Gay pride flag. (Marcio Jose Sanchez / AP Photo)
Subscribe now for as little as $2 a month!
The LGBTQ community has officially and emphatically been included in the protection offered by the Civil Rights Act of 1964. In three consolidated cases called Bostock v. Clayton County Georgia, the Supreme Court ruled on Monday that the Civil Right Acts Title VII prohibition of discrimination in the workplace on the basis of sex includes a prohibition against discriminating against gays, lesbians, and transgendered people.Ad Policy
Archconservative Neil Gorsuch wrote the majority opinion. He was joined by Chief Justice John Roberts, as well as the four liberal justices: Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor, and Elena Kagan. Often, when you have one of these opinions signed by both liberal and conservative justices, the decision is very narrow. In such situations, its not unusual for one side or the other to write whats called concurring opinions, in which they will agree with the outcome but offer their own, usually more expansive, reasons for arriving at the conclusion.
Not this time. Gorsuch wrote a civil rights opinion whose main substance could have been written by Sotomayoror Thurgood Marshall or Harvey Milk. Here are two sentences from the opinion that I never expected to hear from a conservative justice appointed by Donald Trump and approved by Mike Pence: The statutes message for our cases is equally simple and momentous: An individuals homosexuality or transgender status is not relevant to employment decisions. Thats because it is impossible to discriminate against a person for being homosexual or transgender without discriminating against that individual based on sex.
That is no half measure. Those sentences are a complete victory for the activists and advocates and lawyers and allies who have long said that discrimination against the LGBTQ community is illegal. It is also, by far, the biggest legal win for the transgender community, ever.
It is not a perfect ruling. While any of the liberal justices could have written the same opinion in substance, the chief justices decision to let Gorsuch write it gave Gorsuch a chance to lay intellectual cover for future bad decisions he will make. Gorsuch is doing whats called a textualist reading: Hes saying that when the text is clear, he doesnt have to go back to the original intent of the lawmakers. Which sounds good, until you remember that Gorsuch claims special powers to know when the text is clear and when it is unclear.Current Issue
Subscribe today and Save up to $129.
In this case, Gorsuchs interpretation of the text comports with a modern understanding of the law. In another case, however, Gorsuch might decide that an archaic definition is clear, while in still another he might decide the text is unclear and look at what Thomas Jefferson would have wanted. Gorsuchs interpretation of the text is going to work against a robust protection of rights more often than it works to promote them.
But that can be a problem for another day. Today, Gorsuch divined that the text of Title VII clearly protects gay and trans people, which is a happy conclusion and the right conclusion. It is also, it must be said, the same conclusion a mere mortal could have come to by simply looking at the last 30 years of legal precedent.
Despite the seismic nature of the ruling, no new rights were granted in this case. Thats because many lower federal courts have deemed that the LGBTQ community is functionally protected by Title VII since the 1989 case Price Waterhouse v. Hopkins. In that case, the court ruled that employers could not discriminate against people who didnt conform to the sexual stereotype preferred by their employer. Its basically the no, she doesnt need to smile more case.
The Bostock case came about all these years later not as part of a progressive effort to make those Title VII protections apply explicitly to the LGBTQ community, but as the result of decades of conservative activism, led by groups like the Federalist Society and the judges they support, to get the LGBTQ community excluded from the protections many judges and scholars think they already enjoy. The conservative goal has been to force Congress to rewrite Title VII to explicitly include LGBTQ people, thus giving conservative political candidates another culture-war issue to fight about, while trusting total gridlock in Washington to prevent any such rewrite from ever happening.
The majority opinion shifts the burden away from the courts and puts it squarely on anti-LGBTQ politicians to continue this fight. If conservatives want to change the law, they are now free to organize and elect congresspeople and senators who oppose LGBTQ rights and want to run on a platform rewriting the Civil Rights Act to exclude them.
