When it comes to free speech on American campuses, there seems to be a law of conservation at work: Just when the internal threat of censorship from left-wing campus activists is abating, the external threat from right-wing lawmakers starts rising. Given that the new threat relies not on the decibel level of immature 18-year-olds but the state power of motivated adults, it may be much harder to fight.
Concerns about political correctness on campus date back at least 25 years before Philip Roth wrote The Human Stain,his brilliant novel depicting the travails of a half-black classics professor pretending to be Jewish who gets summarily fired after black students take offense over his use of the word "spooks." But after a brief hiatus, these concerns came back with a vengeance in the last decade, at least partly because a well-oiled right-wing machine emerged to pounce on every student transgressionbig and small, real and imagined, in order to paint a picture of a "free speech crisis" in academia.
Consider the experience of Ursinus College's Jonathan Marks, a conservative professor who writes extensively about higher education: He recounts with amusement how first The College Fix, a right-wing campus watchdog website, and then Breitbart picked up a piece he wrote for Commentary earlier this year making fun of California State Fresno's new faculty and staff rules prescribing that "everyone be nice to each other." Both outfits distorted the story and blamed students who had nothing to do with the rules, because that was better aligned with their narrative of easily triggered snowflakes demanding safe spaces. The College Fix appended a grudging "update" after some coaxing from Marks, but Breitbart didn't bother. "If you investigated the dental profession with as much intensity as college campuses and devoted entire websites to covering it, you could come up with lots of bad things too," he laughs.
Though the notion of a campus free speech crisis may be overblown, it's still a problem. Otherwise, New York magazine's Jonathan Chait, a liberal, wouldn't write about the damage that a culture rife with trigger warnings and microaggressions does to the cause of free and open dialogue. Vox even thought it fit to run a piece by a liberal professor under a pseudonym complaining that some of his liberal students "terrify" him.
But regardless of how one characterizes what's transpiring on campuses, there are encouraging signs that things are getting better.
A report last year by the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE), an outfit that does yeoman's work tracking the threats to free speech in colleges, found that the percentage of institutions with speech codes "that clearly and substantially restrict freedom of speech," a genuine problem in the 1990s, had diminished by 42 percentage points since 2009 in the sample it surveyed. Even better, 37 universities earned its green light rating for having no speech codes whatsoever compared to merely eight in 2009. Meanwhile, 27 schools or faculty bodies embraced University of Chicago's widely-praised free speech principlesup from just seven the year before. The principles reaffirm the university's commitment to stand firm against the disinvitation of controversial speakers or disruption of events.
There is more good news on the disinvitation front: After peaking in 2016 at 43 disinvitations, the number plummeted to 18 last year, according to FIRE's non-comprehensive tracking list. This year, the disinvitation number has moved up to 30including 13 leftist speakersbut that's still lower than the peak. The most likely reason for the overall drop isn't self-censorship or state laws protecting campus speech, Acadia University's Jeffrey Adam Sachs has convincingly argued. Rather, it is a combination of boredom over the tactics of campus yahoos and a new culture of campus tolerance with students forming clubs and networks to promote respectful cross-political dialogue. It also helps that, unlike 2016, this is not a polarizing presidential election year.
But even as universities are beginning to defuse the threat to free speech from leftist radicals on campus, they are facing new ones from right-wing lawmakers off campus.
Conservatives warn day and night about liberal political correctness but give scarcely a thought to how their own brand of patriotic correctness stifles free expression. If they did, they wouldn't be instigating anti-flag-burning amendments on a regular basis. And they certainly wouldn't have stood squarely behind this president when he berated 49ers quarterback Colin Kaepernick for kneeling during the national anthem to protest police brutality and demanded that the NFL fire him.
Nor are conservative lawmakers shy about launching their own jihad on academic freedom to squelch professors or viewpoints they dislike.
