Both India and the international community have been engaged in a heated debate over whether the decision of a New Delhi magistrates court to suspend exhibition of the film, Indias Daughter, is a violation of freedom of speech. Such was the ire against this order that the director of the film Leslee Udwin called it suicide by India. One of the leading news channels, in a never-before protest, kept a banner of the film playing for the duration of the proposed screening. The British Broadcasting Corporation, of course, simply ignored the order and not only broadcast the film, but also uploaded it on YouTube, only taking it off after several hours.
It surprised me why people were defending hate speech in the name of free speech. I couldnt understand why a 60-minute film, which devoted 41 minutes to victim-blaming and propagating misogynistic ideas, was being defended so vehemently? The only rational explanation that I could find was probably because Indias hate speech laws, inherited from our colonial masters whether in our criminal statute or the exceptions incorporated to the freedom of speech in Article 19 of the Constitution, have always been concerned with maintaining public order and not offending mainstream morality. These laws have, therefore, naturally been used to silence dissent, sexuality and the voice of the marginalised. Whether it was the protests and banning of the film Water as immoral; the works of MF Hussain as obscene; and the statement of two little girls on Facebook against the public inconvenience caused by a bandh after Bal Thackerays death as spreading religious hatred. Public order and morality always enables perpetuation of the dominant discourse. Therefore, until the law defines hate speech as antipathetic to public order rather than as an offence to dignity, misogynistic speech that perpetuates structural violence against women, though it may maintain public order, will never fall within its purview.
A Facebook post shared a few days ago put hate speech into context for me. It read Women are not killed in a bubble. Theyre killed in a world that disenfranchises them, positions them as the other and disadvantages them. They are killed in a society that sends the message clearly and repeatedly that they are sexual objects for mens glorification and possession. The cultural elements that help to create this message arent the cause of violence against women but they are the contest in which they happen.
From khap panchayats, judges, police commissioners, religious pundits, to friends and family, women are told everyday, if you own a mobile phone and are seen in public after sunset, you are going to be raped, because the primitive male brain gets aroused! We are told everyday through television programmes, cinema and advertising what a good woman does and what a bad woman deserves! In this background, when a few weeks ago, the daily papers, advertised a sensational new film to be aired exclusively on a leading news channel on Womens Day, featuring a rape convict blaming the victim for this rape, I couldnt understand the purpose for this. Was this to titillate, present an excuse or just simply get eyeballs? There is nothing new or earth shaking in victim-blaming; we live with it every day, in various forms fictionalised and real and despite advancing technologically, we are simply becoming a more and more misogynistic society, unleashing newer forms of violence against women each decade.
There is, no doubt, that hate speech contributes exponentially to perpetuating patriarchal values in society and these values create the context in which violence against women occurs and is justified. It is no surprise that the German constitution gives human dignity primacy over competing values, because it is a society that realised social re-engineering from an anti-Semitic to an egalitarian society mandates the law silence ideas that validated and amplified values that are sought to be eliminated. Unfortunately, in India despite the mandate of Article 15 of our Constitution providing for positive discrimination in favour of women and Article 21 which has been defined by the Supreme Court to mean a life with dignity, words that take away the dignity of women, that encourage and validate violence against them are still being defended in the name of freedom of speech.
Free speech is a myth like the free market. Ideas of the majority and those that benefit commerce will always pervade society more deeply and if we have to change the context in which violence is perpetuated on women by replacing patriarchal values with progressive ones, we have to privilege the safety and dignity of women over the freedom to broadcast hate speech.
December 2012, India Gate, the power corridor of Delhi, was filled with protestors, after the media reported the brutal rape of a young girl. This girl was soon named Nirbhaya (The Fearless) by the crowds. For days people fought water cannons demanding answers, demanding justice, demanding safety. Such had been the courage of this young woman whose only crime was that she boarded a city bus at 8.30 at night despite being brutally raped on the bus, Nirbhaya fought from hospital, reporting what she could recall and refused to be defined by this violence. The crowds fighting on the streets demanded the state ensure that the city was safe for women. People wanted street lights, public transport, police patrols, community spaces that were safe for women, gender audits of communities and public places. People wanted actions not diagnosis; 60 years of diagnosis and excuses for rape culture had exhausted India. In December 2012, the discourse had moved, from Why rape happens, to What the government is not doing to make the city safe! Until in 2015, Leslee Udwin sent it back by giving a platform to misogyny. Lets not defend this in the name of freedom of speech.
