The legal team advocating the repeal of Section 377A of the Penal Code which criminalises acts of gross indecency between men argued before the High Court on Mon (18 Nov) that sexual orientation is a product of genetic and environmental factors, and cannot be changed at will.
Lawyers Eugene Thuraisingam, Suang Wijaya and Johannes Hadi of Eugene Thuraisingam LLP, on behalf of applicant DJ Johnson Ong Ming, said that the preponderance of scientific evidence shows that human sexual orientation ranges along a continuum, from completely heterosexual to completely homosexual.
In between are bisexuals who have varying degrees of preference for either sex, the lawyers added.
Homosexuals, like heterosexuals, cannot wilfully change their sexual orientation and/or attraction. There is no credible scientific evidence which supports the proposition that therapy aimed at changing sexual orientation (such as reparative or conversion therapy) is safe or effective, they argued.
Consequently, the crux of the legal teams argument is that Section 377A in the Penal Code violates two provisions in the Singapore Constitution, namely Article 9 of the Constitution which guarantees the right to life and personal liberty, and Article 12 which guarantees equal protection before the law.
Sexual activity between consenting adult males in private, according to Mr Ongs lawyers, neither harms nor impinges upon the rights or interests of any other persons.
Section 377A therefore violates Article 9 and 12 of the Constitution. It is absurd, irrational and discriminatory to criminalise a person on the basis of his natural, unchangeable identity and for non-harmful private acts, they added.
The relevant section in the Penal Code also reinforces the majoritys good old-fashioned discrimination against male homosexuals, who are a minority in Singapore, according to Ongs legal team.
The role of our Constitution and the Court is to protect minorities against the absurd, irrational prejudices of the majority, his lawyers argued.
Three medical experts were called by Mr Ongs legal team in the immediate case, namely:
The Attorney-Generals Chambers (AGC), the respondent in all three cases, called the following experts:
Little to no scientific evidence in support of proposition pinpointing socio-environmental factors as cause for homosexuality and bisexuality, according to medical experts on both sides
Experts from both sides concurred that genetic and non-social environmental factors (like the womb environment) contribute to the causality of sexual orientation and/or attraction.
There is little if any scientific evidence which supports the proposition that social environmental factors (like culture, parenting) play any role in the causality of sexual orientation and/or attraction, said Mr Ongs lawyers.
One of the sources cited by Dr Cai is a study by Bailey, J.M., Vesey, P.L., Diamond, L.M., Breedlove, S.M., Villian, E,M & Epprecht, M. (in press), titled Sexual orientation controversy, and science, Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 2016, Vol 17(2) 45-101 summarises the position, which details the following:
No causal theory of sexual orientation has yet gained widespread support. The most scientifically plausible causal hypotheses are difficult to test. However, there is considerably more evidence supporting non-social causes of sexual orientation than social causes.
This evidence includes the cross-culturally robust finding that adult homosexuality is strongly related to childhood gender non-conformity; moderate genetic influences demonstrated in well sampled twin studies; the cross-culturally robust fraternal birth order effect on male sexual orientation; and the finding that when infant boys are surgically and socially changed into girls, their eventual sexual orientation is unchanged (i.e., they remain sexually attracted to females).
In contrast, evidence for the most commonly hypothesized social causes of homosexuality sexual recruitment by homosexual adults, patterns of disordered parenting, or the influence of homosexual parents is generally weak in magnitude and distorted by numerous confounding factors.
Citing Dr Cais report, the lawyers argued that it can be inferred that Dr Cais findings align with those of Dr Rajesh, who posited that biological and non-social environmental factors influence sexual orientation, and that [e]vidence for the most commonly hypothesised social causes of homosexuality have generally been debunked.
First, Dr Cai states that [s]exual orientation is no unchanging in everyone, and cites studies showing that some individuals have been found to experience spontaneous and naturally-occurring changes in sexual orientation, as opposed to willful changes.
Second, Dr Cai does not cite any literature or study supporting the proposition that sexual orientation can be willfully changed, such as through sexual orientation change efforts, conversion therapy or reparative therapy.
Mr Ongs lawyers also argued that Dr Cai has offered no credible evidence that sexual orientation can be willfully changed.
