(by Ben Rothke)
Learn a few pages in the Mishnah Berurah and youll come to the phrase hamachmir tavo alav bracha. While the Chofetz Chaim didnt coin the phrase, he made it his calling card. He will accept an opinion, but commend those who want to be strict. These stringencies apply throughout Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim, even though most of the topics do not deal with potential capital crimes.
Had the Chofetz Chaim written on Yoreh Deah hilchos Avodah Zara, I think its safe to say the phrase would be pervasive.
In a new book, Alternative Medicine in Halachah, Rabbi Rephoel Szmerla attempts to make the halakhic case for alternative medical treatments. Its a heavy tome; 11 English-language chapters and about 400 pages of Hebrew appendixes.
Yet in close to 200 pages, I was struck by the fact that never once does Szmerla use hamachmir tavo alav bracha. This is noteworthy given that avoda zara is one of the 3 prohibitions one must give up their live rather than violating.
Some of the therapies to which the book details the practical halacha include:
Remote healing Reiki Acupuncture Kinesiology Dowsing Homeopathy and flow essences Gem therapy Geobiology and Feng Shiu Hypnotherapy Yoga Therapeutic touch Shamanic healing
Szmerla is a proponent of these alternative therapies. Hes been involved with so-called energy medicine for twenty years and is something of an evangelist for this cause. For this reason, his devotion to this project, perhaps, the author struggled to provide a cogent rationale for his arguments. He also represents a curious trend among some elements of the Orthodox Right to declaim modern science as wisdom. The sinuous logic often takes some unorthodox and untraditional turns.
A Scientific Halakhist?
The failure centers on the authors attempt to be the medical and halakhic expert. This was not a challenge for some of the twentieth centurys leading halakhic authorities. For example, Rabbi Moshe Feinstein frequently called on the scientific knowledge of his son-in-law Rabbi Moshe Tendler, who had received his Ph.D. in microbiology from Columbia University. In Israel, Rabbi Shlomo Zalman Auerbach relied on experts in biology and physics when addressing halakhic issues related to these fields.
But it is troubling in this more recent project. While he quotes extensively from myriad new age sources, Szmerla does not reference any non-alternative scientists or medical doctors. What is more, the books bibliography lists a mere 29 citations, none of which are science-based works. The result is a goodly number of botched scientific proofs and impreciseor wrongterminologies. One example is his equating data and evidence as being the same.
Sometimes, the scholarship just does not back up the claim. For instance, an aura, according to new age thought is an emanation that encloses a human body. However, the myth-buster Joe Nickell writes that tests to observe alleged aura emanations have repeatedly met with failure. Nonetheless, Szmerla writes that it is worthwhile to note that there exists scientific data supporting the existence of the aura.
Rabbinic Authority
Its not just Szmerlas understanding of science that is lacking, his disdain for the halakhic process and understanding of the nature of halakhic development are also quite troubling. His portrayal of the rabbis of the Talmud deserves specific mention. Szmerla portrays rabbis of the Talmud as gullible. He writes that halachic determinations do not require the rigorous evidence of scientific double-blind studies. This is plainly crass, ignoring the fruitful scholarship conducted by Rabbi Nahum Rabinovitch, among others. The rabbis of the Talmud certainly didnt use a chi-squared test or regression and correlation analysis as we know it, they did operate with sophisticated levels of statistical analysis, the best of what was known to them in their time.
To boot, Szmerlas proof for this criticism is rather simplistic. For example, he notes that in the eyes of the Torah, any phenomenon that has been validated three times is considered authentic. He is referring to the Talmud in Shabbat 61a that discusses when amulets are to be approved as medical devices. He takes a discussion limited to amulets and applies it to all medical therapies. In any system, be it legal, mathematical, or theological, one cant take a limited item; and pro forma apply it globally.