One way to know that this was a major victory for the LGBTQ community is that alt-right forces are having a meltdown over the decision. (Ben Shapiros tears taste particularly delicious right now.) While Gorsuchs majority opinion was just 33 pages, Justice Samuel Alitos dissent was 54 pages, and included 172 pages of appendices that he offered as evidence, clear as I can tell, of the importance of genitalia over time. Trying to include all of this supposed evidence briefly crashed the Supreme Court website when the opinion was initially released. Anything that makes Alito this mad is, almost by definition, very good.
Still, the more important dissent might have been written by alleged attempted rapist Brett Kavanaugh. Yes, the justice that Susan Collins vouched for dissented from an LGBTQ rights opinion, something that Collins herself pretended not to notice when she tweeted out support for the courts decision in Bostock. Kavanaugh argued that whether or not he thinks the LGBTQ community should be included in Title VII protections is irrelevant, since we are judges, not Members of Congress. Under the Constitutions separation of powers, our role as judges is to interpret and follow the law as written, regardless of whether we like the result. He, like the conservative lawyers who argued this case, pretends that Title VII does not already include the LGBTQ community, and argues that it is not the role of the court to extend the scope of that law.
This is significant, because it is exactly the same argument John Roberts made in his dissent from the marriage-equality decision, Obergefell v. Hodges. In that case, Roberts wrote: Understand well what this dissent is about: It is not about whether, in my judgment, the institution of marriage should be changed to include same-sex couples. It is instead about whether, in our democratic republic, that decision should rest with the people acting through their elected representatives, or with five lawyers who happen to hold commissions authorizing them to resolve legal disputes according to law.More from Mystal
I dont know if Roberts has changed his mind on marriage equality. But I do know that when Kavanaugh effectively read Robertss own argument against marriage equality back to him, Roberts declined to go in for another round.
Robertss decision to switch sides is an important sign. Given the polarization of American politics, its unlikely that new LGBTQ rights laws are going to be written any time soon. Conservative politicians are very good at stoking MAGA fears over which bathroom people use, while many purple-state Democrats would rather hope for gay and trans rights than fight for them. If were not going to get new, robust laws about equality, then were going to need courts to continue including the LGBTQ community in what equal rights laws already exist.
Bostock is a significant civil rights victory and, with Gorsuch and Roberts on board, it feels durable as well. But make no mistake: Anti-LGBTQ discrimination has not been defeated. To risk a war analogy: This case is like surviving the Battle of Britaininvading Normandy and kicking the fascists off the continent is still a long way off.
Republicans will try to use this judicial defeat to motivate their base to show up to vote on November 3. Liberals have to be equally motivated to turn out in November and defend this victory.
Originally posted here:
Neil Gorsuch Stuns the Nation, Does the Right Thing - The Nation
- Neighborly discord in the Galwan Valley - Observer Research Foundation - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Why human beings are so irrational, and never learn podcasts of the week - The Guardian - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Canceling Joe Rogan Would be the Left's Worst Nightmare - Here's Why - CCN.com - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Down with symbols - The News International - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- The Voice of America Will Sound Like Trump - The Atlantic - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- License to Analyze Media - The Dispatch - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- New Boss May Test Voice of Americas Credibility - The New York Times - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Destroying the Statues of Slavers to Rewrite History - Morocco World News - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- What to Cook Right Now - The New York Times - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- The Voice Of America Is Not The Voice Of Trump - The Pavlovic Today - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Philly