Of all the mental shortcuts embedded in human languages which impede understanding of mindless processes (such as natural selection), few are more obnoxious than because. From this comes a tendency to anthropomorphise, and read all outcomes in nature as if they were ordained by something approximating an intention. Religion has to be an adaptation, because the religious (currently) outbreed the irreligious. The second clause in that sentence is (currently) correct, but the because makes it sound as though the current religious selection advantage represents some design feature with the desired (by what?) end of promoting reproductive fitness (adaptation). And fitness is where the matter rests. Contrast with the following sentence:
Under current conditions in which the religious outbreed the irreligious, religion is adaptive. This statement is of course tautologous, since to say that a trait or behaviour is adaptive means merely that under condition X it gives one a reproductive edge. The term adaptation, though, is often applied to traits or behaviours which are selectively neutral or even counter-adaptive in particular environments. Genes which contribute to an overzealous appetite may be fitness-neutral to a subsistence farmer but become obesogenic in the modern world of easily available food. The genes carrier still exercises this adaptation, but it is no longer adaptive, reproductively useful, except in an environment full of fat-fetishists.
Human society has changed so dramatically in the last two centuries that it would be hasty to say the least to assume that everything with a current selective disadvantage is an illness (due to pathogens, mutational load, or whatever). Just as equally, one cannot assume that something with a current advantage exists having evolved by resolving an adaptive problem. Religion was ubiquitous across cultures before the 20th century, yet now the religious fraction represent an ever tinier percentage of the population in many countries, and it remains to be seen just how tiny the genetic hard core of religiosity will get before the trend is reversed. If the presence of religion were explicable in terms of fitness benefit, why are the genes not already more widespread? This alone should be enough to tell you that genes (and thus, adaptation) per se had little to do with religions evolution.
But apparently this is not obvious to some. Many people are inclined to view adaptations as intricate mechanisms, which by dint of their intricacy are delicate and susceptible to dysfunction, rather like the springs and levers of a pocket-watch. All analogies are imperfect, but this is a useless one. Some traits, and indeed behaviours, are more prone to changing by exogenous insults than others. For instance, a particularly naive person might imagine that in a pandemic of severe endometriosis, whereby female beauty and youth cease to be predictive as indicators of fertility, males would be disincentivised from their sexual attraction to these traits because the attraction would no longer perform its original functions. Needless to say, this would not happen. Male callogamy (attention to beauty) has proven so reliably fitness-enhancing over the eons, since even before the human species, that it is extraordinarily resilient to any incentive change: selection will always favour a deterministic developmental pathway for such consistently valuable traits. General intelligence is yet another example: the current dysgenic trend is a product of the last few generations and on the order of ~1 point per generation despite ramping up of mutational load globally (well see how long it can last), and almost no non-genetic factors seem capable of depressing its expression to any appreciable degree. Lead looked plausible at some point, but then you remember that Victorians liked to use mercury in their make-up, and yet the 19th century was the most intellectually productive in human history.
Viewed under this light, the religion as adaptation thesis looks all the more dubious. Evolutionary forces selection, mutation, drift, etc are just as capable of acting on general intelligence and other psychological traits as anything else, hence the well-documented evolved changes in the European peoples since around AD1000: declines in violence, and probably gains in intelligence, culminating ultimately in the zenith of the 19th century. Evolution can indeed happen fast, but not that fast. The bulk of these changes took place over a period of, at minimum, 20 generations, not 2-3, and our intelligence has more or less survived the last 2-3 generations intact. Religion has not. It has none of the hallmarks of an adaptation, but all the hallmarks of a complex socially learned behaviour, maintained by powerful norm-enforcers and epistemic authorities, which has lost currency in recent decades for a variety of reasons, the most commonsense explanation being that it no longer appeals to the educated because the answers it gives are inferior to those of other epistemic authorities, i.e. scientists.
