We can have beautiful cities without turning our cities into surveillance cities.
Cities across the U.S. are forcing operators of shared bikes and scooters to use dangerous and privacy invasive APIs developed by the Los Angeles Department of Transportation. These APIscollectively called the mobility data specification, or MDSrequire that operators share granular location data on every trip taken. The location data that cities are demanding is incredibly sensitive and relates to the movements of real people. And some cities, like Los Angeles and soon Santa Monica and Washington, D.C., even require that the data be shared with a five-second delayessentially in real-time.
The local authorities demanding access to individual trip data are failing to comply with existing privacy protections in the law. Meanwhile, cities cannot point to even a single use case to show why they need access to the individual level trip data. That means cities are recklessly and illegally stockpiling sensitive location data that they do not need.
As City Labs recent investigative deep-dive into MDS reports, LADOTs APIs were designed to enable cities to operate as the air traffic controllers of our streetsto send out real-time route instructions and control the path of individual vehicles. That vision is not only unrealistic, but it would necessitate real-time surveillance of all of our movements on city streets, no matter our mode of transportation. What some cities are trying to paint as a vision of a future utopia is actually just a scene straight out of Minority Report.
Think this wont impact you if you dont use shared bikes or scooters? Think again. Cities hope to use MDS as a model for regulating all forms of connected vehiclesincluding carsin the future.
In California, EFF is asking the legislature to step in and protect Californians from LADOTs invasive APIsby placing sensitive individual trip data off-limits for planning purposes, and by limiting local authorities to aggregate and deidentified trip data. Such guardrails are necessary to protect the privacy interests of people who rely on shared mobility devices, and to clearly tell local authorities that they do not have a free pass to operate outside of the law.
As we told the legislature last month during a hearing of the Senate Transportation and Judiciary Committees, when cities start demanding individual level trip data, they are no longer just smart citiesthey are surveillance cities. Turning our cities into surveillance cities is not necessary to achieve the laudable planning goals of city and regional transportation agencies. What we need are smart enough citiescities that harness the power of data and technology in a way that respects everyones privacy interests.
Local transportation planning agencies across the country are currently demanding that operators of shared mobility devices turn over individual trip data as a condition of getting a permit to operate within their jurisdictions. They hope to someday obtain the same data for other forms of transportation.
The local authorities making these demands are not balancing their planning goals with the privacy interests of residents who rely on these new modes of transportation. And they do not even seem to believe that individual level trip data is personal information.In a letter opposing a location privacy bill sent last June, five California cities argued that removing customer identifiers like names should be enough to protect rider privacy.That is simply not the case. Human mobility patterns are highly unique, and that makes anonymizing location data a notoriously difficult technical challenge. Studies have shown that when it comes to location data, removing names is not enough to protect privacy.
The local authorities demanding individual trip data are violating multiple privacy protections in existing law. In California, for example, they are failing to comply with the California Electronic Communications Privacy Act, which provides that a government entity shall not compel the production of electronic device information from any person or entity other than the authorized possessor of the device, except in specific circumstances not present here (such as when they have a warrant). They are also failing to comply with the California constitutional right to privacy, which prevents governments from collecting and stockpiling unnecessary information about Californians, and from misusing information gathered for one purpose in order to serve other purposes[.]
Local authorities demanding individual trip data are also failing to comply with the Fourth Amendment. The Supreme Court was clear in Carpenter v. United States that location data is incredibly sensitive personal information, and that it is protected by the Fourth Amendments reasonable expectation of privacy.And in the administrative search context, the Court requires that subjects of searches have an opportunity for a neutral decision maker to weigh in on the legality of the search before complying. The MDSs ongoing searches of operators trip data provide no such opportunity for review.
Courts have already been clear that similar searches violate the Fourth Amendment. The Southern District of New York held in 2019, for example, in a case involving New York Citys demand for Airbnb user data, that [existing] Fourth Amendment law does not afford a charter for such a wholesale regulatory appropriation of a companys user database. Cities are ignoring Fourth Amendment precedent with their invasive and unreasonable demands for individual trip data.
Whats more, the cities demanding access to this sensitive location data have not shown that they actually need this data. At EFF, we have yet to hear a single use case that would necessitate it.
The key for transportation research and city planning is patterns of movement. Cities dont need time-stamped route information for a specific individual; they need to know where most people go, and when most people go there. Thats why there are so many data aggregators out there helping cities make sense of all the data they are getting. Data on individual level trips is not necessary or even useful to cities for city planning purposes. The idea that you will never know what you might find until you have the data is not compelling when you are talking about incredibly sensitive personal information, like granular location data. It might be interesting for cities to force their residents to all wear GPS ankle monitors so they could better understand residents mobilities, but that doesnt mean they should be allowed to do so. There have to be limits on cities ability to collect sensitive location data.
For enforcing scooter caps and equitable distribution of scooters, cities dont actually need trip data at all; all cities need is data regarding where scooter are parked. Data about specific scooter locations when they are not tied to individual trips does not raise the same privacy concerns as when they are tied to the movements of particular individuals.