Studies showing that some individuals experience spontaneous and naturally occurring change in sexual orientation is nothing to the point, they argued, citing two reasons, namely:
i) spontaneous and naturally-occurring change is not willful change as demonstrated by the literature cited by Dr Cai himself; and
(ii) the studies show that close to 100% of homosexual males do not experience even any spontaneous or natural change.
Secondly, said Ongs lawyers, the literature cited by Dr Cai himself supports the point that persons do not experience choice over their sexual orientation and/or sexual attraction.
Ongs legal team added that the literature cited by Dr Cai demonstrates that there is no credible evidence for the purported effectiveness of conversion therapy, reparative therapy, and other forms of intervention to change sexual orientation are effective, which have been known present a significant risk of harm to individuals undergoing such interventions.
Genetics and other biological factors, including non-social environmental factors, contribute strongly to the development of sexual orientation
Another source cited by Dr Cai is a study by Roselli, C.E. titled Neurobiology of Gender Identity and Sexual Orientation, published in Journal of Neuroendocrinology, 2018, which states the following:
Most people experience little or no sense of choice about their sexual orientation. There Is no scientifically convincing research to show that therapy aimed at changing sexual orientation (ie, reparative or conversion therapy) is safe or effective. The origin of sexual orientation is far from being understood, although there is no proof that it is affected by social factors after birth. On the other hand, a large amount of empirical data suggests that genes and hormones are important regulators of sexual orientation
The data summarised in the present review suggest that both gender identity and sexual orientation are significantly influenced by events occurring during the early developmental period when the brain is differentiating under the influence of gonadal steroid hormones, genes and maternal factors. However, our current understanding of these factors is far from complete and the results are not always consistent
Our current understanding suffers from many limitations in the data Despite these limitations, the existing empirical evidence makes it clear that there is a significant biological contribution to the development of an individuals identity and sexual orientation.
Ongs lawyers pointed out thatDr Cai accepted the proposition that it is not disputed by experts in the field that genetics has some contribution to the causation of homosexuality.
Secondly, the lawyers highlighted that Dr Cai cited, in approval, papers which conclude that there can be little doubt that [sexual orientation] is influenced by environmental factors.
The environmental factors referred to by the papers cited by Dr Cai are non-social environmental factors such as the womb environment, not social environmental factors, Mr Ongs legal team highlighted, adding that Dr Cai has already cited various studies and literature pointing to genetic and non-social environmental factors of sexual orientation.
Dr Cai, according to the lawyers, also cited studies indicating that hormones play a part in the causation of sexual orientation, and the fraternal birth order effect play a role in shaping a persons sexual orientation.
Mr Ongs lawyers also rejected Dr Tays assertion that cultural and social environmental factors are also likely to play a role in determining sexual orientation, as the expert has cited no material that supports such an assertion.
This assertion is also demonstrably false, Mr Ongs lawyers argued.
The closed High Court hearing on Mon was the second out of three cases to be presented against Section 377A this month.
The current cases, according to a statement by Mr Ongs legal team, set a precedent in examining legal questions on the nature of sexual orientation, as expert evidence is now presented before the courts.
Previously, the court was only asked to take judicial notice of scientific facts which required a different legal test, Mr Ongs legal team added.
The AGC began its submissions on Mon, and will conclude its submissions at the next hearing on Wed.
