In the early hours this morning, after a flurry of last-minute filings, a divided Supreme Court cleared the way for federal executions to resume for the first time in nearly 20 years. According to news reports, the federal government then moved quickly to carry out an execution that had been scheduled for Monday afternoon, executing Daniel Lewis Lee at a federal prison in Indiana shortly after 8 a.m. EDT this morning.
The battle over the federal governments efforts to resume executions has been a hard-fought one for the last few months. Late last month, the justices declined to intervene in the dispute over the new lethal-injection protocol that the Department of Justice devised in order to avoid problems obtaining the drugs that have historically been used to put inmates to death. The court denied a request by four federal death-row inmates, including Lee, to review a ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit that upheld the new federal regulations for carrying out the death penalty. The decision by a divided three-judge panel had overturned a ruling by U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan, who held that federal law requires the government to carry out executions using precisely the same protocol as the state where the execution takes place.
Lee was scheduled to be executed Monday at 4 p.m. EDT for the 1996 murders of William and Nancy Mueller and Nancys daughter, eight-year-old Sarah Powell. After stealing approximately $50,000 worth of cash, guns and ammunition from the Muellers to fund a white supremacist movement, Lee and his accomplice shot the Muellers with a stun gun, placed plastic bags over their heads, and threw them into a bayou.
On July 10, a federal district court in Indiana put the execution on hold. The postponement came at the request of Earlene Peterson, the 80-year-old mother of Nancy Mueller, and other family members of the victims. The family members have long said Lee should not be executed, but they insisted that, if he were going to be executed, they wanted to attend the execution. In their request for a postponement, they argued that traveling to the prison to attend Lees execution during the COVID-19 pandemic would risk their health. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit lifted the district courts stay on July 12, prompting Peterson and the other family members to seek emergency relief at the Supreme Court on Monday.
In a 29-page filing, Peterson asked the justices to reinstate the district courts order blocking Lees execution until her right to safely travel and attend the execution during the resurgent pandemic can be adequately considered. Peterson suffers from congestive heart failure, while Monica Veillette, Nancy Muellers niece, has chronic asthma. They would have faced substantial risks from the unprecedented COVID-19 pandemic had they traveled to attend the execution as matters now stand, Peterson wrote, particularly when a staff member at the prison who has tested positive for COVID-19 was at the death chamber after he was exposed to the virus.
Peterson contended that the Supreme Court should intervene because it was likely to eventually grant review to weigh in on whether the federal government can disregard the rights of crime victims and their families to attend the execution. They are not trying, Peterson stressed, to dictate the Attorney Generals choice of a date for an execution. Instead, Peterson argued, the district courts decision simply would require the government to consider the danger to close family members of the victims from traveling and attending an execution to which they have already been invited. And if Lees execution goes forward as scheduled, when she cannot safely attend, Peterson concluded, she and her family members will effectively be denied their right to attend. By contrast, Peterson observed, there was no reason why the government had to go forward with Lees execution; there was no deadline, and it did not explain why a delay would cause any problems.
Lee also filed his own request on Monday asking the Supreme Court to put his execution on hold to give the justices time to review his appeal, which raised Sixth Amendment arguments and other issues. In a petition for review, Lee urged the justices to weigh in on whether federal laws governing post-conviction relief would allow him to challenge the adequacy of his trial lawyer.
Also on Monday, Chutkan again put the scheduled executions on hold. She concluded that Lee and other inmates with upcoming execution dates were likely to succeed on their claim the standard for temporary relief that the federal governments lethal-injection protocol violates the Eighth Amendments ban on cruel and unusual punishment. Among other things, she noted, the scientific evidence before the court overwhelmingly indicates that the protocol is very likely to cause Plaintiffs extreme pain and needless suffering during their executions. Moreover, she added, the inmates identified two other options that would reduce the risk of such serious pain: giving the inmate a dose of either pain medication or an anti-anxiety medication before the execution begins; or execution by firing squad. In the governments emergency appeal from Chutkans order, the D.C. Circuit late on Monday rejected the governments request to allow the executions to go forward and ordered the appeal to be fast-tracked.
Shortly before 4 p.m. EDT, when Lees execution was scheduled to take place, the federal government came to the Supreme Court, asking the justices to block Chutkans order or lift it altogether. In a filing signed by Acting U.S. Solicitor General Jeffrey Wall, the government complained about the last-minute nature of the order, writing that the justices should not permit such tactics. But more broadly, the government continued, Chutkans order was meritless and highly unlikely to survive on appeal. The order, the government argued, turns on a profound misunderstanding of this Courts Eighth Amendment jurisprudence. It also would produce the implausible results that huge numbers of recent state executions have violated the Constitution and would convert courts into precisely the kinds of boards of inquiry refereeing battles of the experts this Court has repeatedly made clear they are not, the government said.