The author is a practicing lawyer at the Delhi High Court
See the article here:
- Turkey's crackdown on freedom of speech intensifies - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- Bill of Rights Transcript Text - National Archives and ... - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- Freedom of Speech (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy) - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- 3 Muslims shot dead by Atheist || #muslimlivesmatter - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- Media Studies 104A - 2015-02-10 - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- USA Freedom of Speech and Jesus Christ - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- France Arrests French Comedian Dieudonne 3 Days After Charlie Hebdo Freedom of Speech - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- Charlie Hebdo's "Freedom of Speech" - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- John Robertson on Greg Shapiro's United States of Europe - S3Ep01 - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- The Illuminati: The Freedom of Speech 2015 Conspiracy - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- Muslims oppose insult to Islam in the name of freedom of speech - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- RE: HannibalTheVictor13's resentment over thunderf00t and his "freedom of speech". - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- Policy update restricts demonstrations - February 14th, 2015 [February 14th, 2015]
- Italian senators pass bill criminalizing denial of genocides - February 14th, 2015 [February 14th, 2015]
- Michael Buerk Interview - Freedom of Speech & Paris Attacks - Video - February 14th, 2015 [February 14th, 2015]
- 'Freedom Of Speech' Topic Tuesday #12 - Video - February 14th, 2015 [February 14th, 2015]
- One dead after shots fired at Copenhagen freedom of speech meeting - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Shots Fired at Copenhagen Free Speech Event: Reports - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- One man dead and three policemen wounded at freedom of speech seminar in Denmark - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Copenhagen caf: two gunmen in terror attack at freedom of speech event - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- One dead in gun attack on Danish freedom of speech meeting - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Free Speech Debate Still Alive After Attack in Denmark - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Esau uses Freedom of Speech as a weapon! - Video - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Copenhagen attacks an 'affront to freedom of speech': Tony Abbott - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Copenhagen suspect known to police - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Copenhagen police kill suspect linked to two fatal attacks - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Freedom of Speech and Freedom of Press - Lincoln University - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Copenhagen Shooting: Deadly attack at free speech meeting with cartoonist who depicted Muh - Video - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Shots fired at Copenhagens Krudttoenden cafe free speech event a report - Video - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Media Studies 104A - 2015-02-12 - Video - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- WallBuilders Live 2015-02-11 Wednesday - Freedom of Speech on College Campuses - Video - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Yisrael Beytenu at Charlie Hebdo freedom of speech protest - Video - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- TOI debate on freedom of speech wows Kolkata - The Times ... - February 16th, 2015 [February 16th, 2015]
- Muslims Killing Atheists! - Video - February 16th, 2015 [February 16th, 2015]
- AP Top Stories February 14 P - Video - February 16th, 2015 [February 16th, 2015]
- Duck Dynasty's Phil Robertson to Receive Freedom of Speech Award - February 17th, 2015 [February 17th, 2015]
- Freedom of speech, but... SHOTS - Video - February 17th, 2015 [February 17th, 2015]
- Letters to the editor: We must do more to stop terrorists - February 18th, 2015 [February 18th, 2015]
