When it was first published last week, a controversial New York Times column about the secrets of Jewish genius linked to a 2005 study from a researcher labeled an extremist, revered by white supremacists and discredited by scientists and who, for years, worked as a distinguished professor at the University of Utah.
Citing the late U. anthropologist Henry Harpending, expectedly, touched off criticism. Hours after it appeared online, The Times commentary was updated with an editors note saying it had been a mistake to mention the study, which has been widely questioned and long seen as an argument of racial superiority.
The note suggests that conservative columnist Bret Stephens did not know that Harpending promoted racist ideas. It also says Stephens was not endorsing the study or its authors views but acknowledges that his reference to the research, nevertheless, left an impression with many readers that Mr. Stephens was arguing that Jews are genetically superior. That was not his intent.
The paragraph Stephens wrote about Harpendings research has since been deleted online. And on Friday, the University of Utah deleted a complimentary memorial post from its Department of Anthropology that had said Harpendings scholarly and personal footprint will be long lasting in the field.
The U. also noted in response to the column that none of the three authors of the paper Harpending, Gregory Cochran or then-student Jason Hardy work at the school any longer. Harpending was there from 1997 until he died of a stroke in 2016.
Statements attributed to Henry Harpending that promote ideas in line with white nationalist ideology stand in direct opposition to the University of Utahs values of equity, diversity and inclusion ... " said Annalisa Purser, the universitys spokeswoman.
As such, we will meet these words with ours: Racist views and rhetoric that position one race as superior to another are inaccurate and harmful," she said. "The University of Utah is bolstered by its diversity, which allows individuals from different backgrounds and perspectives to come together to address challenges in new and creative ways.
Neither Cochran nor Hardy could not be reached by The Salt Lake Tribune for comment. Its unclear why none of the researchers faced censure while at the university for publishing the piece, though Purser added, Speech even when it is racist is protected by the U.S. Constitution and is necessary for the free exchange of ideas.
This has been a very painful time already for Jews in the United States, said Amy Spiro, a Jewish journalist whose work has been published in Variety, Jewish Insider and The Jerusalem Post. And then this column came out, she told The Tribune in a phone interview. Its just generated a lot of controversy. It doesnt seem like this is helpful in any way.
In their disputed study, the U. researchers focused on Ashkenazi Jews, or those who settled in central and Eastern Europe (as opposed to Spain or the Middle East). Among supremacists, the group is often seen as pure because many are white.
Harpending, Cochran and Hardy argue that Ashkenazi Jews have higher IQs, on average, than the general public (including other non-Ashkenazi Jews). Their theory is that in medieval times, individuals in the faith group in Europe were pushed into finance jobs because of the Christian prohibition of usury, or lending money for interest. Over time, many became rich and had more surviving children than poorer families who worked on farms. They also married within the community and stayed fairly isolated.
The University of Utah has long been known as an expert in genetic research, but this paper Natural History of Ashkenazi Intelligence is typically seen as a low point in that expertise. The authors created their own algorithm for determining genetic makeup and cited several scientists also viewed as racist.
The researchers have been criticized on and off since the study came out in 2005 and was published in The Journal of Biosocial Science the next year; that publication was previously called The Eugenics Review up until the 1970s. Eugenics is the controversial pseudo-science popular among Nazis for improving the human race by forced sterilization of poor people.
The Times piece on the study was largely uncritical beyond that; it was written by reporter Nicholas Wade, who later wrote his own book on genetics that shares some ideas with Harpending and Cochran. (Cochran had previously written about incorrect claims that being gay was caused by an infectious disease.)
The head of New York Universitys human-genetics program said: Its bad science not because its provocative, but because its bad genetics and bad epidemiology.
In a 2007 press release about later research by Harpending, the school acknowledged his 2005 paper had created a stir and that critics had questioned the quality of the science.
Harpending continued to speak, though, including at white supremacist conferences, about his also inaccurate ideas that black people are genetically prone to be lazy. His profile on the Southern Poverty Law Centers page lists him as a white nationalist and an extremist who believed in eugenics.
In other words, as an anthropologist looking around the world, he said in 2009 at the Preserving Western Civilization conference, what I see is that men work and produce things when theyre forced into it, and when theyre not, they quit. And Im thinking about, you know tribes in central Africa, but you know its true in Baltimore too, right?
His obituary noted he came to Utah from Pennsylvania State University after earning his doctorate at Harvard.
Stephens, who is Jewish, ultimately argues in his column that theres a cultural not genetic explanation for Jewish genius, stemming from Judaisms religious tradition of encouraging believers to not only observe and obey but also discuss and disagree. He also believes group members became more innovative and creative by typically being in the minority wherever theyve lived.
His original mention of the study read: The common answer is that Jews are, or tend to be, smart. When it comes to Ashkenazi Jews, its true. Ashkenazi Jews have the highest average I.Q. of any ethnic group for which there are reliable data, noted one 2005 paper. During the 20th century, they made up about 3 percent of the U.S. population but won 27 percent of the U.S. Nobel science prizes and 25 percent of the ACM Turing awards. They account for more than half of world chess champions.
