Presidential candidate Andrew Yang fields questions from the audience at a New York City gathering.
As the clock ticks and cameras glare across the stages of the democratic debates like the one held Thursday night in Los Angeles, Andrew Yang and the rest of the presidential contenders know to sacrifice policy proposal details for performative punch lines that might better resonate across Twitter. Yet without the finer explanation, voters must come to conclusions based only on a basic understanding of complex plans that might fundamentally change our country.
Away from debate stages, Mr. Yang has begun an effort to address the problem, connecting with smaller audiences to more deeply discuss his flagship policy proposal for universal basic income (UBI). His version of UBI, which he calls the Freedom Dividend, would give $1,000 a month to every American adult. On a recent Sunday night in a SoHo apartment, Mr. Yang sat casually in the center of the living room answering questions and discussing the details.
The plan, though straightforward in its most basic structure, attracts criticism for its audacity in the context of our free market mentality and the countrys already mounting debt obligations. As U.S. national debt crosses the $23 trillion mark, skeptics particularly question the plans cost, which Mr. Yang acknowledges could exceed $2.8 trillion in the first year of its implementation.
While Mr. Yang has struggled to widely project his responses to criticisms partially thanks to the lack of speaking time hes had in front of national debate stage cameras, his argument in defense of the plan also consists of historical context, economic theory and even biological thinking that feels best fitted for a TED Talks stage. With these kinds of mini, TED-like gatherings, it seems Mr. Yang is hoping that people who think about the plan more deeply might have more impassioned conversations that make their way to Mondays water coolers and beyond.
With the room to discuss the dividends more nuanced details, Mr. Yang framed the costs and effects in ways even some loyalist attendees may not have heard. But first, and true to the point of his MATH button adorning his blue blazer lapel, Mr. Yang spent much of the early part of the evening making the room think about the numbers, citing specific, dollar-for-dollar revenues that he argued would offset the dividends costs, including the institution of a 10% value-added tax (VAT).
Still, some economists, though not present at the event, have consistently argued that Mr. Yangs math doesnt add up. Andy Laperriere, head of policy research at market research and investment firm Cornerstone Macro, suggests that while the dividend could theoretically provide some benefit to the broad economy given the risks facing the labor market amid exponential automation, the plan couldnt gain its footing because of its sheer cost of implementation.
Theres a basic logic problem here thats hard to overcome given UBI requires such an enormous amount of money, Mr. Laperriere says. Even if you accept as fact that were spending $1 trillion on things like health care and homelessness and that we could recoup $1 trillion from the VAT, that still doesnt come close to raising the money.
Economists like Mr. Laperriere also often raise the issue of a VAT diminishing the intended benefit of the UBI, since consumers would effectively need to use those new dollars to pay that new cost of consumption. Since a VAT taxes the production of goods and services, companies could subsequently increase the price of those goods and services, thereby at least partially passing the tax on to the consumer.
To some extent, paying for UBI with a VAT just means were putting money in one pocket that comes out of the other, Mr. Laperriere said. And if youre exempting some consumer staples from tax, then the tax would just have to be higher elsewhere.
At the event, Mr. Yang acknowledged the possibility of companies passing along the tax, but argued that the extra costs would not come close to canceling out the UBI. Mr. Yang and others also pointed to the more indirect ways in which UBI could pay for itself by eliminating other government costs. Congressional candidates Chivona Renee Newsome and James Felton Keith both argued that while means-based benefit programs like welfare emphasize the neediness of Americans, UBI instead reflects inherent deservedness, which sheds stigma and can convert government dependency into personal motivation.
Its not a handout and everyone gets it, Ms. Newsome said. That takes the shame out of poverty.
That paradigm shift, along with the fact that recipients cant stack UBI on top of existing benefits, could theoretically pull people away from current welfare programs that cost roughly $550 billion annually.
Beyond these secondary revenue sources, Mr. Yang explored the intangible effects on families that he believes best support the cost of the plan, suggesting that Americans happiness and overall mindset matter most to the economic outcome. In fact, Mr. Yang explained the Freedom Dividend found its name not just from polling well for its flag-waving charm, but for what the dividend is actually intended to provide: A sense of freedom from the burden of financial hardship. This more nuanced thinking about the interconnectedness of mental health and personal finances seemed revelatory even to some of the more obvious supporters in the audience.
Our human mind is programmed for scarcity, Mr. Yang said. While Americans are the unhappiest theyve ever been, creating a sense of abundance can create secondary effects that economists overlook when considering how to pay for the policy.
With 40% of American families unable to cover a $400 unexpected expense, Mr. Yang suggested such financial pressure can hurt close personal relationships and breed decisions that drive families deeper into distress, issues that contribute to happiness in the U.S. reaching its lowest level ever. This breathing room from financial burden and a sense of basic financial security allows families a better opportunity to reduce anxiety and increase happiness, which in turn yields better financial decisions, and so on in a virtuous cycle.
Something like the freedom dividend can be profound to the lived experience, Mr. Yang said.