At approximately 2 a.m. EDT, the Supreme Court issued a trio of rulings. In an unsigned three-page opinion, by a vote of 5-4, the justices granted the governments request to lift Chutkans order and allow the executions to proceed. Stressing that the inmates claim that the governments lethal-injection protocol violates the Eighth Amendment faces an exceedingly high bar, the court explained that the inmates had not shown that they are likely to succeed on that claim. The Supreme Court, the opinion noted, has yet to hold that a States method of execution qualifies as cruel and unusual, in all likelihood because states have generally tried to make their methods of execution more humane, rather than more painful. And although the inmates have presented evidence suggesting that pentobarbital, the drug that the federal government has selected for its lethal-injection protocol, will cause the inmate to experience a form of respiratory distress that temporarily produces the sensation of drowning or asphyxiation, the government has countered that such a condition occurs only after the inmate has become unconscious or dies. The court emphasized that last-minute intervention like Chutkans Monday-morning order should be the extreme exception, not the norm. It is our responsibility, the court concluded, to ensure that method-of-execution challenges to lawfully issued sentences are resolved fairly and expeditiously, so that the question of capital punishment can remain with the people and their representatives, not the courts, to resolve.
Justice Stephen Breyer dissented from the courts ruling, in an opinion joined by Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Lees case, Breyer argued, illustrates at least some of the problems the death penalty raises in light of the Constitutions prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment. Lee spent over 20 years on death row, Breyer noted, which can cause severe psychological suffering and undermine the penological rationale for the death penalty. Moreover, Breyer continued, the death penalty is often imposed arbitrarily: Lees accomplice received a life sentence even though he committed the same crime. And there are significant questions regarding the constitutionality of the lethal-injection protocol that the federal government has adopted for the executions of Lee and other federal prisoners. Because the resumption of federal executions promises to provide examples that illustrate the difficulties of administering the death penalty consistent with the Constitution, Breyer reiterated his view that the solution may be for this Court to directly examine the question whether the death penalty violates the Constitution.
Justice Sonia Sotomayor also filed a dissenting opinion, which was joined by Ginsburg and Justice Elena Kagan. She warned that the majority had set a dangerous precedent by granting the governments request to allow the executions to proceed. In accepting the governments artificial claim of urgency to truncate ordinary procedures of judicial review, Sotomayor cautioned, there will be no meaningful judicial review of the grave, fact-heavy challenges respondents bring to the way in which the Government plans to execute them. She noted that when the Supreme Court denied a government request to allow executions to go forward late last year, three of her colleagues Justices Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh observed that in light of what is at stake, it would be preferable for the D.C. Circuit to review the district courts decision on the merits before the federal government could carry out the executions. And more broadly, Sotomayor noted that the court was again granting what she described as an emergency application from the Government for extraordinary relief, resulting in the most irreparable of harms without the deliberation such an action warrants.
At the same time that the court granted the governments request to lift the stay that Chutkan imposed, it also denied in brief orders, without any noted dissents the requests by Peterson and Lee to postpone Lees execution. According to CNN, Lee was pronounced dead at 8:07 a.m. EDT in Terre Haute, Indiana.
The justices did not act on a separate request by the government to allow the execution of Wesley Purkey, scheduled for Wednesday afternoon, to go forward. The 7th Circuit put Purkeys execution on hold earlier this month.
This post was originally published atHowe on the Court.
