In 2009, the critic and curator Nicolas Bourriaud published (in English) a book-length essay called The Radicant. The term radicant refers to plants that root from the stem above ground instead of below; to be radicant, Bourriaud wrote, meant setting ones roots in motion, staging them in heterogeneous contexts and formats, denying them any value as origins. It was a critical concept that he already lived, de-emphasizing his home base in Paris in favour of an itinerant existence amongst international museums, galleries and studios, the roosting points of art-world peregrination. Bourriaud documented his travels explicitly in his introduction, as if to demonstrate his commitment to cultural nomadism: This book was written between 2005 and 2007 in the places to which circumstances brought me: Paris, Venice, Kiev, Madrid, Havana, New York, Moscow, Turin and, finally, London. Cities and places, rather than countries. Nations are abstractions I distrust, he wrote too xed, too ideological.
To Bourriaud, the Centre Pompidous pointedly international 1989 mega-exhibition Magiciens de la terre (Magicians of the Earth) represented the official entry of art into a globalized world shorn of master narratives, a world that is henceforth our own. In other words, the art world grew to encompass territories beyond its usual Western poles. At the same time, perhaps, art history lost its previous teleological thrust in exchange for a continuous, low-amplitude motion. Cultural globalization represented a kind of loss of self: Nothing counts, since nothing really binds us or requires us to commit to ourselves. The diaphanous, churning loss of self must be countered instead by travel, constant juxtaposition against new people and places.
Over the past decade, Bourriauds itinerancy has become commonplace not just for academic celebrities and the milieu of less-famous curators, artists and critics, but for a wide swathe of those who are or want to be associated with the cultural vanguard: from collectors and start-up CEOs to so-called digital nomads remote freelancers tapping away at laptops in co-working spaces in Bali, maybe making a living by ghostwriting gallery press releases distributed by e-flux. Radicant living has been codified and commodified via the neverending global schedule of biennials, art fairs, panels and openings. Tech companies like Airbnb and Uber extract prot from mobility as we rely on them for on-demand apartments and rides in each new city, while critics and curators fare no better than drivers in the precarious gig economy. Bourriauds itinerary now resembles not a whimsical intellectual adventure but the stops of atravellingsalesman.
Its a lifestyle the critic Andrew Berardini both summarized and parodied in a 2014 essay for the Canadian art website Momus, How to Survive International Art: Notes from the Poverty Jetset. Already that piece reads like a nostalgic elegy for a bygone time. Berardini trades Bourriauds theoretical polemics for a soft sensualism, evoking the pleasures of travel in the lifestyle of the art nomad: You live on one continent and work on two others. You have a firsthand knowledge of the sunrise over the Po, the sunset over Shenzhen, the crackle of the midday sun as the Acqua Alta wets your calves. You might be a poor culture-ronin, but you have accidentally attained an enviable air of weary cosmopolitan glamour, which follows you back to your shabby, expensive at.
The art worlds addiction to travel and the aura it imparts is chronic and its only getting worse. Today, as I watch colleagues depart for another fair, residency or retrospective, I think not of their open-bar, expenses-paid, five-star destination, but of the plane trip there. The three square metres of Arctic sea ice that melt for every tonne of carbon dioxide released into the atmosphere. (A return flight New York to London generates approximately 986 kg.) The fact that one small group the 12 percent of Americans who make more than six round-trip flights a year are responsible for two-thirds of the USs aviation emissions. We see the pointed internationalism of the cultural vanguard as a bulwark against the inward-oriented conservatism of our moment, but we talk less about how all that movement is only accelerating climate change.
Its a strange double-consciousness, reflective of what the writer Daisy Hildyard has called the second body in her 2018 book of that name. When I fly for work, I feel briefly enlightened, empowered, like I am someone valuable enough to have been transported simply to see a talk or exhibition. (A delusion, of course, but one many people share.) And yet, I also have the crushing awareness of that collective second body: the way that each of us, undertaking our mundane lives, is also invisibly contributing to the damage, our habits and hobbies inseparable from flooding in Bangladesh, droughts in East Africa and extreme heatwaves across European cities.