That data on awards is not technically wrong, though it broadly counts anyone as Jewish who has a grandparent with ancestry in the faith.
Stephens mentioned Albert Einstein and Franz Kafka and Karl Marx as prime examples of Jewish intelligence, before asking: How is it that a people who never amounted to even one-third of 1 percent of the worlds population contributed so seminally to so many of its most pathbreaking ideas and innovations?
His use of the paper is just stunning, Kennedy told The Tribune, saying the study was obviously a main tenet of Stephens argument, and not a minor point, like the editors note suggests. I think it should have been killed before it ever got published.
In the later edits, all references to Ashkenazi Jews (which also appeared in two other places in the column) were removed. Many have questioned why Stephens referred to Ashkenazi Jews at all if he didnt agree with the paper and was generally talking about Jewish culture, and not superiority.
What was even the point of the column? Spiro asked. Its confusing.
Stephens joined The Times in 2017, after winning a Pulitzer Prize for his work at The Wall Street Journal in 2013 and serving as editor in chief of The Jerusalem Post. He has previously come under fire for bullying a professor who called him a bedbug.
Some have called for his resignation, particularly liberal readers who disagree with his more conservative pieces, but Kennedy believes the Jewish genius piece is a new low. The associate professor, who teaches ethics in journalism at Northeastern, said the commentary needed more than an editors note about the concerns raised.
- Scientist Who Discovered BRCA1 Gene to Give Free Talk on Cancer And Genetics - Noozhawk - January 19th, 2020
- Genetic testing firm 23andMe is first to create a drug using its customers' DNA - The Times - January 19th, 2020
- Hackensack Meridian Health Center for Discovery and Innovation to Host Genomic Medicine Symposium - P&T Community - January 19th, 2020
- 11 Year-Old Bertrand Might Cant Cry Scientists Have Now Discovered Why - SciTechDaily - January 19th, 2020
- Transposons Identified as Likely Cause of Undiagnosed Diseases - The Scientist - January 19th, 2020
- Do genetic ancestry tests know if you're Palestinian? A cautionary tale of race and science - ABC News - January 19th, 2020
- Controlling Our Own Evolution: What is the Future of Gene-Editing? - The Globe Post - January 19th, 2020
- There is a new player in adult bone healing - Baylor College of Medicine News - January 19th, 2020
- Air Pollution, Evolution, and the Fate of Billions of Humans - The New York Times - January 19th, 2020
- Ambroxol Reverses Bone Damage in Girl With GD Type 1, Case Study Shows - Gaucher Disease News - January 5th, 2020
- Gene editing breakthroughs that cured genetic diseases in 2019 - The Star Online - January 5th, 2020
- Digid8 and the Emergence of DNA Matchmaking - Study Breaks - January 5th, 2020
- Etched in DNA: Decoding the secrets of the past - Christian Science Monitor - January 5th, 2020
- The Face of Science - Clemson World magazine - January 5th, 2020
- Aborting Babies Because They're Gay: Coming Soon to China - Patheos - January 5th, 2020
- Mutants among us: "Natural short sleepers" reveal the genetics of sleep - Inverse - January 5th, 2020
- The End of Infertility Is in Sight - UCSF News Services - January 5th, 2020
- Who is a Jew? DNA home testing adds new wrinkle to age-old debate - The Jewish News of Northern California - December 1st, 2019
- Humans and autoimmune diseases continue to evolve together - Medical News Today - December 1st, 2019
- Mutations in emerging autism gene tied to distinct traits - Spectrum - December 1st, 2019
- Gail Fisher's 'Dog Tracks': Spoiling you dog with extra food could cut short its life - The Union Leader - December 1st, 2019
- In a Wisconsin village, the doctor makes house calls and sees the rarest diseases on Earth - USA TODAY - December 1st, 2019
- Alzheimer's and Autism: Researchers Pinpoint Genetic Mutations Overlapping in Both Diseases - Being Patient - December 1st, 2019
- How do consumer DNA tests from the US and China stack up? - Abacus - December 1st, 2019
- Is Nature vs. Nurture an Outdated Concept? - The National Interest Online - December 1st, 2019
- Collection of genetic data leads to privacy concerns - The New Economy - December 1st, 2019
- Is sexual orientation genetic? Yes and no, an extensive study finds - Haaretz - November 19th, 2019
- Sexual orientation cannot be changed at will, lawyers argue - The Straits Times - November 19th, 2019
- Adam and Eve Are Possible: A Second Bite at the Genetic Apple - Christianheadlines.com - November 19th, 2019
- InterVenn Biosciences Announces Positive Interim Clinical Trial Results and Appoints Biotech Veteran Klaus Lindpaintner, M.D. as Chief Scientific and... - November 19th, 2019
- How maternal Zika infection results in newborn microcephaly - Baylor College of Medicine News - November 19th, 2019
- Dicerna scores broad, 'rest of liver' deal with Novo Nordisk, bagging $225M in cash to hit some 30 targets with RNAi platform - Endpoints News - November 19th, 2019
