click to enlarge
Young Kwak photo
Last week, Innovia Foundation CEO Shelly O'Quinn initially refused to say whether the foundation would stop contributing to the alt-right website VDare.
There's one thing the Innovia Foundation can never say: That it hadn't been told.
Mark Hurtubise, the outgoing president of the foundation then known as the Inland Northwest Community Foundation was first alerted by his grants department in late January of 2017 that his organization was being used as a middleman to help fund VDare, a racist alt-right website.
So way back in February of 2017, Hurtubise says, he sent a six-page letter to the foundation's board members, warning them that the institution's integrity was at stake, and laying out a number of noxious statements that had been published on VDare.
There were articles accusing black people and immigrants of having lower IQs, arguing that America was founded explicitly as a "white nation, for white people," blaming Jews for "weakening America's historic white majority," and a quote, from VDare's founder, that "Hispanics do specialize in rape, particularly of children."
A wealthy donor wanted to use the "donor-advised fund" he'd set up with the community foundation to donate thousands of dollars to VDare.
Legally, the ultimate destination of his money was solely controlled by the community foundation. But the foundation's board chair at the time, Bob Bishopp, argued that they had "no legal basis" to not send the money to the hate group, although he also noted that, in the near future, the board should revisit the issue, and potentially rewrite their policies.
Hurtubise refused to sign the check, but the board which included community figures like Patricia McCrae, president of KHQ, Inc., and Sandi Bloem, former mayor of Coeur d'Alene went forward with the donation anyway.
For the next three years, Hurtubise repeatedly pleaded with the foundation's leadership to officially commit to no longer funding hate groups. But records suggest that Hurtubise was rebuffed, accused of trying to hurt the foundation and told he might need to consider getting a lawyer, all while Innovia continued lavishing increasingly large sums upon VDare.
Since Hurtubise stepped down as the foundation's president in June of 2017, the group has sent an additional $34,500 in donor-advised funds to VDare.
"I had concluded there was no empathy, no real concern for people who were being affected by these grants," Hurtubise says. "It's not moral."
But last week, the Southern Poverty Law Center, an anti-hate group, and the Council on American-Islamic Relations released a white paper on how charities contribute to hate groups. It starred Innovia under a section titled "Donor Recommends a Grant to a White Nationalist Organization."
Within six days, Innovia announced that they would no longer support VDare, and that a new anti-hate policy would be passed next month to ensure they "never again provide grant funds to organizations that promote hate."
Innovia says that they'd spent years laying the groundwork for the new policy.
Daniel Walters photo
Betsy Wilkerson, recently appointed to the Spokane City Council, rejoined the Innovia board in 2018.
"The community has taken the foundation out behind the woodshed and we got spanked. We did," acknowledges Spokane City Councilwoman Betsy Wilkerson, a black woman who rejoined the Innovia Foundation board in 2018. "We were slow in responding. But we had to work through the process."
TRUTH OR VDARE
Named after "Virginia Dare," supposedly the first white child to be born in America, VDare's mission goes beyond the rhetoric of a typical anti-immigration group and into claims that changing the country's racial balance threatens the very survival of America's identity.
"VDare.com also regularly publishes articles by prominent white nationalists, race scientists and anti-Semites," notes the Southern Poverty Law Center in an article labeling VDare a "hate group."
Conservatives often reflexively dismiss the SPLC, accusing them of tarring even mainstream conservative groups by calling them bigots. But many of those conservative groups also accuse VDare of bigotry. Conservative pundit Ben Shapiro, for instance, calls VDare a "white supremacist" website. In 2018, the Trump administration fired speechwriter Darren Beattie just for speaking at a panel with the founder of VDare.
And when conservative outlets exile a right-wing figure as too beyond-the-pale for their views to be even published, VDare welcomes them with open arms. The conservative National Review magazine fired John Derbyshire for writing a piece for another publication urging parents to tell their children to avoid "events likely to draw a lot of blacks."