Our second bodies become bigger and bigger. We know that an overall rise in temperature of just two degrees would mean the displacement of 30 million people a year, 388 million people exposed to water scarcity, a 25 percent increase in hot days.1 It is the age of climate panic, according to journalist David Wallace-Wells, and each year we do not solve the problem, the harder it gets to solve. Any sense of optimism often takes the form of nationalist narcissism: in November 2019, Donald Trump withdrew from the Paris Climate Agreement on the grounds that it would punish the American people. This kind of exceptionalism is like the subconscious assumption that your flight alone wont hurt the environment.
Despite our awareness of the apocalyptic Anthropocene a curatorial buzzword long before it became mainstream we seem to feel that travel is either a right or a necessity. There are plenty of good reasons. The small, scattered art world is kept united by flights and human relationships built on both planned and chance physical encounters. Museums, galleries, magazines and individual freelancers alike must maintain their networks and knowledge of what is happening elsewhere, not just because of the cosmopolitan ethic, but to stay competitive in the creative marketplace. Still, the deeper reason for our desire to travel might have something to do with the nature of art itself, particularly in the digital era, when the Benjaminian aura seems scarcer than ever.
Art has always had an aspect of pilgrimage the imperative to travel to encounter the physical object in its original surroundings. The Grand Tour, the 18th-century tradition for the British gentry to travel continental Europe as a kind of cultural coming of age, was oriented around seeing and buying art. One such 1722 guide to Italys pictures and statues put forth its goal to endeavour to persuade our nobility and gentry to become lovers of painting, andconnoisseurs.2
First we visited individual works, then the great museums and collections, then the ephemeral academic salons of Paris. 1895 saw the first Venice Biennale. Since the 2000s, art fairs and all sorts of -ennials have taken up the mantle of pilgrimage destination. The motivation to attend these events chimes with the goal of the Grand Tour, as the critic Dave Hickey described in his account of the fair circuit c.2007 in Vanity Fair: No matter how rich you are, you cant learn how to be rich playing pitch and putt in Sun Valley or throwing down vodka shooters in Misto Kyyiv. You need to absorb the evolving global etiquette by immersion.
I would argue that it is neither the art nor the artists that provide the attraction these days, but the surrounding social scene. Each event forms a de facto installation of relational aesthetics, a 1998 coinage again of Bourriauds, which privileges social experiences as art objects. The party-as-art was documented, disseminated and intensified through Artforums tongue-in-cheek Scene & Herd diaries, an online column that, from 2003, became weekly propaganda for the privilege of travel. Its name-dropping established an exclusive social cohort. Geoff Dyer satirized the scene in his 2009 novel Jeff in Venice, Death in Varanasi: This was the Biennale, there were lots of other parties to go to and as soon as a party began flagging it quickly fizzled out. Dyer, via his writer-protagonist, evokes a zone of encounters with art objects, vaguely theoretical discourse with colleagues in which consensus is easily reached, casual sex and cocaine ingestion.
Hans Ulrich Obrist is the latest patron saint of art-world travel, his reliquary a rolling suitcase. In a 2014 New Yorker profile, D.T. Max recounted that the curator had made 2,000 trips over the past 20 years and travelled for 50 of the previous 52 weekends. (All in, we could say hes responsible for at least 6,000 square metres of melted Arctic ice.) The curator made meeting artists and having conversations his practice; both necessitate physical co-presence. Obrists travel habit trickled down. How many participants in the art world today must fall within that 12 percent demographic of maximum polluters?