residents call for Taney Street to be renamed - PhillyVoice.com - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Wizards Ends Their Relationship with Terese Nielsen - Hipsters of the Coast - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Magic: The Gathering Ends Relationship With Controversial Artist - We Got This Covered - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- How game theory not chaos rules the Trump White House - Los Angeles Times - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- What we know about the 'Boogaloo Bois,' the far-right group tied to killings in Santa Cruz and Oakland - San Francisco Chronicle - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Four Years Embedded With the Alt-Right - The Atlantic - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Influence of COVID-19 Crisis on Global Right-Wing Agenda - Valdai Discussion Club - June 22nd, 2020 [June 22nd, 2020]
- Mendocino County Board of Supervisors Approves Issuance of Fines for Refusing to Wear Facial Coverings - Redheaded Blackbelt - July 10th, 2020 [July 10th, 2020]
- Far Right Reading List Shows Link Between Its Literature and Real-World Violence - Truthout - July 10th, 2020 [July 10th, 2020]
- America Is in the Grips of a Fundamentalist Revival - The Dispatch - July 10th, 2020 [July 10th, 2020]
- New Zealand police warned of another mosque threat before Christchurch shooting massacre - Reuters - July 10th, 2020 [July 10th, 2020]
- The saffron swastika - The Express Tribune - July 10th, 2020 [July 10th, 2020]
- Banned by PayPal and YouTube, this alt-right comedian is back on PayPal and YouTube (updated) - The Daily Dot - July 10th, 2020 [July 10th, 2020]
- Why White House Catholics are concerned about Trumps Catholic tweets - Catholic News Agency - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- GAA's tiresome culture war insults and ignores players - RTE.ie - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- Review: Rabbit Hole hops into the Internets greatest failures and successes - The Charlatan - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- Colleges are flimflamming college students and parents about reopening in the fall (opinion) - Inside Higher Ed - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- New Conservatives defend Western culture as 'greatest in the world', warn NZ 'sliding toward socialism' - Newshub - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- Fire Island Partier Who Flouted COVID Rules Says He's Not Sorry, Reveals Himself to Be QAnon Follower: WATCH - Towleroad - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- 'Draining the swamp' and other metaphors - Idaho State Journal - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- Fire Island partier who flouted coronavirus rules refuses to apologise: 'I'm not going to fall for the lab-made virus' - PinkNews - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- Slate Star Codex and Silicon Valleys War Against the Media - The New Yorker - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- Alt-Weeklies Face Total Annihilation. But Theyre Thriving in the Chaos. - The Ringer - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- Dana Canedy, the New Head of Simon & Schuster, on Facts, Diversity, and the Future of Publishing - The New Yorker - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- The fallacy of white privilege and how it's corroding society - New York Post - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- Facing America's History of Racism Requires Facing the Origins of 'Race' as a Concept - TIME - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- Stone Shares Meme With Roots In Alt-Right To Attack Judge - TPM - July 12th, 2020 [July 12th, 2020]
- When it comes to modern slavery, many of us turn a blind eye - iNews - July 18th, 2020 [July 18th, 2020]
- How to add alt text to images on Twitter so that they can be read with screen readers - Business Insider - Business Insider - July 18th, 2020 [July 18th, 2020]
- A decade of emoji: How aubergines and crying faces connected us all online - The Independent - July 18th, 2020 [July 18th, 2020]
- A Dreyfusard from the Right - Twilight of Democracy - Visegrad Insight - July 18th, 2020 [July 18th, 2020]
- The Man in the Antifa Mask: Who he is and why he regrets showing up at a Coeur d'Alene protest with a crowbar - Pacific Northwest Inlander - July 18th, 2020 [July 18th, 2020]
- Best of Philly: Heres to the People Who Protested - Philadelphia magazine - July 18th, 2020 [July 18th, 2020]
