It's no secret that governments worldwide are increasingly hostile to scrutiny of their conduct. But, at a moment when too many media outlets see their role as working with the state to reinforce official narratives, one advocate of press freedom reminds us that the struggle isn't over the "disinformation" and "misinformation" called out by opportunistic politicians, it's over control of information. Will people be free in the future to decide for themselves what's truth and what's BS? Or will we be spoon-fed whatever the powers-that-be endorse?
"Governments realize that they are in an existential battle over who controls information, who controls the narrative, and they are waging a frontal assault against independent journalism around the world," Joel Simon, the exiting head of the Committee to Protects Journalists (CPJ), told CNN's Brian Stelter.
"This is the information age, and we are in a kind of millennial battle over who controls information," he added. "Who controls it? That's the power struggle. And so, governments recognizerepressive governments, but even democratic governmentsthat this is an essential tool that they need to maintain power and journalists are their adversaries."
Simon spoke after the release of a CPJ report warning of escalating attacks on journalists, demonstrating that the stakes for those who offend government officials are very high. The report found 293 reporters jailed for their work around the world, and at least 24 killed because of their efforts.
CPJ isn't the only organization recognizing that independent sources of information are under attack. Last October, the Norwegian Nobel Committee awarded the Nobel Peace Prize to Maria Ressa and Dmitry Muratov for their coverage of government conduct in the Philippines and Russia "in a world in which democracy and freedom of the press face increasingly adverse conditions."
"Free, independent and fact-based journalism serves to protect against abuse of power, lies and war propaganda," the committee added.
Unfortunately, the award illustrated the extent to which journalists can be co-opted as gatekeepers. Ressa sniffed in 2019 that "the wholesale dumping of Wikileaks actually isn't journalism," distinguishing her efforts from those of the organization's founder, Julian Assange, who languishes in prison, awaiting his fate after exposing abuse of power, lies, and war propaganda by the U.S. government. Too many journalists are open to cultivation by politicians as a separate class from purveyors of alleged "misinformation," disinformation," or "extremism" depending on what's convenient at the moment.
Before the pandemic, New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern joined with French President Emmanuel Macron to develop the Christchurch Call targeting "extremist content" online. Since then, New Zealand in particular has moved to emphasize "freedom from misinformation" especially with regard to efforts against COVID-19.
Similarly, the British government commissioned a 2021 report from RAND Europe promoting practices by "civil society, government, media and social-media-company actors in terms of reducing the spread of false information and building societal resilience" with regard to "hateful extremism within society during COVID-19." The report highlights Germany's notorious NetzDG Act as an example that "levying large fines on tech companies that do not remove false information and hateful extremist content in a timely way can increase companies' responsiveness in removing this content from their platforms."
Despite robust First Amendment protections for free speech rights, the U.S. is not immune to powerful people's desire to control information.
"We're going to have to figure out how we rein in our media environment so that you can't just spew disinformation and misinformation," Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) insisted last year.
In July, White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki called on social media companies to act as government proxies by removing what the administration flags as "narratives dangerous to public health."
Interestingly, CPJ's Joel Simon predicted the pandemic would empower efforts to control information.
"[W]e must be mindful that when we get to the other side of the pandemic, we may be left with a narrative, being written by China, that government control over information was essential to combating the crisis," he warned in March 2020. "That would be a devastating blow to the global information system, one that could endure even as the memories of the terrible pandemic we are currently facing slowly fade."
Since then, he's been proven painfully prescient as politicians' concerns have morphed from fighting "extremism" to suppressing "disinformation" to a weird amalgam of the two, unified by the alleged need to control what the public says, reads, and shares.
That's not to say, by the way, that material tagged as extremism isn't extreme, or that posts called out as disinformation aren't false. To open a web browser is to encounter a wide world of bigotry, bogus concerns about vaccine safety, nonsensical charges about election integrity, and fact-free arguments over whether or not COVID-19 even exists. But bullshit isn't a recent invention.
Free societies recognize that it's a lot more dangerous to let government officials designate what constitutes capital-T Truth than it is to respect people's rights to decide for themselves. When officialdom makes the call, legitimate news outlets get called "fake," as former President Trump often smeared his critics, extremists get conflated with opponents of school policies, as the Justice Department did last fall, and claims that COVID-19 originated in a lab leak in China are suppressed as conspiracy theories before later earning respectful treatment.