- Sexual orientation cannot be wilfully changed, say lawyers fighting to repeal Section 377A - The Straits Times - November 19th, 2019
- The American Heart Association's Annual Conference Comes to Philly This Weekend - Philadelphia magazine - November 19th, 2019
- Clear link between genetics and depressive symptoms uncovered - The Age - November 19th, 2019
- At-Home DNA Tests Still Need the 'Human Touch,' Say Panelists at Genomics Roundtable Workshop - National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and... - November 19th, 2019
- How in utero Zika virus infection can lead to microcephaly in newborns: Baylor research - Outbreak News Today - November 19th, 2019
- Taller People have Increased Risk of Irregular Heartbeat - News18 - November 19th, 2019
- In Down syndrome mouse model, scientists reverse intellectual deficits with drugs - University of California - November 19th, 2019
- Alector Reports Recent Business Highlights and Third Quarter 2019 Financial Results - GlobeNewswire - November 19th, 2019
- One of the World's Greatest Geneticists, He Gave Up British Citizenship for India - The Better India - November 19th, 2019
- Section 377A constitutional challenge: Expert evidence reveal sexual orientation cannot be changed at will, lawyers argue - The Online Citizen - November 19th, 2019
- Co-creator of CRISPR lectures about future applications of genome editing technology - Daily Bruin - November 19th, 2019
- Connecting gene mutations, rare genetic diseases - Baylor College of Medicine News - October 28th, 2019
- Utah researchers discover link between certain brain cells and anxiety, OCD - KSL.com - October 28th, 2019
- UH Receives $2M to Study Cancer Risks of Environmental Toxins - Big Island Now - October 28th, 2019
- Genetic testing could keep you healthy. But what about personal info? - Deseret News - October 28th, 2019
- Student group works to foster diversity in the sciences - UChicago News - October 28th, 2019
- Takeaways from ASHG 2019 in Houston: Users of Bionano's Saphyr System Presented Validation Results for FSHD, Repeat Expansion Disorders and Digital... - October 28th, 2019
- DNA research holds the keys to human history but it's being weaponized by politicians - Haaretz - October 28th, 2019
- Scientists have created the first-ever 18-carbon ring, a major feat of molecular architecture - Massive Science - October 28th, 2019
- Law, Privacy and Genome Human Rights Failure in Russia - Putin's Fascination with Hitler's Eugenics Project - Communal News - October 28th, 2019
- Neural activity plays an important role in longevity - CMU The Tartan Online - October 28th, 2019
- Book Summary: Genetics and the Aryan Debate by Shrikant Talageri- I - IndiaFacts - October 28th, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: This Week on Bitfinex, Tether, Coinbase, & More - May 25th, 2019
- Ripple Price Forecast: XRP vs SWIFT, SEC Updates, and More - May 25th, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: Bitcoin ETFs, Andreessen Horowitz, and Contradictions in Crypto - May 25th, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: Looking Past the Bithumb Crypto Hack - May 25th, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: XRP Validators, Malta, and Practical Tokens - May 25th, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: Bitcoin ETF Rejection, AMD Microchip Sales, and Hedge Funds - May 25th, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: What You Need to Know This Week - May 25th, 2019
- Bitcoin Rise: Is the Recent Bitcoin Price Surge a Sign of Things to Come or Another Misdirection? - May 25th, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: Vitalik Buterin Doesn’t Care About Bitcoin ETFs - May 25th, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: New Exchanges Could Boost Crypto Liquidity - May 25th, 2019
- Human genetics - Wikipedia - May 5th, 2019
- Human Genetics - medschool.ucla.edu - May 5th, 2019
- Department of Human Genetics | The University of Chicago - May 5th, 2019
- Human genetics | biology | Britannica.com - May 2nd, 2019
- What is Bitcoin Cash? - finance.yahoo.com - April 29th, 2019
- Bitcoin Soars As Ethereum, Ripple's XRP, Bitcoin Cash, And ... - April 29th, 2019
- Bitcoin Cash - finance.yahoo.com - April 29th, 2019
- What is Bitcoin Cash? - Coin Rivet - April 29th, 2019
- Bitcoin Cash - Wikipedia - April 29th, 2019
- Ripple Price Forecast: XRP vs SWIFT, SEC Updates, and More - April 21st, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: Looking Past the Bithumb Crypto Hack - April 21st, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: This Week on Bitfinex, Tether, Coinbase, & More - April 21st, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: XRP Validators, Malta, and Practical Tokens - April 21st, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: Bitcoin ETFs, Andreessen Horowitz, and Contradictions in Crypto - April 21st, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: New Exchanges Could Boost Crypto Liquidity - April 21st, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: Bitcoin ETF Rejection, AMD Microchip Sales, and Hedge Funds - April 21st, 2019