For DISs 2014 disaster issue, it collaborated with the magazine ECOCORE to solicit data about the climate impact of individual exhibitions; one show at Artists Space in New York with works shipped from Germany produced 0.0449 tonnes of carbon dioxide bad, but not as bad as one intercontinental flight, which produces twice as much. (Multiply that by thousands to get the impact of a single art fair.) In 2018, Olafur Eliassons Ice Watch brought 30 chunks of glacier from Greenland to London, slowly melting in order to incite us into second-body guilt. But the installation also produced 55 tonnes of carbon dioxide between the flights, hotels, ships and trucks needed to execute the project its mechanical and human resources.3
In regard to climate change, theres a gap between what art attempts to communicate and its literal consequences. If a work is particularly memetically successful, as Ice Watch was, perhaps the cost was worth it. Judging between the frivolous and the adequately persuasive is a gamble. In installations such as these, the problem tends to get aestheticized rather than solved, because its easier to respond to or engage with than to undertake the obvious fix, which is to opt out of the global circuit. In his book The Uninhabitable Earth (2019), Wallace-Wells critiques the neoliberal misconception that consumer choices can be a substitute for political action if only we conscientiously buy the right things, we might fix the environment. The climate crisis demands political commitment well beyond the easy engagement of rhetorical sympathies, comfortable partisan tribalism and ethical consumption, he writes. This applies to the consumerism of the art world as well: buying environmentally woke art isnt going to stop the seas from rising.
Art does have the potential for activism in the sense of changing the way we envision climate change and its causes. It can remind us that, for most people in the West, its not too much flying that is their greatest contribution to the warming planet, but emissions from their cars and the way they heat and air-condition their homes. Or it can show that individual choice doesnt even play the most significant role in climate change: 100 corporations including ExxonMobil, Shell, BP and Chevron cause 71 percent of global carbon emissions.4
We are all implicated in making travel aspirational, for accepting the idea that living between places is more cosmopolitan, more creative, than settling in just one and staying there. We keep choosing to leave every few weeks, constantly advertising for subletters on Facebook, melting the Arctic ice, because movement is so pleasurable.
I remember how legitimizing travel felt to me as I tried to make my way through the art world a decade ago as a journalist and critic. Previews, press trips, opening parties, panels: I was a professional spectator. My first full-time job out of university was as the English editor of the Beijing-based magazine Leap. The first moment I felt like I was part of a scene that I barely knew existed as a student the Scene & Herd zone I was leaning against the wall of my own giant hotel suite in Hangzhou, having travelled there in a van from Shanghai with three Chinese art critics to attend an artists museum opening. At the afterparty, there were bowls of Zhongnanhai cigarette packs and plates of smoked duck necks stacked on the bar, which the artist owned. Later came the junkets, the upgraded flights to Istanbul, the dinners on drifting boats or in the courtyards of closed museum, the several times I went to Savannah, Georgia, less for the art than because I liked the Spanish moss and the ageing neoclassical architecture.
In the end, I wasnt even that successful at gaming the system. I always marvel at one friend who seems to have been on the road for the past five years straight: biennial, art fair, fashion retrospective, boutique hotel opening, all with the dubious veneer of art-world relevance. Travel doesnt cost writers anything except the questionable value of our time; the payment we offer in return is often no more than a quick dispatch posted on the website of a major glossy magazine. Some triangulation of real and cultural capital happens between the client, PR agency and publication and, all of a sudden, youre halfway around the world.
In retrospect, I feel both guilty at my own largesse and embarrassed that it wasnt as extreme as others. Was it worth the environmental price? The travel seems like a kind of social pressure that, if we decided to, we might be able to give up, or at least cut back on sneaking in just a few flights like clandestine cigarettes. The young Swedish climate activist Greta Thunberg has pioneered environmental guilt-tripping, mounting her activism using sustainable methods like sailing across the Atlantic, a durational performance of two weeks. In her home country, Thunberg has pushed the term flygskam (or flight shame) to some effect: this past summer, Swedish domestic flights decreased by eight percent compared to the previous year.