While economic theory suggests supplemental income could incentivize some to work less, Mr. Yang believes the sense of relief among most families would inevitably benefit the broader economy. As people feel more secure and optimistic of the future, theyre more likely to consume appropriately and to find better-matched jobs, an important factor to productivity that economists and other candidates federal jobs guarantee plan overlook.
There is something to that part of the argument, Mr. Laperriere says. When I graduated college and I wanted to work on Capitol Hill where I knew Id make no money, I went home to work at a restaurant first. With the safety net of some money in my pocket, I was more willing and equipped to take the risk.
While its clear some economists and Mr. Yang might disagree on the math when it comes to budgetary building blocks like the VAT, the detailed thinking around UBIs more theoretical benefits seemed to strike a chord with attendees who left with enthusiasm to continue the conversation.
As Mr. Yang continues along the campaign trail, voters will need to decide whether theyre willing to take the expensive leap of faith toward a solution that might improve Americans mental health, families financial well-being and our economy amid technological disruption. And whether or not Mr. Yang can convince enough of the electorate, he seems willing to not only explore the math, but the details beyond the numbers that might matter most.
Read the original post:
- Freedom is never defined as mob rule | Opinion - nj.com - May 19th, 2020
- American freedom was tug-of-war from the start - York Dispatch - May 19th, 2020
- Finding the balance between safety and freedom in the shadow of COVID-19 - VentureBeat - May 19th, 2020
- In time of quarantine, we must resist Grand Inquisitors view of freedom - Crux: Covering all things Catholic - May 19th, 2020
- Freedom Does Not Mean Being on the Loose - Psychiatric Times - May 19th, 2020
- The van gives me such freedom: Custom conversion gives Eugene woman wheels on which to roam - The Register-Guard - May 19th, 2020
- Freedom is Never Free - The Hudson Reporter - May 19th, 2020
- Germany's flag burning ban is a threat to freedom of expression - Spectator.co.uk - May 19th, 2020
- What will we do with the new freedom to shop and dine? - cleveland.com - May 19th, 2020
- What does freedom mean in this moment? - The Irish Times - May 19th, 2020
- Event captures memories of Freedom Riders' heroic journey between Anniston and Birmingham - Bham Now - May 19th, 2020
- Are Contact Tracing Apps the Key to Lockdown Freedom? - Redbrick - May 19th, 2020
- Hundreds expected to gather for local Faith & Freedom Rally - KDRV - May 19th, 2020
- Freedom of information laws 'have failed to keep pace with public services' - Aberdeen Evening Express - May 19th, 2020
- Captain Tom Moore receives Freedom award during City of London's first 'virtual' ceremony - FE News - May 11th, 2020
- Boris Johnson's roadmap to ease lockdown will start with more freedom to exercise and back-to-work moves from Wednesday - Telegraph.co.uk - May 11th, 2020
- God alone is the source of liberty and freedom - Akron Beacon Journal - May 11th, 2020
- 'Deadly Dictatorship': How Rodrigo Duterte Has Attacked Freedom of the Media in Latest Closure of Main Broadcaster - The National Interest - May 11th, 2020
- Conjure Women is a tale of slavery and its aftermath - The Economist - May 11th, 2020
- Freedom Haven Emergency Shelter and Transitional Living Home - - KUSI - May 11th, 2020
- Freedom Festival events postponed to 2021, firework show will be held - Deseret News - May 11th, 2020
- Granite State confined at home find freedom and calm in the garden - The Union Leader - May 11th, 2020
- MSNBC contributor: Americans 'freedom-obsessed' to point 'we're blind to other types of threats' | TheHill - The Hill - May 11th, 2020
- Faith and freedom of choice are key ingredients for parenting - The New Indian Express - May 11th, 2020
- Just after Elon Musk denounced coronavirus lockdowns as infringements of freedom, research shows Britons are too scared to leave their homes anyway -... - May 11th, 2020
- Another Freedom Square resident has died of COVID-19 in Pinellas - Tampa Bay Times - May 11th, 2020
- Celebrating freedom in the same garden 75 years on - Jersey Evening Post - May 11th, 2020
- Freedom Is An Issue That Stirs Voters - America's 1st Freedom - May 11th, 2020
- How You Can Advance the Cause of Reason and Freedom - New Ideal - May 11th, 2020
- As Spaniards got their first real taste of freedom this weekend, hundreds of them got arrested and thousands were fined - MarketWatch - May 11th, 2020
- Lockdown phase one freedoms in Spains holiday island Mallorca - Euro Weekly News - May 11th, 2020
- Book Review: America, Guns, and Freedom - Accuracy in Academia - April 27th, 2020
- Accountability goes hand-in-hand with personal freedom, especially during adversity - Green Bay Press Gazette - April 27th, 2020
- Letter to the editor: Freedom & rallies to reopen - TribLIVE - April 27th, 2020
