Health products powered by artificial intelligence are streaming into our lives, from virtual doctor apps to wearable sensors and drugstore chatbots.
IBM boasted that its AI could outthink cancer. Others say computer systems that read X-rays will make radiologists obsolete. AI can help doctors interpret MRIs of the heart, CT scans of the head and photographs of the back of the eye, and could potentially take over many mundane medical chores, freeing doctors to spend more time talking to patients, said Dr. Eric Topol, a cardiologist and executive vice president of Scripps Research in La Jolla.
Theres nothing that Ive seen in my 30-plus years studying medicine that could be as impactful and transformative as AI, Topol said. Even the Food and Drug Administration which has approved more than 40 AI products in the last five years says the potential of digital health is nothing short of revolutionary.
Yet many health industry experts fear AI-based products wont be able to match the hype. Some doctors and consumer advocates fear that the tech industry, which lives by the mantra fail fast and fix it later, is putting patients at risk and that regulators arent doing enough to keep consumers safe.
Early experiments in AI provide a reason for caution, said Mildred Cho, a professor of pediatrics at Stanfords Center for Biomedical Ethics.
Systems developed in one hospital often flop when deployed in a different facility, Cho said. Software used in the care of millions of Americans has been shown to discriminate against minorities. And AI systems sometimes learn to make predictions based on factors that have less to do with disease than the brand of MRI machine used, the time a blood test is taken or whether a patient was visited by a chaplain.
In one case, AI software incorrectly concluded that people with pneumonia were less likely to die if they had asthma an error that could have led doctors to deprive asthma patients of the extra care they need.
Its only a matter of time before something like this leads to a serious health problem, said Dr. Steven Nissen, chairman of cardiology at the Cleveland Clinic.
Medical AI, which pulled in $1.6 billion in venture capital funding in the third quarter alone, is nearly at the peak of inflated expectations, concluded a July report from research company Gartner. As the reality gets tested, there will likely be a rough slide into the trough of disillusionment.
That reality check could come in the form of disappointing results when AI products are ushered into the real world. Even Topol, the author of Deep Medicine: How Artificial Intelligence Can Make Healthcare Human Again, acknowledges that many AI products are little more than hot air.
Experts such as Dr. Bob Kocher, a partner at the venture capital firm Venrock, are blunter. Most AI products have little evidence to support them, Kocher said. Some risks wont become apparent until an AI system has been used by large numbers of patients. Were going to keep discovering a whole bunch of risks and unintended consequences of using AI on medical data, Kocher said.
None of the AI products sold in the U.S. have been tested in randomized clinical trials, the strongest source of medical evidence, Topol said. The first and only randomized trial of an AI system which found that colonoscopy with computer-aided diagnosis found more small polyps than standard colonoscopy was published online in October.
Few tech start-ups publish their research in peer-reviewed journals, which allow other scientists to scrutinize their work, according to a January article in the European Journal of Clinical Investigation. Such stealth research described only in press releases or promotional events often overstates a companys accomplishments.
And although software developers may boast about the accuracy of their AI devices, experts note that AI models are mostly tested on computers, not in hospitals or other medical facilities. Using unproven software may make patients into unwitting guinea pigs, said Dr. Ron Li, medical informatics director for AI clinical integration at Stanford Health Care.
AI systems that learn to recognize patterns in data are often described as black boxes because even their developers dont know how they reached their conclusions. Given that AI is so new and many of its risks unknown the field needs careful oversight, said Pilar Ossorio, a professor of law and bioethics at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.
Yet the majority of AI devices dont require FDA approval. None of the companies that I have invested in are covered by the FDA regulations, Kocher said.
Legislation passed by Congress in 2016 and championed by the tech industry exempts many types of medical software from federal review, including certain fitness apps, electronic health records and tools that help doctors make medical decisions.
Theres been little research on whether the 320,000 medical apps now in use actually improve health, according to a report on AI published Dec. 17 by the National Academy of Medicine.
