Apparently, that "monster black hole" that researchers found isn't so monstrous after all. But finding errors and working to correct them in how science pushes forward.
In a recent study (a peer-reviewed study published Nov. 27), a team of scientists reported the discovery of the binary system LB-1, which contains a star and, according to the findings, a black hole companion 70 times the mass of our sun. This was major news, a stellar-mass black holes (black holes formed by the gravitational collapse of a star) are typically less than half that massive. But while the study, led by Jifeng Liu, of the National Astronomical Observatory of China (NAOC) of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, was exciting, it was also wrong.
Three new papers came out this week that reexamined the findings from Liu's study, and these studies say that LB-1's black hole isn't actually all that massive.
Video: Monster Black Hole 15,000 Light-Years Away? Likely NotRelated:Images: Black Holes of the Universe
Stellar-mass black holes are typically identified by the bright X-ray emissions that come from the gas that the objects accrete, or pull in, from their companion stars. But the black hole spotted in LB-1 is "noninteracting"; in other words, it doesn't accrete gas from its star, so it can't be found through bright emissions. Scientists think that there are many examples of this type of black hole in the universe, but because these objects are tough to spot, there are few observations to show just how many might be out there.
So, to determine that the system had a black hole, Liu's team had to find and study the object indirectly, by observing movement in the Doppler shift of the system's star and a deep-red emission line.
Under the Doppler phenomenon, objects moving toward Earth appear blue, because the light wavelengths are getting shorter, and red when moving away from us, because the wavelengths are getting longer. The emission line, known as an H-alpha emission line, is a spectral line, or a dark line in a spectrum. Spectral lines are often used to identify atoms or molecules and this specific line is created by hydrogen electrons. Liu's team completed their work under the presumption that this line was coming from the accretion disk around the black hole.
Related: Why Are Black Holes So Weird?
By measuring changes in the Doppler shift, researchers could determine the velocity of the objects and, therefore, their mass. "If the star and the companion were accelerating the same amount, that would mean they have the same mass, and if one is accelerating much less, it would be much heavier," University of California, Berkeley, astronomy doctoral student Kareem El-Badry, a co-author on one of the three papers analyzing these results, said. So, in measuring the wiggling movement of the emission coming from (what Liu's team assumed was) the black hole, Liu's team determined that the velocity of the black hole must mean it was extremely massive for a stellar-mass black hole.
Now, if the emission was, in fact, coming from a black hole and moving as they reported, that indeed would mean that there was an extremely massive object in the system, El-Badry explained.
The main problem with this conclusion? It turns out that that this emission line, the motion of which served as the main evidence for the proposed ultramassive object, wasn't wiggling. In fact, it wasn't moving at all, the new papers addressing Liu's team's conclusions found.
The claim of a strangely massive black hole discovery first struck El-Badry as strange, because this type of black hole has never before been observed with such a mass. "My first thought when the paper came out is this is such a bold claim that the evidence better be really good," El-Badry told Space.com. "You should always keep an open mind, but in this case, the claim was definitely extraordinary and the evidence was a bit more shaky."
The main issue that El-Badry found was that the emission line only appeared to be moving; it wasn't actually wiggling.
El-Badry and Eliot Quataert, a professor of astronomy and physics at UC Berkeley, published their analysis on Monday (Dec. 9) to the preprint server arXiv. Their paper has also been submitted for publication in the journal the Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society.
Related: The Strangest Black Holes in the Universe
So, how can an emission line only "appear to be moving"? Well, it just so happened to line up on top of an absorption line, which created the illusion.
To understand the illusion, you first need to know what an absorption line is. The outer atmospheric layers surrounding stars serve as an absorbing material to absorb light coming from the star. So, when researchers study the spectrum of light coming from stars, they can see absorption lines, which are created by atoms in the atmosphere transitioning between atomic states.
With the star in LB-1, there was an absorption line "hidden" by the emission line, El-Badry said. Such a situation can create the illusion that the emission line is moving, producing the appearance of Doppler shift, which El-Badry and the scientists behind the other papers explained and showed in the studies. By simply subtracting the absorption line from measurements of the emission line, El-Badry and Quataert, who used the same data for their study as Liu's team did, found that the emission line wasn't moving at all.
