In the wake of a mass movement against racial injustice and police brutality in America, affiliates of Stanford Medical School are speaking up about their experiences with institutionalized racism in the field of medicine and championing diversity initiatives at Stanford.
Students from underrepresented minority groups make up 20% of all graduate students at Stanford and 6% of all postdoctoral scholars at the School of Medicine. Similarly, underrepresented minorities make up 6% of professoriate faculty and 13% of staff.
Associate Dean of the Office of Student Medical Affairs Mijiza Sanchez-Guzman, who serves on the School of Medicines diversity cabinet, said that being one of few people of color in a department is a common source of anxiety for many underrepresented minorities in medicine.
Theres not a lot of us in the field, and so for the ones of us that are here, theres a minority tax, Sanchez-Guzman said. Its the stress of having to serve on every committee and having to do everything its a lot, its a burden.
A leaky recruitment pipeline
Affiliates cited recruiting as a pivotal step towards fostering a diverse and inclusive environment, stressing the importance of starting at the application process.
There is a leaky pipeline when it comes to education leading to the field of medicine, Clinical Assistant Professor of Pediatrics Lahia Yemane told The Daily. There are many points where we are losing folks from underrepresented backgrounds. It goes back all the way to what your teachers are telling you that you can and cannot do in elementary school.
She added that bias and racism in college advising contribute to racial disparities in medicine.
There are a lot of people who start out as pre-med and drop out, Yemane said. Unfortunately many of these end up being minority students because they are faced with barriers to succeeding. Advisors are the gatekeepers and often tell students when they get a B or C on that test that they shouldnt be pre-med anymore.
Yemane told The Daily that these barriers include academic backgrounds that do not prepare minority students for college pre-med classes, financial barriers and racial stereotypes that peg these students as weak.
Medical school and medical training are in general very expensive, Yemane said. That in and of itself is a deterrence. To make a commitment to medical school, there are enormous costs.
The price of medical school is apparent as early as the application process; both medical school programs and residency programs often require applicants to fly to campus for in-person interviews, which can end up costing thousands of dollars. According to Yemane, this is emblematic of the process and the result: most medical students come from families from the top two quintiles for income status.
The system is not set up for folks that dont have a lot of money, and theres bias through each step of the process, Yemane said.
School of Medicine Scholar in Residence Arghavan Salles M.D. 06 Ph.D. 14 echoed Yemane in saying, There are a lot of factors that make it so that the people going into medicine are the same group over and over again.
You have to fly to every interview on your own budget and stay at a hotel. And of course its very competitive so people go to as many interviews as they can. All of that creates barriers for people who dont come from wealthy families, she added.
Sanchez-Guzman pointed out that at Stanford, potential students also have to worry about studying in a place with high housing and living costs.
Students and residents alike say, I dont know if I could afford to live here on a resident salary, and thats real, Sanchez-Guzman said. As administrators we can try to work with University leaders and offset or subsidize some of these burdens, but due to the high cost of living in the Bay Area its ultimately out of our control.
However, she said, this does not mean that the University should give up.
Recruitment is paramount because when people from underrepresented backgrounds can see themselves here, theyre more likely to want to come here, Sanchez-Guzman added.
When they see people who look like them thriving, not being burdened by being on every diversity committee, and living their best lives, they are likely to think, okay, I could see myself there. And often that is what makes the difference.
Salles said that medical institutions need to do a better job of reaching out to traditionally underrepresented communities in order to select diverse applicants from a pool of potential students or faculty members.
We have a huge challenge recruiting Native people, Salles told The Daily. The percentage of faculty across the country in academic medicine who are indigenous is less than 1% of all faculty, and Black and Latinx faculty members are each only 2% of our total population.
She noted that these statistics pale in comparison to the make up of the national population, which is 13% Black and 18% Latinx.
We have either not made the career welcoming to people who are not White or Asian, or we have not removed barriers for those people to get into the profession, Salles concluded.
You cant be what you cant see, Yemane added.
Cultural change must follow
Affiliates stressed that the recruitment process is only the first step. Cultural change must follow.
We need to figure out a way to make sure that people who are coming in with a different perspective actually feel included, Salles said. Recruiting people who look different is a challenge but its not insurmountable there are excellent candidates at every level. But those people come to the institution, and if the culture around them expects them to fit in to be just like everybody else, thats where the diversity fails. Theres a common saying that diversity without inclusion is really exclusion, and I think thats what were seeing at a lot of places.
