(Image created in Midjourney.)
Deep indeed run the roots of Evil, and the black sap is strong in them. That tree will never be slain. Let men hew it as often as they may, it will thrust up shoots again as soon as they turn aside.
It is with this depressing thought that Borlas begins his dialogue about the nature of evil with his interlocutor Saelon in The New Shadow, J.R.R. Tolkiens scrapped sequel to the Lord of the Rings trilogy. The text is brief, just the beginning of a novel that was meant to show the inevitable boredom of Men with the good. Amazon has brought attention to what occurred before the trilogy in its new series The Rings of Power, but it is worth examining the few pages Tolkien wrote in which he explored what came next. His understanding of human nature makes what little of The New Shadow that he wrote deeply insightful, and an unsettling warning about our own political climate.
As a devout Catholic, Tolkien believed we live in a sinful, fallen world that will never be perfected by human hands. Its a concept reflected in his works; the whole of the Middle Earth writings is a saga about the rise and fall and rise and fall and rise and fall of evil. Over and over again, Middle Earth is faced with a dark force, which Middle Eartheans band together to defeat, only to see another malevolent threat rise after. The lesson ought to be clear: At best, evil can be guarded against and squashed out when it first starts to rear its head. But the inhabitants of Middle Earth, like those of our world, tend not to go for that strategy, falling, instead, into complacency. As Tolkien noted in one of his letters, mankind has a quick satiety with good.
This satiety is bad enough when it leads to blindness to the rise of a new evil, but in The New Shadow, Tolkien sought to explore a more frightening outcome of it: What happens when people dont just ignore the threat of evil, but forget why it is a threat to begin with. Set in one of the kingdoms of men, Gondor, 105 years after the Lord of the Rings trilogy, Sauron and his Orcs have been relegated to the stuff of legend while all the humans who fought them have died off. Only a few survive who have even the slightest memory of the War of the Ring from their childhood, and having known nothing but peace and prosperity for their entire lives, a restless sect of young Gondorians become fascinated by the evil figures of old. Boys run around committing acts of vandalism pretending to be Orcs, and there are whispers that a cult devoted to the old evil has begun. Our introduction to these goings-on is through the conversation between the elderly Borlas, who was a boy during the War of the Ring, and Saelon, a young man who subtly reveals he may be a part of the new cult. The two go back and forth, each using the conversation to probe the extent of the others knowledge of the cult while debating morality.
The storyline will sound familiar to anyone paying attention to the politics of millennials and Gen Zers today. In our time of unprecedented wealth and safety, the once-defeated foe of illiberalism has made a reappearence. Young leftists have increasingly positive views of socialism, while young right-wingers have increasingly positive views of nationalism. As Jonah Goldberg laid out in Suicide of the West, illiberal views in the West are due largely to a lack of appreciation for how good we have things right now, a lack of understanding of how we got here, and a lack of understanding of how a radical overhaul of society would alter the world as we know it. This is especially true of younger generations, who have little to no direct experience with the failures of illiberalism. Having not witnessed others try and fail, theyre more open to limiting free speech, race-based nationalism, polyamory, and a whole host of other ideas that were long thought unacceptable in America.
Tolkien has a sharp understanding of this peace-time radical mindset, and in the little he wrote of The New Shadow he managed to capture not just how they think and are motivated, but how they operate in early stages as well. In The New Shadow, Saelon never outright says hes in the cult. He hints at it, and tries to draw out Borlas view of it by using language and references that would be familiar to only those in the know. The radicals of today use the same strategies, using words that mean little to outside observers, but show a deeper, esoteric meaning to fellow travelers, like bringing up land acknowledgements to show that youre a true believer on the far left or casually dropping the white nationalist Sam Francis name in conversation to show that youre a true believer on the far right.