Without the movement of this emission, Todd Thompson, a professor in the Department of Astronomy at The Ohio State University, who wasn't involved in any of these papers, explained to Space.com, there are two possible interpretations. Either the second object in the system is far more massive than has ever been observed (way more than 70 solar masses) or, much more likely, there could just an average-size black hole in LB-1 and the emission line is coming from somewhere else, Thompson said.
"There's something there. It's just that it's probably just a regular, stellar-mass black hole," Jackie Faherty, a senior scientist at the American Museum of Natural History in New York and a co-host of "StarTalk Radio," told Space.com. Faherty wasn't involved in any of these papers.
However, because the emission line is probably not coming from the black hole, researchers can't get a super precise estimate of the black hole's mass. But the analysis of El-Badry's team suggests that the black hole is most likely between 5 and 20 solar masses, which, as they described in their paper, "seems most plausible."
Related: No Escape: Dive Into a Black Hole (Infographic)
Two additional papers have come out that also reexamine the claims made by Liu's team. One, a study led by New Zealand theoretical astronomer J.J. Eldridge, which has been published to arXiv, took a theoretical approach to analyzing the system. Researchers in that study simulated a large library of different kinds of binary systems to see if the scientists could find a binary that matched the observations reported for LB-1. They found several that could, but none with 70-solar-mass black holes.
The other study, also published to arXiv, and led by Michael Abdul-Masih of the Institute of Astronomy at the university KU Leuven in Belgium, took a similar approach to El-Badry's. However, instead of using the same data as Liu's team, these researchers collected their own spectrum of the binary system using a different telescope. They also did simulations in which they put an absorption line beneath an emission line to see if the emission appeared to move as the one in LB-1 did. In these simulations, Abdul-Masih's team found that the line did appear to move back and forth, providing further evidence that the emission line in the system only looks like it's moving.
"It did seem a little too exciting to be true," Faherty said. But, she added, "this is also the way science progresses."
Faherty emphasized that "This is OK for this kind of thing to happen. It's just a correction to a previous result it's OK to have this kind of situation," she added. "Science advances and moves forward."
These follow-up studies have provided evidence that the secondary object in LB-1 is not actually an ultrarare, ultramassive black hole. However, it is still an exceptionally interesting object and worth studying further, El-Badry said.
Because there has been so much attention on the original study, including with these follow-up analyses, it has increased interest in the study of the LB-1 system and systems like it.
By identifying and studying noninteracting black holes like the one associated with LB-1, scientists can learn more about these elusive objects. Said to be common in space, they are tough to spot, because they don't produce bright X-ray emissions.
"It's a very interesting time to go looking for these noninteracting black holes, and they definitely have found a very interesting system," Thompson said. There is a "population that must be out there of black holes in stellar binaries where there's no active interaction between the two components," he added.
Additionally, it could be interesting if scientists continue to investigate where exactly this H-alpha emission line is coming from. The papers reexamining LB-1 suggest "that it's possible that circumbinary material could account for it, but it's a slight mystery it's OK to have some mystery involved in a result," Faherty said.
Space.com reached out to Liu's team for comment, and Liu said that "We are writing a paper to address all these concerns." He added that his team expects that paper to be out sometime next week.
Follow Chelsea Gohd on Twitter @chelsea_gohd. Follow us on Twitter @Spacedotcom and on Facebook.