Its one thing to get people through the door, but its another to have them stay and really feel valued, Yemane added.
Affiliates said that a true culture shift will only come when the University takes proactive measures towards progress, such as pipeline programs and supporting existing diverse faculty and students. .
Id rather work more proactively rather than reactionary, Sanchez-Guzman said. I feel like a lot of work that weve been doing is in response to whats happening in the community and the country rather than just doing what we should be doing.
This issue obviously started over four-hundred years ago, Yemane said. And now its not that there has to be a tragedy for us to do something. We already know that discrimination is happening and we need to be figuring out how can we as an academic institution do better.
Fifth-year medical student Osama El-Gabalaway B.A 15 M.S 16, who is the outgoing chair of Stanford University Minority Medical Alliance (SUMMA) added that the Universitys reaction should be thoughtful and inclusive.
After tragic crises boil over the country or locally, the University twiddles its thumbs, and puts out half-baked PR statements, El-Gabalway said. One of our goals is to bring the stakeholders into the room where the decisions are made. For example, if there is a Muslim ban, the University should bring Muslim facutly and students to the table and center their voices.
A history of racism, pushed under the carpet
Affiliates said that the University could not succeed in creating a diverse and inclusive environment without acknowledging and addressing the legacy of racism in modern medicine.
We want anti-racist history within medicine, El-Gabalway said. Every section of the curriculum should dedicate time to the history of exploitation of people of color.
He pointed to the Tuskegee Syphilis Study, in which researchers experimented on Black men, intentionally withholding treatment from a control group, and the forced sterilization of indigenous communities as evidence of what he calls a discipline built on exploiting minorities.
Sometimes they say oh a risk factor for this disease is race, El-Gabalway said. But its not race its racism that creates the health disparities. That gets kind of pushed under the carpet here. Theres huge amounts of historic distrust and huge amounts of health disparities, so without Black doctors and people within the institution fighting for the change that they know their communities need, none of that trust can be restored or fixed.
Programmingto process and heal
Many affiliates have taken matters into their own hands, championing their own diversity initiatives at Stanford. El-Gabalway said that progress was often frustratingly slow in his experience fighting for an inclusive curriculum and diversity resources and funding.
El-Gabalaway was one of many students who advocated for the Diversity Center of Representation and Empowerment, or D-CORE, which provides a space where any member of the Stanford Medicine community interested in issues of inclusion and diversity can hold meetings or just hang out and study, according to the D-CORE website.
The D-CORE came on the heels of the last BLM wave, El-Gabalway said. There were a ton of notes that were shared between Ph.D. students, masters students and medical students, and these groups joined and put together a proposal of 10 points for the administration.
One of these points, El-Gabalway said was a physical space on campus for students of color in the medical school to congregate and organize.
Other requests outlined in the October of 2016 letter included hiring a full-time Chief Diversity Officer, mandatory diversity training for all community members and a published strategy for recruiting more faculty members form underrepresented groups.
Dean Minor responded to the letter by implementing the D-CORE over the course of the 2016-2017 school year, officially opening the space in October of 2017.
While the D-CORE was a success for student advocates, securing funding presented more of a challenge, El-Gabalway said.
There were points where we ended up having to beg from different departments, which was a painful, slow, labor-intensive and arduous process, El-Gabalway added.
He added that advocates have experienced pushback when asking for pay for students who are working on fostering diversity and inclusion.
The burden is on the students to make change, El-Gabalway told The Daily. The challenge is getting the University to compensate students who often go unpaid for the labor they put into this.
Every time we bring this up, the administration says, your payoff is seeing this place become a better school, El Gabalway continued. And while that seems nice thats not really a sustainable method. The administration makes students put in all the work and when things go bad, the students take the fall.
They are using students to shield themselves from the really hard responsibility of creating sustainable change, El Gabalway added.
Community members have also been working to foster diversity at the residency level. Yemane is the co-director of Stanford Medicine Leadership Education and Advancing Diversity (LEAD), a program she helped found in 2017 with the goal of creating diverse leadership at Stanford Medicine through training and mentorship.
The 10 month program meets once a month for two hours. In this time, residents engage in case-based discussions, attend interactive lectures on diversity and leadership and work in small groups to create workshops with the values of equity and inclusion in mind. Past group projects include designing curriculum about Limited English Proficiency (LEP) patients and researching implicit bias in performance evaluations.
The program started in the Department of Pediatrics, but expanded to other departments very quickly, doubling in size to 25 departments after a year. by the second year
Every year as we get bigger and bring in more folks, we also bring in a sense of community, Yemane said.