But he found a home at VDare, where he quickly wrote that "white supremacy, in the sense of a society in which key decisions are made by white Europeans, is one of the better arrangements history has come up with."
The conservative Canadian outlet Rebel Media fired commenter Faith Goldy after she celebrated a "rising white racial consciousness" at the infamous 2017 alt-right rally in Charlottesville and then appeared on a neo-Nazi Daily Stormer podcast. Today, Goldy publishes podcasts with titles like "Whites Have Rights: It's Time to Get Serious About Secession" on VDare.
While VDare founder Peter Brimelow denies he's a white nationalist he's said that his "heart is with civic nationalism," but his "head is with racial nationalism" he's repeatedly celebrated the fact that VDare publishes white nationalists. Fifteen years ago, Brimelow was publishing a far-right figure named Jared Taylor, praising him as "the most brilliant and accomplished figure among white nationalists."
The month before the 2017 rally in Charlottesville, one of the organizers had penned a VDare article titled, "Yes Virginia (Dare), There Is Such a Thing as a White Genocide." When a woman was killed by a white supremacist in the rally, even the online payment service PayPal refused to process donations to VDare.
But for two and a half years after Charlottesville, donor-advised funds continued to support VDare. In 2018, the Inland Northwest Community Foundation spent $90,000 and held numerous meetings with around 50 different stakeholders to rebrand itself as "Innovia," but continued to shell out increasing amounts of funding to VDare on behalf of its mystery donor.
Their tax records released that year show that during the first year of the foundation's new CEO, former County Commissioner Shelly O'Quinn, donor-advised grants to VDare cracked the $5,000 threshold for the first time.
In June of 2018, Hurtubise wrote about his frustrations in Alliance, a magazine about the philanthropic world: "In my long career," he wrote, without naming Innovia, "I believe passive racism was ratified over my objection when the board unanimously favored the biases of a wealthy donor instead of supporting the advancement of all races."
In September of 2018, he sent a letter to the board and O'Quinn. He cited the Alliance article and pleaded with them to explicitly guarantee that foundation funding would not be used to support "racist/and or discriminatory endeavors."
But Innovia quadrupled down. Between the summer of 2018 and the summer of 2019, it quietly channeled $22,000 more in donor-advised funding to VDare. Hurtubise had no idea it was that much. But he kept pestering the board to change their policies.
"I even said to the board, 'I'm assuming most of you are Christian,'" Hurtubise says. "'It's easy to say that you're a Christian if you've never had to be one.'"
By June of 2019, legal action was being discussed.
"As I am reading through emails you have sent to others over the past six months, including this weekend, I have to ask: What is your motivation?" O'Quinn wrote to Hurtubise. "Is it to: Destroy the foundation? Indict certain board members? Right a perceived wrong? If this is the case, then perhaps we both need to 'weigh seeking legal counsel.'"
In the email, O'Quinn stressed that she didn't want to get lawyers involved, but also that she refused to discuss what happened in the past.
Today, O'Quinn tells the Inlander that Hurtubise first raised the prospect of legal counsel and that she'd invited him to work with Innovia to change their donor-advised fund policy.
Hurtubise disputes that characterization and says O'Quinn's email was the final straw. In August of 2019, he sat down at a symposium about nonprofits funding hate groups that included the Southern Poverty Law Center and shared his story.
Still, the Innovia spigot continued flowing to VDare, with Innovia donating an additional $7,500 between September and November of last year. It was only this week that Innovia was willing to say they'd no longer fund VDare.
O'Quinn, however, claims the board hadn't been ignoring the issue. Instead, she says they'd been on a "journey over the last two and a half years" to change the board's policies.
"We did take action. It was not as fast as I would have liked," O'Quinn says. "It's not as simple as simply adopting an anti-hate statement."
But Hurtubise says it was as simple as telling the donor "no."