Truthful information doesn't require a government seal of approval because government officials are as flawed and biased as anybody else. They're prone to declaring debates over for convenient reasons of their own even as new evidence emerges and disagreements remain unresolved not necessarily because of rejection of facts, but often over fundamental differences in values and preferences. Powerful figures are in no position to save us from bad information because they're a major source of the stuff themselves and, if allowed, can use force to impose their versions of reality on dissenters.
We really are in an existential battle over who controls information, just as Joel Simon warned. It's not a battle over what constitutes truth, which remains as hard as ever to determine. Instead, this battle over control of information is a struggle over our freedom to decide for ourselves without having other people's decisions crammed down our throats.
More:
It's Dangerous to Allow Politicians and Officials to Decide What Constitutes 'Truth' - Reason
- Jacinda Ardern fury as NZ in lockdown after ONE Covid case: 'Never-ending nightmare' - Daily Express - August 24th, 2021 [August 24th, 2021]
- Should we be wearing masks while exercising? Jacinda Ardern, Ashley Bloomfield respond to confusion - Newshub - August 24th, 2021 [August 24th, 2021]
- Lockdowns or Vaccines? 3 Pacific Nations Try Diverging Paths - VOA Asia - August 24th, 2021 [August 24th, 2021]
- Fall of Afghanistan: Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern says NZ unlikely to rescue 'everyone we want to' - New Zealand Herald - August 24th, 2021 [August 24th, 2021]
- COVID-19: Jacinda Ardern defends pace locations of interest are released to public after Wellington Mayor criticism - Newshub - August 24th, 2021 [August 24th, 2021]
- Jacinda Ardern asks the Taliban to be 'nice' to women - The Spectator Australia - August 24th, 2021 [August 24th, 2021]
- Graham Adams: Is Jacinda Ardern the Messiah? Or just a very crafty politician? - New Zealand Herald - August 24th, 2021 [August 24th, 2021]
- Will Jacinda Ardern Suffer Churchills Fate Once The (Covid) War Is Over? - Forbes - August 24th, 2021 [August 24th, 2021]
- Covid-19: 'Prepare for the inevitability of community transmission' - Stuff.co.nz - October 9th, 2021 [October 9th, 2021]
- New Zealand's Jacinda Ardern admits nation can't get rid of coronavirus | TheHill - The Hill - October 9th, 2021 [October 9th, 2021]
- Why Jacinda Ardern giving up on eliminating COVID-19 is a political gamble for the popular PM - ABC News - October 9th, 2021 [October 9th, 2021]
- New Zealand increases climate aid ahead of UN summit - The Indian Express - October 20th, 2021 [October 20th, 2021]
- Covid 19: No change likely for Auckland, Waikato but alert levels now on borrowed time - Stuff.co.nz - October 20th, 2021 [October 20th, 2021]
- Anniversary of a landslide: new research reveals what really swung New Zealand's 2020 'COVID election' - The Conversation AU - October 20th, 2021 [October 20th, 2021]
- Covid 19 Delta outbreak: Scathing feedback from experts on Jacinda Ardern's traffic light system to replace alert levels - New Zealand Herald - October 20th, 2021 [October 20th, 2021]
- Why Jacinda Arderns clumsy leadership response to Delta could still be the right approach - The Conversation AU - October 20th, 2021 [October 20th, 2021]
- Everyday activities won't be available to the unvaccinated - Jacinda Ardern - RNZ - October 20th, 2021 [October 20th, 2021]
- When will Aucklanders turn on Jacinda Ardern? - MacroBusiness - October 20th, 2021 [October 20th, 2021]
- Time for the National Party to embrace kindness - Stuff.co.nz - November 29th, 2021 [November 29th, 2021]
- Leadership in the time of Covid is a thankless job, in politics and in sport - Stuff.co.nz - November 29th, 2021 [November 29th, 2021]
- New Zealand PM Ardern backs Five Eyes, open to other alliances - Reuters - November 29th, 2021 [November 29th, 2021]
- PM Jacinda Ardern: 'Throughout this pandemic one of the hardest things to do has been to plan' - RNZ - November 29th, 2021 [November 29th, 2021]
- Covid 19 Delta outbreak: PM Jacinda Ardern on Covid, visit to Auckland, and National Party turmoil - New Zealand Herald - November 29th, 2021 [November 29th, 2021]