The FDA has long focused its attention on devices that pose the greatest threat to patients. And consumer advocates acknowledge that some devices such as ones that help people count their daily steps need less scrutiny than ones that diagnose or treat disease.
Some software developers dont bother to apply for FDA clearance or authorization, even when legally required, according to a 2018 study in Annals of Internal Medicine.
Industry analysts say that AI developers have little interest in conducting expensive and time-consuming trials. Its not the main concern of these firms to submit themselves to rigorous evaluation that would be published in a peer-reviewed journal, said Joachim Roski, a principal at Booz Allen Hamilton, a technology consulting firm, and coauthor of the National Academys report. Thats not how the U.S. economy works.
But Oren Etzioni, chief executive at the Allen Institute for AI in Seattle, said AI developers have a financial incentive to make sure their medical products are safe.
If failing fast means a whole bunch of people will die, I dont think we want to fail fast, Etzioni said. Nobody is going to be happy, including investors, if people die or are severely hurt.
The FDA has come under fire in recent years for allowing the sale of dangerous medical devices, which have been linked by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists to 80,000 deaths and 1.7 million injuries over the last decade.
Many of these devices were cleared for use through a controversial process called the 510(k) pathway, which allows companies to market moderate-risk products with no clinical testing as long as theyre deemed similar to existing devices.
In 2011, a committee of the National Academy of Medicine concluded the 510(k) process is so fundamentally flawed that the FDA should throw it out and start over.
Instead, the FDA is using the process to greenlight AI devices.
Of the 14 AI products authorized by the FDA in 2017 and 2018, 11 were cleared through the 510(k) process, according to a November article in JAMA. None of these appear to have had new clinical testing, the study said.
The FDA cleared an AI device designed to help diagnose liver and lung cancer in 2018 based on its similarity to imaging software approved 20 years earlier. That software had itself been cleared because it was deemed substantially equivalent to products marketed before 1976.
AI products cleared by the FDA today are largely locked, so that their calculations and results will not change after they enter the market, said Bakul Patel, director for digital health at the FDAs Center for Devices and Radiological Health. The FDA has not yet authorized unlocked AI devices, whose results could vary from month to month in ways that developers cannot predict.
To deal with the flood of AI products, the FDA is testing a radically different approach to digital device regulation, focusing on evaluating companies, not products.
The FDAs pilot pre-certification program, launched in 2017, is designed to reduce the time and cost of market entry for software developers, imposing the least burdensome system possible. FDA officials say they want to keep pace with AI software developers, who update their products much more frequently than makers of traditional devices, such as X-ray machines.
Scott Gottlieb said in 2017 while he was FDA commissioner that government regulators need to make sure its approach to innovative products is efficient and that it fosters, not impedes, innovation.
Under the plan, the FDA would pre-certify companies that demonstrate a culture of quality and organizational excellence, which would allow them to provide less upfront data about devices.
Pre-certified companies could then release devices with a streamlined review or no FDA review at all. Once products are on the market, companies will be responsible for monitoring their own products safety and reporting back to the FDA.
High-risk products, such as software used in pacemakers, will still get a comprehensive FDA evaluation.
But research shows that even low- and moderate-risk devices have been recalled due to serious risks to patients, said Diana Zuckerman, president of the National Center for Health Research. Johnson & Johnson, for example, has recalled hip implants and surgical mesh.
Some AI devices are more carefully tested than others. An AI-powered screening tool for diabetic eye disease was studied in 900 patients at 10 primary care offices before being approved in 2018. The manufacturer, IDx Technologies, worked with the FDA for eight years to get the test, sold as IDx-DR, right, said Dr. Michael Abramoff, the companys founder and executive chairman.
IDx-DR is the first autonomous AI product one that can make a screening decision without a doctor. The company is now installing it in primary care clinics and grocery stores, where it can be operated by employees with a high school diploma.