For wealthy donors, donor-advised funds offer an appealing deal: They can donate assets including money, stocks and land to a community organization, get a big, immediate tax write-off for it, and get to suggest how the funds should be spent. The catch? According to the IRS, the community organizations "must have the ultimate authority over how the assets in the funds are invested and distributed."
But O'Quinn says that, in the case of the donor recommending Innovia donate to VDare, he had the "expectation" that Innovia would donate to whatever 501(c)(3) nonprofit he recommended. O'Quinn argues Innovia had to consider issues like avoiding potential litigation. (Some donor-advised fund providers have been sued by donors who accused them of breaking promises.)
Hurtubise, however, notes that the attorney's law firm for the foundation was also the attorney's law firm for the donor.
"There's obviously an appearance of a conflict of interest," Hurtubise says.
But it's complicated, O'Quinn says. During her half-hour interview with the Inlander on Monday, O'Quinn uses the phrase "legal complexities" or "legally complex" nine times.
"Do you realize that of the 750-plus community foundations in the country, there's only a handful that actually developed anti-hate policy statements and we are going to be among them?" O'Quinn says. "Most of them have not, because it is not a simple issue."
Indeed, in a 2019 article in Sludge, a left-leaning journalistic website, investigative reporter Alex Kotch calculated that two of the largest donor-advised fund providers, Fidelity Charitable Gift Fund and Vanguard Charitable, donated a combined $46,100 to VDare over a three-year period.
And as Kotch argues, these foundations aren't just giving the donors the right to donate to controversial organizations, they're giving them the power of anonymity. The IRS doesn't know who the donor is sending his money to VDare through Innovia. Even VDare doesn't know.
"The new white hood is the anonymity that is provided by foundations to facilitate the awarding of millions of dollars going to hate organizations," Hurtubise says.
For all his brashness, even Hurtubise isn't willing to identify the name of the donor, feeling bound by his fiduciary duty to the organization he just led.
But, increasingly, nonprofits are pushing back against the issue. Last year, the Amalgamated Foundation launched a "Hate Is Not Charitable" campaign to urge nonprofits to promise to no longer allow donor-advised funds to go toward hate groups.
And, next month, Innovia will officially be making that promise, part of what Wilkerson and O'Quinn characterize as their larger commitment to diversity and racial equity.
Hurtubise says that, at least, is a cause for celebration.
"It can be a model for what other community foundations can do," he says. "This is exactly what I thought the foundation should have done back in January of 2017."
- Voice of the People: Columnist Thiessen an 'alt-right' conspiracy troll; uncertainty an added burden during pandemic - Akron Beacon Journal - May 3rd, 2020
- The alt-right: identity politics on steroids - Spiked - May 3rd, 2020
- Bill Maher Refuses to Touch the Joe Biden Sexual-Assault Allegation - The Daily Beast - May 3rd, 2020
- Justin Rohrwasser tattoos: Patriots kicker would help himself by further explaining his Three Percenters ink - MassLive.com - May 3rd, 2020
- If ever there was a time for hygge, its now - Marin Independent Journal - May 3rd, 2020
- Amazon and other platforms allowing payments to far-right groups - The Guardian - May 3rd, 2020
- The Future of the American Left, Part Two: The Tactics of Our Opponents - Quad - April 27th, 2020
- Author of book about victim blaming bombarded with misogynist abuse - The Guardian - April 27th, 2020
- Law Enforcement Must Be Too Busy Policing POC to Stop Swastikas and Alt-Right Gatherings - BELatina - April 27th, 2020
- Ben Shapiro branded as 'white supremacist' by student leaders who condemn his planned speech: 'We do not have to follow the First Amendment' -... - April 27th, 2020
