I woke up on Saturday to a heartbreaking front-page article in the New York Times about a terminally ill young woman who chooses to freeze her brain. She is drawn into a cottage industry spurred by transhumanist principles that offers to preserve people in liquid nitrogen immediately after death and store their bodies (or at least their heads) in hopes that they can be reanimated or digitally replicated in a technologically advanced future.
Proponents have added a patina of scientific plausibility to this idea by citing the promise of new technologies in neuroscience, particularly recent work in connectomicsa field that maps the connections between neurons. The suggestion is that a detailed map of neural connections could be enough to restore a persons mind, memories, and personality by uploading it into a computer simulation.
Science tells us that a map of connections is not sufficient to simulate, let alone replicate, a nervous system, and that there are enormous barriers to achieving immortality in silico. First, what information is required to replicate a human mind? Second, do current or foreseeable freezing methods preserve the necessary information, and how will this information be recovered? Third, and most confounding to our intuition, would a simulation really be you?
I study a small roundworm, Caenorhabditis elegans, which is by far the best-described animal in all of biology. We know all of its genes and all of its cells (a little over 1,000). We know the identity and complete synaptic connectivity of its 302 neurons, and we have known it for 30 years.
If we could upload or roughly simulate any brain, it should be that of C. elegans. Yet even with the full connectome in hand, a static model of this network of connections lacks most of the information necessary to simulate the mind of the worm. In short, brain activity cannot be inferred from synaptic neuroanatomy.
Synapses are the physical contacts between neurons where a special form of chemoelectric signalingneurotransmissionoccurs, and they come in many varieties. They are complex molecular machines made of thousands of proteins and specialized lipid structures. It is the precise molecular composition of synapses and the membranes they are embedded in that confers their properties. The presence or absence of a synapse, which is all that current connectomics methods tell us, suggests that a possible functional relationship between two neurons exists, but little or nothing about the nature of this relationshipprecisely what you need to know to simulate it.
Additionally, neurons and other cells in the brain are in constant communication through signaling pathways that do not act through synapses. Many of the signals that regulate fundamental behaviors such as eating, sleeping, mood, mating, and social bonding are mediated by chemical cues acting through networks that are invisible to us anatomically. We know that the same set of synaptic connections can function very differently depending on what mix of these signals is present at a given time. These issues highlight an important distinction: the colossally hard problem of simulating any brain as opposed to the stupendously more difficult task of replicating a particular brain, which is required for the promised personal immortality of uploading.
The features of your neurons (and other cells) and synapses that make you you are not generic. The vast array of subtle chemical modifications, states of gene regulation, and subcellular distributions of molecular complexes are all part of the dynamic flux of a living brain. These things are not details that average out in a large nervous system; rather, they are the very things that engrams (the physical constituents of memories) are made of.
While it might be theoretically possible to preserve these features in dead tissue, that certainly is not happening now. The technology to do so, let alone the ability to read this information back out of such a specimen, does not yet exist even in principle. It is this purposeful conflation of what is theoretically conceivable with what is ever practically possible that exploits peoples vulnerability.
Finally, would an upload really be you? This is unanswerable, but we can dip our toes in. Whatever our subjective sense of self is, lets assume it arises from the operation of the physical matter of the brain. We could also tentatively conclude that such awareness is substrate-neutral: if brains can be conscious, a computer program that does everything a brain does should be conscious, too. If one is also willing to imagine arbitrarily complex technology, then we can also think about simulating a brain down to the synaptic or molecular or (why not?) atomic or quantum level.
But what is this replica? Is it subjectively you or is it a new, separate being? The idea that you can be conscious in two places at the same time defies our intuition. Parsimony suggests that replication will result in two different conscious entities. Simulation, if it were to occur, would result in a new person who is like you but whose conscious experience you dont have access to.
