Wednesday, April 22, 2020
The DOJ Antitrust Divisions recent challenge to the United Technologies/Raytheon merger highlights a few key considerations for antitrust reviews of aerospace and defense industry transactions. The case is a useful illustration of important principles applicable to this unique industry.
The DOJ Antitrust Divisions (DOJ) recent challenge to the United Technologies (UTC)/Raytheon (RTN) merger highlights a few key considerations for antitrust reviews of aerospace and defense industry transactions. The case is a useful illustration of important principles applicable to this unique industry.
First, the case highlights that defense product markets will be narrowly defined based on the specific product application, and suppliers of the same type of system may be in different antitrust markets if they supply the system for different applications (e.g., aircraft versus ground vehicle). Second, the case shows that theories of harm from vertical integration are flexible, and they frequently focus on whether a transaction will create the incentive and ability for a company to use its control over one capability to foreclose competition in another product market. Vertical issues often arise in the aerospace and defense industry because of the frequent subcontracting and teaming relationships among firms at different levels of the supply chain in order to create the highly complex products demanded by military and other government customers.
This is the first aerospace and defense merger review since the DOJ and Federal Trade Commission (FTC) released their new draft Vertical Merger Guidelines in January, and it provides a useful practical application of some of the key principles and theories outlined in those guidelines.
Aerospace and defense product markets are narrowly defined.The agencies define relevant antitrust product markets based on demand side substitution. If one product can readily be substituted for another to serve the same application, then they are likely to be in the same antitrust product market. On the other hand, products that may initially appear quite similar but have unique characteristics that make them suitable for different applications are likely not going to be in the same relevant product market.
DOJ evaluated military GPS receivers as part of the UTC/RTN transaction. DOJ concluded that [m]ilitary GPS systems for aviation/maritime applications and military GPS systems for ground applications (e.g., tanks or trucks) serve different functions and cannot be substituted for one another. For example, DOJ noted that there are different power, performance and form factor requirements for aviation/maritime GPS systems and ground GPS systems. Customers therefore cannot substitute an aviation/maritime GPS system for a ground GPS system (or vice versa) without sacrificing important functionality. In short, DOJ found that the requirements for a ground GPS system were significantly different than the requirements for an aviation/maritime system. While both may need to provide location information using GPS signals in a secure environment, they are not substitutable. DOJ likewise challenged the transaction in airborne military radios, finding that military radios have different requirements than commercial radios, and airborne radios have different requirements and capabilities than ground or naval radios.
DOJs application of the market definition principles in the Horizontal Merger Guidelines appears to be fairly straightforward in this case, but it is a useful reminder of how those principles are applied in the aerospace and defense industry. Market definition is a highly fact-driven exercise, and when the products involved have a common base technology but are then specialized for usage in different applications, those different applications likely will be found to represent separate relevant product markets.
Theories of anticompetitive effects from vertical combinations are flexible.The draft Vertical Merger Guidelines published by the FTC and DOJ earlier this year provide insight into the antitrust enforcers theories of harm from vertical integration. Vertical integration that forecloses access to inputs or customers and either raises rivals costs or, at the extreme, precludes their ability to compete at all, are the core theories of vertical harm. Given the ubiquity of subcontracting and teaming relationships, aerospace and defense industry transactions frequently raise vertical antitrust issues. (Seehttps://www.antitrustalert.com/2020/02/articles/doj-developments/aerospace-and-defense-series-doj-and-ftc-vertical-merger-guidelines-will-impact-government-contractors/.) The DOJs challenge to the UTC/RTN transaction demonstrates the flexibility of vertical theories of competitive harm.