Travelling doesnt have to be such a burden on our industry. We consume images on Instagram already; why not leave installation shots to be produced by those who live close to an exhibition or a studio and then just look at them online? Alternatively, there seems to be an opportunity for a kind of Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) certification for exhibitions: sustainably curated art experiences, biennials that travel on ships, like Thunberg, or on lower-impact trains, which remain an evocative mode of continuous movement. The trick might be coming up with new formats and new expectations, admitting that our current methods of drop-shipping shows are unsustainable at best. How do we re-localize art through curation, without sacrificing the global culture that we prize?
An answer could come from Obrist, with his formula-based do it exhibitions, launched in 1993, in which works take the form a set of instructions that can be restaged by other artists who are conveniently accessible. Or, we could move at a consciously slower speed, with residencies instead of junkets, commissions instead of short-term installations. I recall Dougald Hine co-founder of the UKs Dark Mountain Project, which advocates retreat from civilization in response to climate change mentioning an idea for a pan-European theatre troupe that travelled only by land. Hines latest project is Home: a school based in rural Sweden for studying the mess the world is in, grounded in bringing people together, in one spot, on a small scale. The goal here is finding a sustainable ecology not just for the climate but also cultural community, rooted in place. We dont need to stop travelling, but its worth admitting that the trips can be made more worthwhile. There are enough parties wherever you already live.
In 2009 Bourriaud asked us to deny our origins any value as origins, to travel as a means of challenging our identities and our aesthetics. But to continue accelerating on the nomadic path risks homogenization in the short term and literal disaster in the long. Ignoring nationhood now seems ignorant, patronizing. Beyond a connoisseurship of places, of cities and their various charms, we need to cultivate an appreciation of staying put. Invite a few local friends over, light some candles and call it hygge it might even be fun.
1The Impacts of Climate Change at 1.5C, 2C and Beyond,CarbonBrief, 20182 Cited in Bruce Redford, Venice and the Grand Tour, 1996, YaleUniversity Press, New Haven, p. 363Ice Watch, report produced by the London-based arts environmental awareness nonprofit Julies Bicycle in collaboration with Studio Olafur Eliasson, February 20194 Dr Paul Griffin,The Carbon Majors Database: CDP Carbon Majors Report 2017, EJ/CJ Digital Hub, July 2017
This article first appeared in frieze issue 208 with the titleVanity & Vapour Trails.
Main image:Roger Hiorns, A Retrospective View of the Pathway, 1990-2016, jet airliner, burial, dimensions variable. Courtesy: Roger Hiorns, Luhring Augustine, New York, Corvi-Mora, London, Marc Foxx Gallery, Los Angeles, and Annet Gelink Gallery, Amsterdam
- 26 destinations that are reopening for travel this summer | Etcetera - Daily Hive - June 21st, 2020
- American Express Makes History With the First Black Woman on its Executive Committee - Black Enterprise - June 21st, 2020
- Which international destinations are reopening to tourists? - CNN - June 21st, 2020
- Boom in all-inclusive holidays as skiers look for security and luxury in post-pandemic world - Telegraph.co.uk - June 21st, 2020
- Tony Robinson takes house-bound viewers Around The World By Train - Stuff.co.nz - June 21st, 2020
- Experiential Travels Market Expected to Witness the Highest Growth 2025 - Jewish Life News - June 21st, 2020
- The end of tourism? | Travel - The Guardian - June 21st, 2020
- Paddling the river of mirrors: 'The spot to head if you need to leave the world behind' - The Guardian - June 21st, 2020
