Donald Trump delivers his first speech to    Congress  
    THE TRUMP administration is planning to create a new agency    inside the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) whose main    purpose is to inflame xenophobia and spread the lie that    immigrants are likely to be violent criminals.  
    Trump first called for the creation of the VOICE (Victims of    Immigration Crime Engagement) Office     in his January 25 executive order. The details of how this    order would be carried out were released a month later     in a memo issued by DHS Director John Kelly. The order and    Kelly's memo establish three priorities for VOICE:  
    First, act as a liaison between Immigration and Customs    Enforcement (ICE) and "known victims of crimes committed by    removable aliens," providing information to victims and their    families about the immigration and custody status of the    alleged offenders.  
    Second, issue monthly reports of "statistical data regarding    aliens apprehended by ICE," including a wide variety of    information concerning the alleged offenders' countries of    origin, criminal history, gang affiliation, prior immigration    violations, etc.  
    Third, issue weekly reports concerning "non-Federal    jurisdictions that release aliens from their custody,    notwithstanding that such aliens are subject to a detainer or    similar request for custody issued by ICE to that    jurisdiction"--in other words, to name and shame sanctuary    jurisdictions for refusing to cooperate with deportation    efforts. As outlined in Kelly's memo, this report, too, will    contain as much information as possible about the alleged    offenders.  
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -  
    VOICE IS being proposed as a solution to something that few    people outside the right wing's bubble think is a problem: that    crime victims aren't given enough information about the    immigration status of the alleged offenders. According to the    DHS memo:  
      Criminal aliens routinely victimize Americans and other legal      residents. Often, these victims are not provided adequate      information about the offender, the offender's immigration      status, or any enforcement action taken by ICE against the      offender. Efforts by ICE to engage these victims have been      hampered by prior Department of Homeland Security (DHS)      policy extending certain Privacy Act protections to persons      other than U.S. citizens and lawful permanent residents,      leaving victims feeling marginalized and without a voice.    
    This is pure demagoguery. If someone is victimized by, for    example, a drunk driver, their concern is with the criminal act    of drunk driving, not the immigration status of the driver. Not    being aware a driver's immigration status doesn't make them any    more marginalized or "voiceless" than not knowing the driver's    religion or political affiliation.  
    The same principle applies to any crime, however serious: From    the standpoint of seeking justice for victims and their loved    ones, the immigration status of the offenders can make no    possible difference.  
    It can, however, have considerable political value, and this is    surely what Trump and Kelly are seeking to exploit.  
    There is an undeniable emotional power to claiming to the    family of a murder victim that their loved one's killer "never    should have been in the country to begin with." The shock and    grief resulting from this news can easily be used for    propaganda purposes: Even if the grieving family do not    themselves become activists against "criminal aliens," their    story can still be exploited to encourage others to follow this    path.  
    It was for precisely this reason that, when announcing the    creation of VOICE in his February 28 joint address to Congress,    Trump pointed out "four very brave Americans" in the audience,    all of whom have lost loved ones to violent crimes allegedly    perpetrated by undocumented immigrants.  
    This, apparently, is what it means to "give a voice" to such    people: trotting them out for an internationally televised    event and publicly exploiting their grief and loss in order to    further your own racist anti-immigrant agenda.  
    The executive order that gave rise to VOICE also directs the    DHS to "prioritize the removal" of undocumented immigrants in a    variety of categories, including those who have been convicted    of a crime, charged with a crime--or committed "acts that    constitute a chargeable criminal offense," but have not been    charged or otherwise pose a threat to public safety or national    security "in the judgment of an immigration officer."  
    The effect of these guidelines, in short, is to declare any    undocumented immigrant whom an ICE agent thinks is a criminal    to be a criminal.  
    It remains to be seen whether this very broad conception of    "crime" will be carried over into the reports produced by VOICE    compiling "statistical data" about crimes committed by    undocumented immigrants and weekly reports concerning the    non-cooperation of sanctuary jurisdictions. The possibility is    certainly there--notice, for instance, that VOICE's monthly    report will provide statistics about people apprehended    by ICE.  