The key issues in a vertical theory include whether the merger creates the incentive and the ability to withhold or condition access to key inputs in a way that not only hurts rivals, but also harms competition more broadly in the market. The DOJs UTC/RTN complaint describes its theory of competitive harm arising from the combination of RTNs focal plane array and electro optical (EO)/infrared (IR) payload business with UTCs large space-based optics business. According to the DOJs complaint, certain types of spacecraft have imaging payloads that include two key elements: The components of an EO/IR reconnaissance satellite payload are advanced versions of the components found in consumer digital cameras: an optical systema lens or mirrorfocuses light onto an electronic detector, known as a focal plane array (FPA), which converts light to digital images for transmission via radio signals. Optical systems and FPAs are critical inputs in EO/IR reconnaissance satellite payloads.
DOJ alleged that RTN has benefited from decades of investment in its technologies funded by the US government or prime contractors, and is the leading supplier of FPAs for capturing EO images (visible light) and one of two leaders for IR applications. DOJ alleged that UTC is one of two suppliers of large optical systems.
DOJ alleged the combination of UTC and RTN would result in several anticompetitive effects.
Theory 1. RTN could use its dominant FPA position to force the use of the UTC large optical systems.
There may be applications for which RTNs FPA must be used, because the payload will process visible (EO) light where only RTN has fully developed capabilities, according to DOJ.
If RTNs FPA must be used on a payload, UTC/RTN could condition access to or pricing of the RTN FPA on a customer also using the UTC large optical system, even if it might not offer the best quality or lowest price for the application.
DOJ notes that the merger creates a change in incentive by combining the FPA provider and large optics provider under common control.
Theory 2. UTC could use its dominant large optical position to force customers to use RTNs EO/IR payload capability.
There may be applications for which UTCs large optical system must be used as part of a payload because the government customer directs its use.
If UTCs large optical system must be used on a payload, UTC/RTN could withhold access to that optical system from its rivals, or increase the prices charged for that optical system, either of which would reduce competition at the EO/IR payload level.
Thus, there are two different theories of harm created by the vertical combination of RTNs FPAs and UTCs large optical systems. Under one theory, UTC/RTN could use its dominant position as an FPA supplier to force a customer to take the UTC optical system. Under the second theory, RTN could withhold access to the UTC optical system in order to disadvantage companies seeking to compete with RTN as a payload supplier (combining the FPA and the optical system).These two different theories show the inherent flexibility in vertical antitrust analysis. Both hinge upon the merger changing the incentives, either to select a component or to supply a component, from what applies prior to the transaction. If the DOJ or FTC (which also performs antitrust reviews of aerospace and defense transactions) determines that the merger creates the incentive and ability for the merged company to execute this type of strategy, the agency will seek to eliminate the potential anticompetitive harm arising from that aspect of the transaction.DOJ under the Trump administration has required structural relief, meaning a divestiture, to resolve vertical concerns. In the UTC/RTN matter, having found that combining the UTC large optical system capability with the RTN FPA and payload business created competitive concerns, DOJ required a divestiture of the UTC large optical system business. That relief would maintain the premerger competitive dynamic in which the UTC large optical system business was not owned by the same company that owned the RTN FPA and payload business. Historically, DOJ and FTC have resolved vertical issues with restrictions on the post-merger companys conduct (i.e., a behavioral remedy). For example, FTC imposed a behavioral remedy to resolve its vertical concerns with the Northrop Grumman / Orbital ATK transaction. However,, the pendulum has swung toward DOJ requiring a divestiture of one of the businesses creating the vertical concern (i.e., a structural remedy).
DOJs press release announcing the settlement noted that [t]hese horizontal and vertical concerns are resolved by the Divisions structural remedy, which includes the divestiture of three separate business units. This is consistent with the policy announced by Assistant Attorney General Delrahim when he took office in 2017. In one of his first actions, AAG Delrahim stated a new DOJ policy: that it would no longer accept behavioral remedies limiting a merged companys conduct but instead would insist on structural remedies (i.e., divestitures) to resolve any competitive issues created by M&A transactions.The UTC/RTN merger does not make new law or announce new legal principles, but it serves as a useful example of the application of antitrust principles in the context of aerospace and defense merger reviews.