- Young Knives announce first new album in seven years 'Barbarians' - DIY Magazine - March 26th, 2020
- How Kevin DeAnna Orchestrated the Alt-Right's Approach to Conservative Institutions - Southern Poverty Law Center - March 6th, 2020
- Review: Going Dark The Secret Social Lives of Extremists by Julia Ebner - PoliticsHome.com - March 6th, 2020
- Billy Porter will play a powerful genderless fairy godmother in Cinderella and the alt-right must be shaking - PinkNews - March 6th, 2020
- FIVE PIECES OF PAPER Set For Matrix Theatre On Holocaust Remembrance Day - Broadway World - March 6th, 2020
- Knowingly or Unknowingly, CIS Newsletters Promote the Work of White Nationalist Kevin DeAnna - Southern Poverty Law Center - March 6th, 2020
- English Professor Publishes Book of Critical Essays with Slavoj Zizek - Seton Hall University News & Events - March 6th, 2020
- Darwinism, Jews, and White Nationalists - Discovery Institute - March 6th, 2020
- So Listen: The alt-right is not the right - The Post - February 29th, 2020
- My double life among the alt-Right: Taking a punch was something that I mentally prepared for' - Telegraph.co.uk - February 29th, 2020
- Heres how a conspiracy theorist banned from Twitter made the journey from the alt-right fringe to a GOP congressional candidate - AlterNet - February 29th, 2020
- 4chan Thinks It Is so Smart, but Its Plan to Mess up the Democratic Primary Is Actually Incredibly Stupid. - Mother Jones - February 29th, 2020
- 'You're Scumbags': We Went to the GOP's Annual Confab and Had a Nice Chat With Seb Gorka - VICE - February 29th, 2020
- The Travesty of Comparing Jordan Peterson to Hitler - Merion West - February 29th, 2020
- Rose McGowan on Weinstein Verdict: "I Can Breathe for the First Time in Years" - Hollywood Reporter - February 29th, 2020
- White supremacists spread propaganda in the Lehigh Valley in 2019, ADL reports - lehighvalleylive.com - February 24th, 2020
- This Researcher Juggled Five Different Identities to Go Undercover With Far-Right and Islamist Extremists. Here's What She Found - TIME - February 24th, 2020
- The NY Post Published 12 AOC Stories In One Day - BuzzFeed News - February 24th, 2020
- Documentary that examines recent rise of anti-Semitism in U.S. and globally will open in NYC on Friday - amNY - February 24th, 2020
- Who Is Kaitlin Bennett, And Why Did Her Liberty Hangout Promote Holocaust Denial? - Snopes.com - February 24th, 2020
- 'Breitbart' Editor in Chief Alex Marlow Coming to University of Cincinnati - Cincinnati CityBeat - January 30th, 2020
- 'The playbook is the American alt-right': Bolsonaristas follow familiar extremist tactics - The Guardian - January 30th, 2020
- Get your tickets now for Neil Gaiman in Conversation with N. K. Jemisin at Bard - Hudson Valley One - January 30th, 2020
- Spoken Word muddies the issue of consent - Chicago Reader - January 30th, 2020
- Its okay to be white posters put up in Bristol city centre - The Independent - January 30th, 2020
- Trump supporting congressman bizarrely claims AOC wants to 'force you to eat nothing but kale and quinoa' - indy100 - January 30th, 2020
- A YouTube Doc Exposes What Went Down at the "Unite the Right" Rally - Hyperallergic - January 5th, 2020
- The Monsey Attack Shows Anti-Semitic Violence Isn't Always Tied to the Far Right - Reason - January 5th, 2020
- The right wing thinks there are more trans murderers than trans murder victims - LGBTQ Nation - January 5th, 2020
- If Mayor Pete Is So Smart, Why Does He Say Such Dumb Things? - City Watch - January 5th, 2020
- Let the alt-right have their 'War on Christmas' if it means more delicious cookies for the rest of us - PGH City Paper - December 21st, 2019
- How did the OK sign become a symbol of white supremacy? - The Independent - December 21st, 2019
- VIDEO: Ben Shapiro harassed by Holocaust denier as he is out with his pregnant wife and children - TheBlaze - December 21st, 2019