- What happened on Santorini when the tourism 'machine' stopped - CNN - June 21st, 2020
- Take a virtual tour to any place around the world and earn $1000 as award - Happytrips - June 21st, 2020
- For tourism, here is an Incredible India 2.0 plan - Hindustan Times - June 21st, 2020
- Foreign holidays 'to restart on July 4' - The Telegraph - June 21st, 2020
- Space tourism firm Space Perspective will send passengers into the stratosphere aboard giant balloon from 2024 - The Sun - June 21st, 2020
- Ensure the tray table is up and your mask on: air travel in the era of COVID-19 - CityNews Edmonton - June 21st, 2020
- Travel, Tourism & Hospitality The future of tourism in the Americas - Travel & Tourism News Middle East - June 21st, 2020
- Into the Wild bus removed from the Alaskan wild, citing safety issues - Happytrips - June 21st, 2020
- More than a 66-million-year-old egg found in Antarctica, scientists finally resolve the mystery behind 'The Thing' - Happytrips - June 21st, 2020
- Go on a treasure hunt of the trolls in Copenhagen - Happytrips - June 21st, 2020
- In Congress, a New Bill Asks for Mass Survey of Blockchain Technology in the US - Cointelegraph - May 21st, 2020
- Blockchain Technology market worldwide is projected to grow by US$14.3 Billion - GlobeNewswire - May 21st, 2020
- Full Court WordPress: Coil Deal Boosts Functional Blockchain And XRP - Forbes - May 21st, 2020
- The Impact of COVID-19 on Blockchain and Cryptocurrency - SupplyChainBrain - May 21st, 2020
- Covid-19 Might Be the Best Thing To Happen to the Blockchain Industry - CTech - May 21st, 2020
- Blockchain flashback: Legislative issues unchanged in time of coronavirus - Roll Call - May 21st, 2020
- Blockchain Bites: Last Day of Consensus, Will Crypto Save the Internet? - CoinDesk - CoinDesk - May 21st, 2020
- Blockchain Bites: What You Need to Know About the Last Day of Consensus: Distributed - CoinDesk - CoinDesk - May 21st, 2020
- Corona SeroStatus App Launches, Leverages Blockchain and Testing to Offer a Pathway to Reopen Economies While Protecting User Privacy - PR Web - May 21st, 2020
- New COVID-19 Antibody Test Platform Combines Antibody Testing and Blockchain Technology - HospiMedica - May 21st, 2020
- Travel startups look to find new stars among the industry-wide layoffs - PhocusWire - May 19th, 2020
- These 10 video games will satisfy your wanderlust - USA Today 10Best - May 19th, 2020
- Travel will never be the same, thanks to COVID-19 - Global News - May 19th, 2020
- Key dates: When will destinations around the world reopen to tourism? - Telegraph.co.uk - May 19th, 2020
- Trump administration to extend border and travel restrictions related to coronavirus - CNN - May 19th, 2020
- WTTC welcomes European Commission guidelines to safely restart Travel & Tourism in Europe in 2020 and beyond - Hospitality Net - May 19th, 2020
- Special deals and domestic travel: 'The world has shrunk, but not necessarily in a bad way' - The Guardian - May 19th, 2020
- Endangered species may be yet another virus victim - The Japan Times - May 19th, 2020
- Travel restrictions live: Lift holiday ban before planning 'air bridges', Government urged - The Telegraph - May 19th, 2020
- 2020 is a catastrophe for tourism businesses. Here's what the industry needs to get back on its feet - CNN - May 19th, 2020
- Noma, one of the world's best restaurants, to return as a wine bar - CNN - May 19th, 2020
- Dream Vacations, CruiseOne and Cruises Inc. adapt to current environment with enhanced support - Travel Daily News International - May 19th, 2020
- Enhancing our mission of beauty innovation for a better world Shiseido becomes Platinum Partner for Moodie Davitt Virtual Travel Retail Expo - The... - May 19th, 2020
- Aviation industry opens up slowly, and steadily - Times of India - May 19th, 2020
- Goldman Sachs warns jet fuel demand may never fully recover from the crisis - CNBC - May 11th, 2020