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -  
    FROM THE earliest days of his presidential campaign, Trump    declared loudly and often that the U.S. is experiencing an    epidemic of crime committed by undocumented immigrants, and he    cultivated alliances with racist anti-immigration groups and    individuals.  
    Now that he's in power, Trump's executive order is an attempt    to criminalize immigration itself--and VOICE is the poison he    wants to pump into the culture to get people to go along with    it.  
    One of Trump's key allies in this effort is Maria Espinoza,    co-founder and National Director of the Remembrance    Project, a Houston-based organization that "advocates for    families whose loved ones were killed by illegal aliens," most    notably by adding their names and images to its "Stolen Lives    Quilt."  
    According to    Espinoza's biography on the project's website--which    doesn't mention her     ties to white nationalists like John Tanton--she has worked    since 2009 to "unite the 'stolen lives' families, educating the    public of the epidemic of killings across the country, and    raising the awareness of the effects of illegal immigration. It    is not a victimless crime."  
    This brief passage lays bare the two lies at the heart of the    Remembrance Project, and of Trump's own agenda: First, that    undocumented immigrants are responsible for an "epidemic of    killings across the country"; and second, that illegal    immigration itself leads to violent crime.  
    In fact, research has consistently shown that     immigrants are statistically less likely to commit crimes than    native-born Americans, and that there is either no    correlation between crime rates and levels of immigration. If    anything, crime rates appear to decrease as immigration    levels rise.  
    But even if immigrants were not less likely to commit crimes,    VOICE would still be cause for concern. The clear intent of    these measures is to stoke public hatred of immigrants--and the    administration's rhetoric about "upholding the laws of this    nation" is     a coded racist message aimed at that end.  
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -  
    THE UNVEILING of VOICE immediately--and rightly--prompted    comparisons to Nazi Germany. As     Peter Beinart wrote in The Atlantic:  
      In The Nazi Conscience, Duke historian Claudia Koonz      notes that the Nazi newspaper Der Strmer ran a      feature called "Letter Box," which published readers'      accounts of Jewish crimes. When the Nazis took power, the      German state began doing something similar. Frustrated by the      failure of most Germans to participate in a boycott of Jewish      businesses in April 1933, Adolf Hitler's government began      publicizing Jewish crime statistics as a way of stoking      anti-Semitism.    
      In Nazi Germany and the Jews: The Years of      Persecution, the historian Saul Friedlander notes that,      until 1938, Hitler's Ministry of Justice ordered prosecutors      to forward every criminal indictment against a Jew so the      ministry's press office could publicize it.    
    The parallels between the Nazis' use of crime statistics and    those contemplated by VOICE are troubling enough. But because    of its status as a "legitimate" government agency, VOICE's    programs also have the potential to inject into the mainstream    the propaganda of far-right publications and websites that are    the modern-day equivalent of Der Strmer's.  
    These publications have already managed to do great harm. For    instance, Dylann Roof, the anti-Black terrorist who slaughtered    nine people in a South Carolina church in 2015,     acknowledges that he he came across "pages upon pages of    these brutal Black on white murders" on the website of the    Council of Conservative Citizens (CCC), a notorious white    supremacist organization.  
    In Roof's case, the connection between racist "reporting" of    crimes and violence is unusually direct and explicit. But if    his story is an extreme case, it is by no means unique. And, of    course, the CCC is far from the only such group publishing    lists of the alleged crimes of nonwhite Americans, as we've    already seen with the Remembrance Project.  
    Notably, Breitbart News, when it was under the leadership of    Trump's current chief strategist Steve Bannon, responded to the    Black Lives Matter movement by gathering stories of alleged    crimes committed by African Americans under the "Black    Crime" tag.  
    These sites are notorious for cherry-picking their stories for    maximum effect and     publishing false or misleading information. One reason    they've found a wide audience is that "Black-on-white" crime        is also overreported in the more "respectable" media.  
    Now Trump, Bannon and Kelly want the U.S. government to get in    on the act. We shouldn't let them get away with it.  
Originally posted here: 
This VOICE tells racist lies - Socialist Worker Online