- Military Officials Are Investigating Possible White Power Signs Flashed During the Army-Navy Game - Esquire.com - December 21st, 2019
- 'Knives Out's Rian Johnson On The One Thing Missing From Modern Mysteries The Contenders NY Video - Deadline - December 21st, 2019
- Im Tired: Controversial Star PewDiePie Is Taking A Break From YouTube, Deletes Twitter - Forbes - December 21st, 2019
- 'Touching and Triggering': 'Knives Out' sparks question of how to tell immigration stories - NBC News - December 21st, 2019
- Owen Jones thanks people for support after being subjected to Twitter campaign of 'pure hatred and abuse' - Evening Standard - December 21st, 2019
- Unmasking the Alt-Right: Real-World Implications of a Virtual Movement - The McGill International Review - December 12th, 2019
- How to Fight the Alt-Right Online in 2020 - Houston Press - December 12th, 2019
- The Internet Is Coming to Taylor Swift's Defense After an Alt-Right Troll Tweeted About Her Egg Count - Yahoo Lifestyle - December 12th, 2019
- Michelle Malkin Appears on White Nationalist YouTube Show - Right Wing Watch - December 12th, 2019
- Tucker Carlson hosted a guest with white nationalist ties to help him promote a run for Congress - Media Matters for America - December 12th, 2019
- Trumps Executive Order and the Rise of Anti-Semitism - The New York Times - December 12th, 2019
- How Alexander Downer set off a chain of events that may lead to Donald Trump's impeachment - ABC News - December 12th, 2019
- The False Romance of Russia - The Atlantic - December 12th, 2019
- Henry Louis Gates Talks Reconstruction To Alt-Right, Trump And Voter Suppression - WFAE - October 16th, 2019
- Shallow Woke-Scolding Won't Save White Boys From the Alt-Right - Patheos - October 16th, 2019
- In Sri Lanka, Cartoonists Take on the Alt-Right - Fair Observer - October 16th, 2019
- Louis Theroux: The world has changed a lot since I started making my programmes - BreakingNews.ie - October 16th, 2019
- Dad of Sandy Hook victim wins $450K suit against conspiracy theorist - New York Post - October 16th, 2019
- 'Big Mouth' Mouths Off To Anti-Semites In Its Third Season - Forward - October 16th, 2019
- Caught out that it was Abiy Ahmed, not Greta? I can help repurpose your rant content - The Guardian - October 16th, 2019
- Elizabeth Warren is trying to be even tougher on China than Trump, says Steve Bannon - CNBC - October 16th, 2019
- The US has a role in the Middle East - Daily Sabah - October 16th, 2019
- Police Officer Who Funded 'Violent' Activities by Far-Right Proud Boys Group Goes Unpunished - Newsweek - October 16th, 2019
- Louis Theroux 'very wary' of platforming hate after neo-Nazi documentary - Metro.co.uk - October 16th, 2019
- Satire or Propaganda? The Free Speech Implications of the Violent Trump Video - WDET - October 16th, 2019
- Gabbard slams New York Times profile of her | TheHill - The Hill - October 16th, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: This Week on Bitfinex, Tether, Coinbase, & More - May 25th, 2019
- Ripple Price Forecast: XRP vs SWIFT, SEC Updates, and More - May 25th, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: Looking Past the Bithumb Crypto Hack - May 25th, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: Bitcoin ETFs, Andreessen Horowitz, and Contradictions in Crypto - May 25th, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: XRP Validators, Malta, and Practical Tokens - May 25th, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: Bitcoin ETF Rejection, AMD Microchip Sales, and Hedge Funds - May 25th, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: What You Need to Know This Week - May 25th, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: Vitalik Buterin Doesn’t Care About Bitcoin ETFs - May 25th, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: New Exchanges Could Boost Crypto Liquidity - May 25th, 2019
- Bitcoin Rise: Is the Recent Bitcoin Price Surge a Sign of Things to Come or Another Misdirection? - May 25th, 2019
- Cryptocurrency News: Looking Past the Bithumb Crypto Hack - April 21st, 2019