Yet some AI-based innovations intended to improve care have had the opposite effect.
A Canadian company, for example, developed AI software to predict a persons risk of Alzheimers based on their speech. Predictions were more accurate for some patients than others. Difficulty finding the right word may be due to unfamiliarity with English, rather than to cognitive impairment, said coauthor Frank Rudzicz, an associate professor of computer science at the University of Toronto.
Doctors at New Yorks Mount Sinai Hospital hoped AI could help them use chest X-rays to predict which patients were at high risk of pneumonia. Although the system made accurate predictions from X-rays shot at Mount Sinai, the technology flopped when tested on images taken at other hospitals. Eventually, researchers realized the computer had merely learned to tell the difference between that hospitals portable chest X-rays taken at a patients bedside with those taken in the radiology department. Doctors tend to use portable chest X-rays for patients too sick to leave their room, so its not surprising that these patients had a greater risk of lung infection.
DeepMind, a company owned by Google, has created an AI-based mobile app that can predict which hospitalized patients will develop acute kidney failure up to 48 hours in advance. A blog post on the DeepMind website described the system, used at a London hospital, as a game changer. But the AI system also produced two false alarms for every correct result, according to a July study in Nature. That may explain why patients kidney function didnt improve, said Dr. Saurabh Jha, associate professor of radiology at the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania. Any benefit from early detection of serious kidney problems may have been diluted by a high rate of overdiagnosis, in which the AI system flagged borderline kidney issues that didnt need treatment, Jha said.
Google had no comment in response to Jhas conclusions.
This story was written for Kaiser Health News, an editorially independent publication of the Kaiser Family Foundation.
- Break into artificial intelligence with this four-course ... - July 13th, 2020
- New Report from Corinium and FICO Signals Increased Demand for Artificial Intelligence in the Age of COVID-19 - PRNewswire - July 13th, 2020
- Burden of COVID-19 on the Market & Rehabilitation Plan | Artificial Intelligence (AI) Market in Manufacturing Industry 2019-2023 | The Increasing... - July 13th, 2020
- Where it Counts, U.S. Leads in Artificial Intelligence - Department of Defense - July 13th, 2020
- The path to real-world artificial intelligence - TechRepublic - July 13th, 2020
- Healthcare Artificial Intelligence Market Analysis Of Global Trends, Demand And Competition 2020-2028 - Cole of Duty - July 13th, 2020
- The journey that organizations should embark on to realize the true potential of AI - The Indian Express - July 13th, 2020
- Commentary: Artificial intelligence and automation would actually benefit Singapore - CNA - July 13th, 2020
- How Artificial Intelligence Innovations Induced Industrywide Advancements? - Analytics Insight - July 13th, 2020
- Break into artificial intelligence with this four-course online training for $35 - ZDNet - July 13th, 2020
- Integrating Artificial Intelligence in Treatment Planning - Imaging Technology News - July 13th, 2020
- Automotive Artificial Intelligence Industry Market Trend Analysis and Major Factors Forecast Report till 2025 - CueReport - July 13th, 2020
- Artificial Intelligence in Transportation Market, Share, Growth, Trends And Forecast To 2025 - Cole of Duty - July 13th, 2020
- Artificial Intelligence In Transportation Market 2020: Industry Analysis By Size, Share, Key Players, Growth Trends and Forecast Till 2025 - Apsters... - July 13th, 2020
