In a recent public interest litigation (Alakh Alok Srivastava vs Union of India), the Centre sought a direction from the Supreme Court that no electronic / print media / web portal or social media shall print / publish or telecast anything without first ascertaining the true factual position from the separate mechanism provided by the central government.
This direction has been sought in a status report submitted by the state detailing the steps it has taken thus far to fight the coronavirus pandemic. Such a direction has been sought on the basis of the claim that, Any deliberate or unintended fake or inaccurate reporting either in electronic, print or social media and, particularly, in web portals has a serious and inevitable potential of causing panic in large sections of the society. Considering the very nature of this infectious disease which the world is struggling with, any panic reaction by any section of the society based on such reporting would not only be harmful for such section but harmful for the entire nation.
A direction of this nature, to be constitutionally protected, must be reasonable and covered within the ambit of Article 19(2) of the constitution. In order for government action against the media to be protected under Article 19(2), there has to be a proximate relationship between the speech/expression that is sought to be curtailed and the parameters set out in Article 19(2). This relationship must not be remote, fanciful or far-fetched and should be based on material evidence that demonstrably proves the states claim.
Also read: Coronavirus v. Free Speech: Modi Government Opens New Battlefront in Supreme Court
It has been amply documented in various reports that adequate steps were not immediately taken to provide migrant workers with basic and humane living conditions after the lockdown was announced. In this vacuum, migrant workers and their families were left with no alternative but to leave for their villages. The images of migrant workers walking helplessly on highways, putting their lives and that of their young children at peril, is testament to the failure of the government in effectively protecting these workers.
At present, there are no credible studies or reports that argue, let alone establish, the migration of workers was motivated by anything other than the announcement of the lockdown measures. Even the status report filed by the Centre does not cite any data that could back the claim that the migration was due to the dissemination of fake news. This suggests that the states claim evidently made orally by the solicitor general and noted in the courts order that workers migrated because of fake news is at best based on conjecture or surmise, and at worst is a blatant attempt to deflect responsibility and accountability.
We live in an age where the collection, dissemination and consumption of information has defined the realisation of and access to human rights. The cornerstone of efficient and democratic policy making is to incorporate public debate and criticism within its fold. To see public debate and the critique of state action as adversarial is to misconceive its indispensable role in democratic nation building.
The Supreme Court in a catena of judgments, ever since the landmark Sakal Papers case in 1962, has consistently held that the right to circulate ones views is an integral part of the right to freedom of speech and expression. The Supreme Court also ruled that the freedom of the press cannot be curtailed in the interest of the general public. Any restriction to the freedom of press must thus fall in line with the stipulations enumerated in Article 19(2) of the constitution:
Nothing in sub clause (a) of clause ( 1 ) shall affect the operation of any existing law, or prevent the State from making any law, in so far as such law imposes reasonable restrictions on the exercise of the right conferred by the said sub clause in the interests of the sovereignty and integrity of India, the security of the State, friendly relations with foreign States, public order, decency or morality or in relation to contempt of court, defamation or incitement to an offence.
The freedoms enshrined in Article 19 also include the peoples right to know. During a public health crisis, like the one faced by the world today, the value of the right to be informed is undeniable. Given the dynamic nature of the crisis, and the evolving responses to it coming from various scientific and medical experts, there can be no singular source of information that encompasses all strands of research and expert opinion.
The WHO, in its operational guidelines, highlights the vital role played by media houses in disseminating information, which is arguably one of the most important steps towards fighting a disease of mammoth proportions. It is pertinent to acknowledge the ability of the free media to unearth vital information which may still be unknown even to the state. This makes the media not only a source of constant critique but also an independent ally for better governance.
The Centres demand, if eventually conceded, will effectively act as a gag on the free flow and circulation of information which may not always be palatable to the government. Such a step will inevitably also have a chilling effect on robust and uncompromised journalism.
The law with regard to prior restraint of media is well settled and the Supreme Court has consistently held that it would not be in consonance with the constitutional scheme to prevent the publication of news. As recently as 2017, in a petition filed by Common Cause, a bench comprising the then Chief Justice J.S. Khehar and Justice D.Y. Chandrachud noted that prior restraint on the publication of news is not the job of the court or administrative authorities, and that all grievances should be dealt with in accordance with the law of the land only after its publication.
Also read: UP Police FIR Against The Wire an Attack on Freedom of the Press
The court had said, We cannot ask them (Centre) to monitor the content of channels. How can we do that? You can approach us or the authority concerned after telecast or airing of objectionable contents only. If something happens and you find them obnoxious, then we will certainly deal with them. Generally speaking, we cannot interfere with it and do content regulation.
While quashing an order which had restrained Cobrapost from publishing an expos on media houses, Justice S.R. Bhat of the Delhi high court had also in 2018 noted that despite the challenges posed by the new age media, especially the electronic media and internet posts, it cannot per se dilute the valuable right of free speech, which the court stated is the lifeblood of democracy.
The state has time and again utilised the rhetoric and bogey of fake news, just as it does claims of national security and/or national interest, to justify the whittling down of the right to freedom of speech and expression.