There is a rising trend that goes something like this, as per New York University's Jonathan Haidt: A left-wing professor says something provocative on social media or elsewhere and the right-wing media goes into overdrive, covering the story ad nauseum to gin up viewer outrage. Republican politicos jump in and demand action. University administrators, terrified of the PR damage but unworried about academic freedom, put the professor on leave and begin the "process of termination," especially if the professor isn't tenured. (Haidt, incidentally, is no liberal pleader. He is a celebrity in conservative circles because he founded the highly respected Heterodox Academy, whose purpose is to address the lack of intellectual diversity on liberal-dominated campuses.)
In just the last six months, Acadia University's Sachs has documented several incidents in Iowa, California, and Connecticut that fit exactly this pattern.
In another incident just last month, the University of Alabama fired Jamie R. Riley, its black assistant vice president and dean of students, after Breitbart exposed past tweets in which Riley criticized the American flag and made a connection between police and racism. Meanwhile, the chief of staff of Rep. Jeff Fortenberry (RNeb.) personally called and threatened University of Nebraska Professor Ari Kohen for "liking" a Facebook post depicting a defaced campaign sign of the congressman showing googly eyes and calling him Fartenberry. The staffer accused Kohen of encouraging "vandalism," arguably an attempt at chilling speech.
It isn't just professors that Republicans are going after. In January, FIRE had to send a cease-and-desist letter to the University of Georgia after it invited an investigation by the state's Republican attorney general into a philosophy graduate student who called white people "crappy" at a meeting.
Meanwhile, bills are proliferating across Republican-controlled states such as Wisconsin requiring universities to expel students engaging in "disruptive" protests, which could potentially include anything from loud clapping to walkouts, according to the ACLU. Also in Wisconsin, a Republican lawmaker threatened to cut the University of Wisconsin's budget over an "obscene" reading assignment aimed at exploring how sexual preferences can lead to racial segregation in the gay community.
In another disturbing incident, Rep. Ted Budd (RN.C.), successfully petitioned the Department of Education secretary to investigate Duke University and the University of North Carolina to ensure that the $235,000 grant that the universities' Middle East consortium received isn't being used to promote "anti-Israel bias."
Conservatives pose as the guardians of free speech against the excesses of political correctness. Yet they have few qualms about deploying the purse and power of the state to police the boundaries of acceptable speech and speakers. It is too bad that conservatives' threat of censorship is heating up just when campus snowflakes are showing signs of melting away.
A version of this column originally appeared in The Week.
See more here:
- What's the Best Way To Protect Free Speech? Ken White and Greg Lukianoff Debate Cancel Culture - Reason - August 9th, 2020
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR | "Free Speech" should apply to all, not just some - The Auburn Plainsman - August 9th, 2020
- SC tells Prashant Bhushan there is a thin line between contempt and freedom of speech - Scroll.in - August 9th, 2020
- TikTok to Trump: We're Ready to Fight Your Executive Order in Court - PCMag - August 9th, 2020
- An Angel Investors Tryst With BYJUS And LinkedIn; The Free Speech Conundrum - Inc42 Media - August 9th, 2020
- Free speech experts call on public schools to not penalize students for sharing images of maskless classmates - CNN - August 8th, 2020
- What's the Best Way To Protect Free Speech? Ken White and Greg Lukianoff Debate Cancel Culture - Reason - August 8th, 2020
