In New Jersey, yet another bill amending the animal cruelty statute (S1640) was recently passed into law. The amendments [e]stablish . . . requirements concerning necessary care of dogs, domestic companion animals, and service animals, and for tethering of dogs.
Many of the other provisions requiring necessary care to a companion animal are reasonable if the laws are appropriately enforced by professional law officers, who have sought guidance from individuals with expertise in animal health, care, and handling. Unfortunately this is not the case in New Jersey, where the animal cruelty statute is improperly enforced.
This makes the following provision extremely problematic and of concern to companion animal owners and their attorneys in the State:
any humane law enforcement officer or agent of the New Jersey Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals or county society for the prevention of cruelty to animals, certified animal control officer, or other State or local law enforcement officer may immediately enter onto private property where a dog, domestic companion animal, or service animal is located and take physical custody of the animal, if the officer or agent has reasonable suspicion to believe that the animal is at risk of imminent harm due to a violation of this act.
While an earlier provision requires a showing of probable cause before a court of competent jurisdiction could issue a subpoena permitting law enforcement to enter private property and seize an animal, this latter provision impermissibly violates the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution.
A district court case provides clarity of rights under the Fourth Amendment:
In Badillo v. Amato, Case No. 13-1553, slip op. (D.N.J. Jan. 28, 2014) the Court denied then Monmouth County SPCA Chief Amatos motion to dismiss, in relevant part, Badillos allegation that Amato violated his right to be free from illegal search and seizure under the Fourth Amendment. In this case, Badillo, a priest of the Santeria religion was issued nine municipal court summons for animal animal abuse and neglect after Amato went around to the back of . . . [Badillos house, opened the gate and let himself in the fenced backyard without permission or a warrant and began taking pictures . . . Case No. 13-1553, slip op., at p. 3 (D.N.J. Jan. 28, 2014).
As the Court explained, finding that the Complaint sufficiently pleaded Fourth Amendment violations by Amato to survive a motion to dismiss, the Fourth Amendment provides:
The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and persons or things to be seized. Id., at p. 8 (quoting U.S. Const. amend. IV.)
The Court reaffirmed that not only is the home sacrosanct but that protections afforded by the Fourth Amendment extend not only to a persons home, but also to the curtilage surrounding the property. Id., at p. 8-9 (citing Estate of Smith v. Maraso, 318 F.3d 497, 518-519 (3d Cir. 2003).
It appears that the foregoing provision of the newly amended animal cruelty statute, permitting entry to private property based on merely reasonable suspicion and in the absence of a court order would violate the Fourth Amendment.
Additional concerns about these amendments, previously discussed, remain included in the final adopted law.
For example, a person may not keep a dog (or other domestic companion animal) in an animal crate or carrier for transport, exhibition, show, contest, training or similar event if the top of the head of the dog touches the ceiling of the animal carrier or crate when the dog is in a normal standing position. There are many acceptable, safe dog carriers that permit dogs to stand, turn around and lie down comfortably, but the top of their head would touch the ceiling of the crate.
The public must be adequately informed about this new requirementthat does nothing to provide for the welfare of dogs transported in dog carriersso they are not victims of animal cruelty citations issued by over zealous agents and officers of the NJ or County SPCAs. As noted in the State of New Jersey Commission of Investigation 2000 report on Societies for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, at least one County society (Warren) routinely stopped vehicles with horse trailers for proof that a Coggins test certificate was available as required by the NJ Department of Agriculture. As the report concluded:
Not only is the absence of a certificate not cruelty, but SPCA personnel lack the expertise to know whether the horse described in the certificate, such as a Bay or Chestnut [which are specific horse colors and patterns], is in fact the horse being transported.
It would not be unprecedented if humane officers decided to target people traveling with dogs throughout the state, and started pulling over and issuing summons related to the size the their dog carriers.
Dog owners beware!