Yemane says that the program also provides students with the opportunity to share personal stories of microaggressions and discriminating, allowing them to process and heal.
A marathon, not a sprint
As an avenue for making progress towards fostering an inclusive culture, Salles has championed creating an accessible and streamlined process for reporting incidents of discrimination.
These issues are very complicated because if you think about just one incident where something inappropriate is said to someone, reporting those types of incidents is not straightforward and often does not benefit the person who is doing the reporting, Salles said.
As long as that continues to be the case, people will be hesitant to report, and as long as people arent reporting we dont know whats happening. If we dont know whats happening, we cant make change, she added.
She argued that appointing a diversity officer or commissioning a committee to look into discrimination was not enough to eradicate racism and other forms of discrimination.
When incidents happen, the University creates commissions and task forces and committees hoping that something comes out of those, but these bodies arent always empowered to make change, Salles told The Daily. People often create a Chief Diversity Officer role and they think that dedicating salary to a human is going to solve the problem, but that one person cannot change the culture of an institution.
Salles added that these commissions need to include diverse perspectives.
We see a lot of people creating committees or task forces where they dont include people from all different backgrounds, so we need to make sure theres diversity at each level Salles said. The more we can take into account different perspectives the better the solutions will be.
Affiliates also stressed the importance of mentorship.
In many places they just match new hires up with people in their department, and although they have something in common, its hard for them to speak freely because those are the same people that are going to be involved in assessing them for a promotion or a performance review, Salles said.
Thats why its so important to help people from underrepresented backgrounds identify mentors who understand University policies and procedures, she added. Black and Latinx faculty dont get promoted at the same rate as white faculty, so helping people understand early on what milestones they need to meet for promotion would be really helpful.
Mentorship is one of the big keys to helping keep people of color and underrepresented in medicine folks in academic medicine, Sanchez-Guzman added.
El-Gabalway called upon the University to implement mandatory anti-racism training and fully-funded diversity positions as integral solutions.
When the School of Medicine was trying to devise a split curriculum, they brought in consultants and experts and did paid focus groups, El-Gabalway said. So we know theyre capable of doing things, and we want them to attack anti-racism training with the same rigor and same funding that they do with other things.
El-Gabalway requested research assistantships within the Center of Excellence and Diversity in Medical Education, funded teaching assistantships and funding for student research projects that explore racism in the field of medicine.
University President Marc Tessier-Lavigne recently announced a number of initiatives intended to combat anti-Black racism at Stanford, including new diversity and inclusion fellowships and added support for research on race.
The University releases metrics, but doesnt act upon them, El-Gabalway told The Daily. We want them to present precise strategies. They love the term precision medicine and we want them to weaponize that term to attack the lack of Black and minority faculty with the same rigor as other issues. We want to see them attack retaining faculty of color.
Finally, El-Gabalway asked the School of Medicine to provide mental health support for Black and other minority trainees.
Oftentimes, even after George Floyd, we were using Black faculty we know to do healing circles, El Galabaway continued. They do that out of labor of love, but we want that to be compensated because. Its not fair that we expect Black faculty to do these tasks without compensation or recognition for what that is worth.
Yemane stressed the importance of capitalizing on this time in history at which equity and inclusion are at the center of discourse.
We need to be sure to not lose this moment and to really affect change, she said. A lot of people of color are cautiously optimistic right now. Its nice to hear the words, but we want to hear that there is true action and change. This is a marathon, not a sprint, and to really be anti-riacst is going to take active work.
Salles echoed Yemane, stressing substance over form.
Its really important for people at the top of an organization to not just say the right thing but to really be devoted to these problems, Salles said. That dictates the culture of the organization all the way down. When people see someone saying the right things but never doing the right things, then they dont really believe that that person is truly committed to that issue.
That feeling of it being disingenuous is really damaging to minoritized groups or marginalized groups.
She concluded by arguing that diversity and equity are important because they empower institutions to work at their best.
I think that were seeing more and more that ultimately having a workforce that is diverse is the best way to deliver care, Salles said. Even if all you care about is providing quality care to patients, you have to realize that having a diverse workforce is key to that mission.