Further, Szmerlas methods are precarious from a practical halakhic perspective. He assumes to know exactly what the Talmud is discussing, and can precisely correlate it to a particular new age therapy. Contrast that with the notion that the Talmud states in Shabbat 35a: that we are not experts in identifying medium-sized stars to determine nightfall. If we cant expertly identify the size of the stars in the sky, its hard to understand how he can know the specific new age therapy. Yet, Szmerla does exactly that. For example, the Talmud in Horayot 12a discusses the concept of a babuah di-babuah, a shadow of a shadow. Szmerla writes that this description is identical to the description of the aura given by energy healing practitioners, a therapy he therefore allows.
He also ignores notions of rabbinic consensus and debate. In the foreword, Rabbi Shmuel Meir Katz of Lakewood writes that a hallmark of a genuine moreh horaah is the intellectual honesty to examine an issue from various standpoints and the capability to honestly evaluate dissenting opinions. Yet, one of the most egregious problems with Szmerlas approach is that he does not significantly reference those dissenting opinions. He writes that there is scientific data to support his findings, but much of his data is based on vibrational medicine, to which a 2008 study by noted researcher Edzard Ernst found that the evidence is not fully convincing for most complementary and alternative medicine modalities.
Finally, he writes the efficacy of homeopathy has been well-established. That simply is not true. No large-scale study has found homeopathy any more effective than a placebo. Yet that assertion is what allows him to permit ineffectual therapies, as he believes that any phenomenon that has been validated three times is considered authentic. With enough of a sample size, its easy to get three cases of anything. Science would call that the placebo effect. Szmerla would call that authentic.
An Orthodox Counterculture
Looked at more broadly, this book reflects disturbing trends in some subculture elements of Orthodoxy to disdain modern science and certain medical developments and to engage new age therapies.
Why the opposition? For Szmerla, modern science is not God-focused. He contrasts the opinions of atheistic scientists with those of the creators of alternative therapies, who he feels realize that their healing powers originate from the Divine. Both characterizations are overly generalized, and his simplistic observation does nothing to support his claims. The author does not explain why alternative therapies, which may have their ancient roots in Krishna or Vishnu, may be more acceptable or effective than those from non-believing scientists and doctors such as Linus Pauling or Franois Jacob.
What Hath the New Age Movement Done to Us?
The New Age movement, with its acceptance of occult practices, pantheism, and a spirituality without borders or confining dogmas that is inclusive and pluralistic is anathema to halakhah. Rabbi Szmerlas book, I fear, reflects a trend within some parts of the Orthodox Right to eschew modern science and contemporary medicine.
This comes at a significant cost. The authors weltanschauung leads him to be a promulgator of bad science while misrepresenting Chazal. The danger with Alternative Medicine in Halachah is that the author oversimplifies both halakhah and the often-complex fields of science and medicine. This leads to his acquiescence to therapies that other major poskim outright forbid. Perhaps more disturbing than the poor scholarship in this book, is the underlying trend it illustrates.
Ben Rothke lives in New Jersey and works in the information security field. He blogs about information security at The Security Meltdown and is the associate editor of the Information Security Journal: A Global Perspective. He writes technology book reviews for Security Management, and reviews of books on Jewish thought for The Jewish Press, The Lehrhaus and Times of Israel.