That means that any suggestion that you can come back to life is simply snake oil. Transhumanists have responses to these issues. In my experience, they consist of alternating demands that we trust our intuition about nonexistent technology (uploading could work) but deny our intuition about consciousness (it would not be me).
No one who has experienced the disbelief of losing a loved one can help but sympathize with someone who pays $80,000 to freeze their brain. But reanimation or simulation is an abjectly false hope that is beyond the promise of technology and is certainly impossible with the frozen, dead tissue offered by the cryonics industry. Those who profit from this hope deserve our anger and contempt.
Michael Hendricks is a neuroscientist and assistant professor of biology at McGill University.
Read the original here:
The False Science of Cryonics - MIT Technology Review
- The Little Glass Boy - Hyperallergic - February 11th, 2017 [February 11th, 2017]
- Florida's First Body-Freezing Cryonics Facility Now Open In Miami - CBS Local - February 14th, 2017 [February 14th, 2017]
- Head Case Scottish writer: 'Decapitate me after death, freeze my ... - Herald Scotland - February 20th, 2017 [February 20th, 2017]
- 50 Years Frozen: Cryonics Today - Paste Magazine - February 20th, 2017 [February 20th, 2017]
- Cryonics This Scottish author pays 50 pounds a month to preserve his brain after death - Zee News - February 20th, 2017 [February 20th, 2017]
- There's a completely legal reason this American dentist has an office full of human heads - Quartz - February 21st, 2017 [February 21st, 2017]
- Going Underground: Cheltenham author's book about cryonics to be used in groundbreaking scheme - Gloucestershire Live - February 25th, 2017 [February 25th, 2017]
- Keegan Macintosh-British Columbia Guy Signs First Canadian Cryonic Contract - E Canada Now - March 1st, 2017 [March 1st, 2017]
- Heart tissue cryogenics breakthrough gives hope for transplant patients - The Guardian - March 2nd, 2017 [March 2nd, 2017]
- Murray Ballard shoots cryonics in The Prospect of Immortality - British Journal of Photography - March 7th, 2017 [March 7th, 2017]
- Stayin' Alive - The Stute - March 10th, 2017 [March 10th, 2017]
- Frozen Dead Guy Days: The story behind Nederland's most famous resident - The Denver Channel - March 11th, 2017 [March 11th, 2017]
- Off the Cuffs: Bibbs considers donation, cremation, cryonics - Cecil Whig - June 6th, 2017 [June 6th, 2017]
- Can A Human Be Frozen And Brought Back To Life? - Zidbits - June 7th, 2017 [June 7th, 2017]
- JoAnn Ruth Martin, Riverside, Calif. - Mason City Globe Gazette - June 13th, 2017 [June 13th, 2017]
- The confounding world of Cryonics, and the Kiwi scientists trying to ... - Stuff.co.nz - June 17th, 2017 [June 17th, 2017]
- Thirty years since its launch, Athens Photo Festival is 'still searching' - Kathimerini - June 21st, 2017 [June 21st, 2017]
- The plan to 'reawaken' cryogenically frozen brains and transplant them into someone else's skull - National Post - June 21st, 2017 [June 21st, 2017]
- A last-ditch attempt to stave off extinction as Sudan goes on Tinder - Irish Times - June 30th, 2017 [June 30th, 2017]
- Interview with entertainment professional Khu - Blasting News - July 15th, 2017 [July 15th, 2017]
- How Would the Human Body Respond to Carbonite Freezing? - Inverse - July 15th, 2017 [July 15th, 2017]
- Comic-Con: Seth MacFarlane's 'The Orville' Brings Unique Fan ... - Deadline - July 20th, 2017 [July 20th, 2017]