- High Growth of Steady Explore Artificial Intelligence (AI) in Construction Market size, Growth analysis & forecast report to 2025 - 3rd Watch News - July 13th, 2020
- Enterprise Artificial Intelligence Market 2020: Challenges, Growth, Types, Applications, Revenue, Insights, Growth Analysis, Competitive Landscape,... - July 13th, 2020
- Artificial Intelligence in Construction Market will drastically increase in the Future | brandessenceresearch.biz - Cole of Duty - July 13th, 2020
- Top 12 Ways Artificial Intelligence Will Impact Healthcare - July 12th, 2020
- Using Artificial Intelligence to Address Criminal Justice ... - July 12th, 2020
- Augmented Intelligence is the New Intelligence - Analytics Insight - July 12th, 2020
- MULTIMEDIA UPDATE - New Research Reveals Adoption and Implementation of Artificial Intelligence in the Enterprise - GlobeNewswire - July 12th, 2020
- trusted computing artificial intelligence (AI) information warfare - Military & Aerospace Electronics - July 12th, 2020
- Artificial Intelligence will aid in better decision-making capacity - Livemint - July 12th, 2020
- COVID-19 Impact & Recovery Analysis - Artificial Intelligence Platforms Market 2020-2024 | Rise in Demand for AI-based Solutions to Boost Growth |... - July 12th, 2020
- COVID-19 and Artificial Intelligence: How the pandemic has re-ignited a focus on the software - Savannah Morning News - July 12th, 2020
- Second plenary meeting of the Ad Hoc Committee on Artificial Intelligence (CAHAI) - Council of Europe - July 12th, 2020
- LI startup predicts where COVID-19 will spike - Newsday - July 12th, 2020
- How Innovation is Changing the Artificial Intelligence in Telecommunication Market - 3rd Watch News - July 12th, 2020
- AI In Human Resources To AI or not to AI? - Analytics Insight - July 12th, 2020
- Ardigen Enters Into Research Collaboration With CVC to Apply Artificial Intelligence for Identification of T-cell Targets - PRNewswire - July 12th, 2020
- 'Make in India': Artificial Intelligence Company, AiBridge ML, Adds Handwriting and Image Recognition Capabilities to AiMunshi, the Popular Financial... - July 12th, 2020
- CORRECTION - OMNIQs Artificial Intelligence-Based Quest Shield Solution Selected by the Talmudical Academy of Baltimore - Financialbuzz.com - July 12th, 2020
- How Artificial Intelligence Could Lead to Better Investment Decisions - Barron's - July 12th, 2020
- European Parliament names MEPs on artificial intelligence, cancer plan and foreign interference committees - Science Business - July 12th, 2020
- Artificial Intelligence: worth the hype? - BusinessCloud - July 12th, 2020
- The Amalgamation of Human Brain and Artificial Intelligence - Analytics Insight - July 12th, 2020
- Latest Trends in the Field of Artificial Intelligence - Analytics Insight - July 11th, 2020
- The main beneficiaries of artificial intelligence success are IT departments themselves - ZDNet - July 11th, 2020
- Artificial Intelligence Robots Market is Anticipated to Cross US$ 15 Billion By 2025 MRE Analysis - Cole of Duty - July 11th, 2020
- Charting the Role of Artificial Intelligence in Shipping - BBN Times - July 11th, 2020
- Artificial Intelligence in Education System Market: Revenue Growth and Applications Insights till 2030 - Cole of Duty - July 11th, 2020
- COVID-19 Impact and Recovery Analysis | Artificial Intelligence (AI) Market In BFSI Sector 2019-2023 | Focus On Autonomous Banking to Boost Growth |... - July 8th, 2020
- Artificial Intelligence Powered COVID-19 Diagnosis Tool to Seek Lung Scan Images from India - The Weather Channel - July 8th, 2020
- Artificial intelligence should be used to augment human creativity - not replace it - Bizcommunity.com - July 8th, 2020
- Forums held ahead of World Artificial Intelligence Conference - Chinadaily USA - July 8th, 2020
- VeChain Is Attending the World Artificial Intelligence Conference 2020 Hosted - AiThority - July 8th, 2020