Read the original:
A Critical Look At A New Sefer: Alternative Medicine in Halachah - Yeshiva World News
- PANTHEISM: Nature, universe, science and religion - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- Pantheism - New World Encyclopedia - Info:Main Page - New ... - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- Is your spiritual home right here on Earth? | World Pantheism - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- The Higher Pantheism - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- Does pantheism relate to free will? - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- Pantheism Master (Original Mix) - Video - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Pantheism (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy) - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Pantheism - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Never losing dignity - February 19th, 2015 [February 19th, 2015]
- How to Pronounce Pantheism - Video - March 5th, 2015 [March 5th, 2015]
- Pantheism explained - Video - March 8th, 2015 [March 8th, 2015]
- Wk 40 Katey on Pantheism and Souls - Video - March 31st, 2015 [March 31st, 2015]
- Metaphysics of Pantheism - Famous Pantheist Quotes - April 8th, 2015 [April 8th, 2015]
- What is pantheism? - Bible Questions Answered - April 8th, 2015 [April 8th, 2015]
- The Presence of God The Holy Spirit and Pantheism - December 8th, 2016 [December 8th, 2016]
- Roman Gods And Pantheism - AllAboutHistory.org - December 8th, 2016 [December 8th, 2016]
- Pantheism - RationalWiki - December 18th, 2016 [December 18th, 2016]
- Pantheism | Neo-Paganism.com - December 22nd, 2016 [December 22nd, 2016]
- Monism - Wikipedia - January 12th, 2017 [January 12th, 2017]
- Pantheism Beliefs Explained - About.com Religion ... - January 21st, 2017 [January 21st, 2017]
- Our fight to the death with nature is not one we can win - The Age - The Age - February 7th, 2017 [February 7th, 2017]
- Pantheism - Norse Mythology for Smart People - February 8th, 2017 [February 8th, 2017]
- How Alexis de Tocqueville can help us stay sane - The Washington ... - Washington Post - February 10th, 2017 [February 10th, 2017]
- Veljo Tormis obituary - The Guardian - February 12th, 2017 [February 12th, 2017]
- Educational Reformer Hirsch Promotes Knowledge Against Its ... - National Review - February 18th, 2017 [February 18th, 2017]
- 'Evilution:' The Secret Luciferian, Spiritual Origin To One of The Biggest Hoaxes in History Evolution - The Christian Truther - February 20th, 2017 [February 20th, 2017]
- Poet Robinson Jeffers to be topic at OLLI meeting - Chico Enterprise-Record - February 24th, 2017 [February 24th, 2017]
- Our Lady of Fatima and the Battle With Freemasonry, Part 1 - Church Militant - February 25th, 2017 [February 25th, 2017]
- What Is Wrong With Yoga? - Catholic Church - March 1st, 2017 [March 1st, 2017]
- 4 books tell stories of Ky. drug world - Glasgow Daily Times - March 3rd, 2017 [March 3rd, 2017]
- Hinduism vs Hindutva: The search for an ideology in times of cow ... - Hindustan Times - April 8th, 2017 [April 8th, 2017]
- Demystifying the Beliefs of Pantheism - thoughtco.com - April 8th, 2017 [April 8th, 2017]
- Adventists appeal court ruling on Kellogg Sabbath accommodation case - Adventist News Network - April 8th, 2017 [April 8th, 2017]
- 'Sgt. Pepper's' Turns 50: The Newsweek Review of The Beatles' Masterpiece - Newsweek - June 7th, 2017 [June 7th, 2017]
- Seven Things Evil Is Not: What the Death of My Son Taught Me - ChristianityToday.com - June 8th, 2017 [June 8th, 2017]
- How Scotland inspired Bram Stoker's Dracula - The Scotsman - June 14th, 2017 [June 14th, 2017]
- My Turn: Respecting Mother - Concord Monitor - June 16th, 2017 [June 16th, 2017]
- Who were the authors of the so-called Gnostic gospels, and what did they believe? - Aleteia EN - June 24th, 2017 [June 24th, 2017]
- This Former MTV Icon Found Inner Peace Through Islam - HuffPost - June 24th, 2017 [June 24th, 2017]