See the article here:
- What's Trending in Aerospace - July 5, 2020 - Aviation Today - July 10th, 2020
- Aerospace Industry Presses Market Brief Analysis and Application, Growth by 2026 - Cole of Duty - July 10th, 2020
- Value of Aerospace Oxygen System Market Predicted to Surpass US$ by the of 2017 2025 - Cole of Duty - July 10th, 2020
- Aerospace Industry Measuring Arms Augmented Expansion to be Registered by 2019-2025 - Cole of Duty - July 10th, 2020
- Comprehensive Report on Aerospace Thermoplastics Market Set to Witness Huge Growth by 2026 | BASF SE, SABIC, Solvay SA, Victrex plc, DIC Corporation -... - July 10th, 2020
- Aerospace Industry Turning Tools Market 2019 By Advancements, Application, Challenges, Trends, Top Key Players, Growth & Forecast Till 2024 - Cole... - July 10th, 2020
- Impact of Covid-19 on EDA in Aerospace and Defense Market 2020 Revenue Status & Forecast Report 2027 | Agnisys ,Ansys - Cole of Duty - July 10th, 2020
- Aerospace and defence sectors warn negotiators over Brexit - The Irish Times - July 10th, 2020
- KKIP Aerospace starts training programme for aviation technicians - The Star Online - July 10th, 2020
- Mark Drakeford shares Welsh Government's 'disappointment' that support for aerospace industry was not mentioned in summer statement - LeaderLive - July 10th, 2020
- Global Advanced Aerospace Materials Market Future Growth Analysis, Business Demand And 2024 Opportunities - Cole of Duty - July 10th, 2020
- Aerospace Industry Inspection Machines Market: Comprehensive Analysis of Factors That Drive Aerospace Industry Inspection Machines Market Growth (2019... - July 10th, 2020
- Aerospace Bearings Market Analysis with Key Players, Applications, Trends and Forecasts to 2025 - 3rd Watch News - July 10th, 2020
- Aerospace Industry Furnaces Market Size Analysis, Competitive Landscape, Revenue Status, Future Opportunities and Demand by Top 10 Global Players -... - July 10th, 2020
- Middle East and Africa Aerospace Adhesives and Sealants Market to Show Incredible Growth by 2025 | COVID-19 Analysis - Daily Research Chronicles - July 10th, 2020
- Aerospace Tapes Market Application Analysis by 2025 Cole of Duty - Cole of Duty - July 10th, 2020
- Aerospace Hose and Tube Assemblies Market (impact of COVID-19) to See Massive Growth by 2026| Ametek, Inc., Eaton Corporation, Flexfab, LLC, ITT Inc.,... - July 10th, 2020
- This Aerospace Powerhouse Will Double Your Money (and Seriously Upgrade Your Vacations) - Money Morning - July 10th, 2020
- Taiwan: Supporting the Next Generation of Aerospace Manufacturing - Modern Machine Shop - July 10th, 2020
- Exposing The Black Lives Matter Movement For What It Is ... - July 6th, 2020
- OK, we've agreed that Black lives matter. Now what? - Los Angeles Times - July 6th, 2020
- NBA, players agree to Black Lives Matter and other messages to wear on jerseys - Tampa Bay Times - July 6th, 2020
- Black Lives Matter protest on wheels rolls through New Bedford - SouthCoastToday.com - July 6th, 2020
- Black Lives Matter Mural Painted By Evanston Township H.S. Boys Basketball Team Splattered With Paint; They Believe It Was Defaced - CBS Chicago - July 6th, 2020
- How Black Lives Matter transformed the Fourth of July - CNN - July 6th, 2020
- WATCH NOW: Black Lives Matter protests in Martinsville area have brought together inspired youth of today with the veterans of racial injustice -... - July 6th, 2020