(Radical leftists are further along in their project on most issues and are, thus, relatively open about their views compared to the young radical right, who are still generally quiet about the full extent of what they believe. Their influences are little discussed, pulled from unsavory corners of the conservative movement that the generation before them ignoredthey had no reason to read them, these figures were driven out of the movement either directly before or during their lifetimes. As Matthew Rose noted in his book After Liberalism: The Philosophers of the Radical Right: That you might be unfamiliar with some of [the philosophers of the radical right] does not make you unusual. In congressional offices, Republican politicians wont know them all either, but their young aides will. At conservative magazines, senior editors dont read them, but junior staff do.)
Tolkien gave up on The New Shadow, saying in a letter that the story proved both sinister and depressing. (Writing on human nature often is.) What little he was able to complete serves as a reminder of the importance of engendering gratitude in every generation and of avoiding moral complacency. Never underestimate the ability of small wrongs to grow into something bigger. Hew the tree of evil at its first sign of growth.
See the original post here:
Socialism, Nationalism, and Tolkien - by Alec Dent - The Dispatch
- Opinion: Why we don't need to meet in the middle but we can't allow political polarization to fester unchecked - Times Record News - June 10th, 2021 [June 10th, 2021]
- Two Books on the Bizarreness of Texas - The New York Times - June 10th, 2021 [June 10th, 2021]
- Rev. William Barber Calls For Restructuring U.S. Policies To Root Out Racism, Poverty - Here And Now - June 10th, 2021 [June 10th, 2021]
- The Impact of an All NOVA Democratic Ticket This Fall - WVTF - June 10th, 2021 [June 10th, 2021]
- A Hindu foundation has filed a complaint against University of Pennsylvania, saying an online conference perpetuated stereotypes - The Philadelphia... - October 20th, 2021 [October 20th, 2021]
- Why Hungary is infected by ultras who are almost impossible to control - The Guardian - October 20th, 2021 [October 20th, 2021]
- Explainer: White Nationalism | Facing History and Ourselves - October 20th, 2021 [October 20th, 2021]
- No one seems to like the Lincoln Project anymore - Politico - November 29th, 2021 [November 29th, 2021]
- White Nationalism Has Taken Many Forms - December 4th, 2021 [December 4th, 2021]
- Pan-Africanism is the panacea to the Wests systemic racism - Al Jazeera English - April 28th, 2022 [April 28th, 2022]
- Elites From Russia, Europe, and the United States Are Still Getting Nationalism Wrong - Foreign Policy - April 28th, 2022 [April 28th, 2022]
- How the most Powerful Israel Lobby started Preferring anti ... - April 28th, 2022 [April 28th, 2022]
- Ndabaningi Sithole: Zimbabwe's forgotten intellectual and leader - The Conversation Indonesia - July 8th, 2022 [July 8th, 2022]
- Baseball, barbecue and losing freedom this Fourth of July - ESPN - July 8th, 2022 [July 8th, 2022]
- In May, a Month of Mass Shootings, One After Another - The New York Times - July 8th, 2022 [July 8th, 2022]
- The Soviet Union never really solved Russian nationalism - Aeon - July 8th, 2022 [July 8th, 2022]
- Guerrero: Im officially reclaiming the U.S. flag from the fascists - Los Angeles Times - July 8th, 2022 [July 8th, 2022]
- White supremacy poses increasing threats in the U.S.: We are dealing with a massive movement. - WBUR News - July 8th, 2022 [July 8th, 2022]
- Buffalo gunman's racism appears linked to mainstreaming of white ... - July 8th, 2022 [July 8th, 2022]
- In the Fight Against White Nationalism, White People Are Key - American ... - July 8th, 2022 [July 8th, 2022]
- Jemar Tisby: White Christian nationalism fueled Jan. 6 attack - July 8th, 2022 [July 8th, 2022]
- The Facts on White Nationalism - FactCheck.org - July 8th, 2022 [July 8th, 2022]
- Fueled by virtually unrestricted social media access, white nationalism is on the rise and attracting violent young white men - The Conversation... - August 5th, 2022 [August 5th, 2022]