- Travel changed after 9/11; Here's how it will look after the Covid-19 pandemic finally recedes - CNBC - May 11th, 2020
- 5 charts show which travel sectors were worst hit by the coronavirus - CNBC - May 11th, 2020
- When will we start traveling again? Here's what experts are saying - CNBC - May 11th, 2020
- World tourism faces worst crisis since records began, says UNWTO - The Guardian - May 11th, 2020
- Greece could be one of the first countries that welcomes tourists after coronavirus shutdown - Greek City Times - May 11th, 2020
- WTTC launches urgent appeal to support the African travel and tourism sector - ITIJ - May 11th, 2020
- World Travel & Tourism Council believes international holidaymakers could return to Spain this summer given huge interest from Brits & Germans... - May 11th, 2020
- Dreaming of the deeps: World's most epic scuba diving destinations - CNN - May 11th, 2020
- EHang Joins Hands with LN Holdings in Building the World's First "UAM" Theme Hotel - GlobeNewswire - May 11th, 2020
- Abu Dhabi bets on virtual events to revive tourism - CNN - May 11th, 2020
- Travel from New York City seeded wave of U.S. outbreaks - Seattle Times - May 11th, 2020
- The UAE has Offered to Host the IPL Reveals BCCI - Essentially Sports - May 11th, 2020
- Pursuing goats and getting stuck in the Arabian desert - Jewish News - May 11th, 2020
- Anger as Italy slowly emerges from long Covid-19 lockdown - The Guardian - May 3rd, 2020
- Putting the economy back together again: What the future holds for Americans - CNBC - May 3rd, 2020
- While at Home, Lets Color the World - The New York Times - May 3rd, 2020
- If Australia and New Zealand restart travel, they should include the Pacific in their bubble - The Guardian - May 3rd, 2020
- Animal Crossing replaced my real-life vacation, and that's OK - Tom's Guide - May 3rd, 2020
- Cuban Travel : 5 Tips That Will Make Your Trip To Cuba Easy - CEOWORLD magazine - May 3rd, 2020
- Coronavirus live news: Russia and Afghanistan announce their biggest rises in cases - The Guardian - May 3rd, 2020
- The imaginary American town that became a tourist attraction - The Guardian - May 3rd, 2020
- Travel to a land of sun and dust with The Leopard - The Economist - May 3rd, 2020
- Outlook for Disney World and Disneyland reopenings: What will it be like? And when will parks be running? - CNN - May 3rd, 2020
- Coronavirus: How future travel is going to be so different - The National - May 3rd, 2020
- Daily Distraction: Travel the world without leaving your house - The Next Web - May 3rd, 2020
- Coronavirus: Why expensive airline fares and airport health checks could become the norm - The National - May 3rd, 2020
- No fly zone: will Race Across the World be the last travel TV of its kind? - The Guardian - May 3rd, 2020
- Miss air travel? Heres a selection of the best boarding music in the world - A Journal of Musical Things - May 3rd, 2020
- A trip around the world through local radio stations - The Guardian - May 3rd, 2020
- Travel with your taste buds recipes from around the world by Britain's top chefs - Telegraph.co.uk - April 19th, 2020
- Gudrid Thorbjarnardttir the woman who found the New World 500 years before Columbus - The Guardian - April 19th, 2020
- WTTC thanks all those in the travel & tourism sector - Arabian Industry - April 19th, 2020
- Three cataclysmic events have changed travel forever this will be the fourth - Telegraph.co.uk - April 19th, 2020
- WTTC: Travel & Tourism Sector Key for Economic Recovery in the Americas - Hotel Business - April 19th, 2020
- We can all be inspired by thoughts of future travel - The Voice Online - April 19th, 2020
- Inside the creepy abandoned US theme park used to film Jurassic World and Planet of the Apes - The Sun - April 19th, 2020
- Vaccination cards and seat spacing: Air travel in a post-coronavirus world could be vastly different, experts say - Stuff.co.nz - April 19th, 2020