Follow this link:
- The Sky This Week from February 21 to March 1 - Astronomy Magazine - February 24th, 2020
- Astronomers Have Detected Molecular Oxygen in Another Galaxy For The First Time - ScienceAlert - February 24th, 2020
- Could alien life hitchhike to Earth on space rocks from other stars? - Astronomy Magazine - February 24th, 2020
- Controversial simulation creates galaxies without using dark matter - Astronomy Magazine - February 24th, 2020
- How Interferometry Works, and Why it's so Powerful for Astronomy - Universe Today - February 24th, 2020
- Heather Couper, 19492020 - Astronomy Now Online - February 24th, 2020
- Star Betelgeuse's mysterious dimming has the attention of UA astronomer - Arizona Public Media - February 24th, 2020
- Molecular oxygen has been spotted beyond the Milky Way for the first time - Science News - February 24th, 2020
- Heather Couper: Astronomer who brought the stars to a wide audience - The Independent - February 24th, 2020
- These 60 Hyderabad kids are falling in love with astronomy at BMBSC. Do you know how? - EdexLive - February 24th, 2020
- How a Single Image Taken in 1995 Revolutionized Astronomy - Fstoppers - February 24th, 2020
- Look up: Astronomical event on the way - WOODTV.com - February 24th, 2020
- Astronomers look to preserve the night sky as thousands of satellites set to launch - CBC.ca - February 24th, 2020
- SETI and other alien-hunting strategies are dealing with new tools and new troubles - GeekWire - February 24th, 2020
- Watch out, Avengers: This asteroid has a more violent track record than Thanos - SYFY WIRE - February 24th, 2020
- On Student Success, This Astronomer Walks the Walk - UANews - February 17th, 2020
- Astronomers Have Aired Concerns About Musk's Starlink in a Paper, And It's Intense - ScienceAlert - February 17th, 2020
- Orion and its dimming star Betelgeuse shine over a stargazer in this sentimental night-sky photo - Space.com - February 17th, 2020
- When Betelgeuse goes supernova, what will it look like from Earth? - Astronomy Magazine - February 17th, 2020
- The Sky This Week from February 14 to 23 - Astronomy Magazine - February 17th, 2020
- Planetesimal Arrokoth is helping astronomers understand the formation of the planets - Firstpost - February 17th, 2020
- How many planets are there in the universe? - Astronomy Magazine - February 17th, 2020
- What is a neutron star? | Astronomy Essentials - EarthSky - February 17th, 2020
- Astronomers Simulated How the Universe Would Look Without Dark Matter - Universe Today - February 17th, 2020
- What is a fast radio burst? What causes the signal from space? - Vox.com - February 17th, 2020
- SpaceX's next Starlink volley remains stuck on Earth to glee of astronomers everywhere - The Register - February 17th, 2020
- Weekly Round-Up Of Space And Astronomy Opportunities For Africans - Space in Africa - February 17th, 2020
- Astronomers Discover Eleven Dangerous Asteroids That Could Impact the Earth - SciTechDaily - February 17th, 2020
- Astronomers want you to help them count the stars this Valentine's Day - CBC.ca - February 17th, 2020
- Scientists theorize that space aliens may already be here, but we dont recognize them - San Francisco Chronicle - February 17th, 2020
- Indian Astronomy And Mathematics: When Kerala Became The Locus Of Genius - Swarajya - February 17th, 2020
- Cosmic Rays from beyond Solar System Affect Atmosphere of Titan | Astronomy - Sci-News.com - February 17th, 2020
- astronomy | Definition & Facts | Britannica - February 12th, 2020
- Astronomy | Definition of Astronomy by Merriam-Webster - February 12th, 2020
- What is Astronomy? Definition & History | Space - February 12th, 2020
- Benefits Of Astronomy As A Subject In Primary And Secondary Schools Curricula - Space in Africa - February 12th, 2020
- The Sky This Week from February 7 to 16 - Astronomy Magazine - February 12th, 2020
- Solar Orbiter is on its way to study the Sun - Astronomy Magazine - February 12th, 2020
- Astronomers Find Three Massive Exoplanets Orbiting Evolved Star | Astronomy - Sci-News.com - February 12th, 2020
- The Night Sky Will Never Be the Same - The Atlantic - February 12th, 2020
- Astronomers Find Ultramassive Galaxy From The Early Universe That Suddenly Died - ScienceAlert - February 12th, 2020