Posted in Lee v. Watson, Peterson v. Barr, Barr v. Lee, Featured, Capital Cases
Recommended Citation: Amy Howe, In overnight orders, justices allow federal execution to proceed, SCOTUSblog (Jul. 14, 2020, 11:00 AM), https://www.scotusblog.com/2020/07/in-overnight-orders-justices-allow-federal-execution-to-proceed/
Read the original post:
In overnight orders, justices allow federal execution to proceed - SCOTUSblog
- Peterson-Warren Academy : Peterson-Warren Academy Inkster MI - February 6th, 2018 [February 6th, 2018]
- Oscar Peterson - Wikipedia - February 6th, 2018 [February 6th, 2018]
- Peterson Pipes (#1 in Amazing Selection!) Fast/Free Shipping - March 6th, 2018 [March 6th, 2018]
- Peterson Cat - Caterpillar Equipment Dealer - March 6th, 2018 [March 6th, 2018]
- Fort Mill, SC: Peterson Law Firm PA - March 19th, 2018 [March 19th, 2018]
- New Evidence In Laci Peterson Case May Prove Her Husband ... - May 12th, 2018 [May 12th, 2018]
- Welcome to Peterson Machinery Sales - June 6th, 2018 [June 6th, 2018]
- Peterson Law Firm PA | Fort Mill, SC - June 6th, 2018 [June 6th, 2018]
- Lamont Peterson - Next Fight, Fighter Bio, Stats & News - August 7th, 2018 [August 7th, 2018]
- Drew Peterson - Murderer - Biography - August 7th, 2018 [August 7th, 2018]
- Welcome to Congressman Collin Peterson | Congressman Collin ... - August 7th, 2018 [August 7th, 2018]
- Peterson Kraemer Funeral Homes & Crematory Inc. :: Home - August 7th, 2018 [August 7th, 2018]
- Home - Lighthouse Public Affairs, LLC - November 9th, 2018 [November 9th, 2018]
- Dr. Paul Peterson, MD - Book an Appointment - Knoxville, TN - December 8th, 2018 [December 8th, 2018]
- Brave Wilderness - YouTube - January 3rd, 2019 [January 3rd, 2019]
- Careers - Home - Peterson and Control Union - Peterson and ... - January 3rd, 2019 [January 3rd, 2019]
- The Intellectual We Deserve | Current Affairs - February 12th, 2019 [February 12th, 2019]
- Paterson, New Jersey - Wikipedia - March 8th, 2019 [March 8th, 2019]
- Welcome to Congressman Collin Peterson | Congressman ... - March 28th, 2019 [March 28th, 2019]
- Peterson - Pipedia - April 20th, 2019 [April 20th, 2019]
- Careers - Peterson and Control Union - Peterson and Control Union - April 20th, 2019 [April 20th, 2019]
- EXCLUSIVE: Jordan Peterson film cancelled in Canadian movie theatre - The Post Millennial - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- Adrian Peterson moves to fifth in all-time NFL rushing TDs - 247Sports - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- Kansas City Chiefs reportedly no longer pursuing Patrick Peterson or Jalen Ramsey - Blasting News United States - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- JetBlue Chairman Joel Peterson: Why we need a movement to learn how to listen without an agenda - Thrive Global - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- Afflicted by 'inner voice of reason' council declines to censure Peterson - Banning Record Gazette - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- Terry McLaurin impresses future Hall of Famer Adrian Peterson - 247Sports - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- Police haven't caught his sister's killer, so Ed Peterson is trying to solve the case himself - Yahoo News Canada - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- Gary Peterson: Giants pitcher Barry Zito rooted against his own teammates in 2010 postseason before saving their bacon in 2012 - Fairfield Daily... - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- Jesse Lee Peterson: Satan Controlled the Pastor Who Died of Suicide - Patheos - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- University of Iowa loses another diversity director - The Gazette - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- Peterson doesn't sound bothered by lesser role, for now - NBCSports.com - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- Jerry "Pete" Levern Peterson - WISC - Channel3000.com - WISC-TV3 - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- Congressman Collin Peterson on Farm Bill & payments for farmers: "You can't do this with just one party." - KFGO News - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- OU football: Adrian Peterson passes Jim Brown, Kyler Murray plays Marquise Brown, Sooners in the NFL week 2 - The Oklahoma Daily - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- A personal perspective on Jordan B. Peterson's psychology - The Justice - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- Jordan Peterson documentary shut out of Toronto cinema, say filmmakers - Toronto Star - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- UI Diversity Director Tracy Peterson leaves for Penn State - UI The Daily Iowan - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- Elvira Performer Cassandra Peterson Reflects on Her Legacy and Teases Her Upcoming Projects - Comicbook.com - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- Jesse Lee Peterson: A True Christian Is Never Depressed - Patheos - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- NFL rumors: Redskins' Jay Gruden's comments on Adrian Peterson hint at tension in relationship - NJ.com - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- Peterson to fifth on all-time rushing TD list - ESPN - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- Unbeaten Joey Davis meets Jeff Peterson at Bellator 229 - MMA Fighting - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- JetBlues Chairman Reveals 6 Ways To Communicate A Compelling Mission To Motivate Your Team - Forbes - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- Peterson AFB hosts annual Prisoners of War/Missing in Action remembrance ceremony - KRDO - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- Peterson reflects on passing Jim Brown on the all-time TD list - NBCSports.com - September 20th, 2019 [September 20th, 2019]