- 'Shut Down the Oceanfront': Black Lives Matter 757 holds rally in response to ongoing racial injustices - wtkr.com - July 6th, 2020
- Black Lives Matter holds '4th of You Lie' Rally and March - WWAY NewsChannel 3 - July 6th, 2020
- Afro Latinx and Black Lives Matter : Alt.Latino - NPR - July 6th, 2020
- Indians are being held up as a model minority. That's not helping the Black Lives Matter movement - CNN - July 6th, 2020
- Black Lives Matter demonstration disrupted by third-party - WPTV.com - July 6th, 2020
- Martin Luther King III on a Pivotal Wave of Black Lives Matter Protests - The New York Times - July 6th, 2020
- Fact check: Before Obama there was no Black Lives Matter, but there was ISIS and antifa - USA TODAY - July 6th, 2020
- One hundred people attend Black Lives Matter rally in Hay River - CBC.ca - July 6th, 2020
- Aerospace Additive Manufacturing Market 2020 Global analysis, opportunities and forecast to 2026 | By Top Leading Vendors like Stratasys, 3D Systems,... - June 21st, 2020
- Coming up: AM in Aerospace webinars to add to your calendar - 3DPMN - June 21st, 2020
- Why Boeing and Aerospace Suppliers Are Up Today - The Motley Fool - June 21st, 2020
- Global Aerospace, Defence and Space Market with Coronavirus (COVID-19) Impact Analysis | likewise Industry is Booming Globaly with Top Key Players |... - June 21st, 2020
- Coronavirus (COVID-19) Business Impact Aerospace Bearings Market Size, Growth Trends, Top Players, Application Potential and Forecast to 2027 - Medic... - June 21st, 2020
- Aerospace Insulation Market Size Worth $12.28 Billion By 2027: Grand View Research, Inc. - PRNewswire - June 21st, 2020
- Global Aerospace Epoxy Market Demand Analysis and Projected huge Growth by 2026 - Cole of Duty - June 21st, 2020
- $279 Million Worldwide Shortwave Infrared Industry to 2025 - Featuring Collins Aerospace, Flir Systems & Xenics Among Others -... - June 21st, 2020
- Covid-19 Lockdown Impact On Global Aerospace Bolts Market Growth and Demand, Projected MarketResearchStore - Cole of Duty - June 21st, 2020
- Aerospace Filter Market to Witness an Outstanding Growth by 2017 to 2022 - Personal Injury Bureau UK - June 21st, 2020
- How Coronavirus Pandemic Will Impact Aerospace Metal Closed-die Forging Market Steady Growth to Be Witnessed by 2019-2031 - Farmers Ledger - June 21st, 2020
- Collins Aerospace develops process to convert passenger jets to cargo jets - The Gazette - June 21st, 2020
- US Needs New Policies With Move To Cislunar: Aerospace Corp. - Breaking Defense - June 21st, 2020
- Global Aerospace Materials Market is anticipated to reach the growing at a CAGR of 6.8% during the forecast period 2019- 2025 - Medic Insider - June 21st, 2020
- Military Aerospace Simulation and Training Market to Discern Magnified Growth During 2020 to 2029 - Owned - June 21st, 2020
- Global Artificial Intelligence and Robotics in Aerospace and Defense Industry Market Insights, Opportunity, Analysis, Market Shares & Forecast... - June 21st, 2020
- Aerospace and Military Auxiliary Power Units MARKET RESEARCH REPORT 2020-2025 | ALSO UNDERSTAND THE IMPACT OF COVID-19 SITUATION ACROSS THE GLOBE -... - June 21st, 2020
- Aerospace and Defense Telemetry Market 2020 Key Players, Share, Trend, Segmentation and Forecast to 2026 - Cole of Duty - June 21st, 2020
- Research into flexible aircraft wing surfaces at DLR - Aerospace Testing International - June 21st, 2020
