The Obama administration has announced a series of modest    changes in the use of private data collected for intelligence    purposes, a move that underscores how little the Edward Snowden    revelations    have impeded the National Security Agency's exploitation of    global Internet communications.  
    Eighteen months after the first Snowden-fueled news story and    one year after President Obama     delivered a major speech calling for changes to NSA data    collection, the White House on Tuesday said it had    tightened rules governing how the FBI, CIA and other    intelligence agencies use Internet and phone communications of    foreigners collected by the NSA. But the bulk collection would    continue as robustly as ever, the announcement made clear.  
    Where once the data could be used for any reason and held    forever, now it must fall into six specific threat categories    and irrelevant data is to be purged after five years. But the    categories are broad enough that an intelligence officer could    find justification to use a piece of information on a foreigner    if he or she feels the need. The information need only have    some relevance to counter-espionage, counterterrorism,    counter-proliferation, cybersecurity, countering threats to    U.S. or allied armed forces or personnel; and combating    transnational criminal threats.  
    The new policy also imposed more supervision over how    intelligence agencies use the communications of Americans they    acquire without individual warrants, making clear, for example,    that such data may only be used to prosecute someone for    "serious crimes" such as a murder or kidnapping, or national    security crimes.  
    But the changes stopped well short of the recommendations of a    presidential task force, including one that data collected by    the NSA without warrants should never be used against an    American in court, and another that such data should only be    searched using the name of an American with a specific court    order naming that person. Robert Litt, general counsel for the    Office of the Director of National Intelligence, said in a    conference call with reporters that those ideas were deemed too    restrictive.  
    The result is that the private communications of Americans    collected without warrants are still circulating around the    government.  
    Moreover, Mr. Obama's most significant proposal in response to    the Snowden leaks - to end the NSA's bulk collection of    domestic calling records - has not been enacted. The president    wants Congress to pass a law, and Congress has balked. The NSA    is still collecting the records, even though Mr. Obama could    stop the practice on his own.  
    "There's pressure to say we're doing something, and that leads    to some symbolic changes or tweaks, but there would be a great    reluctance to forswear access to intelligence like this," said    Richard Betts, a professor at Columbia's School of    International & Public Affairs and a former staffer in the    1970s congressional investigations of intelligence agencies.  
    "The reforms are far from sufficient and they really do tinker    around the edges," said Neema Singh Guliani, legislative    counsel for the American Civil Liberties Union. "It's clear the    administration is going to continue to stand by a lot of the    mass surveillance policies."  
    In a statement, White House counter terrorism adviser Lisa    Monaco said U.S. digital spying "must take into account that    all persons have legitimate privacy interests in the handling    of their personal information. At the same time, we must ensure    that our Intelligence Community has the resources and    authorities necessary for the United States to advance its    national security and foreign policy interests and to protect    its citizens and the citizens of its allies and partners from    harm."  
Read more:
White House allows NSA's bulk data collection to continue