Contact Sarina Deb at sdeb7 at stanford.edu
Continue reading here:
- 5 ways the pandemic may transform medical education - American Medical Association - October 8th, 2020
- Trump doctor Conley degree from Philadelphia College of Osteopathic Medicine: What it means - On top of Philly news - Billy Penn - October 8th, 2020
- Students Share Medical School Details You Won't Find Anywhere Else | University of Michigan - Michigan Medicine - October 8th, 2020
- In a First, New England Journal of Medicine Joins Never-Trumpers - The New York Times - October 8th, 2020
- Brown University Medical School Dean to Lead Second Session of Five-Part Virtual Future of Medicine Summit : SF STAT! - South Florida Hospital News - October 8th, 2020
- Human brain dissected live in front of medical school students - The Argus - October 8th, 2020
- After 40 years in medicine, here's what a Maine addiction expert has learned about alcohol, opioids and public health - Bangor Daily News - October 8th, 2020
- Trumps Lying Personal Physician And Dr. Umar Johnson Went To The Same Med School - News One - October 8th, 2020
- Study Finds Older Adults Using Cannabis to Treat Common Health Conditions - UC San Diego Health - October 8th, 2020
- U of M Medical School Researchers Found Traces Of COVID-19 On Beaches - FOX 21 Online - October 8th, 2020
- My Body, Whose Choice? - The Regulatory Review - October 8th, 2020
- American Sign Language and the Power of Communication - Pager Publications, Inc. - October 8th, 2020
- Experimental COVID-19 Treatment Given To President Trump Part of Study At U of M Medical School - FOX 21 Online - October 8th, 2020
- Trump Returns Home After Downplaying Disease, but Doctor Says He Isnt Out of the Woods - The New York Times - October 8th, 2020
- Texas doctor, 28, dies of Covid: 'She wore the same mask for weeks, if not months' - The Guardian - October 8th, 2020
- Nobel awarded to Charles Rice for hepatitis C discoveries at Washington University School of Medicine Washington University School of Medicine -... - October 8th, 2020
- Warrior M.D. Chat: What to Expect - School of Medicine - Wayne State University - The South End - October 8th, 2020
- Hershey Medical Center: Celebrating 50 years of people helping people - Penn State News - October 8th, 2020
- UMass Medical School-affiliated study finds federal rule will negatively impact immigrant health care - Worcester Business Journal - October 1st, 2020
- Medical school class writes own Hippocratic Oath acknowledging racism, Covid-19 deaths and the killing of Breonna Taylor - CNN - October 1st, 2020
- Just what the doctor ordered - Isaac accepted to med school - Jamaica Gleaner - October 1st, 2020
- These medical students just wrote their own Hippocratic oath. Here's what it says. - The Daily Briefing - October 1st, 2020
- Maryland researchers identify what works to help children avoid obesity - WTOP - October 1st, 2020
- Call It What It Is in-Training, the online peer-reviewed publication for medical students - Pager Publications, Inc. - October 1st, 2020
- Medical Education market seeking excellent growth | Stanford University School of Medicine, GE Healthcare Institute, Zimmer Biomet Institute, Olympus... - October 1st, 2020
- Political newcomer Cameron Webb looks beyond party in 5th District bid - Fauquier Times - October 1st, 2020
- Irregular periods linked to a greater risk of an early death, study suggests - CNN - October 1st, 2020
- This biologist helped trace SARS to bats. Now, he's working to uncover the origins of COVID-19 - Science Magazine - October 1st, 2020
- How This NYC Bill Would Address Harassment And Discrimination In Healthcare - Forbes - October 1st, 2020
- To deal with the A levels fiasco fallout, medical schools need a cash injection - Times Higher Education (THE) - September 8th, 2020
- Mercer University Breaks Ground on New Medical School Campus in Columbus - Mercer News - September 8th, 2020
- COVID-19-induced 'sophomore medical student syndrome' | TheHill - The Hill - September 8th, 2020
- New crop of medical students are headed to the lab - Stanford Medical Center Report - September 8th, 2020
- U of M Medical School researchers look to beach water for COVID community infection - KARE11.com - September 8th, 2020
- When's the right time to choose a medical specialty? - American Medical Association - September 8th, 2020
- Gujarat medical school to carry out autopsies of COVID-19 victims to study effects on body - Republic World - Republic World - September 8th, 2020
- Durham student with dreams of med school wins $100,000 in lottery game - WRAL.com - September 8th, 2020
- How to help medical students keep tabs on their mental health - American Medical Association - September 8th, 2020
- Industry VoicesCould less emphasis on the MCAT bring more diversity to medicine? - FierceHealthcare - September 8th, 2020