- Lincoln the Emancipator: The Civil War & the Continuous Battle against Northern Negrophobia (Part 1 of a two-part series) - Milwaukee Courier... - July 18th, 2020 [July 18th, 2020]
- The Fascist Messaging of the Trump Campaign Eagle - Hyperallergic - July 18th, 2020 [July 18th, 2020]
- AOC on League of Legends: Right-wing Twitter is childs play compared to inting 13-year-olds - VG247 - July 20th, 2020 [July 20th, 2020]
- MSNBC's Joy Reid Makes Cable Network History With the Debut of "The ReidOut" - Vogue - July 20th, 2020 [July 20th, 2020]
- NY: Hundreds of free Uber e-bikes coming to WNY for proposed 'transportation libraries' - MassTransitMag.com - July 20th, 2020 [July 20th, 2020]
- What is alt text on Instagram? How to add alt text - Business Insider - Business Insider - July 20th, 2020 [July 20th, 2020]
- What is the deal with 'woke' culture and writing letters? - The National - July 20th, 2020 [July 20th, 2020]
- The Return of the Cooch - Bacon's Rebellion - July 20th, 2020 [July 20th, 2020]
- Anti-Greta and the challenges faced by young activists | Forge - ForgeToday - July 20th, 2020 [July 20th, 2020]
- Anti-maskers bring their misinformation to Halifax - Halifax Examiner - July 20th, 2020 [July 20th, 2020]
- MSNBCs Joy Reid Makes Cable-Network History With the Debut of The ReidOut - Vogue - July 20th, 2020 [July 20th, 2020]
- Is This Roger Stone and Proud Boys Flashing a White Power Symbol? - Snopes.com - July 20th, 2020 [July 20th, 2020]
- Trump's pick to head Office of Personnel Management spread 'satanic' conspiracy theory, called Democrats party of 'Islam' and 'gender-bending' -... - July 24th, 2020 [July 24th, 2020]
- Joe Rogan Is Spreading Transphobic Hate Speech and It's Putting Lives in Danger - Men's Health - July 25th, 2020 [July 25th, 2020]
- 'Pure Invention': How Japan's pop culture became the 'lingua franca' of the internet - The Japan Times - July 25th, 2020 [July 25th, 2020]
- Redefine Meat wants to disrupt meat industry with 3D printed Alt-Steak - Food Dive - July 25th, 2020 [July 25th, 2020]
- How it feels to survive Silicon Valley and a pandemic - Engadget - July 25th, 2020 [July 25th, 2020]
- New Mexico's thin blurred line (The thin blurred line) High Country News Know the West - High Country News - July 25th, 2020 [July 25th, 2020]
- Artist Canyon Castator Is Making The Apocalypse Palatable - Interview - July 25th, 2020 [July 25th, 2020]
- Does Tucker Carlson hate America? - The Independent - July 25th, 2020 [July 25th, 2020]
- How to add alt text in Excel to make images accessible - Business Insider - Business Insider - July 29th, 2020 [July 29th, 2020]
- Why Portland Became the Test Case for Trumps Secret Police - The Nation - July 29th, 2020 [July 29th, 2020]
- What IS your point? - The Bear Insider - July 29th, 2020 [July 29th, 2020]
- What is alt text in WordPress? How to add image descriptions on your web page to improve accessibility and web - Business Insider India - July 29th, 2020 [July 29th, 2020]
- Herman Mashaba: Why he might draw the crowds at election time Chuck Stephens - BizNews - July 29th, 2020 [July 29th, 2020]
- How Brooks Brothers Became a Symbol of What Not to Wear to the Revolution - TownandCountrymag.com - July 29th, 2020 [July 29th, 2020]
- Hillsdale Must Join the National Reckoning on Race - The Bulwark - July 29th, 2020 [July 29th, 2020]
- What is alt text in WordPress? How to add the accessibility feature - Business Insider - Business Insider - July 29th, 2020 [July 29th, 2020]
- Pittsburgh-based Steelers reporter quits PennLive in protest of site calling a Nazi rally "peaceful" - PGH City Paper - July 29th, 2020 [July 29th, 2020]
- 'You Do the Right Things, and Still You Get It' - The New York Times - July 29th, 2020 [July 29th, 2020]
- Who wants to cancel cancel culture? The voiceless or the privileged? - Coconuts - July 29th, 2020 [July 29th, 2020]
- Amazon compared to heroin dealer as Bezos, Zuckerberg, Cook and Google CEO accused of squeezing out com - The Sun - July 29th, 2020 [July 29th, 2020]
- Courtney Love hopes Jeffrey Epstein burns in hell after her name appeared in his address book - The Independent - July 29th, 2020 [July 29th, 2020]
- Elon Musk has finally confirmed whether his take the red pill tweet was a Trump endorsement - indy100 - August 1st, 2020 [August 1st, 2020]
- The Lakers Hold On to Beat the Clippers in Thriller - The New York Times - August 1st, 2020 [August 1st, 2020]
- The Fight review: A jubilant look at changing the world for the better - Evening Standard - August 1st, 2020 [August 1st, 2020]
- Mike Foltynewicz clears waivers, sent to Braves alternate site - Sports and Weather Right Now - August 1st, 2020 [August 1st, 2020]