Brexit food standards: ‘This is not even Marie Antoinette saying let them eat cake… it is let them eat crap’ – The London Economic

The PM is facing a barrage of criticism regarding the potential of lowering food standards in the UK post-Brexit.

The Conservative Party was elected on a manifesto which committed Mr Johnsons Government to not compromise on the UKs high environmental protection, animal welfare and food standards in all our trade negotiations.

But peers continued to voice concerns about the prospect of cheap imports and pressed for new guarantees to be included in law via the Agriculture Bill, which sets out new policy as the UK quits the EU-wide Common Agricultural Policy.

Labours Baroness Young of Old Scone also warned it would be pretty invidious to allow wealthier people to choose to buy food produced to higher standards while poorer people would have to buy what they could afford.

She said: This is not even Marie Antoinette saying let them eat cake, it is worse, it is let them eat crap.

Green Party peer Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb said she was terrified the Government, desperate to secure a US trade deal, would give in to the Americans on standards.

The Government argues protections are already in place, although it lacks a majority in the Lords and could suffer a series of defeats when the Bill undergoes further scrutiny at report stage after the summer recess.

It would be then for MPs to overturn any amendments, with some Tory backbenchers having already expressed a desire for future trade deals to ensure a level playing field for British farmers.

Liberal Democrat Lord Addington said the Government would be bound to its commitment on standards if it was written into the Bill.

He told the Lords: If we dont get something on the face of this Bill we have no other way of at least making the Government stand up and say yes, were changing it because and I think thats what this is about.

I hope the minister is taking this on board because ping and pong, backhand, forehand and the odd smash might be involved on this one.

We can actually get involved in a very long discussion on this when the House is asking the Government to honour its own manifesto commitment. I wouldnt have thought any government wants that.

Ping-pong in parliamentary terms is when a Bill moves between the Commons and Lords as both Houses seek to come to an agreement over amendments thereby delaying the implementation of the legislation.

Conservative Lord Cormack said his partys 2019 election manifesto made a total commitment to enhance rather than diminish UK food standards, adding: If this Bill does not create a situation where that can happen then it is indeed not fit for purpose.

Lord Cormack predicted there could be a lengthy report stage for the Bill and quite a lot of contact with the Commons as a result of any amendments made by peers if the Government did not make the desired changes.

Labour argued the legislation must include a requirement for agricultural and food imports to meet domestic standards.

Speaking on day seven of the Bills committee stage, shadow environment minister Lord Grantchester said: The simplest way to decide this matter is by enshrining the UKs position here in law.

The Conservative voters that read the Conservative Party manifesto can be forgiven for thinking this is what they were going to get when they voted to get Brexit done.

The Conservative Government is happy to enshrine Brexit twice in legislation.

The Conservative Government is happy to enshrine the position on Huawei into law.

It is happy to do it again on the wearing of face masks.

Id welcome the ministers U-turn on the matter of food standards as well, as soon as he can make it.

Labour former Cabinet minister Lord Hain said so desperate are the Brexiteers to declare UDI (unilateral declaration of independence) from the EU that they are prepared to prostrate themselves at the door of Donald Trumps America-first trade and sell out our farmers while turning a blind eye to environmental degradation and poor animal welfare standards.

But House Of Cards author and Tory peer Lord Dobbs warned the changes being sought to the legislation on food standards would cut off future export opportunities by making trade deals very much more difficult to negotiate or even block them altogether.

But I would suggest the desire to make a post-EU future difficult or impossible may well be the hidden agenda, he added.

For the Government, rural affairs minister Lord Gardiner of Kimble said existing Brexit legislation already retained standards on environmental protections, animal welfare and food safety.

He said: This provides a firm basis for maintaining the same high level of protection for both domestic and imported products.

We already have the rules and robust processes in place to protect UK standards.

Food regulators and current stringent processes would continue to ensure that all food imports into the UK are safe and meet the relevant UK product rules and regulations, he said.

This will include imports under new free trade agreements, he added.

Lord Gardiner said: Given the protections outlined, the Government believes that sufficient measures are already in place. We are committed to ensuring that trade agreements do not compromise our high standards.

Related Tractors descend on Parliament to protest trade deals undermining British food standards

While you are here, we wanted to ask for your help.

Free, independent journalism in Britain is under threat. The government is becoming increasingly authoritarian and our media is run by a handful handful of billionaires, most of whom reside overseas and all of them have strong political allegiances and financial motivations.

Our mission is to hold the powerful to account. It is vital that free, independent media is allowed to exist to expose hypocrisy, corruption, wrongdoing and abuse of power. But we can't do it without you.

If you can afford to contribute a small donation to the site it will help us to continue our work in the best interests of the public. We only ask you to donate what you can afford, with an option to cancel your subscription at any point.

To donate or subscribe to The London Economic, click here.

The TLE shop is also now open, with all profits going to supporting free, independent journalism.

The shop can be found here.

See the original post:

Brexit food standards: 'This is not even Marie Antoinette saying let them eat cake... it is let them eat crap' - The London Economic

Related Posts

Comments are closed.