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR | "Free Speech" should apply to all, not just some - The Auburn Plainsman - August 8th, 2020
- Settlement reached after former Gov. Matt Bevin blocked users on social media - LEX18 Lexington KY News - August 8th, 2020
- TikTok to Trump: We're Ready to Fight Your Executive Order in Court - PCMag - August 8th, 2020
- An Angel Investor's Tryst With BYJU'S And LinkedIn; The Free Speech Conundrum - Inc42 Media - August 8th, 2020
- In Australia, Academic Freedom Case Will Have Far-Reaching Consequences - Discovery Institute - August 8th, 2020
- Varner: Trials and tests of the First Amendment - Bloomington Pantagraph - August 8th, 2020
- Mike Kirby: You don't have to like it - The Sun Chronicle - August 8th, 2020
- Townhall: Congressional and state efforts to reform doctrine of Qualified Immunity underway - Pacific Legal Foundation (PLF) - August 8th, 2020
- UNSW criticised for letter in Chinese with no mention of freedom of speech - The Guardian - August 7th, 2020
- Draft Terms of Reference: Adoption of Model Code on Freedom of Speech and Academic Freedom - Mirage News - August 7th, 2020
- Freedom of Speech - HISTORY - August 7th, 2020
- The Student Press Law Center condemns the suspension of Georgia students for posting photos of their crowded school during COVID-19 - Student Press... - August 7th, 2020
- Harbor Commission declines to take action on controversial billboard - The Triplicate - August 7th, 2020
- SC tells Prashant Bhushan there is a thin line between contempt and freedom of speech - Scroll.in - August 4th, 2020
- Ahmed Albasheer: if freedom of speech is under threat in the West, the rest of us will never have it - Telegraph.co.uk - August 4th, 2020
- An Angel Investors Tryst With BYJUS And LinkedIn; The Free Speech Conundrum - Inc42 Media - August 4th, 2020
- Letter: A sad sign of the times - Huron Daily Tribune - August 4th, 2020
- Press Release: New social media regulation will further stifle free speech in Turkey - Stockholm Center for Freedom - August 4th, 2020
- As threats to the company mount, TikTok pushes back - TechCrunch - August 4th, 2020
- Is There a Moral Panic Over Campus Speech? - Slate - August 4th, 2020
- Commissioners narrowly pass anti-hate resolution | News - Fort Bend Herald - August 2nd, 2020
- Letters to the Editor, July 29, 2020 - Mad River Union - August 2nd, 2020
- Fort Bend Countys COVID-19 Anti-Hate Resolution wins approval - Chron.com - August 2nd, 2020
- Federal Agents, Insurrection, and the Long, Bloody History of US Counterinsurgency - History News Network - August 2nd, 2020
- At the University of North Texas, the Mob Comes Calling for a Music Theorist - National Review - August 1st, 2020
- Federal government materially interfering with lawful dissent in Portland - Washington Times - August 1st, 2020
- Judge Andrew Napolitano: Portland protests are about dissent, and without dissent we'd have little freedom - Fox News - July 31st, 2020
- Harassing E-Mail to Sen. McConnell Can't Be Punished as "Speech Integral to Criminal Conduct" - Reason - July 31st, 2020
- Federal court order restricts Oakland police use of tear gas, rubber bullets - East Bay Times - July 31st, 2020
- Kosovo Pushes Ahead with Law to Protect KLA's Reputation - Balkan Insight - July 30th, 2020
- Sen. Rubio: NBA is a partner of the Chinese Communist Party, looks the other way on 'atrocious' actions - Fox News - July 30th, 2020
- Egypt is cracking down on women's freedoms on and offline. But they are fighting back - Middle East Eye - July 30th, 2020
- BLM billboard next to Confederate flag to be removed - The Chatham News + Record - July 30th, 2020
- Paul Gosar, Conservatives Introduce Legislation to Protect 'Political Speech' on the Internet - The Jewish Voice - July 30th, 2020
- Thousands in Bulgaria's streets demanding government resign - Trumbull Times - July 30th, 2020
- Freedom of Speech and of the Press | The Heritage Guide to ... - July 29th, 2020
