Sam Williams Macaw Recovery Network in Costa Rica rewilds captivity-hatched fledgling scarlet and great green macaws. But introducing young birds into a complex forest world bereft of the cultural education normally provided by parents is slow and risky.
For 30 years or so scientists have referred to the diversity of life on Earth as biological diversity, or just biodiversity. They usually define biodiversity as operating at three levels: the diversity of genes within any particular species; the diversity of species in a given place; and the diversity of habitat types such as forests, coral reefs, and so on. But does that cover it? Not really. A fourth level has been almost entirely overlooked: cultural diversity.
Culture is knowledge and skills that flow socially from individual to individual and generation to generation. Its not in genes. Socially learned skills, traditions and dialects that answer the question of how we live here are crucial to helping many populations survive or recover. Crucially, culturally learned skills vary from place to place. In the human family many cultures, underappreciated, have been lost. Culture in the other-than-human world has been almost entirely missed.
We are just recognising that in many species, survival skills must be learned from elders who learned from their elders. Until now, culture has remained a largely hidden, unrecognised layer of wild lives. Yet for many species culture is both crucial and fragile. Long before a population declines to numbers low enough to seem threatened with extinction, their special cultural knowledge, earned and passed down over long generations, begins disappearing. Recovery of lost populations then becomes much more difficult than bringing in a few individuals and turning them loose.
Many young birds learn much by observing their parents, and parrots probably need to learn more than most. Survival of released individuals is severely undermined if there are no free-living elder role models. Trying to restore parrot populations by captive breeding is not as easy as training young or orphaned creatures to recognise what is food while theyre in the safety of a cage then simply opening the door. In a cage, Williams says, you cant train them to know where, when and how to find that food, or about trees with good nest sites. Parents would normally have done exactly that.
A generational break in cultural traditions hampered attempts to reintroduce thick-billed parrots to parts of south-west America, where theyd been wiped out. Conservation workers could not teach the captive-raised parrots to search for and find their traditional wild foods, skills they would have learned from parents.
Landscapes, always complex, are under accelerated change. Culture enables adaptation far faster than genes alone can navigate hairpin turns in time. In some places, pigeons and sparrows have learned to use motion-sensors to get inside enclosed shopping malls and forage for crumbs. Crows have in some locales learned to drop nuts on the road for cars to crack. In at least one area they do this at intersections, so they can safely walk out and collect their cracked prizes when the light turns red and the cars stop. Theyve developed answers to the new question: How can we survive here, in this never-before world?
Because the answers are local, and learned from elders, wild cultures can be lost faster than genetic diversity. When populations plummet, traditions that helped animals survive and adapt to a place begin to vanish.
In a scientific article on the vocabulary of larks living in north Africa and Spain titled, Erosion of animal cultures in fragmented landscapes, researchers reported that as human development shrinks habitats into patches, isolation is associated with impoverishment. They write: Song repertoires pass through a cultural bottleneck and significantly decline in variety.
Unfortunately, isolated larks are not an isolated case. Researchers studying South Americas orange-billed sparrow found that sparrow song complexity the number of syllables per song and song length deteriorated as humans continued whittling their forests into fragments. When a scientist replayed 24-year-old recordings of singing male white-crowned sparrows at the same location shed recorded them, they elicited half the responses they had when first recorded. The birds responses show that changes in the dialect lead to changes in listener preference, a bit analogous to pop music. And as with humans, preferences can affect whether a particular bird will be accepted as a mate. White-crowned sparrows singing a local dialect become fathers of more offspring than do singers of unfamiliar dialects, indicating females prefer a familiar tune.
Im not just talking about a few songs. Survival of numerous species depends on cultural adaptation. How many? Were just beginning to ask such questions. But the preliminary answers indicate surprising and widespread ways that animals survive by cultural learning. Regionally different vocalisations are sometimes called song traditions but the more commonly used word is dialects. More than a hundred studies have been published on dialects in birds. And its not just birds but a wide array of animals Including some fish.
Cod particularly, said Steve Simpson of the University of Exeter, have very elaborate calls compared with many fish. You can easily hear differences in recorded calls of American and European Atlantic cod. This species is highly vocal with traditional breeding grounds established over hundreds or even thousands of years. Many fish follow elders to feeding, resting and breeding areas. In experiments, introduced outsiders who learned such preferred locales by following elders continued to use these traditional routes after all the original fish from whom they learned were gone.
