. The idea is to talk the talk, but only to mask that fact that no substantive concession or change will be allowed to happen that threatens the land status quo.
The class that has benefited from land accumulation can hardly be entrusted with guardianship of a Constitution which, in the form of Chapter Five, seeks to reform a historic system of unequal land relations.
Prof Issa Shivji in his book Accumulation in an African Periphery has explored how at independence a system of racial privilege was replaced with that of ethnic privilege. Prof Atieno-Odhiambo described this as "the tyranny of property" that pitted the haves against the have nots. We cannot understand Kenyan history and specifically its class formation without paying close attention to the history of land.
GOING BEYOND LAW
So, have we put too much faith in the Constitution and in law reform? What are the limits of law in challenging inequalities in land so deeply rooted in colonialism and now benefiting its successor regimes?
For lawyers who wish to be clear-sighted and self-critical, it is important to ask if, by putting so much hope in the law, we have obscured other choices. How land is distributed is the result of political and historical choices. It is not inevitable. But we know from reading Prof Ghai and Prof Patrick McAuslans landmark Public Law and Political Change in Kenya that law was used to achieve land dispossession in the colonial era. The best example was how when the Maasai challenged the legal basis of their removal to facilitate the white reservation of land the courts ruled that the Maasai had sufficient sovereignty to sign away their land in the agreements they had signed in 1904 and in 1911 - a happy outcome for the colonial regime.
Looking back over the past decade, we must consider whether we have allowed our liberal legalism to suppress wider demands for fairer land distribution. Strong institutions alone cannot replace the critical debates we need to have about redistribution, restitution and a reckoning with dispossession.
What intellectual resources are available to us with which to approach this vexed question? How might we shift the current dominant grammar on land - the grammar of law? Have we been too reliant on technical legal solutions to bring about piecemeal change? As law teachers and writers, we must move beyond legal dogma and ask these questions.
WAYS OF SEEING LAND
To do this requires us to find new grammars. Amongst the harms of colonialism was the philosophical assault it involved. Ways of seeing land and our relationship to it were fundamentally changed by the colonial encounter.
Holding land communally, and treating it as an intergenerational asset which carries with it great responsibilities and duties, was viewed as backward. Rather than emphasising a relationship with land (which the South African, Antje Krog, has described as peoples recognition that they are land-owned), importance has been attached to owning land. Land grabbing on a vast scale has been one result.
In a twisted logic, failing to acquire land is presented as personal failure, an outlook summed up in President Jomo Kenyattas question to Bildad Kaggia, "What have you done for yourself? Acquiring land marks you out as special, even when that acquisition has taken place by illegal and irregular means. This is the ethos of the ruling class who believe that by their individual effort they have accumulated wealth and power and can bequeath it accordingly.
This notion is of course built on a deeply gendered and patriarchal model of land and family: A man with a tight grip on his land is expected to have a similarly tight grip on his wife and family. Other ways of seeing land are castigated as backward and wasteful.
The heterosexual family ensures that wealth can be transmitted generationally. A decade-long resistance to the Constitutions provisions on gender representation must be understood in this light. The patriarch and his reproductive wife guard their individual wealth, believing it to be acquired by their unique hard work, and keeping alert to other, more dangerous ways of wishing to organise society. Insurgent demands for fairness - in the organisation of the family (or Parliament) or in access to land - are keenly felt as threats.
This analysis suggests that to assess the past 10 years of the Constitution, we need to think broadly and conceptually. Land wrongs are not episodic. We need to pay attention to structures such as class and the family. We need to see the history of land grabbing not as deviant but as fundamental to the formation of todays state.
For lawyers, this means taking our lead from the University of Dar es Salaam in the 1960 and 1970s and reading and teaching history, economics, political science, and literature alongside law. We must move beyond the formal boundaries of law and we must understand Kenyas reactionary history in both its public and private manifestations. And we must seek to understand the daily struggles of the people in relation to the land and to build out of them a constitutionalism for the people.
Ambreena Manji is Professor of Land Law and Development at Cardiff University, Wales. She has published widely on land law reform and is the author of The Struggle for Land and Justice in Kenya (James Currey: 2020).