The human capacity for cultural transmission through language makes a nonsense of the notion that anything which is not adaptive, even across all environments, should be impossible to sustain. The most obvious example in Christian cultures is the vow of celibacy, and there are numerous others such as taboos against eating highly nutrient-dense foods, which persist among the undernourished tribes of Papua New Guinea. So too with the European wars of religion, which resulted in millions of young men dying childless in their haste to protect a non-existent natural resource, i.e. Gods favour.
Group selection is another temptation when formulating theories about the origin of religion the idea that even a behaviour which reduces fitness at the individual level can persist if it provides some advantage at the level of the social group. It is a neat idea, but clearly unworkable in practice. Suppose some cohort of ones country likes spreading the word of God through warfare call this behaviour X. They can seize new territory in Gods name and provide new land for others in their group who are not quite so zealous, and this may look like a success to the people who reap those rewards, but at the end of the day: the behaviour is still going to diminish because everyone who engages in it is at a massively elevated risk of dying before reproduction. Evolution does not care about states or dominions.
It is understandable why post hoc stories about religion as adaptation are popular, even among well-informed people. Intelligence is not a good predictor of having sensible views where political matters are concerned, since politics is about group loyalty more than anything else. This is why the number of US Democrats who thought immigration was an important social issue declined precipitously in the 2010s when it became the issue of the right; what mattered was showing solidarity against rival political coalitions (i.e. the right) rather than the truth. Adaptive stories about religion seem to appeal an awful lot to European traditionalist-nationalists who are hoping to use Christianity as the conduit for some kind of renewed ethnocentrism to uplift the European spirit. The Chinese do not seem to need it, oddly enough. Nor even the Czechs, much closer to home. It did not work for Rome, and it sure as fuck wont for us.
Like Loading...
Continued here:
AltLeft.com "The Left of the AltRight"
- A Clockwork Greenshirt Introducing the Alt Left ... - February 6th, 2018 [February 6th, 2018]
- Jordan Towers 70news - March 7th, 2018 [March 7th, 2018]
- Robert Stark Talks to Ashley Messinger About ... - altleft.com - March 18th, 2018 [March 18th, 2018]
- KNOPPIX 8.1.0 - Linux Live System - March 19th, 2018 [March 19th, 2018]
- Protesters Try to Shut Down Jordan Peterson at Queen's ... - April 27th, 2018 [April 27th, 2018]
- KNOPPIX 8.0.0 - Linux Live System - May 25th, 2018 [May 25th, 2018]
- John McCain: Dying Without Dignity - committedconservative.com - June 10th, 2018 [June 10th, 2018]
- What is the Alt Left? - American Greatness - June 29th, 2018 [June 29th, 2018]
- event object JavaScript - Dottoro - July 28th, 2018 [July 28th, 2018]
- Virginia Election Predictions: Will Weather Rain on ... - August 24th, 2018 [August 24th, 2018]
- Alt-Left Melts Down Over "Unmasking Antifa" Act | Zero Hedge - December 19th, 2018 [December 19th, 2018]
- KNOPPIX 7.4.2 / ADRIANE 1.7 - Live CD / DVD - December 19th, 2018 [December 19th, 2018]
- Jacobs Email - IT - Teamwork at Jacobs University - January 4th, 2019 [January 4th, 2019]
- KNOPPIX 7.7.1 - Linux Live System - January 4th, 2019 [January 4th, 2019]
- KNOPPIX 8.1.0 - Linux Live System - knopper.net - March 5th, 2019 [March 5th, 2019]
- The Politically Incorrect Australian - April 22nd, 2019 [April 22nd, 2019]