- Astronomers have found a deep space radio burst that pulses every 16 days - MIT Technology Review - February 12th, 2020
- Scientists detect an unexplainable radio signal from outer space that repeats every 16 days - USA TODAY - February 12th, 2020
- Here are some astronomical LEGO facts in honor of LEGO Masters upcoming space-themed episode - FOX 10 News Phoenix - February 12th, 2020
- Ask An Astronomer: Here's All You Need to Know About Decade's First Supermoon on February 9 - The Weather Channel - February 12th, 2020
- The economic cost of destroying nature is astronomical - Fast Company - February 12th, 2020
- Darkest county in Georgia has its own astronomy village - 13WMAZ.com - February 12th, 2020
- The 2020 'Super Bowl of Astronomy' Kicks Off in Hawaii - Space.com - January 5th, 2020
- Crater found from asteroid that covered 10% of Earth's surface in deb - Astronomy Magazine - January 5th, 2020
- East Haven Coffee Shop To Host Astronomy Night on January 24th - East Haven, CT Patch - January 5th, 2020
- Astronomy 2020: Every major meteor shower, supermoon and more - The Know - January 5th, 2020
- Rocket Launches, Trips to Mars and More 2020 Space and Astronomy Events - The New York Times - January 5th, 2020
- The Sky This Week from January 3 to 12 - Astronomy Magazine - January 5th, 2020
- Hubble Team Produces 30th Anniversary Calendar for 2020 | Astronomy - Sci-News.com - January 5th, 2020
- Thousands of astronomers are gathering in Honolulu as TMT discord looms - Honolulu Star-Advertiser - January 5th, 2020
- Astronomy Before the Telescope set - The Greater New Milford Spectrum - January 5th, 2020
- Astronomy VLOG: What the 2020s Mean for Space Travel - WAVY.com - January 5th, 2020
- The Steady State: When Astronomers Tried to Overthrow the Big Bang - Discover Magazine - January 5th, 2020
- We Have Absolutely No Idea Whats Out There Astronomers 2019 Views on Extraterrestrial Life (Weekend Featu - The Daily Galaxy --Great Discoveries... - January 5th, 2020
- What is the asteroid belt? | Space - EarthSky - January 5th, 2020
- Wanda Diaz Merced is a blind astronomer who hears the science of the stars - Boing Boing - January 5th, 2020
- What the interstellar medium tells us about the early universe - Astronomy Magazine - December 13th, 2019
- Astronomers find 19 more galaxies missing their dark matter - Astronomy Magazine - December 13th, 2019
- Europe's XMM-Newton Telescope Celebrates 20 Years of X-Ray Astronomy - Space.com - December 13th, 2019
- See interstellar comet Borisov on its way toward the Sun - Astronomy Magazine - December 13th, 2019
- The Sky This Week from December 6 to 15 - Astronomy Magazine - December 13th, 2019
- Mars 2020's landing site could be a good place to hunt for fossils - Astronomy Magazine - December 13th, 2019
- Can Astronomy Explain the Biblical Star of Bethlehem? - Snopes.com - December 13th, 2019
- This Is How Astronomers Know The Age Of The Universe (And You Can, Too) - Forbes - December 13th, 2019
- Milky Way's Thick Disk is 10 Billion Years Old, Astronomers Say | Astronomy - Sci-News.com - December 13th, 2019
- Science needs true diversity to succeed -- and Australian astronomy shows how we can get it - The Conversation AU - December 13th, 2019
- Astronomers Discover MAMBO-9, Most Distant Dusty Star-Forming Galaxy We Were in Doubt if It Was Real - SciTechDaily - December 13th, 2019
- Merging Pair of Dusty Star-Forming Galaxies Spotted 13 Billion Light-Years Away | Astronomy - Sci-News.com - December 13th, 2019
- Astronomers look inside meteorites and find the sugars needed for life - Astronomy Magazine - November 24th, 2019
- That Starlink Problem Astronomers Were Worried About Is Totally Happening - ScienceAlert - November 24th, 2019
- Will SpaceXs Starlink Mega-Constellation Ruin Astronomys Biggest Ever Eye On The Sky? - Forbes - November 24th, 2019
- A weird, orbital dance keeps these moons of Neptune safely on track - Astronomy Magazine - November 24th, 2019
- Astronomers Finally Find the Neutron Star Leftover from Supernova 1987A - Universe Today - November 24th, 2019
- Astronomers Observe Host Galaxy of Extremely Bright and Long Gamma-Ray Burst | Astronomy - Sci-News.com - November 24th, 2019
- Meet the NASA Engineer Who Secretly Practices Astrology - Free - November 24th, 2019