Read more from the original source:
- The genetic architecture of the human cerebral cortex - Science Magazine - March 26th, 2020
- The Coronavirus Pandemic Shows Us The Importance Of Combatting Climate Change - Forbes - March 26th, 2020
- Kallyope Inc. Announces $112M Series C Financing to Support First Clinical Trials and Advance Portfolio of Programs Targeting the Gut-Brain Axis - P&T... - March 26th, 2020
- IN CONSERVATION: DR. JEFF STROVEL, CEO of VERALOX THERAPEUTICS - BioBuzz - March 26th, 2020
- How healthtech startup Bione aims to use genetic testing in the fight against coronavirus - YourStory - March 26th, 2020
- Coronavirus: Massive gap in US response revealed after scientists learn colleague tested positive through twee - MEAWW - March 26th, 2020
- Avera announces ability to test for COVID-19 in South Dakota - The Dickinson Press - March 24th, 2020
- University of Utah experts advise caution over drugs hyped as possible coronavirus treatments - Salt Lake Tribune - March 24th, 2020
- Invitae and Muscular Dystrophy Association (MDA) Expand Access to No-Charge Genetic Testing in the US and Canada - PRNewswire - March 24th, 2020
- Studying the African genome could yield new medical treatments for everyone - Genetic Literacy Project - March 24th, 2020
- Human Genetics Market Higher Growth Rate / CAGR over the Forecast Period to 2026 by Key Players like QIAGEN, Agilent Technologies, Illumina - New Day... - March 16th, 2020
- Coronavirus is hard on older people and scientists aren't sure why - NBCNews.com - March 16th, 2020
- Researchers study irregular horse heartbeats, hoping to find a cure - Minnesota Daily - March 16th, 2020
- Dr. John T. Macdonald Foundation seeking to fund community-based organizations with major grant dollars - Miami's Community Newspapers - March 16th, 2020
- A book that could save lives: Adam Rutherford's How to Argue with a Racist reviewed - Spectator.co.uk - March 16th, 2020
- Validea's Top Five Healthcare Stocks Based On Motley Fool - 3/15/2020 - Nasdaq - March 16th, 2020
- Fighting the coronavirus outbreak with genetic sequencing, CRISPR and synthetic biology - Genetic Literacy Project - March 16th, 2020
- human genetics | Description, Chromosomes, & Inheritance ... - February 29th, 2020
- Human Genetics | Pitt Public Health | University of Pittsburgh - February 29th, 2020
- Amgen To Present At The Cowen 40th Annual Healthcare Conference - BioSpace - February 29th, 2020
- Working on 'the human side' of heritable cancers - Penn: Office of University Communications - February 29th, 2020
- Ancient Scotsman with Protruding Rear End Found Carved on Monolith - The Vintage News - February 29th, 2020
- Her parents taught her grit, caring for others. She's using those traits to fight heart disease. - Thrive Global - February 29th, 2020
- IFFGD Raises Awareness for Rare Digestive Diseases on Rare Disease Day 2020 - P&T Community - February 29th, 2020
- Research on intermittent fasting shows health benefits - National Institute on Aging - February 29th, 2020
- When a Supervolcano Erupted, These Ancient People Survived the Blankets of Ash - Discover Magazine - February 29th, 2020
- Why This S&P 500 Stock Is Defying the Brutal Coronavirus Plunge - CCN.com - February 29th, 2020
- Stone tools show humans in India survived the cataclysmic Toba eruption 74,000 years ago - Firstpost - February 29th, 2020
- Scientist Who Discovered BRCA1 Gene to Give Free Talk on Cancer And Genetics - Noozhawk - January 19th, 2020
- Genetic testing firm 23andMe is first to create a drug using its customers' DNA - The Times - January 19th, 2020
- Hackensack Meridian Health Center for Discovery and Innovation to Host Genomic Medicine Symposium - P&T Community - January 19th, 2020
- 11 Year-Old Bertrand Might Cant Cry Scientists Have Now Discovered Why - SciTechDaily - January 19th, 2020
- Transposons Identified as Likely Cause of Undiagnosed Diseases - The Scientist - January 19th, 2020
- Do genetic ancestry tests know if you're Palestinian? A cautionary tale of race and science - ABC News - January 19th, 2020
- Controlling Our Own Evolution: What is the Future of Gene-Editing? - The Globe Post - January 19th, 2020
- There is a new player in adult bone healing - Baylor College of Medicine News - January 19th, 2020
- Air Pollution, Evolution, and the Fate of Billions of Humans - The New York Times - January 19th, 2020
- A New York Times column on 'Jewish genius' draws criticism for linking to a debunked University of Utah study - Salt Lake Tribune - January 5th, 2020
- Ambroxol Reverses Bone Damage in Girl With GD Type 1, Case Study Shows - Gaucher Disease News - January 5th, 2020