- ContractPodAi and Bowmans Partner to Bring Artificial Intelligence-Powered Contract Management to the African Market - Business Wire - July 8th, 2020
- How Machine Learning Will Impact the Future of Software Development and Testing - ReadWrite - July 8th, 2020
- Artificial Intelligence (AI) Definition - Investopedia - May 31st, 2020
- The Temptations Of Artificial Intelligence Technology And The Price Of Admission - Forbes - May 31st, 2020
- Artificial intelligence offers a chance to optimize COVID-19 treatment in international partnership - Vanderbilt University News - May 31st, 2020
- Reality Check: The Benefits of Artificial Intelligence - AiThority - May 31st, 2020
- Thanks To Renewables And Machine Learning, Google Now Forecasts The Wind - Forbes - May 31st, 2020
- Artificial intelligence is hopelessly biased - and that's how it will stay - TechRadar India - May 31st, 2020
- Top Artificial Intelligence Trends that will Change the Decade - Analytics Insight - May 31st, 2020
- Art and artifice - The Indian Express - May 31st, 2020
- The Role of Artificial Intelligence in Ethical Hacking | EC-Council Official Blog - EC-Council Blog - May 31st, 2020
- Microsoft is cutting dozens of MSN news production workers and replacing them with artificial intelligence - Seattle Times - May 31st, 2020
- Artificial intelligence software improves accuracy, doubles speed in evaluating CT scans of advanced cancer - UAB News - May 31st, 2020
- Coronavirus tests the value of artificial intelligence in medicine - FierceHealthcare - May 31st, 2020
- The Use of Artificial Intelligence by Investment Advisers: Considerations Based on an Advisers Fiduciary Duties - JD Supra - May 31st, 2020
- Lecturer in Artificial Intelligence for Digital Infrastructures job with UNIVERSITY OF BRISTOL | 208485 - Times Higher Education (THE) - May 31st, 2020
- Artificial Intelligence (AI) Market to Reach USD 202.57 Billion by 2026; Rising Demand for Cloud-based Applications to Aid Growth: Fortune Business... - May 31st, 2020
- Walmart Employees Are Out to Show Its Anti-Shoplifting AI Doesn't Work - WIRED - May 31st, 2020
- How artificial intelligence is keeping time-critical shipments on track during pandemic - FreightWaves - May 31st, 2020
- Coronavirus Update: Recent FTC Guidance on the Use of Artificial Intelligence and Algorithms in the Age of COVID-19 - Government Contracts Legal Forum - May 31st, 2020
- COVID-19 Impact: A Mix of Challenges and Opportunities | Artificial Intelligence-as-a-Service (AIaaS) Market 2020-2024 | Growing Adoption of Cloud... - May 31st, 2020
- IIT-Ropar and TSW Launch a PG Programme in Artificial Intelligence - THE WEEK - May 31st, 2020
- MS in Artificial Intelligence | Artificial Intelligence - May 19th, 2020
- What is Artificial Intelligence? | Azure Blog and Updates ... - May 19th, 2020
- What Are the Advantages of Artificial Intelligence ... - May 19th, 2020
- AI Tutorial | Artificial Intelligence Tutorial - Javatpoint - May 19th, 2020
- It's Called Artificial Intelligencebut What Is Intelligence? - WIRED - May 19th, 2020
- Powering the Artificial Intelligence Revolution - HPCwire - May 19th, 2020
- Artificial intelligence is struggling to cope with how the world has changed - ZDNet - May 19th, 2020
- An AI future set to take over post-Covid world - The Indian Express - May 19th, 2020
- A New Way To Think About Artificial Intelligence With This ETF - MarketWatch - May 19th, 2020
- Artificial intelligence-based imaging reconstruction may lead to incorrect diagnoses, experts caution - Radiology Business - May 19th, 2020
- Artificial Intelligence in the Covid Frontline - Morningstar - May 19th, 2020
- Patent Analytics Market to Reach USD 1,668.4 Million by 2027; Integration of Machine Learning and Artificial Intelligence to Spur Business... - May 19th, 2020