- George Hulstrand Jr.: Collin Peterson's opponent will face a fight - West Central Tribune - October 7th, 2019 [October 7th, 2019]
- Peterson: Iowa State checks all the important boxes after beating TCU - Des Moines Register - October 7th, 2019 [October 7th, 2019]
- Former Idaho state budget director charged with sexual exploitation of a minor - East Idaho News - October 7th, 2019 [October 7th, 2019]
- Jordan Peterson, Nietzsche, and Avoiding Living for Happiness Alone - Merion West - October 7th, 2019 [October 7th, 2019]
- Bird Droppings: Arizona Cardinals loss to 49ers, Patrick Peterson off the field and more news from around the - Revenge of the Birds - November 8th, 2019 [November 8th, 2019]
- Man pulled from water off Marco defies odds and lives - Wink News - November 8th, 2019 [November 8th, 2019]
- Kliff Kingsbury expects Patrick Peterson to be great vs. Buccaneers - Cards Wire - November 8th, 2019 [November 8th, 2019]
- Minn. US Rep Peterson waiting to announce if he's running - Albany Times Union - November 8th, 2019 [November 8th, 2019]
- Congressman Collin Peterson explains impeachment vote: "I don't believe we should be doing this without Republican support." - KFGO News - November 8th, 2019 [November 8th, 2019]
- What Collin Peterson Is Up To (2019-11-20) - Pop Top News - November 21st, 2019 [November 21st, 2019]
- Unfalsifiability and Evolution | Dan Peterson - Patheos - November 21st, 2019 [November 21st, 2019]
- Peterson: Camping World Bowl actually thought it had Iowa State football team and fans last year - Des Moines Register - November 21st, 2019 [November 21st, 2019]
- WIAA D2 swim: Peterson carries the torch for the EagleJays - Daily Union - November 21st, 2019 [November 21st, 2019]
- 400 cadets at the Air Force Academy have had symptoms of Norovirus since October - KKTV 11 News - November 21st, 2019 [November 21st, 2019]
- Athletics: Warrior athletes have their signing day - Brainerd Dispatch - November 21st, 2019 [November 21st, 2019]
- Adrian Peterson only active RB on all-time team finalists - Yahoo Sports - November 21st, 2019 [November 21st, 2019]
- There does seem to be something special about science - Patheos - November 25th, 2019 [November 25th, 2019]
- Australian Michael Peterson forced to celebrate wifes birthday from behind bars in Bali - PerthNow - November 25th, 2019 [November 25th, 2019]
- Jordan Peterson: Why the Western emphasis on individuals is the ultimate in intersectionality - National Post - November 25th, 2019 [November 25th, 2019]
- Former AG Woods to lead probe of suspended assessor Peterson - Arizona Capitol Times - November 25th, 2019 [November 25th, 2019]
- Noelle Broughton chooses her own adventure as the Peterson fellow in the Indianapolis mayor's office - IU Newsroom - November 25th, 2019 [November 25th, 2019]
- Patrick Peterson is Projected to Be the #161 DB the Rest of the 2019 Season... Keep on the Waiver Wire - Scout - November 25th, 2019 [November 25th, 2019]
- 'I think it'll help': City plans to install traffic lights at Dublin and Peterson - KKTV 11 News - November 25th, 2019 [November 25th, 2019]
- Adrian Peterson not selected to the NFLs All-Time Team - The Viking Age - November 25th, 2019 [November 25th, 2019]
- Peterson: Iowa State recruiting is still about turning three-star recruits into five-star players - Des Moines Register - December 18th, 2019 [December 18th, 2019]
- Champaign moms to open preschool that will 'immerse children in nature, play' - Champaign/Urbana News-Gazette - December 18th, 2019 [December 18th, 2019]
- OU football: Kyler Murray beats Baker Mayfield, Adrian Peterson breaks a record, more Sooners in the NFL week 15 - The Oklahoma Daily - December 18th, 2019 [December 18th, 2019]
- Justice for Kona: Puppy Station in Post Oak Mall closed in wake of lawsuit - KAGSTV.com - December 18th, 2019 [December 18th, 2019]
- Patrick Peterson says he will be back with the Cardinals in 2020 - ClutchPoints - December 18th, 2019 [December 18th, 2019]
- 'The Irishman' costume designers Sandy Powell and Christopher Peterson on working with Martin Scorsese - Screen International - December 18th, 2019 [December 18th, 2019]
- These Are The Democrats Who Voted Against Impeaching President Trump - BuzzFeed News - December 18th, 2019 [December 18th, 2019]
- Peterson, a Gretna resident, outskates the competition for the game she loves - Omaha World-Herald - December 18th, 2019 [December 18th, 2019]
- AP's road to 1000 yards is hard, but doable - NBCSports.com - December 18th, 2019 [December 18th, 2019]
- Hosey: Where in the world is Drew Peterson? - DeKalb Daily Chronicle - December 26th, 2019 [December 26th, 2019]