Cultural survival skills erode as habitats shrink. Maintaining genetic diversity is not enough. Weve become accustomed to a perilous satisfaction with precariously minimal populations that not only risk genetic viability of populations but almost guarantee losing local cultural knowledge by which populations have lived and survived.
In all free-living parrots that have been studied, nestlings develop individually unique calls, learned from their parents. Researchers have described this as an intriguing parallel with human parents naming infants. Indeed, these vocal identities help individuals distinguish neighbours, mates, sexes and individuals; the same functions that human names serve.
Williams tells me that when he studied Amazon parrots, he could hear differences between them saying, essentially, Lets go, Im here, where are you? and Darling, I just brought breakfast. Researchers who develop really good ears for parrot vocalisation and use technology to study recordings show that parrot noise is more organised and meaningful than it sounds to beginners like me. In a study of budgerigars, for instance, birds who were unfamiliar with each other were placed together. Groups of unfamiliar females took a few weeks for their calls to converge and sound similar. Males copied the calls of females. Black-capped chickadees flock members calls converge, so they can distinguish members of their own flock from those of other flocks. The fact that this happens, and that it takes weeks, suggests that free-living groups must normally be stable, that groups have their own identity, and that the members identify with their group.
Group identity, we see repeatedly, is not exclusively human. Sperm whales learn and announce their group identity. Young fruit bats learn the dialects of the crowds theyre in. Ravens know whos in, whos out. Too many animals to list know what group, troop, family or pack they belong with. In Brazil, some dolphins drive fish toward fishermens nets for a share of the catch. Other dolphins dont. The ones who do, sound different from the ones who dont. Various dolphin groups who specialise in a food-getting technique wont socialise with other groups who use different techniques. And orca whales, the most socially complex non-humans, have layered societies of pods, clans and communities, with community members all knowing the members of all their constituent pods, but each community scrupulously avoiding contact with members of another community. All this social organisation is learned from elders.
Elders appear important for social learning of migratory routes. Various storks, vultures, eagles and hawks all depend on following the cues of elders to locate strategic migration flyways or important stopover sites. These could be called their migration cultures. Famously, conservationists have raised young cranes, geese and swans to follow microlight aircraft as a surrogate parent on first migrations. Without such enculturation, they would not have known where to go. The young birds absorbed knowledge of routes, then used them in later seasons on their own self-guided migrations. Four thousand species of birds migrate, so Andrew Whiten of the University of St Andrews in Scotland speculates that following experienced birds may be an underappreciated but very significant realm of cultural transmission.
When you look at free-living animals, you dont usually see culture. Culture makes itself visible when it gets disrupted. Then we see that the road back to reestablishing cultures the answers to the questions of how we live in this place is difficult, often fatal.
Young mammals too moose, bison, deer, antelope, wild sheep, ibex and many others learn crucial migration routes and destinations from elder keepers of traditional knowledge. Conservationists have recently reintroduced large mammals in a few areas where theyve been wiped out, but because animals released into unfamiliar landscapes dont know where food is, where dangers lurk, or where to go in changing seasons, many translocations have failed.
Williams describes his procedure with the macaws as very much a slow release. First his team trains the birds to use a feeder. With that safety net, they can explore the forest, gain local knowledge, begin dispersing and using wild foods.
Some rescue programmes declare success if a released animal survives one year. A year is meaningless for a bird like a macaw that doesnt mature until its eight years old, says Williams.
I ask what theyre doing for those eight long years.
Social learning, Williams replies immediately. Working out whos who, how to interact, like kids in school.
To gain access to the future, to mate and to raise young, the birds Williams is releasing must enter into the culture of their kind. But from whom will they learn, if no one is out there? At the very least they must be socially oriented to one another. Ex-pets are the worst candidates for release; they dont interact appropriately with other macaws, and they want to hang around near humans.
To assess the social abilities of 13 scarlet macaws who were scheduled for release, Williams and his crew documented how much time they spent close to another bird, how often they initiated aggression, things like that. When the bird scoring lowest for social skills was released, he flew out the door and was never seen again. The next-to-lowest didnt adapt to the free-living life and had to be retrieved. The third-lowest social scorer remained at liberty but stayed alone a lot. The rest did well.