See the original post:
- What's Next: The Fourth Amendment at The Border and Beyond + Meeting Hackers in the Middle + What to Watch in Google v. Oracle - Law.com - November 25th, 2019
- Fare Inspections and the Fourth Amendment - Montgomery County Sentinel - November 25th, 2019
- Rights not violated when police took photos and fingerprints of detained teens: court - MLive.com - November 25th, 2019
- This Week in Technology + Press Freedom: Nov. 24, 2019 - Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press - November 25th, 2019
- Privacy at the Border: Reasonable Suspicion Required to Search Electronic Devices - Lexology - November 25th, 2019
- Amazon: Cops Can Get Recordings From Ring, Keep Them Forever, And Share Them With Whoever They Want - Techdirt - November 25th, 2019
- Lawmakers Abandon Bill Regulating Facial Recognition Software Over Concerns Of Inadequate Protection - KUER 90.1 - November 25th, 2019
- Cops Can Pull Drivers Over Who Aren't Breaking the Law. The Supreme Court Could Change That. - VICE - November 25th, 2019
- The End of the Rule of Law: The 12 Impeachable Offenses Committed By Trump - Common Dreams - November 25th, 2019
- An accused bank robber claims the police broke the law when they used Google location data to track him down. Privacy advocates agree. - Business... - November 25th, 2019
- Utah Court of Appeals upholds the controversial police practice of stop and frisk - KSTU FOX 13 Salt Lake City - November 25th, 2019
- POLL: Most say they'd rather hear nothing more about impeachment - Sharyl Attkisson - November 25th, 2019
- Surprise search nets warrants, arrest - The Torrington Telegram - November 25th, 2019
- Impeachment revelation: The Swamp Bites Back - Sharyl Attkisson - November 25th, 2019
- Former Oregon securities broker charged with investment fraud, tax evasion - OregonLive - November 25th, 2019
- American Citizen Detained While Trying to Pay a Customs Fee - The Intercept - October 24th, 2019
- The Media Yawns as Our Civil Liberties are Trampled Upon - Townhall - October 24th, 2019
- Trump administration ruling gives states the option to allow drug testing for unemployment benefits - KRTV Great Falls News - October 24th, 2019
- Lombardo vows to remove "worst of the worst" as Metro agrees to suspend ICE partnership - Nevada Current - October 24th, 2019
- Tech Company Gave 2 New Orleans-area Sheriff's Offices Access To Track Cell Phones Without Warrants - The Appeal - October 24th, 2019
- ACLU Sues Over Harassment of Immigrant Advocates - The Intercept - October 24th, 2019
- Sobriety Checkpoint Will Be Held In Cuyahoga County - Patch.com - October 24th, 2019
- FPC Demands Police Training in the Wake of Another Unjustifiable Kill - AmmoLand Shooting Sports News - October 24th, 2019
- President Trump Is Violating More Than The Emoluments Clause With His Doral Summit - Above the Law - October 24th, 2019
- The World Watched as an ICE Agent Pushed an Immigration Lawyer to the Ground. Now, Shes Suing the U.S. Government. - ELLE.com - October 24th, 2019
- Secret Court Rules That the FBI's Backdoor Searches of Americans Violated the Fourth Amendment - EFF - October 16th, 2019
- ACLU Sues Worthington For Arrest That Left Man With Nearly $150K In Medical Bills - WCCO | CBS Minnesota - October 16th, 2019
- Editorial: FBI caught breaking the rules | Editorials - Charleston Post Courier - October 16th, 2019
- The FISA Court's 702 Opinions, Part I: A History of Non-Compliance Repeats Itself - Just Security - October 16th, 2019
- Is smell enough to justify search warrant? Bloomfield Township man appealing decision on marijuana case - The Oakland Press - October 16th, 2019
- Former court reporter's theft trial pushed back again - Kokomo Perspective - October 16th, 2019
- My Family Story of Love, the Mob, and Government Surveillance - The Atlantic - October 16th, 2019
- FBI Carried Out Thousands of Unconstitutional Searches of NSA Archives - Democracy Now! - October 16th, 2019
- Best of the Decade: TV Shows with real world implications - Mashable - October 16th, 2019
- Secret Court Rules That the FBI's Backdoor Searches of Americans Violated the Fourth Amendment - EFF - October 12th, 2019
- FISA Court Finds The FBI Is Still Violating The Fourth Amendment With Its Abuse Of NSA Collections - Techdirt - October 12th, 2019
- Column: Facebook May Be the Solution To Guarantee Citizens' Liberty - Southern Pines Pilot - October 12th, 2019
- Editorial: FBI violates the Constitution - Opinion - The Providence Journal - October 12th, 2019