- From The Editor: Barriers to Freedom - America's 1st Freedom - April 27th, 2020
- Freedom binds us all. Today is all about the greater good - News24 - April 27th, 2020
- Watchdog: Pandemic worsening threat to global media freedom - The Associated Press - April 27th, 2020
- Theodore Gaffney, who photographed the Freedom Riders as they protested segregation, dies of Covid-19 complications - CNN - April 27th, 2020
- This Week in Technology + Press Freedom: April 26, 2020 - Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press - April 27th, 2020
- 15:32 Armenia Ombudsman on freedom of expression in the country - Information-Analytic Agency NEWS.am - April 27th, 2020
- Protesting for the Freedom to Catch the Coronavirus - The New York Times - April 27th, 2020
- From lions to lambs: Covid-19 reveals supposedly freedom-loving British to be anything but, as we happily clap away our liberty - RT - April 27th, 2020
- Outrage as thousands abuse guidelines on first day of freedom - The Leader Newspaper Online - April 27th, 2020
- Freedom, the first casualty in Covid-19 war - Free Malaysia Today - April 27th, 2020
- Hazel C. Boone of Freedom Twp., OH - The Weekly Villager - April 27th, 2020
- Freedom Day: We have a way to go to be truly free - Daily Maverick - April 27th, 2020
- Whither freedom? - The News International - April 27th, 2020
- The rising cost of religious freedom in Vietnam | TheHill - The Hill - April 27th, 2020
- Calls for NHS workers to receive the Freedom of the Borough for their tireless bravery - Wrexham.com - April 27th, 2020
- Passover, Freedom and the Coronavirus | Clifford Rieders - The Times of Israel - April 11th, 2020
- Shaw warns that Freedom Mobile isn't adding as many customers as planned due to COVID-19 - CBC.ca - April 11th, 2020
- America Must Prove the Future Is Freedom - American Greatness - April 11th, 2020
- Israelis mark Passover, a celebration of freedom, in virtual isolation - Reuters - April 11th, 2020
- Eric Johnson on Breaking Patterns to Play with More Freedom - Premier Guitar - April 11th, 2020
- Freedom for man who killed brother in 1996 in argument over smoking - SILive.com - April 11th, 2020
- Whitmer issues order allowing delayed in-person processing of Freedom of Information Act requests - MLive.com - April 11th, 2020
- Wife of imprisoned former congressman cites COVID-19 risk in plea to Trump for husband's freedom | TheHill - The Hill - April 11th, 2020
- Freedom From Facebook Expands To Take On Google - Oakland News Now - April 11th, 2020
- Freedom in the time of COVID-19 - The New Indian Express - April 11th, 2020
- Dispute in Ireland over academic freedom and internationalization - Inside Higher Ed - April 11th, 2020
- Married With Kids: Freedom in the age of the coronavirus - Canadian Jewish News - April 11th, 2020
- 30 Years of Freedom: The Opposition Roundtable Laying the Groundwork for Democratic Hungary - Budapest Business Journal - April 11th, 2020
- The cost to freedom in the war against COVID-19 - Pursuit - April 11th, 2020
- Coronavirus has exposed the myth of British exceptionalism - The Guardian - April 11th, 2020
- Jennifer Kohan of Fellowship Freedom Plans selected as Top Director of the Year by the International Association of Top Professionals - TAPinto.net - March 4th, 2020
- Schools must earn the freedom to make decisions, says Premier - The Sydney Morning Herald - March 4th, 2020
- LETTERS TO THE EDITOR: Supporting freedom; part of the package; end death penalty - NWAOnline - March 4th, 2020
- Darmanovi on Freedom of Religion Act: No need for international arbitrage in Montenegro - European Western Balkans - March 4th, 2020
- Freedom Solar: record profits and growth in Texas residential and commercial PV - pv magazine USA - March 4th, 2020
- How Some Union Bosses Menace American Workers' Freedom - The National Interest Online - March 4th, 2020
- Ask a North Korean: can money buy freedom in the DPRK? - NK News - March 4th, 2020
- Freedom in the World 2020: Armenia and Artsakh rated as 'partly free' - - March 4th, 2020
- Freedom of movement could be retained in Scotland post-Brexit - The Scotsman - March 4th, 2020
- The Reverse Freedom Rides And Their Long Aftermath : Code Switch - NPR - March 4th, 2020
- Freedom boys hoops clips No. 1 seed Allen, is 1 win away from ending 44-year drought - lehighvalleylive.com - March 4th, 2020
- A Tweet Shows How Scared Gun-Control Activists are of Women and Minorities Enjoying Their Freedom - America's 1st Freedom - March 4th, 2020
- Sophie and Hans Scholl died resisting the Nazis. Let's not take freedom for granted - TheArticle - March 4th, 2020
- Tacky's Revolt review: Britain, Jamaica, slavery and an early fight for freedom - The Guardian - March 4th, 2020
- These Are the 10 'Most Urgent' Threats to Press Freedom in March 2020 - TIME - March 4th, 2020
- Submariners from HMS Vengeance and Bury sea cadets exercise Freedom of Bury St Edmunds with parade in town centre | Latest Suffolk and Essex News -... - March 4th, 2020