- PERSISTENCE OF LONG-TERM MEMORY: in Vitrified and Revived Simple Animals - h+ Magazine - July 22nd, 2017 [July 22nd, 2017]
- Brain Freeze: Have yours preserved in Salem for possible future revival - KATU - July 29th, 2017 [July 29th, 2017]
- A first in China cryonics: Dead woman put in deep freeze - EJ Insight - EJ Insight - August 15th, 2017 [August 15th, 2017]
- Walt Disney Was NOT Frozen - MousePlanet - August 16th, 2017 [August 16th, 2017]
- This Company Freezes Your Body So That You Could One Day Be Resurrected - Billionaire BLLNR | Singapore (registration) - August 18th, 2017 [August 18th, 2017]
- Husband of China's first cryogenics subject keeps his love and hope ... - South China Morning Post - August 18th, 2017 [August 18th, 2017]
- Frozen body of Chinese woman waits for science to breathe life into it - International Business Times, India Edition - August 19th, 2017 [August 19th, 2017]
- The Future is Here! Human Body Cryogenically Frozen for First Time Ever in China - Sputnik International - August 21st, 2017 [August 21st, 2017]
- A first in China cryonics: Dead woman put in deep freeze - EJ Insight - August 21st, 2017 [August 21st, 2017]
- How to live forever - TechRadar - August 22nd, 2017 [August 22nd, 2017]
- For The First Time Ever, a Woman in China Has Been Cryogenically ... - DeathRattleSports.com - August 24th, 2017 [August 24th, 2017]
- Freeze Frame: Lifting The Lid On Cryonics - Billionaire.com - August 24th, 2017 [August 24th, 2017]
- For The First Time Ever, A Woman in China Was Cryogenically Frozen - Futurism - August 25th, 2017 [August 25th, 2017]
- Chinese woman cryogenically frozen with 'COMPLETE possibility' of ... - Express.co.uk - August 25th, 2017 [August 25th, 2017]
- This company freezes your body so that you could one day be resurrected - AsiaOne - August 25th, 2017 [August 25th, 2017]
- Cryogenics Human & Pet Freezing for Preservation and Revival - March 19th, 2018 [March 19th, 2018]
- Cryonics: Putting Death on Ice - Visual Capitalist - June 4th, 2018 [June 4th, 2018]
- What is cryonics? - June 21st, 2018 [June 21st, 2018]
- Cryonics Failure - TV Tropes - June 26th, 2018 [June 26th, 2018]
- What is cryonics? - Cryogenics Human & Pet Freezing for ... - May 14th, 2019 [May 14th, 2019]
- Success in Cryonics - osiriscryonics.com - May 26th, 2019 [May 26th, 2019]
- A Novel That Riffs on Sex Dolls, Mary Shelley and Brexit - The New York Times - October 12th, 2019 [October 12th, 2019]
- Cryonics Technology Market Strategic New Technology Advancements and Future Outlook - TheLoop21 - October 12th, 2019 [October 12th, 2019]
- Huge Demand of Cryonics Technology Market 2019 Predictable to Witness Sustainable Evolution Over 2024 Including Leading Vendors- Praxair, Cellulis,... - October 12th, 2019 [October 12th, 2019]
- Cryonics Technology Market Present Scenario and the Growth Prospects with Forecast 2025 - Midnight Stocks - October 24th, 2019 [October 24th, 2019]
- Trends in Cryonics Technology Market Reviewed with 2027 Opportunities in New Research Report - TheLoop21 - October 24th, 2019 [October 24th, 2019]
- Dangling In Falsehoods And Deceptions: A Response To President Weah - Modern Ghana - December 26th, 2019 [December 26th, 2019]
- More Americans are choosing cremation over traditional burials, survey finds - USA TODAY - January 23rd, 2020 [January 23rd, 2020]
- Chris Pratt Shares the 'Crazy' Story of a Couple Found Completely Preserved in Ice - Pajiba - February 24th, 2020 [February 24th, 2020]
- Work begins on first cryonics storage facility in southern hemisphere - ABC Local - February 29th, 2020 [February 29th, 2020]