- Views | Pantheism.com - June 26th, 2017 [June 26th, 2017]
- New Names for Old Gods - Patheos (blog) - June 29th, 2017 [June 29th, 2017]
- The Universe Is the Mind of God - The Costa Rican Times - June 30th, 2017 [June 30th, 2017]
- On religion: Being aware of our connectivity to God and each other - The Intelligencer - June 30th, 2017 [June 30th, 2017]
- A Modern Day Inquisition: Rabbi Joseph Dweck - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - July 3rd, 2017 [July 3rd, 2017]
- Hinman's ABEAN Argument Part 3: More Objections - Patheos (blog) - July 7th, 2017 [July 7th, 2017]
- 20 Options on God (Find Yours Here) - Patheos (blog) - July 8th, 2017 [July 8th, 2017]
- Nelsons Leads Tanglewood Resurrection - The Boston Musical ... - The Boston Musical Intelligencer - July 8th, 2017 [July 8th, 2017]
- Hindu-Americans Don't Vote Republican - The American Conservative - July 10th, 2017 [July 10th, 2017]
- Through the Viewfinder: Pamela Ryder with Peter Markus - Brooklyn Rail - July 15th, 2017 [July 15th, 2017]
- Why Dina Nath Batra wants Tagore, Urdu, Mughals removed from school books - DailyO - July 25th, 2017 [July 25th, 2017]
- 'Heretics!' Illustrates the Contentiousness Surrounding Philosophy - PopMatters - August 1st, 2017 [August 1st, 2017]
- Is Your Christian Worldview Cohesive? - Cape May County Herald - August 2nd, 2017 [August 2nd, 2017]
- Senryu pries open 'The Jaws of Life' to explore death on latest release - Maryville Daily Times - August 3rd, 2017 [August 3rd, 2017]
- Star Wars' religious imagery is more than just coincidence - Catholic Herald Online (blog) - August 5th, 2017 [August 5th, 2017]
- This World as Philosophically Necessary - Patheos (blog) - August 10th, 2017 [August 10th, 2017]
- Staying power: a poet's place in God's agenda - National Catholic Reporter - August 10th, 2017 [August 10th, 2017]
- Gratitude So Burdensome? - First Things - August 11th, 2017 [August 11th, 2017]
- Unitarian Universalism and Pantheism World Pantheism - August 13th, 2017 [August 13th, 2017]
- Pantheism - Simple English Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - August 22nd, 2017 [August 22nd, 2017]
- Pantheism - History - AllAboutHistory.org - August 22nd, 2017 [August 22nd, 2017]
- Dennis Andrew from Poole says 'I am Druid' - Somerset Live - August 25th, 2017 [August 25th, 2017]
- Spinozism - Wikipedia - August 25th, 2017 [August 25th, 2017]
- World Pantheist Movement - Official Site - January 26th, 2018 [January 26th, 2018]
- World Pantheism - The online community for scientific pantheists - February 4th, 2018 [February 4th, 2018]
- Pantheism. I believe that the universe created itself ... - February 6th, 2018 [February 6th, 2018]
- Lesson 10: Pantheism and New-Age Mysticism | Free Sunday ... - July 15th, 2018 [July 15th, 2018]
- Naturalistic pantheism - Wikipedia - July 27th, 2018 [July 27th, 2018]
- Pantheism | Inters.org - September 2nd, 2018 [September 2nd, 2018]
- Pantheism | Encyclopedia.com - September 7th, 2018 [September 7th, 2018]
- Pantheism - New World Encyclopedia - October 6th, 2018 [October 6th, 2018]
- AN INTRODUCTION TO PANTHEISM - Personal/Professional - October 6th, 2018 [October 6th, 2018]
- About | Pantheism.com - November 5th, 2018 [November 5th, 2018]
- What is pantheism? | CARM.org - November 5th, 2018 [November 5th, 2018]
- Pantheism | Philosophy Talk - December 16th, 2018 [December 16th, 2018]
- Pantheism - Pantheism and panentheism in ancient and ... - December 19th, 2018 [December 19th, 2018]
- Against Pantheism Undivided Looking - Wall - January 7th, 2019 [January 7th, 2019]
- Pantheism | Britannica.com - April 16th, 2019 [April 16th, 2019]
- Lay Faithful to Gather in Rome to Pray for the Church on Eve of Amazon Synod - National Catholic Register - October 1st, 2019 [October 1st, 2019]
- Cdl. Burke: Revolution Is the Goal - Church Militant - October 1st, 2019 [October 1st, 2019]
- EXCLUSIVE: Catholic priest defends burning Pachamama effigy as within law of God - Lifesite - November 13th, 2019 [November 13th, 2019]