See the rest here:
Look beyond law for answers to the land question - The Star, Kenya
- Haringey: Further tales of Labour Party discontent on the 'Corbyn... - onlondon.co.uk - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- West Bengal- The Israel for Hindu Bengalis? Its time to redeem the pledge on the day Bengal was partitioned - OpIndia - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Rocked to the core: Mining giants confront an ancient, incalculable risk - Sydney Morning Herald - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Flag flap: Retired UA prof says the American flag on Flattop is abuse of power by Dunleavy Administration - Must Read Alaska - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Perhaps We Don't Understand?- The End of the West - Visegrad Insight - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Beijings violent rise must be checked - The New Indian Express - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- When riot cops came to Bowral - Red Flag - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- From Prison to the Halls of Power: A Politician's Son Lobbies to Let People on Parole Vote - Lost Coast Outpost - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- The remarkable life and legacy of indigenous leader Berta Cceras - Salon - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Move to annex parts of West Bank could come as early as July 1 - jewishpresstampa - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- President says he will renew effort to end DACA protections - - KUSI - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Delhis urban planners must stop ignoring the shoddy infrastructure in its 135 urban villages - Scroll.in - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Japan to revise security strategy with halt to Aegis Ashore system : The Asahi Shimbun - Asahi Shimbun - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- How my colonial smugness evaporated with one explosive revelation - Stuff.co.nz - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- With the World Focused on the Pandemic, Israel Prepares to Annex Large Swaths of the West Bank - The Intercept - First Look Media - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Trump is about to land his 200th federal judge. The impact will last 'generations.' - NBC News - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Tribune Editorial: Make DACA the law of the land - Salt Lake Tribune - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Visualizing the True Size of Land Masses from Largest to Smallest - Visual Capitalist - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Harris's path on police reform littered with land mines | TheHill - The Hill - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Elon Musk denies threesome with Amber Heard and Cara Delevingne - Page Six - June 24th, 2020 [June 24th, 2020]
- Column: Tesla's reluctant commitment to cobalt a warning to others - Andy Home - Reuters - June 24th, 2020 [June 24th, 2020]
- Why Intelligent Minds Like Elon Musk and Steve Jobs Embrace the Rule of Awkward Silence - Inc. - June 24th, 2020 [June 24th, 2020]
- Elon Musk Bitcoin vanity addresses used to scam users out of $2 million - ZDNet - June 24th, 2020 [June 24th, 2020]
- Artist turns Elon Musks viral tweets into illustrations that are now part of a colouring book - The Indian Express - June 24th, 2020 [June 24th, 2020]
- Elon Musk Is Attempting to Revolutionize HVAC Systems - ACHR NEWS - June 24th, 2020 [June 24th, 2020]
- How to land a job at Elon Musk's SpaceX, according to the rocket company's software team - CNBC - June 24th, 2020 [June 24th, 2020]
- Leaked Elon Musk Email, Plus Tesla Firmware 2020.24.6 and Texas Gigafactory Hearing - TheStreet - June 24th, 2020 [June 24th, 2020]
- Photos: Why The Gypsum Hills Are The 'Best Kept Secret' In Kansas - KMUW - July 10th, 2020 [July 10th, 2020]
- A Powerful Chief And Unexpected Splits: 6 Takeaways From The Supreme Court Term - HPPR - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- One key solution to the world's climate woes? Canada's natural landscapes - The Narwhal - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- 245 homes could be built on greenbelt land in the 'last village in Gloucester' - Gloucestershire Live - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- From the Archives, 1995: Flagging reconciliation - The Age - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- Navigating the Self: African Student Experiences in U.S. Higher Education - The Yale Politic - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- What 9 GOP Campaign Consultants Really Think About Republicans Chances in November - Rolling Stone - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- COMMENTARY: I propose changing the name of Jackson County to Jackson County - The Cherokee One Feather - Cherokee One Feather - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- The end is now in sight for the fight to preserve west basin - The Canberra Times - July 13th, 2020 [July 13th, 2020]
- Beyond the Crossroads - bellacaledonia.org.uk - July 13th, 2020 [July 13th, 2020]
- Friction between liberal ideology and tribal sovereignty comes to the fore - Washington Examiner - July 13th, 2020 [July 13th, 2020]