- Gene editing breakthroughs that cured genetic diseases in 2019 - The Star Online - January 5th, 2020
- Digid8 and the Emergence of DNA Matchmaking - Study Breaks - January 5th, 2020
- Etched in DNA: Decoding the secrets of the past - Christian Science Monitor - January 5th, 2020
- The Face of Science - Clemson World magazine - January 5th, 2020
- Aborting Babies Because They're Gay: Coming Soon to China - Patheos - January 5th, 2020
- Mutants among us: "Natural short sleepers" reveal the genetics of sleep - Inverse - January 5th, 2020
- The End of Infertility Is in Sight - UCSF News Services - January 5th, 2020
- Who is a Jew? DNA home testing adds new wrinkle to age-old debate - The Jewish News of Northern California - December 1st, 2019
- Humans and autoimmune diseases continue to evolve together - Medical News Today - December 1st, 2019
- Mutations in emerging autism gene tied to distinct traits - Spectrum - December 1st, 2019
- Gail Fisher's 'Dog Tracks': Spoiling you dog with extra food could cut short its life - The Union Leader - December 1st, 2019
- In a Wisconsin village, the doctor makes house calls and sees the rarest diseases on Earth - USA TODAY - December 1st, 2019
- Alzheimer's and Autism: Researchers Pinpoint Genetic Mutations Overlapping in Both Diseases - Being Patient - December 1st, 2019
- How do consumer DNA tests from the US and China stack up? - Abacus - December 1st, 2019
- Is Nature vs. Nurture an Outdated Concept? - The National Interest Online - December 1st, 2019
- Collection of genetic data leads to privacy concerns - The New Economy - December 1st, 2019
- Is sexual orientation genetic? Yes and no, an extensive study finds - Haaretz - November 19th, 2019
- Sexual orientation cannot be changed at will, lawyers argue - The Straits Times - November 19th, 2019
- Adam and Eve Are Possible: A Second Bite at the Genetic Apple - Christianheadlines.com - November 19th, 2019
- InterVenn Biosciences Announces Positive Interim Clinical Trial Results and Appoints Biotech Veteran Klaus Lindpaintner, M.D. as Chief Scientific and... - November 19th, 2019
- How maternal Zika infection results in newborn microcephaly - Baylor College of Medicine News - November 19th, 2019
- Dicerna scores broad, 'rest of liver' deal with Novo Nordisk, bagging $225M in cash to hit some 30 targets with RNAi platform - Endpoints News - November 19th, 2019
- Sexual orientation cannot be wilfully changed, say lawyers fighting to repeal Section 377A - The Straits Times - November 19th, 2019
- The American Heart Association's Annual Conference Comes to Philly This Weekend - Philadelphia magazine - November 19th, 2019
- Clear link between genetics and depressive symptoms uncovered - The Age - November 19th, 2019
- At-Home DNA Tests Still Need the 'Human Touch,' Say Panelists at Genomics Roundtable Workshop - National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and... - November 19th, 2019
- How in utero Zika virus infection can lead to microcephaly in newborns: Baylor research - Outbreak News Today - November 19th, 2019
- Taller People have Increased Risk of Irregular Heartbeat - News18 - November 19th, 2019
- In Down syndrome mouse model, scientists reverse intellectual deficits with drugs - University of California - November 19th, 2019
- Alector Reports Recent Business Highlights and Third Quarter 2019 Financial Results - GlobeNewswire - November 19th, 2019
- One of the World's Greatest Geneticists, He Gave Up British Citizenship for India - The Better India - November 19th, 2019
- Co-creator of CRISPR lectures about future applications of genome editing technology - Daily Bruin - November 19th, 2019
- Connecting gene mutations, rare genetic diseases - Baylor College of Medicine News - October 28th, 2019
- Utah researchers discover link between certain brain cells and anxiety, OCD - KSL.com - October 28th, 2019
- UH Receives $2M to Study Cancer Risks of Environmental Toxins - Big Island Now - October 28th, 2019
- Genetic testing could keep you healthy. But what about personal info? - Deseret News - October 28th, 2019
- Student group works to foster diversity in the sciences - UChicago News - October 28th, 2019
- Takeaways from ASHG 2019 in Houston: Users of Bionano's Saphyr System Presented Validation Results for FSHD, Repeat Expansion Disorders and Digital... - October 28th, 2019
- DNA research holds the keys to human history but it's being weaponized by politicians - Haaretz - October 28th, 2019
- Scientists have created the first-ever 18-carbon ring, a major feat of molecular architecture - Massive Science - October 28th, 2019
- Law, Privacy and Genome Human Rights Failure in Russia - Putin's Fascination with Hitler's Eugenics Project - Communal News - October 28th, 2019