- If cryonics suddenly worked, wed need to face the fallout ... - February 29th, 2020 [February 29th, 2020]
- Cheating Death: Inside the Cryonics Institute, Where Your ... - February 29th, 2020 [February 29th, 2020]
- Cryonics Pros and Cons - Vision Launch - February 29th, 2020 [February 29th, 2020]
- Work begins on first cryonics storage facility in southern ... - February 29th, 2020 [February 29th, 2020]
- Cryonics: hype, hope or hell? - The Conversation - February 29th, 2020 [February 29th, 2020]
- The cryonics dilemma: will deep-frozen bodies be fit for new ... - February 29th, 2020 [February 29th, 2020]
- Osiris Cryonics - February 29th, 2020 [February 29th, 2020]
- Cryonics | Definition of Cryonics by Merriam-Webster - February 29th, 2020 [February 29th, 2020]
- Meet the Man Who Looks After Nederland's Frozen Dead Guy - 5280 | The Denver Magazine - March 4th, 2020 [March 4th, 2020]
- Ectogenesis: Overcoming the Shackles of Femininity - Northeast Now - March 10th, 2020 [March 10th, 2020]
- Cryonics, Dakota the Dog, and the Hope of Forever - Gizmodo - March 10th, 2020 [March 10th, 2020]
- Cryonics Technology Market 2020 Global Insights and Business Scenario Praxair, Cellulis, Cryologics, Cryotherm, KrioRus, VWR, Thermo Fisher... - March 10th, 2020 [March 10th, 2020]
- Global trade impact of the Coronavirus Cryonics Technology Market Applications and Company's Active in the Industry - amitnetserver - April 26th, 2020 [April 26th, 2020]
- 9 great reads from CNET this week - MSN Money - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- Hacking the Apocalypse: Your new guide to surviving the end of the world - CNET - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- 9 great reads from CNET this week - CNET - July 14th, 2020 [July 14th, 2020]
- Global Cryonics Technology Market Expected to Reach Highest CAGR by 2025| COVID-19 Impact Analysis and Top Players: Praxair, Cellulis, Cryologics,... - July 14th, 2020 [July 14th, 2020]
- Cryonics, brain preservation and the weird science of cheating death - CNET - July 14th, 2020 [July 14th, 2020]
- Global Cryonics Technology Market 2020 Analysis, Types, Applications, Forecast and COVID-19 Impact Analysis 2026 - Daily Research Chronicles - July 15th, 2020 [July 15th, 2020]
- How to survive the apocalypse: A practical guide to the end of days - CNET - July 26th, 2020 [July 26th, 2020]
- Global Cryonics Technology Market Key Players, Trends, Sales, Supply, Demand, Analysis and Forecast 2027: Praxair, Cellulis, Cryologics, Cryotherm,... - July 29th, 2020 [July 29th, 2020]
- Errol Morris Fans, Theres a Surprise for You on YouTube - Gizmodo Australia - July 30th, 2020 [July 30th, 2020]
- Cryonics Technology Market Share, Size, Cost, Revenue, Applications, Key Players and Forecast 2020-2024 - Bulletin Line - July 30th, 2020 [July 30th, 2020]
- Latest Innovative Report on Cryonics Technology Market 2020 | Trends, Growth Demand, Opportunities & Forecast To 2026 | Alcor Life Extension... - August 1st, 2020 [August 1st, 2020]
- Massive Growth in Russia Cryonics Technology Market Set to Witness Huge Growth by 2026 | Alcor Life Extension Foundation, Biocision, Cellulis, Cesca... - August 3rd, 2020 [August 3rd, 2020]
- How Cryonics Works | HowStuffWorks - August 3rd, 2020 [August 3rd, 2020]
- Cryonics: can death be avoided by freezing someone to revive in the future? - Explica - August 7th, 2020 [August 7th, 2020]
- These are the best films and TV shows to watch on Netflix in September - Milton Keynes Citizen - September 2nd, 2020 [September 2nd, 2020]