- The General Election of 2020 - ft.lk - July 14th, 2020 [July 14th, 2020]
- WILLY MUTUNGA - Saba Saba at 30: The Struggle for Progressive Alternative Political Leadership in Kenya Continues - The Elephant - July 14th, 2020 [July 14th, 2020]
- Four traveller groups arrive in the Black Country - expressandstar.com - July 14th, 2020 [July 14th, 2020]
- America may vote Trump out, but will it ever lose his legacy? - Shout Out UK - July 14th, 2020 [July 14th, 2020]
- An international student's perspective on race relations on campus - University of Dallas University News - July 14th, 2020 [July 14th, 2020]
- TALKING POINT TUESDAY: Party representatives give their views on homelessness in the city - In Your Area - July 14th, 2020 [July 14th, 2020]
- Convoys mark 30th anniversary of Oka crisis as land dispute... - Todayville.com - July 14th, 2020 [July 14th, 2020]
- The fact that Peter Beinart 'no longer believes in a Jewish State' tells us a lot - Middle East Monitor - July 14th, 2020 [July 14th, 2020]
- Controversial decision to sell off land for 110 homes at Lakeside to be reconsidered by committee - Burnham and Highbridge Weekly News - July 14th, 2020 [July 14th, 2020]
- Supreme Court says eastern half of Oklahoma is Native American land - CNBC - July 14th, 2020 [July 14th, 2020]
- Ontario premier won't say if province will cover $1.35B deficit faced by Toronto - CTV News - July 18th, 2020 [July 18th, 2020]
- Being a nation and the bogey of self-determination - The Tribune India - July 18th, 2020 [July 18th, 2020]
- Mompremier happy to land with Sun - News from southeastern Connecticut - theday.com - July 18th, 2020 [July 18th, 2020]
- Book World: How elites distorted the meaning of populism - The Advocate - July 18th, 2020 [July 18th, 2020]
- Eriksmoen: North Dakota mother and daughter represented people they cared about in 'Wizard of Oz' and the real-life Emerald City - Grand Forks Herald - July 18th, 2020 [July 18th, 2020]
- Supreme Court ruling expanded tribal land. What does that mean for Arizona? - AZCentral - July 18th, 2020 [July 18th, 2020]
- Column: Should Slave Owner Jefferson Be a Hero? - Southern Pines Pilot - July 18th, 2020 [July 18th, 2020]
- Murder hornets, unexpected court rulings and nasty politics: 2020 has it all - Bangor Daily News - July 19th, 2020 [July 19th, 2020]
- Liberal Zionism begins to make the journey towards a one-state solution - Middle East Eye - July 19th, 2020 [July 19th, 2020]
- Renaming the Army Bases - The New York Times - July 19th, 2020 [July 19th, 2020]
- Trump opponents' worst traits are Trump's fault | News, Sports, Jobs - Minot Daily News - July 21st, 2020 [July 21st, 2020]
- Here's how much men and women earn at every age - CNBC - July 21st, 2020 [July 21st, 2020]
- From fighting Covid-19 to locusts, drones showcase their potential and wide user-applications - DNA India - July 21st, 2020 [July 21st, 2020]
- Anglin: History illuminated as the sun sets on Ranger - San Antonio Express-News - July 21st, 2020 [July 21st, 2020]
- Art for trying times: reading Richard Ford on a world undone by calamity - The Conversation AU - July 21st, 2020 [July 21st, 2020]
- Kelly Hawes column: Supreme Court holds government to its word - The Herald Bulletin - July 21st, 2020 [July 21st, 2020]
- The Care of our COMMON HOME fires up Priests of Goa - Oherald - July 21st, 2020 [July 21st, 2020]
- Mandryk: Pandemic concerns should have trumped Buffalo grievances - The Province - July 21st, 2020 [July 21st, 2020]
- If Democrats Win, They Must Show Israel That Unilateral Annexation Has Consequences - Foreign Policy - July 21st, 2020 [July 21st, 2020]
- Controversial Lakeside land decision to be reconsidered at virtual meeting this month - Burnham and Highbridge Weekly News - July 21st, 2020 [July 21st, 2020]
- Unable to land hits on Biden, Trump paints him as socialist Trojan horse - NBC News - July 21st, 2020 [July 21st, 2020]
- Do we need to stop eating meat? - Telegraph.co.uk - July 27th, 2020 [July 27th, 2020]
- The Forgotten History of the Jewish, Anti-Zionist Left - Jacobin magazine - July 27th, 2020 [July 27th, 2020]
- Israeli Settlements in the West Bank: Why Palestine is More Vulnerable Than Ever - International Policy Digest - July 27th, 2020 [July 27th, 2020]
- Whose natural resources are they anyway? - Deccan Herald - July 27th, 2020 [July 27th, 2020]
- 'Vande Mataram': My Shock Recognition About Claims to the Matrubhoomi - The Wire - July 27th, 2020 [July 27th, 2020]
- Great American Outdoors Act heads to Trump as Cory Gardner leans on measure in reelection bid - The Colorado Sun - July 27th, 2020 [July 27th, 2020]
- Opposition calls for Sixfields deal to be open to scrutiny but council denies agreement is reached with Cobblers - Northampton Chronicle and Echo - July 29th, 2020 [July 29th, 2020]
- In the News: Wednesday, July 29 - capitalcurrent.ca - July 29th, 2020 [July 29th, 2020]
- Militias' warning of excessive federal power comes true but where are they? - Thehour.com - July 29th, 2020 [July 29th, 2020]
- Supreme Court ruling a reminder of how badly Native Americans have been treated | Quigley - nj.com - July 29th, 2020 [July 29th, 2020]
- Ethics commissioner expands probe of Morneau on eve of PM's WE testimony - The Outlook - July 30th, 2020 [July 30th, 2020]