- COVID-19: No reason to cancel Christmas over Omicron variant - Jacinda Ardern - Newshub - November 29th, 2021 [November 29th, 2021]
- Government needs to work with businesses - Otago Daily Times - January 11th, 2022 [January 11th, 2022]
- New Zealands successful Covid policies hid inequality the government cant ignore it this year - The Guardian - January 11th, 2022 [January 11th, 2022]
- Nearly halfway through the term, parties start to stake out territory - Stuff - April 14th, 2022 [April 14th, 2022]
- Jacinda Ardern and Christopher Luxon's letters to each other revealed - New Zealand Herald - April 14th, 2022 [April 14th, 2022]
- The Front Page: Why neither Louisa Wall nor Jacinda Ardern look good in departure drama - New Zealand Herald - April 14th, 2022 [April 14th, 2022]
- Parliament protest: Jacinda Ardern came into contact with Covid-infected cops while thanking them - New Zealand Herald - April 14th, 2022 [April 14th, 2022]
- On budget day, will Labour be bold enough to seize back the cost-of-living narrative? - The Spinoff - May 12th, 2022 [May 12th, 2022]
- Rugs, perfume, couture: What PM and other MPs declared - New Zealand Herald - May 12th, 2022 [May 12th, 2022]
- Covid 19 Omicron outbreak: 9392 new Covid cases and 9 deaths, 7 in ICU - New Zealand Herald - May 12th, 2022 [May 12th, 2022]
- Two-tier visa system a 'kick in the guts' - RNZ - May 12th, 2022 [May 12th, 2022]
- PM Jacinda Ardern says soft on crime claims 'just wrong' as former detective hails NZ Police's international reputation - Newshub - May 12th, 2022 [May 12th, 2022]
- The Magnificent Seven: The Knight and Dames Jacinda Ardern didn't want to mess with - New Zealand Herald - May 12th, 2022 [May 12th, 2022]
- Taranaki man charged with threatening to kill Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern - New Zealand Herald - May 12th, 2022 [May 12th, 2022]
- Ardern horrified as New Zealand faces record housing crash - MacroBusiness - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- School lunches: Mum's photo of school lunch shows what some school kids are offered - New Zealand Herald - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- 7 Women To Watch At The UN General Assembly - Forbes - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- She has the power! - The Tribune India - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- Government outlines new laws to crackdown on hidden criminal wealth - Stuff - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- NZ government's Working with Survivors continues cover-up of Pike River mine disaster - WSWS - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- PM Jacinda Ardern won't confirm whether Government planning to scrap mask mandates, says they're under review - Newshub - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- New Zealand will continue to cooperate with more assertive China ... - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- Jacinda Ardern to travel to New York for UN meeting later this month - New Zealand Herald - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- Rt Hon Jacinda Ardern - Prime Minister of New Zealand - NZ Labour Party - September 8th, 2022 [September 8th, 2022]
- Jacinda Ardern makes final appearance as New Zealand leader - Los ... - January 31st, 2023 [January 31st, 2023]
- Jacinda Ardern | Biography, Facts, & Partner | Britannica - January 31st, 2023 [January 31st, 2023]
- Jacinda Ardern speech: New Zealand's former prime minister delivers emotional final speech to Parliament: "You can be a mother ... you can lead,... - April 8th, 2023 [April 8th, 2023]
- Former Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern will donate clothing to Te Papa - New Zealand Herald - April 8th, 2023 [April 8th, 2023]
- Jacinda Ardern appointed trustee of Prince William's Earthshot Prize - BBC - April 8th, 2023 [April 8th, 2023]
- Jacinda Ardern joins The Earthshot Prize as a Trustee - Earthshot Prize - April 8th, 2023 [April 8th, 2023]
- Jacinda Ardern says goodbye to parliament: how her politics of kindness fell on unkind times - The Conversation - April 8th, 2023 [April 8th, 2023]
- New Zealand's Jacinda Ardern takes on a new role after leaving politics this week - NPR - April 8th, 2023 [April 8th, 2023]
- Harry, Meghan called toxic as Jacinda Ardern joins Prince William's project - Hindustan Times - April 8th, 2023 [April 8th, 2023]