- Freedom Of Speech Naam Ki Koi Chiz Hoti Hai - Alia Bhatt On AIB Controversy - Video - February 18th, 2015 [February 18th, 2015]
- DoomShow,Freedom of Speech under attack by Terrrorists - Video - February 18th, 2015 [February 18th, 2015]
- Greenpeace activist refutes govt charge of being anti-national - February 19th, 2015 [February 19th, 2015]
- Jailed Al Jazeera journalist concerned about freedom of speech - February 19th, 2015 [February 19th, 2015]
- Fan claims municipal police violating freedom of speech - February 19th, 2015 [February 19th, 2015]
- Jailed journalist concerned about freedom of speech - February 19th, 2015 [February 19th, 2015]
- Denmark: Police launch manhunt for Copenhagen cafe shooter - Video - February 19th, 2015 [February 19th, 2015]
- Freedom of speech denied outside of Skillet concert Pittsburgh - Video - February 19th, 2015 [February 19th, 2015]
- Alex Jones is Right! Snowden is Right! Government Crooks Via FaceBook! - Video - February 21st, 2015 [February 21st, 2015]
- "McCann Trolling" v "Freedom of Speech" - Video - February 21st, 2015 [February 21st, 2015]
- Aamir Khan disapproves AIB Roast, KJo reacts - February 22nd, 2015 [February 22nd, 2015]
- South Africa: Post the State of the Nation Address - February 23rd, 2015 [February 23rd, 2015]
- The Great Purge of Free Speech Has Begun............ - Video - February 23rd, 2015 [February 23rd, 2015]
- Big Brother Watch calls for reform of social media communications laws - February 24th, 2015 [February 24th, 2015]
- Comment on Have an opinion? Stuff it! by boh-liao - February 24th, 2015 [February 24th, 2015]
- Sports Hotline: What happened to freedom of speech - have Rangers fans lost their right to offend? - February 24th, 2015 [February 24th, 2015]
- Freedom of Speech: Canadians support Charlie Hebdos choice to publish images of Prophet Muhammad - February 24th, 2015 [February 24th, 2015]
- Should there be limitations on freedom of speech? - Video - February 24th, 2015 [February 24th, 2015]
- Topic Tuesday #39 - Freedom of Speech? (Minecraft Survival Games Gameplay) - Video - February 24th, 2015 [February 24th, 2015]
- DW Freedom of Speech Award for Raif Badawi - February 25th, 2015 [February 25th, 2015]
- THROWDOWN THURSDAY: The Four Causes of Anti-Israelism - February 26th, 2015 [February 26th, 2015]
- FCC Reinstates Net Neutrality, Protecting Open Internet - February 27th, 2015 [February 27th, 2015]
- CPDP 2015: Online privacy versus freedom of speech. Balancing rights in the EU context. - Video - February 27th, 2015 [February 27th, 2015]
- Net neutrality lobby victorious after FCC ruling - February 27th, 2015 [February 27th, 2015]
- Freedom of speech means tolerating opposing viewpoints - March 2nd, 2015 [March 2nd, 2015]
- The Death of Freedom of Speech on the Internet - Video - March 2nd, 2015 [March 2nd, 2015]
- Dangerman - Freedom Of Speech - Video - March 2nd, 2015 [March 2nd, 2015]
- Rebel Ratepayer Raps 4 Freedom of Speech in City of Melton, Melbourne - Video - March 2nd, 2015 [March 2nd, 2015]
- Students stand up for free speech at UI - March 2nd, 2015 [March 2nd, 2015]
- John Kerry asked to act on murder of Avijit Roy - March 3rd, 2015 [March 3rd, 2015]
- Not so Charlie now? - March 4th, 2015 [March 4th, 2015]
- ISIS Supporters Threaten "Charlie Hedbo style" Attack Against Twitter Employees - March 4th, 2015 [March 4th, 2015]
- AIB trying hard about freedom of speech - Video - March 4th, 2015 [March 4th, 2015]
- Freedom of Speech situation in Bangladesh BBC World Service discussion - Video - March 4th, 2015 [March 4th, 2015]
- Noam Chomsky on Freedom of Speech and Anti-Fascism [full] - Video - March 4th, 2015 [March 4th, 2015]
- AND..Y we should stand up for freedom of speech | AIB Roast | Delhi Elections | AAP - Video - March 4th, 2015 [March 4th, 2015]
- Vclav Havel Fellowship programme helps young journalists from post-Soviet bloc states - March 5th, 2015 [March 5th, 2015]
- Murderers condemned as message of peace is North Herts conferences priority - March 5th, 2015 [March 5th, 2015]
- four freedoms speech - FDR - Video - March 5th, 2015 [March 5th, 2015]
- Watch what the youth feels about the AIB Roast Controversy & so called "freedom of speech" - Video - March 5th, 2015 [March 5th, 2015]
- freedom of speech eminem remix - Video - March 5th, 2015 [March 5th, 2015]
- Freedom of speech has no limits- - Video - March 5th, 2015 [March 5th, 2015]