To ensure the veracity of data, there are technical auditing solutions that can be implemented on the operator side to avoid the need for sensitive data to change hands. Cities can also pass rules that impose liability for providing inaccurate or false data, and then enforce those rules with auditing and monetary penaltiesall without any harm to privacy.
We want to be clear: we do not think that cities should be blocked from accessing all data whatsoever. At EFF, we agree that local public agencies should be able to collect some data in order to ensure that new transportation devices are deployed safely, efficiently, equitably, and sustainably. But local agencies do not need to collect sensitive, personally identifiable information about riders in order to achieve their goals. Civic planning authorities can and should be using sufficiently aggregated and deidentified datadata that is incapable of being tied back to an individual rider, even in combination with other data. This is the solution for ensuring that privacy is not sacrificed in the name of transportation planning.
We can have beautiful cities without turning our cities into surveillance cities. And what we need to get there are clear limits from the Legislature that rein in efforts by local authorities to obtain access to sensitive individual trip data.
- Utopia looks to the future with new product line - Catering Insight - May 22nd, 2020
- ATX Television Festival Adds Perry Mason Reboot, Little Fires Everywhere, HBO Maxs Legendary And More - Deadline - May 22nd, 2020
- We Want to Build Our Own Utopia: In Conversation with Dimitri Shapakidze of Laboratory of Architecture #3 - ArchDaily - May 22nd, 2020
- Taylor Swift, Bob Hope and 8 more ways to get through the week - Minneapolis Star Tribune - May 22nd, 2020
- School of the Art Institute of Chicago students share 18 visions of utopia - Dezeen - May 22nd, 2020
- The Last Time: Recalling Daily Life in New York Just Before the City Went Into the COVID-19 Lockdown - Vogue - May 22nd, 2020
- African Utopia at the end of the coronavirus tunnel - Zimbabwe Independent - May 22nd, 2020
- TriggerMesh's new EveryBridge: Event-driven apps are the endgame of serverless - SiliconANGLE - May 22nd, 2020
- Travel - Why is New Zealand so progressive? - BBC News - May 22nd, 2020
- The scandal of our care home crisis must be a wake-up call for the way society treats our older people - Impartial Reporter - May 22nd, 2020
- Drive-in Concerts Are the Latest Test for Concert Promoters. But Will They Last? - Rolling Stone - May 22nd, 2020
- Global Tomato Paste Market Along With Covid-19 Impact Analysis and Industry Outlook 2020-2026 by Renfros, Barilla, UTOPIA - TigresNation - May 22nd, 2020
- Teaching in the new world of #remote #learning - FE News - May 22nd, 2020
- Sylvia Rhone Emboldens Class Of 2020 To Find What 'Sets Your Soul On Fire' - iHeartRadio - May 22nd, 2020
- ANALYSIS-Rapid recovery of Russian oil production after the release of the Covenant OPEC+: reality or utopia? - The Times Hub - May 22nd, 2020
- Neither Flood, Nor Fire, Nor Virus Shakes The Virtual Calm Of 'Minecraft' - WSKG.org - May 22nd, 2020
- New Images Released From Disney+ Movie Phineas and Ferb The Movie: Candace Against the Universe - What's On Disney Plus - May 22nd, 2020
- New Hampshire venue hosts its first drive-in concert - Independent Tribune - May 22nd, 2020
- Album Review: Bleed From Within Fracture - Kerrang! - May 22nd, 2020
- The far-right assault on the multilateral order and the COVID-19 pandemic - EUROPP - European Politics and Policy - May 22nd, 2020
- Funding for womens cricket in England to be protected - Hindustan Times - May 22nd, 2020
- Will Taiwan Still Be the 'Orphan of Asia' After Covid-19? - The News Lens International - May 22nd, 2020
- The African Utopia at the End of the COVID-19 Tunnel - Africanews English - May 19th, 2020
- Documentary Spaceship Earth resurrects stranger-than-fiction story of utopian Biosphere 2 experiment - ABC News - May 19th, 2020
- Drive-In Concerts Are A Thing In New Hampshire, How About CT? - i95rock.com - May 19th, 2020
- What Sundar Pichais long-term hardware commitment means for the Pixel - The Verge - May 19th, 2020
- Letter to the Editor - The Pioneer - May 19th, 2020
- Literature and Epidemics: In Death, Some Geniuses Sang of Life - The Citizen - May 19th, 2020
- CESAR A. MBA ABOGO: The African Utopia at the End of the COVID-19 Tunnel - Red Pepper - May 19th, 2020
- Television adaptation of Little Fires Everywhere: Small change, in fact - World Socialist Web Site - May 19th, 2020
- Demolition Man's Handshake Explained: How It Predicted The Future - Screen Rant - May 19th, 2020
- Africa's response to COVID-19 will have lasting benefits - World Economic Forum - May 11th, 2020