- Race Reductionism Threatens to Doom the Left - CounterPunch - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- Transcript: Jared Holt and Karen Kornbluh on "Face the Nation," Sept. 4, 2022 - CBS News - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- Guest Commentary: MAGA Abortion Banners and Election Deniers - The Peoples Vanguard of Davis - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- Celebrated Author And Anthropologist Rich Benjamin To Speak At Raue Center - Broadway World - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- We're not as divided as we think - Oneonta Daily Star - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- Tucker Carlson's job ads claim he values diversity, but that's not what he tells his viewers - Daily Kos - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- Former Trump adviser Michael Flynn at the center of new movement based on conspiracies and Christian nationalism - PBS NewsHour - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- Finding Our Place in the Inland Northwest documentary and discussion begins Sept. 8 - spokanefavs.com - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- The Rings of Power is suffering a racist backlash for casting actors of colour but Tolkien's work has always attracted white supremacists - The... - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- Soldier Who Said He Wanted Combat Experience to Kill Black People Booted After FBI Probe - Yahoo News - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- An associate of white nationalist Nick Fuentes claims he interviewed to work on Tucker Carlson's team - Media Matters for America - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- White Nationalism Is Mainstreaming Conspiracy Theories - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- Real Viking History and the Imagined White Supremacist Past - Time - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- Christian Nationalism Is Biblical And America-First, But Not White - October 27th, 2022 [October 27th, 2022]
- White Christian Nationalism and the Mid-Term Elections, Hosted by the ... - October 27th, 2022 [October 27th, 2022]
- What Does White Christian Nationalism Even Mean, Anyway? - October 27th, 2022 [October 27th, 2022]
- Jews, White Supremacism, and White Nationalism | National Vanguard - October 27th, 2022 [October 27th, 2022]
- AOC: Vast Majority of Domestic Terror Comes From White Nationalism ... - November 28th, 2022 [November 28th, 2022]
- Black nationalism - Wikipedia - November 28th, 2022 [November 28th, 2022]
- White Nationalist | Southern Poverty Law Center - November 28th, 2022 [November 28th, 2022]
- Christian nationalism - Wikipedia - November 28th, 2022 [November 28th, 2022]
- White Christian Nationalists: Who Are They? What Do They Want? Why ... - November 28th, 2022 [November 28th, 2022]
- White Christian Nationalism: The Deep Story Behind the Capitol Insurrection - December 30th, 2022 [December 30th, 2022]
- What is white nationalism? Take a look at Trumps agenda. - Vox - December 30th, 2022 [December 30th, 2022]
- Charlottesville: 'Unite the Right' Rally, State of Emergency - TIME.com - December 30th, 2022 [December 30th, 2022]
- White nationalism a threat the Canadian Armed Forces arent equipped ... - December 30th, 2022 [December 30th, 2022]
- Tree of Life trial starts as Pittsburgh synagogue congregations find ... - Pittsburgh Post-Gazette - April 28th, 2023 [April 28th, 2023]
- Government-sponsored review finds religion a force for good in the UK - Church Times - April 28th, 2023 [April 28th, 2023]
- The World According to Tucker Carlson - The New Yorker - April 28th, 2023 [April 28th, 2023]
- Fox finally boots Tucker Carlson - IrishCentral - April 28th, 2023 [April 28th, 2023]
- President Biden Announces Key Appointments to Boards and ... - The White House - April 28th, 2023 [April 28th, 2023]
- Severe immigration policies intensify as Title 42 nears its end - Source New Mexico - April 28th, 2023 [April 28th, 2023]
- Soldier with white nationalist ties pleads guilty to gun charges - ArmyTimes.com - April 28th, 2023 [April 28th, 2023]
- Fox News Could Be Just as Racist Without Tucker Carlson - New York Magazine - April 28th, 2023 [April 28th, 2023]
- Tucker Carlson Should've Been Fired Years Ago - New York Magazine - April 28th, 2023 [April 28th, 2023]
- Idaho White Nationalism: Inside a New Class of Republican Power - The Daily Dot - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]