- Lionel Nation - YouTube - April 22nd, 2019 [April 22nd, 2019]
- Andrew Yang Rejects Support From White Nationalists ... - May 1st, 2019 [May 1st, 2019]
- Automate the Boring Stuff with Python - June 3rd, 2019 [June 3rd, 2019]
- UI Events KeyboardEvent code Values - World Wide Web ... - June 3rd, 2019 [June 3rd, 2019]
- Dont like the facts? Just Schiff the narrative - Boston Herald - October 1st, 2019 [October 1st, 2019]
- Netflix vows crackdown on users who share logins with pals or family and could make you pay EXTRA - The Sun - October 24th, 2019 [October 24th, 2019]
- Everything Paradox Interactive Announced At PDXCON 2019 - Kotaku Australia - October 24th, 2019 [October 24th, 2019]
- The psychology and physiology of propaganda: A study of the radicalization of women - University of Virginia The Cavalier Daily - January 30th, 2020 [January 30th, 2020]
- One of the Vail Valley's fur-baby favorites, Dr. Julie Alt, is calling it a career - Vail Daily News - January 30th, 2020 [January 30th, 2020]
- Netflix FINALLY lets you turn those annoying autoplaying trailers off heres how - The Sun - February 12th, 2020 [February 12th, 2020]
- Netflix FORCED to remove nine movies after government objections including boozy Jesus party film - The Sun - February 12th, 2020 [February 12th, 2020]
- Netflix trialling 2.99 cheapest ever plan but it only works on smartphones or tablets - The Sun - February 12th, 2020 [February 12th, 2020]
- Netflix offers first-ever FREE movie that you dont need account to watch - The Sun - February 12th, 2020 [February 12th, 2020]
- The Death Throes of the Failed Sandernista Revolution - Real Context News - March 16th, 2020 [March 16th, 2020]
- Life under lockdown: Italy is being consumed by panic - Spectator.co.uk - March 16th, 2020 [March 16th, 2020]
- Netflix is testing cheap new mobile-only plan that costs just 2.40 a month - The Sun - March 16th, 2020 [March 16th, 2020]
- Howie Carr: Its time to wake up sleepy Joe Biden - Boston Herald - March 16th, 2020 [March 16th, 2020]
- Living in an Italy consumed by fear - The Spectator USA - March 27th, 2020 [March 27th, 2020]
- Hungarian Press Roundup: Weeklies on the State of Emergency - Hungary Today - March 27th, 2020 [March 27th, 2020]
- Essential Mac keyboard shortcuts and key combinations - Macworld UK - May 3rd, 2020 [May 3rd, 2020]
- AltLeft Shuts Down Toronto Comedy Show Over Words 'Free ... - May 3rd, 2020 [May 3rd, 2020]
- COVID-19 UPDATE: East Hampton Testing Site To Open May 15 - 27east.com - May 9th, 2020 [May 9th, 2020]
- Conservative Jews: Do you care about Israel? Then vote Trump out - Forward - June 21st, 2020 [June 21st, 2020]
- As shul reopens, can we make it more welcoming to Orthodox women? - Forward - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- End the Civil War Before It Starts: Vote Engel and Schleifer - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- The Rising Blood Tide of The Alt-Left & the Real Threat of Antifa - AmmoLand Shooting Sports News - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- The Shot Heard Roundand Round and Roundthe World - The Dispatch - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- Netflix launches shuffle button that plays a random show for viewers who dont know what to watch - The Sun - July 23rd, 2020 [July 23rd, 2020]
- Why the Alt-Left Is a Problem, Too | Vanity Fair - July 23rd, 2020 [July 23rd, 2020]
- What Is Alt-Left? Here's What You Really Need to Know - July 23rd, 2020 [July 23rd, 2020]
- What Is the 'Alt-Left'? For Starters, Not a Thing | WIRED - July 23rd, 2020 [July 23rd, 2020]
- Howie Carr: Alt-left media still cling to their Big (Russia) Lie - Boston Herald - July 28th, 2020 [July 28th, 2020]