- Medical exams postponed amid strike and resurgent virus - University World News - September 8th, 2020
- TCOM creates office of student success - fortworthbusiness.com - September 8th, 2020
- COVID-19 Disproportionately Impacting Those With Developmental Disabilities - Disability Scoop - September 8th, 2020
- Med Students 'Feel Very Behind' Because of COVID-Induced Disruptions in Training - The Southern Maryland Chronicle - September 8th, 2020
- A bill would spend $1 billion on diversifying medical schools to close the racial health gap - NBC News - August 10th, 2020
- Pandemic acts as dress rehearsal for new medical school curriculum - Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis - August 10th, 2020
- The Unnamed Hero - Pager Publications, Inc. - August 10th, 2020
- Testing is the key to a successful fall reopening on campuses (opinion) - Inside Higher Ed - August 10th, 2020
- TUNE IN: Alexandria Addressing Back-to-School Worries in Virtual Town Hall - The Zebra - August 10th, 2020
- Community Healthcare honored during National Health Center Week - Times Record News - August 10th, 2020
- When Things Arent OK With a Childs Mental Health - The New York Times - August 10th, 2020
- Making sure patients, physicians know about the advances in treating female cancers - Norton Healthcare - August 10th, 2020
- 'We Are Here to Help Them' | Harvard Medical School - Harvard Medical School - August 10th, 2020
- In the face of challenges posed by a pandemic and racism, the White Coat Ceremony underscores the importance of our shared humanity - AAMC - August 10th, 2020
- Physician Group Wants Medical Schools To Waive The MCAT This Year - Physicians News Digest - August 10th, 2020
- Born with 1 hand, she's an inspiration in virus fight - ABC News - August 10th, 2020
- What to Expect in Medical School - AAMC for Students ... - August 8th, 2020
- International med students ease the path for others with new mentor group - STAT - August 8th, 2020
- Texas schools reopening mandate sets off another local control debate - The Texas Tribune - August 8th, 2020
- Amid COVID-19 Pandemic, Morehouse School of Medicine Welcomes Its... - Diverse: Issues in Higher Education - August 8th, 2020
- Guntersville native joins Andrews Sports med team | Free Share - Sand Mountain Reporter - August 8th, 2020
- COVID-19 changing study of medicine on Long Island - Newsday - August 8th, 2020
- Health Care Workers Of Color Nearly Twice As Likely As Whites To Get COVID-19 - WUSF News - August 8th, 2020
- Dancing Wildcats Enjoy Smoother Transition to the Field of Medicine - UKNow - August 8th, 2020
- Kindness is the best medicine - Argus Leader - August 8th, 2020
- Kindness is the best medicine | Coronavirus | rocketminer.com - Daily Rocket Miner - August 8th, 2020
- With academic health center, the imagined can be reality - Las Vegas Sun - August 8th, 2020
- Need to Take the MCAT? You'll Still Have to Do It in Person - The New York Times - August 8th, 2020
- Why isn't ventilation part of the conversation on reopening schools? - STAT - August 8th, 2020
- A UT undergrad helped build the app that will assist students coming back to school this fall. Here's what it can do. - UT News | The University of... - August 8th, 2020
- Med School Professor Removed from Fellowship Director Post, Apparently for Publishing Anti-Affirmative-Action Journal Article - Reason - August 7th, 2020
- Good Shepherd celebrates one of it's first graduates on track to realize dream of becoming doctor - WDSU New Orleans - August 7th, 2020
- Change the course of the pandemic: UMass Medical School, Boston tech company at center of national push to - MassLive.com - August 7th, 2020
- Duality Health Begins Rapid Blockchain Innovation Cycle with Health Product Innovation Team at Dell Medical School - Tyler Morning Telegraph - August 7th, 2020
- Deciding whether to send your child back to school? Heres what the experts say to consider - nj.com - August 7th, 2020
- Kaine introduces bill that would support medical schools in underserved areas - WDVM 25 - August 4th, 2020
- International medical school graduates need an easier path to practice in the US | TheHill - The Hill - August 4th, 2020
- The 'dura mater' handles medical training and motherhood with aplomb - DePauw University - August 4th, 2020
- Emory University doctor and former teacher suggests staggered starts, plexiglass lunch barriers to avoid COVID-19 spread in schools - 11Alive.com WXIA - August 4th, 2020
- President Houshmand and CMSRU Dean Reboli named to South Jersey BIZ Power 50 list - Rowan Today - August 4th, 2020
- 'Its a good mix of medicine and social justice': Medical student gets experience at NATIVE Project during pandemic - The Spokesman-Review - August 4th, 2020