- 'People used to think it was a luxury': Internet use is surging and so is UTOPIA Fiber - KSL.com - May 11th, 2020
- After the virus: What utopia will look like for the publishing industry in the UK - Scroll.in - May 11th, 2020
- Humans are basically good. This incredible new book proves it. - Mashable - May 11th, 2020
- From Utopia To Reality: Braslia's 60th Anniversary - ArchDaily - May 11th, 2020
- I Sixty Five is living and singing in a 'Picture Perfect' world - Montgomery Advertiser - May 11th, 2020
- Five Artists to Follow on Instagram Now - The New York Times - May 11th, 2020
- Business is booming for these 14 companies during the coronavirus pandemic - WICZ - May 11th, 2020
- Time is running out to flatten human curve - Vashon-Maury Island Beachcomber - May 11th, 2020
- Why The Way You Talk About Artificial Intelligence Needs To Change - Forbes - May 11th, 2020
- Our cities may never look the same again after the pandemic - CNN - May 11th, 2020
- 9 books to read this summer - The Week - May 11th, 2020
- STREAMING WARS: The Expanse trades sci-fi fantasy for realism and it works - SaltWire Network - May 11th, 2020
- Making a Mess of the World: On Hao Jingfang's Vagabonds - lareviewofbooks - May 11th, 2020
- No Tony Awards This Year, Maybe Next Year, So Who Gets Hurt the Most? David Byrne, Adrienne Warren, Mare Winningham, Jay O. Sanders - Showbiz411 - May 11th, 2020
- Educational reform under Imran Khan is a way of embracing isolationism. - The Indian Express - May 11th, 2020
- The Myth of 'Sanskrit Villages' and the Realm of Soft Power - The Wire - May 11th, 2020
- Author Traces The History Of Chicago And Other American Cities In Pursuit Of Utopia - WBEZ - May 3rd, 2020
- Timing of the martian dynamo: New constraints for a core field 4.5 and 3.7 Ga ago - Science Advances - May 3rd, 2020
- Island Utopia - Inkstick - May 3rd, 2020
- Picture this: Utopia - British Journal of Photography - May 3rd, 2020
- Weekend Hot Topic, part 2: Movies that should be video games - Metro.co.uk - May 3rd, 2020
- Arquettes plan to start production of new film in Trumann - Arkansas Online - May 3rd, 2020
- Beyond the Shelf - Jacksonville Journal-Courier - May 3rd, 2020
- The Best Movies and TV Shows Coming to Netflix, Amazon and More in May - The New York Times - May 3rd, 2020
- Albert Serra on the Utopia of Libert and Pushing the Mental Borders of His Audience - The Film Stage - May 3rd, 2020
- During a pandemic, some companies struggle to provide the community they promise - TechCrunch - May 3rd, 2020
- Bodies on the Market - lareviewofbooks - May 3rd, 2020
- When coronavirus is over, I will remember freedoms stolen like a thief in the night - Chicago Sun-Times - May 3rd, 2020
- How Universal Basic Income changes the future - Mashable - May 3rd, 2020
- The New York Drama Critics' Circle Awards Were Presented to the Public for the First Time in History on STARS IN THE HOUSE - Broadway World - May 3rd, 2020
- Dear Mr. President, Please Don't Stop the Daily Coronavirus Briefings We Need Them. - The Jewish Voice - May 3rd, 2020
- The more we learn about the new G-League iniative the less sense it makes - kentuckysportsradio.com - May 3rd, 2020
- Covid-19 live updates, May 2: Six new cases; one further death - The Spinoff - May 3rd, 2020
- Andrs Barba Crafts a Disquieting Tale of Kids Taking Over in A Luminous Republic - Observer - May 3rd, 2020
- China's First Mars Lander is Going to be Called "Tianwen" - Universe Today - May 3rd, 2020
- Erased from utopia: the hidden history of LA's black and brown resistance - The Guardian - April 15th, 2020
- Nervous Recs: 'Little Fires Everywhere' Shows That the 90s Weren't 'Simpler Times' - VICE - April 15th, 2020
- Animal Crossing Has Some Crazy HousesHere Are the Best - HouseBeautiful.com - April 15th, 2020
- Abigail Thernstrom, conservative voice on voting rights and education, dies at 83 - Thehour.com - April 15th, 2020
- Surveillance Capitalism: Bigger Brother | by Tim Wu - The New York Review of Books - April 15th, 2020
- What Were the Origins of the Holocaust? - The New York Times - April 15th, 2020
- Has Coronavirus Made the Internet Better? - The New York Times - April 15th, 2020
- Brought to you by nature: Death, destruction, and pandemics - Grist - April 15th, 2020
- Life After Capitalism and the New 'al Shatir-Copernicus' Revolution - Manifesto of Hope-II - Kashmir Times - April 15th, 2020
- Review: Sideshow Theatre's The Happiest Place on Earth Now Available to Stream - thirdcoastreview.com - April 15th, 2020
- The future will not follow any of the already imagined Hollywood movie scripts - Spectator.co.uk - April 15th, 2020
- WATCH: An episode of John Dalli and his new Club of Weird - The Shift News - April 15th, 2020
- Minecraft RTX beta launches this week, and it looks incredible - TrustedReviews - April 15th, 2020