All of the above adds up to this: a species isnt just one big jar of jellybeans of the same colour. Its different smaller jars with differing hues in different places. From region to region, genetics can vary. And cultural traditions can differ. Different populations might use different tools, different migration routes, different ways of calling, courting and being understood. All populations have their answers to the question of how to live where they live.
Sometimes a group will be foraging in a tree, Williams says. A pair will fly overhead on a straight path. Someone will make a contact call, and the flying birds will loop around and land with the callers. They seem to have their friends. Bottom line, said Williams, there is much going on in the social and cultural lives of his macaws and other species, much that they understand but we dont. We have a lot of questions. The answers must lurk, somewhere, in their minds.
As land, weather and climate change, some aspects of cultural knowledge will be the tickets necessary for boarding the future. Others will die out. Across the range of chimpanzees, cultures vary greatly, as do habitats. All populations but one use stick tools. Some use simple probes, others fashion multi-stick toolsets. Only one population makes pointed daggers for hunting small nocturnal primates called bush-babies hiding in tree holes. Only the westernmost chimpanzees crack nuts with stones.
As researchers have noted, distinctive tool-using traditions at particular sites are defining features of unique chimpanzee cultures. Whiten wrote: Chimpanzee communities resemble human cultures in possessing suites of local traditions that uniquely identify them A complex social inheritance system that complements the genetic picture.
Some chimpanzee populations have learned to track the progress of dozens of specific trees ripening in their dense forests. Others live in open semi-savannah. Some are more aggressively male-dominated, some populations more egalitarian. Some almost never see people; some live in sight of human settlements and have learned to crop-raid at night. For a long, long time chimpanzees have been works in progress. Weve learned, writes Craig Stanford, not to speak of The Chimpanzee. Chimpanzees vary and chimpanzee culture is variable at every level.
Its not just the loss of populations of chimps that worries me, Cat Hobaiter emphasised when I spent several weeks with her studying chimpanzees in Uganda. I find terrifying the possibility of losing each populations unique culture. Thats permanent.
Diversity in cultural pools perhaps more crucially than in gene pools will make species survival more likely. If pressures cause regional populations to blink out, a species odds of persisting dim.
Williams goal is to re-establish macaws where they range no longer, in hopes that they, and their forests, will recover. (Most of the central American forests that macaws need have been felled and burned, largely so fast-food burger chains can sell cheap beef.) It often takes a couple of generations for human immigrant families to learn how to function effectively in their new culture; it may take two or three generations before an introduced population of macaws succeeds. In other words, macaws are born to be wild. But becoming wild requires an education.
So whats at stake is not just numbers. Whats at stake is: ways of knowing how to be in the world. Culture isnt just a boutique concern. Cultural knowledge is what allows many populations to survive. Keeping the knowledge of how to live in a habitat can be almost as important to the persistence of a species as keeping the habitat; both are needed. Cultural diversity itself is a source of resilience and adaptability to change. And change is accelerating.
