The Islands really isn't the type of place you should go on a first date. That's not to say that it isn't good, but the fact that the dining area is an attic-sized room with poor ventilation, less-than-ideal lighting, and variable service doesn't make it the best setting for a seamless meal. For those of us who don't live near Prospect Heights and can't take advantage of their take-out service, however, dining in is the only option for a chance to try the Jamaican fare.

I was able to wander in thanks to the recommendation of a friend, after stepping inside the first floor, which holds the kitchen and a small counter area, we were able to head upstairs into the dining room to snag the one remaining table. The space is tight, and we could clearly overhear our neighbors' conversations; again, it's a venue to visit solely for the food, and not for the ambiance nor service. There were extended periods of time that the lone server was gone for as she probably doubled up on tasks in the kitchen or on the phone. Thankfully, we were able to get our orders in after deciding on a side and an entree to share.

The Mac & Cheese is worth an order, a cube of pasta that's generously doused in creamy, well-seasoned melted cheese. Most importantly, there's a layer of crisp crust left on the top, the remnants of being properly baked in the oven to produce the much-needed textural contrast. One is enough to share, or make an appetizer of as we did, since the entrees are more than substantial.

The main dishes are served in two sizes, a small and a large, and a large is certainly large enough to consistute two meals. We ended up splitting a large order of the Jerk Chicken, which was a wise decision; the plate consists of three pieces of chicken, rice with peas, and a lightly dressed side salad. The star of the plate is clearly the chicken; braised to an unbelievably tenderness so that it pulls off the bone at the prodding of the pork and marinated in a mixture of various spices, honey, barbecue sauce, and the creeping heat of scotch bonnets, it's an addicting and delicious bite. You'll be tempted not to share, but given the sheer portion of the plate, it's an inevitable outcome.

Also of note is that The Islands accepts Cash Only, and has an additional $2 charge for dining in. Regardless, it's certainly worth a visit for those looking for authentic Jamaican cuisine; just be sure to bring your appetite.

Go here to see the original:

The Islands - Crown Heights - Brooklyn, NY - Yelp