- FBI Carried Out Thousands of Unconstitutional Searches of NSA Archives - Democracy Now! - October 12th, 2019
- Supreme Court May Be Preparing to Consider Several Major Cases on Qualified Immunity - Cato Institute - October 12th, 2019
- FBI worries Facebooks privacy first policy will be a child predators dream - The Sociable - October 12th, 2019
- Impeachment and analysis by Sharyl Attkisson and James Rosen (Podcast) - Sharyl Attkisson - October 12th, 2019
- What Cars Can Teach Us About New Policing Technologies - The New York Review of Books - October 12th, 2019
- NSA on the Future of National Cybersecurity - Security Boulevard - October 1st, 2019
- The Courts Are Fighting Back Against Trump's Brutal Immigration Policies - The Nation - October 1st, 2019
- Trump Judge Rejects Exclusionary Rule in Violation of the Fourth Amendment: Confirmed Judges, Confirmed Fears - People For the American Way - October 1st, 2019
- The Week in Tech: Why Californians Have Better Privacy Protections - The New York Times - October 1st, 2019
- Host of Mequon teen party wins ruling in case over police raid - Milwaukee Journal Sentinel - October 1st, 2019
- Officer, Who Arrested a Photographer for Taking Photos in Public, Has Their Qualified Immunity Claim Rejected - Fstoppers - October 1st, 2019
- New El Camino: A Breaking Bad Movie Teaser Reveals Another Key Cameo - TV Guide - October 1st, 2019
- Utah and other states try to combat increase of child sex abuse online - Salt Lake Tribune - October 1st, 2019
- The Fair Pay to Play Act Presents NCAA With a New Kind of Legal Threat - The Ringer - October 1st, 2019
- The FISA Oversight Hearing Confirmed That Things Need to Change - EFF - October 1st, 2019
- So You Think You Know the Constitution? - Project On Government Oversight - September 19th, 2019
- House search did not violate Fourth Amendment - Virginia Lawyers Weekly - September 19th, 2019
- Voters fired up, but Dems keep the edge - Fox News - September 19th, 2019
- Exiled NSA Contractor Edward Snowden: 'I Haven't And I Won't' Cooperate With Russia - Public Radio Tulsa - September 19th, 2019
- Prosecutors failure to disclose evidence leads to dropped drug charges - Journal & Courier - September 19th, 2019
- A YJI reporter asked: Which Amendment is your favorite? - Youth Journalism International - September 19th, 2019
- Celebrating Constitution Week - Journal Advocate - September 19th, 2019
- Janison: One rough week for the Constitution - Newsday - September 19th, 2019
- Federal Court: Cops Accused Of Stealing Over $225,000 Have Legal Immunity - Forbes - September 19th, 2019
- Court of Appeals finishes Constitution Day at K-State with two cases - Manhattan Mercury - September 19th, 2019
- Woman Claims Sacramento Police Conducted Illegal Probation Search at Her Home - KTXL FOX 40 Sacramento - September 19th, 2019
- Lawsuit against Jackson police officer who shot dog will continue - MLive.com - September 19th, 2019
- This year's state constitutional amendments detailed by PAR - WWL News, Talk, Sports Radio Station - September 19th, 2019
- Savannah-Chatham County students get dose of Constitution - Savannah Morning News - September 19th, 2019
- CPS: Strip-Searching Kids is OK. Um, No! - Home School Legal Defense Association - September 19th, 2019
- US allocates $10m grant for family planning in Egypt - Middle East Monitor - September 19th, 2019
- DeKalb police break down, explain Terry stop before arrest of McDowell - DeKalb Daily Chronicle - September 19th, 2019
- Letters: Second Amendment has nothing to do with hunting - The Advocate - September 19th, 2019
- Federal appeals court ruling sets precedent in 'unreasonable' search case - Richmond Free Press - September 19th, 2019
- Progress reported on Little Rock police use of no-knock searches - Arkansas Times - September 19th, 2019
- Trump Judge Affirms Dismissal of Claims That FBI Agents Lied and Fabricated Evidence: Confirmed Judges, Confirmed Fears - People For the American Way - September 19th, 2019
- Ceremony to remember Matthew Graves set one year since his death - KOBI-TV NBC5 / KOTI-TV NBC2 - September 19th, 2019
- Portland protesters to Greyhound: Stop letting immigration agents on buses - Street Roots News - September 19th, 2019
- Mercer Co. sheriff sued in federal court - Lima Ohio - September 19th, 2019
- Warren BOE gets construction update | News, Sports, Jobs - Marietta Times - September 19th, 2019
- Five Steps You Must Take Today To Defend Your Gun Rights - OutdoorHub - September 19th, 2019
- 1600: Iran hawks bare their talons at Trump - Newsday - September 19th, 2019