- The government wants free speech at universities but not for everyone - The Guardian - July 28th, 2020
- Princeton Grapples With Race, Woodrow Wilsons Controversial Past, And A Professors Dissent - Forbes - July 28th, 2020
- Pushing edgy people to the fringes of the internet silences free speech and silos discourse - The Post Millennial - July 28th, 2020
- Five things John Lewis taught us about getting in good trouble - Brookings Institution - July 26th, 2020
- Judge Orders Cohen Released, Citing Retaliation Over Tell-All Book - The New York Times - July 26th, 2020
- You are not allowed to speak - TheArticle - July 26th, 2020
- Cancelling The Opinions Of Those You Dont Agree With Is A Slippery SlopeHeres A Better Option - Forbes - July 26th, 2020
- Guerin Emig: Lord help us overcome the hate that overran Chuba Hubbard - Tulsa World - July 26th, 2020
- Over 400 alumni call on the U.S. govt. to assist Maria Ressa '86 - The Daily Princetonian - July 26th, 2020
- Yascha Mounk and Osita Nwanevu Debate the State of Free Speech, and That Letter - Slate - July 24th, 2020
- "Who are you to say that?" On free speech and wokeness - TheArticle - July 24th, 2020
- How the pandemic is being used by some as an excuse to clampdown on press freedom - Press Gazette - July 24th, 2020
- Canada's Attacks on Free Speech May Have Cost It a Seat on the Security Council - Washington Report on Middle East Affairs - July 24th, 2020
- News - The Freedom to Speak and Criticize - The Heartland Institute - July 23rd, 2020
- Goya Foods, Free Speech, and Pluralism | William J. Watkins, Jr. - The Beacon - July 23rd, 2020
- Federalization of police threatens the rights of all Americans | Opinion - lehighvalleylive.com - July 23rd, 2020
- Why China continues to gather sway on the UN Human Rights Council - Fox News - July 23rd, 2020
- Malaysia opposition warns of 'chilling effect' of applying old law to social media - WTVB News - July 23rd, 2020
- College Democrats Don't Condemn Threats of Violence Against Conservatives - Texas Scorecard - July 23rd, 2020
- Colwell: Unmask the perpetrators trying to trample on your constitutional freedoms - South Bend Tribune - July 23rd, 2020
- The US Army's Twitch bans may violate the First Amendment - PC Gamer - July 23rd, 2020
- The Synagogue of Satan And Destroying The Right To 'Free Speech' - Final Call News - FinalCall.com News - July 23rd, 2020
- Churchill: Troy preacher has the right to offend - Times Union - July 23rd, 2020
- Opinion: The Future of Free Speech - OnFocus - July 22nd, 2020
- The Synagogue of Satan And Destroying The Right To 'Free Speech' - FinalCall.com News - July 22nd, 2020
- 'Disillusionment With Leadership is About Free Speech, Can't Disqualify for it': Sachin Pilot's Amended H... - News18 - July 22nd, 2020
- The Synagogue of Satan And Destroying The Right To 'Free Speech' | Final Call News - FinalCall.com News - July 21st, 2020
- Churchill: Troy preacher has the right to offend - Beaumont Enterprise - July 21st, 2020
- Parler: what you need to know about the 'free speech' Twitter alternative - The Conversation AU - July 20th, 2020
- Watch | Can states ban the display of the Confederate flag? in 'Legally Speaking' - WKYC.com - July 20th, 2020
- Freedom of speech is under threat like never before and we must fight back, LEO McKINSTRY - Express - July 20th, 2020
- Parler: is this the alternative to Twitters free speech? - Global Village space - July 20th, 2020
- Big Brother would be proud of how millennials are crushing freedom of speech COMMENT - Express - July 19th, 2020
- Humza Yousaf: Hate Crime Bill strikes right balance between respecting freedom of expression and tackling hate speech - Press and Journal - July 19th, 2020
- Fordham student on probation after posing with gun to honor anniversary of Tiananmen Square Massacre - The Sun - July 19th, 2020
- Freedom of Speech: General - Bill of Rights Institute - July 18th, 2020
- EDITORIAL: Protecting your freedom of speech - The Cherokee One Feather - Cherokee One Feather - July 18th, 2020