- McCarthyite witch-hunt over alleged anti-Semitism explodes in British Labour Party - WSWS - August 3rd, 2020 [August 3rd, 2020]
- Antifa Berkeley: Why the 'Alt-Left' Is a Problem | Time - August 7th, 2020 [August 7th, 2020]
- Alt-Right, Alt-Left, Antifa: A Glossary of Extremist ... - August 7th, 2020 [August 7th, 2020]
- What is the "alt-left" Trump was talking about? - CBS News - August 7th, 2020 [August 7th, 2020]
- Is There an 'Alt-Left'? - Snopes.com - August 7th, 2020 [August 7th, 2020]
- Say Goodbye to IITs, IIMs Et Al? NEP 2020 Will Convert Indias Top Institutions Into JNU Copies - Swarajya - August 10th, 2020 [August 10th, 2020]
- Checking In With the Newsletter Economy - New York Magazine - September 2nd, 2020 [September 2nd, 2020]
- Resident Evil survival horror TV series is coming to Netflix and fans think its the next Stranger Things - The Sun - September 2nd, 2020 [September 2nd, 2020]
- With Republicans like these, who needs Ds? - The Highland County Press - September 2nd, 2020 [September 2nd, 2020]
- Here's Why You Should Never Use the Term "Alt-Left" - POPSUGAR - September 8th, 2020 [September 8th, 2020]
- [OPINION] Law and order president? The chaos and violence Trump wants you to be fearful and hateful of is happening now under his watch - Asian... - September 8th, 2020 [September 8th, 2020]
- Hungarian Press Roundup: No Compromise in Sight over Theatre and Film University - Hungary Today - September 8th, 2020 [September 8th, 2020]
- Slow Joe Biden is a few fries short of a Happy Meal: Howie Carr - Boston Herald - September 8th, 2020 [September 8th, 2020]
- Netflix launches its first TV channel that streams shows just like regular telly - The Sun - November 13th, 2020 [November 13th, 2020]
- Bellingcat's Eliot Higgins on messaging Alexei Navalny to say 'we know who tried to kill you' - iNews - February 4th, 2021 [February 4th, 2021]
- Hungarian Press Roundup: Two Opposing Views on the Culture War - Hungary Today - February 7th, 2021 [February 7th, 2021]
- Getting Started with Python PyAutoGUI - November 29th, 2021 [November 29th, 2021]
- Sample Macros - Jitbit - November 29th, 2021 [November 29th, 2021]
- Mario Draghis fall and the death of Italian left-wing populism - The Spectator - July 27th, 2022 [July 27th, 2022]
- I tracked down my Corbynite troll and now he's in prison - The Telegraph - July 27th, 2022 [July 27th, 2022]
- Helping Ukraine Not Provoking Russia But a Proper Response to Years of Global Russian Aggression - smallwarsjournal - July 27th, 2022 [July 27th, 2022]
- US Gov to Crack Down on "Bossware" That Spies On Employees' Computers - November 4th, 2022 [November 4th, 2022]
- Chinese Spaceplane Releases Mystery Object Into Orbit - November 4th, 2022 [November 4th, 2022]
- Hackers Just Took Down One of the World's Most Advanced Telescopes - November 4th, 2022 [November 4th, 2022]
- AOC Says Her Twitter Account Broke After She Made Fun of Elon Musk - November 4th, 2022 [November 4th, 2022]
- Huge Drone Swarm to Form Giant Advertisement Over NYC Skyline - November 4th, 2022 [November 4th, 2022]
- That "Research" About How Smartphones Are Causing Deformed Human Bodies Is SEO Spam, You Idiots - November 4th, 2022 [November 4th, 2022]
- Jeff Bezos' Housekeeper Says She Had to Climb Out the Window to Use the Bathroom - November 4th, 2022 [November 4th, 2022]
- Twitter Working on Plan to Charge Users to Watch Videos - November 4th, 2022 [November 4th, 2022]
- Scientists Use Actual Lunar Soil Sample to Create Rocket Fuel - November 4th, 2022 [November 4th, 2022]
- NASA Sets Launch Date for Mission to $10 Quintillion Asteroid - November 4th, 2022 [November 4th, 2022]
- Elon Musk Meeting With Advertisers, Begging Them Not to Leave Twitter - November 4th, 2022 [November 4th, 2022]