This is an edited extract from Becoming Wild: How Animals Learn to be Animals by Carl Safina, which published in the UK by Oneworld on 9 April and in the US by Henry Holt and Co on 14 April
Continue reading here:
- Human genetics - Wikipedia - June 22nd, 2020
- human genetics | Description, Chromosomes, & Inheritance ... - June 22nd, 2020
- Human Genetics - David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA - June 22nd, 2020
- Genetic Mutations as a Tool To Predict Lifespan and Fertility - Technology Networks - June 22nd, 2020
- Human Genetics Market Analysis with Key Players, Applications, Trends and Forecasts to 2026 - Farmers Ledger - June 22nd, 2020
- China Is Collecting DNA From Tens of Millions of Men and Boys, Using U.S. Equipment - The New York Times - June 22nd, 2020
- Researchers identify environmental components that affect gene expression in cardiovascular disease - The South End - June 22nd, 2020
- China collects DNA from millions of men and boys - BioNews - June 22nd, 2020
- Exposure and engagement with tobacco-related social media and associations with subsequent tobacco use among young adults: A longitudinal analysis. -... - June 22nd, 2020
- COVID-19 Test Samples: Why Do We Swab Instead of Spit? - The Wire - June 22nd, 2020
- Coronavirus news and updates: Does Florida's spike in cases make it a new 'epicenter'?; mask rules on airplanes from the FAA - USA TODAY - June 22nd, 2020
- The beauty of flaws - NCC Linked - June 22nd, 2020
- Study finds genetic factors that make some more susceptible to Covid-19 - Health24 - June 22nd, 2020
- Assessment of COVID-19's Effect on Precision Medicine Software Market 2020-2024 | Benefits of Precision Medicine to Augment Growth | Technavio -... - June 22nd, 2020
- Wellness Experts Discuss The Importance Of Individualizing Your Approach To Health - Forbes - June 22nd, 2020
- 1.4 million for genetics research on how obesity in pregnancy affects mother and baby - Mirage News - June 9th, 2020
- Aerpio Hosting Key Opinion Leader Call on a Novel Mechanism for the Treatment of Glaucoma - GlobeNewswire - June 9th, 2020
- Amgen To Present At The Goldman Sachs 41st Annual Global Healthcare Conference - Monterey County Weekly - June 9th, 2020
- COVID-19 Pandemic: Global Risks of More Complex Character and the Visions of the Future World - Valdai Discussion Club - May 19th, 2020
- Rothamsted turn to harvesting coronavirus data - Lab News - May 19th, 2020
- Complement genes add to sex-based vulnerability in lupus and schizophrenia - UAB News - May 19th, 2020
- DU to set up School of Public Health - The Indian Express - May 19th, 2020
- Covid-19 research: 45 Bengaluru startups working on medicine, testing methods and vaccine - Economic Times - May 19th, 2020
- Immortalized Cell Line Market Development, Trends, Key Driven Factors, Segmentation And Forecast to 2020-2026 - Cole of Duty - May 19th, 2020
- Worlds Shortest Population Reveal the Largest Genetic Contributor to Height - Technology Networks - May 15th, 2020
- Group of Genes Have Altered Expression in Autism - Technology Networks - May 15th, 2020
- Why can two young and healthy individuals be affected so differently by coronavirus? - Health24 - May 15th, 2020
- Amgen To Present At The Bank Of America Merrill Lynch Virtual Global Healthcare Conference - BioSpace - May 15th, 2020
- Viewpoint: Darwin's 'Descent of Man' is both deeply disturbing and more relevant than ever - Genetic Literacy Project - May 15th, 2020
- Study Finds Low Proportion of Individuals With Autism Receive Recommended Genetic Tests - Technology Networks - May 15th, 2020
- Cats can catch Covid-19 from other cats. The question is: Can we? - STAT - May 15th, 2020
- Deficient Expression of DGCR8 in Human Testis is Related to Spermatoge | IJGM - Dove Medical Press - May 15th, 2020
- Prevail Therapeutics Reports First Quarter 2020 Financial Results and Business Highlights - GlobeNewswire - May 15th, 2020
- Fulcrum Therapeutics, Inc. (FULC) Q1 2020 Earnings Call Transcript - The Motley Fool - May 15th, 2020
- Scientists concerned that coronavirus is adapting to humans - The Guardian - May 11th, 2020
- Coronavirus quickly spread around the world starting late last year, new genetic analysis shows - CNN - May 11th, 2020
- Your genes could determine whether the coronavirus puts you in the hospital and we're starting to unravel which ones matter - The Conversation US - May 11th, 2020
- Yes, COVID-19 is mutating, here's what you need to know - ABC News - May 11th, 2020
- Conservatives Are Not the Only Ones Who Ignore Facts and the Science - Merion West - May 11th, 2020