- (2020-2025) Aerospace Industry Paint Market Growth Analysis, Opportunities, Trends, Developments and Forecast - Cole of Duty - June 21st, 2020
- Aerospace Nanotechnology Market to Witness Huge Growth by 2025 | Airbus Glonatech Flight Shield Lockheed Martin Lufthansa Technik tripleO Performance... - May 19th, 2020
- UAVenture Capital announces a spin-off of FreeFall Aerospace to form a new 5G company: FreeFall 5G - PRNewswire - May 19th, 2020
- What will drive the Howmet Aerospace Inc share price higher? - Yahoo Finance UK - May 19th, 2020
- Aerospace Hose And Tube Assemblies Market Development, Trends, Key Driven Factors, Segmentation And Forecast to 2020-2026 - Cole of Duty - May 19th, 2020
- Aerospace Manufacturing Software Market Development, Trends, Key Driven Factors, Segmentation And Forecast to 2020-2026 - Cole of Duty - May 19th, 2020
- Aerospace and Defense Telemetry Market 2020 Global Overview, Growth, Size, Opportunities, Trends, Leading Company Analysis and Forecast to 2026 - Cole... - May 19th, 2020
- Aerospace And Life Science TIC Market Development, Trends, Key Driven Factors, Segmentation And Forecast to 2020-2026 - Cole of Duty - May 19th, 2020
- Building the wings of tomorrow - Aerospace Manufacturing - May 19th, 2020
- Why Would This Aerospace Company Survive? - Motley Fool - May 19th, 2020
- Global Aerospace Foams Market Size, Share, Growth Drivers, Regional Analysis and forecasts to 2025 - Cole of Duty - May 19th, 2020
- Aerospace And Life Sciences Testing, Inspection, And Certification Market Development, Trends, Key Driven Factors, Segmentation And Forecast to... - May 19th, 2020
- Metallurgy Additive Manufacturing for Aerospace Market Anticipated Forecast 2026 In Key Regions World (United States, International Organization And... - May 19th, 2020
- Aerospace Carbon Fiber Market Development, Trends, Key Driven Factors, Segmentation And Forecast to 2020-2026 - Cole of Duty - May 19th, 2020
- Global Aerospace Couplers Market Research Report 2020 By Size,Share, Trends and Analysis up to 2025. - Cole of Duty - May 19th, 2020
- Raising the FDI cap and other incentives in Aerospace and Defence Industry Challenges ahead - - Defence Aviation Post - May 19th, 2020
- Aerospace Thermal Management System Market Development, Trends, Key Driven Factors, Segmentation And Forecast to 2020-2026 - Cole of Duty - May 19th, 2020
- People & Profit - Aerospace in crisis: Safran boss warns of job cuts, need for bailout - FRANCE 24 - May 19th, 2020
- 9 Plane Crashes That Changed the Course of the Aerospace History - Interesting Engineering - May 19th, 2020
- SME's Composites Manufacturing Tech Group Recognizes Leaders in Aerospace and Defense Manufacturing: Kurtis Willden, Receives With the 2020 JH Jud... - May 19th, 2020
- Aerospace engineering - Wikipedia - May 18th, 2020
- How Much Federal Aid Will US Aerospace Sector Get, And What Strings Will Be Attached? - Aviation Week - May 18th, 2020
- 3D Printing Titanium in Aerospace Manufacturing Applications - AZoM - May 18th, 2020
- Aerospace Grade Aluminum Alloys Market Share Analysis and Research Report by 2025 - ZZReport - May 18th, 2020
- Aerospace Industry Semi-Finished Rubber Materials Market Research, Recent Trends and Growth Forecast 2025 - ZZReport - May 18th, 2020
- Insight: Liebherr-Aerospace working hand-in-hand with Boeing - Aerospace Manufacturing - May 18th, 2020
- Thornton Tomasetti Targets Aerospace Sector with New VP - ConnectCRE - May 18th, 2020