- Coronavirus in Scotland: Charity warns Covid will cause a spike in ME cases - as it calls for 'harmful' exercise treatment to be banned -... - May 11th, 2020
- Dr. Misaki Wayengera: The Man Behind Uganda's Covid 19 Test Kits - New Vision - May 11th, 2020
- Its In The Genes? Scientists Think Coronavirus Exploits Silent Hidden Mutations In The Body - International Business Times - May 11th, 2020
- From blood clots to 'Covid toe': Experts confounded by series of medical mysteries - The Straits Times - May 11th, 2020
- MET 2020 Slot booking to commence on July 15, Examination dates available at manipal.edu - Jagran Josh - May 11th, 2020
- Vitagene Launches The First FDA Authorized Saliva based Zero Contact COVID-19 At Home Test - Business Wire - May 10th, 2020
- Genetics in focus after coronavirus deaths of siblings and twins - The Guardian - May 10th, 2020
- 'An anvil on my chest': What it's like to have COVID-19 - LancasterOnline - May 10th, 2020
- Coronavirus may have spread to humans as early as October 2019 - study - The Jerusalem Post - May 10th, 2020
- Team reveals genomic history of ancient civilizations in the Andes - UC Santa Cruz - May 10th, 2020
- Regeneron Reports First Quarter 2020 Financial and Operating Results - BioSpace - May 10th, 2020
- Scientists at Ben-Gurion University of the Negev Develop Anti-Coronavirus Surface Coating Based on Nanomate... - The Auto Channel - May 10th, 2020
- COVID-19 and food security - Fitzwilliam College, University of Cambridge - May 10th, 2020
- Val Sheffield elected to the American Academy of Arts and Sciences - Iowa Now - May 1st, 2020
- DNA gives clues into risk of developing Alzheimer's disease and other dementias - Alabama NewsCenter - May 1st, 2020
- Rare Gene Discovered That Nearly Doubles Risk of Developing a Neurodegenerative Disease - Clinical OMICs News - May 1st, 2020
- Progress in understanding the genetic basis of mental health - SFARI News - May 1st, 2020
- Coronavirus was widespread in UK at very start of pandemic, says genetics expert - Sky News - May 1st, 2020
- This is how you do the genetics heritage filter on Instagram that everyone's doing - The Tab - May 1st, 2020
- COVID-19 vaccine in Ireland could take a year and a half - IrishCentral - May 1st, 2020
- MRC scientists elected Fellows of the Royal Society - Cambridge Network - May 1st, 2020
- Parkinson's discovery implicates "second brain" in the gut - New Atlas - May 1st, 2020
- Humans: are we the most effective vector of disease? - BugBitten - BMC Blogs Network - May 1st, 2020
- Could genetics explain why some COVID-19 patients fare worse than others? - Live Science - April 27th, 2020
- Human Genetics Market Overview, Top Companies, Region, Application and Global Forecast by 2026 - Latest Herald - April 27th, 2020
- American Academy of Arts & Sciences Elects UVM's Wallace to Its Membership - UVM News - April 27th, 2020
- The PBS documentary The Gene showcases genetics promise and pitfalls - Science News - April 9th, 2020
- Few clinical trials are done in Africa: COVID-19 shows why this urgently needs to change - The Conversation Africa - April 9th, 2020
- UCLA web app will enlist publics help in slowing the spread of COVID-19 - Newswise - April 9th, 2020
- Why does the new coronavirus kill some people and barely affect others? - Wilkes-Barre Citizens Voice - April 9th, 2020
- COVID-19: Few Clinical Trials are Done in Africa. This Needs to Change ASAP. - The Wire - April 9th, 2020
- 'Behavioral suppression' needed to decrease coronavirus infections in Japan: experts - The Mainichi - April 9th, 2020
- Yann Joly on the fight against genetic discrimination - McGill Reporter - April 2nd, 2020
- Science to the rescue? How modern genetics could help save the world from coronavirus - Genetic Literacy Project - April 2nd, 2020
- Oldest human genetic data gleaned from 1.8-million-year-old tooth Haaretz - News Collective - April 2nd, 2020
- Science to the rescue? How modern genetics could help save the world from coronavirus - Alliance for Science - Alliance for Science - April 2nd, 2020
- BHU department claims to have discovered new technology to test COVID-19 - Jagran Josh - April 2nd, 2020
- Stealth BioTherapeutics Reports Fiscal Year 2019 Financial Results And Recent Business Highlights - BioSpace - April 2nd, 2020
- Researchers at U of T developing antibodies to 'neutralize' novel coronavirus before it invades cells - News@UofT - April 2nd, 2020
- What is coronavirus and Covid-19? An explainer - KTVZ - April 2nd, 2020
- Plasmid Market was Valued at US$ 89.52 million in 2018 and is Estimated to Reach US$ 447.68 Million by 2027, growing at a CAGR of 19.5% over the... - April 2nd, 2020