In Jammu and Kashmir, the fear of fake news was used to justify severe restrictions on free speech and media rights by curtailing access to the internet, after the Centre read down Article 370. The same fear is now being cited to seek pre-publication screening of media reports. In the race between civil liberties and state control, ground is usually lost bit by bit, and one has to be extremely vigilant to keep pace with the increasing dilution of civil liberties.
Devika Tulsiani is a student of law in New Delhi. Soutik Banerjee is a Delhi-based advocate.
More:
The Centre Is Back to Using the Bogey of 'Fake News' to Try and Suppress Press Freedom - The Wire
- Turkey's crackdown on freedom of speech intensifies - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- Bill of Rights Transcript Text - National Archives and ... - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- Freedom of Speech (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy) - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- 3 Muslims shot dead by Atheist || #muslimlivesmatter - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- Media Studies 104A - 2015-02-10 - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- USA Freedom of Speech and Jesus Christ - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- France Arrests French Comedian Dieudonne 3 Days After Charlie Hebdo Freedom of Speech - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- Charlie Hebdo's "Freedom of Speech" - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- John Robertson on Greg Shapiro's United States of Europe - S3Ep01 - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- The Illuminati: The Freedom of Speech 2015 Conspiracy - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- Muslims oppose insult to Islam in the name of freedom of speech - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- RE: HannibalTheVictor13's resentment over thunderf00t and his "freedom of speech". - Video - February 12th, 2015 [February 12th, 2015]
- Policy update restricts demonstrations - February 14th, 2015 [February 14th, 2015]
- Italian senators pass bill criminalizing denial of genocides - February 14th, 2015 [February 14th, 2015]
- Michael Buerk Interview - Freedom of Speech & Paris Attacks - Video - February 14th, 2015 [February 14th, 2015]
- 'Freedom Of Speech' Topic Tuesday #12 - Video - February 14th, 2015 [February 14th, 2015]
- One dead after shots fired at Copenhagen freedom of speech meeting - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Shots Fired at Copenhagen Free Speech Event: Reports - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- One man dead and three policemen wounded at freedom of speech seminar in Denmark - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Copenhagen caf: two gunmen in terror attack at freedom of speech event - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- One dead in gun attack on Danish freedom of speech meeting - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Free Speech Debate Still Alive After Attack in Denmark - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Esau uses Freedom of Speech as a weapon! - Video - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Copenhagen attacks an 'affront to freedom of speech': Tony Abbott - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Copenhagen suspect known to police - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Copenhagen police kill suspect linked to two fatal attacks - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Freedom of Speech and Freedom of Press - Lincoln University - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Copenhagen Shooting: Deadly attack at free speech meeting with cartoonist who depicted Muh - Video - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Shots fired at Copenhagens Krudttoenden cafe free speech event a report - Video - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Media Studies 104A - 2015-02-12 - Video - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- WallBuilders Live 2015-02-11 Wednesday - Freedom of Speech on College Campuses - Video - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- Yisrael Beytenu at Charlie Hebdo freedom of speech protest - Video - February 15th, 2015 [February 15th, 2015]
- TOI debate on freedom of speech wows Kolkata - The Times ... - February 16th, 2015 [February 16th, 2015]
- Muslims Killing Atheists! - Video - February 16th, 2015 [February 16th, 2015]
- AP Top Stories February 14 P - Video - February 16th, 2015 [February 16th, 2015]
- Duck Dynasty's Phil Robertson to Receive Freedom of Speech Award - February 17th, 2015 [February 17th, 2015]
- Freedom of speech, but... SHOTS - Video - February 17th, 2015 [February 17th, 2015]
- Letters to the editor: We must do more to stop terrorists - February 18th, 2015 [February 18th, 2015]
- Freedom Of Speech Naam Ki Koi Chiz Hoti Hai - Alia Bhatt On AIB Controversy - Video - February 18th, 2015 [February 18th, 2015]
- DoomShow,Freedom of Speech under attack by Terrrorists - Video - February 18th, 2015 [February 18th, 2015]
- Greenpeace activist refutes govt charge of being anti-national - February 19th, 2015 [February 19th, 2015]
- Jailed Al Jazeera journalist concerned about freedom of speech - February 19th, 2015 [February 19th, 2015]
- Fan claims municipal police violating freedom of speech - February 19th, 2015 [February 19th, 2015]
- Jailed journalist concerned about freedom of speech - February 19th, 2015 [February 19th, 2015]
- Denmark: Police launch manhunt for Copenhagen cafe shooter - Video - February 19th, 2015 [February 19th, 2015]
- Freedom of speech denied outside of Skillet concert Pittsburgh - Video - February 19th, 2015 [February 19th, 2015]
- Alex Jones is Right! Snowden is Right! Government Crooks Via FaceBook! - Video - February 21st, 2015 [February 21st, 2015]
- "McCann Trolling" v "Freedom of Speech" - Video - February 21st, 2015 [February 21st, 2015]
- Aamir Khan disapproves AIB Roast, KJo reacts - February 22nd, 2015 [February 22nd, 2015]
- South Africa: Post the State of the Nation Address - February 23rd, 2015 [February 23rd, 2015]
- The Great Purge of Free Speech Has Begun............ - Video - February 23rd, 2015 [February 23rd, 2015]
- Big Brother Watch calls for reform of social media communications laws - February 24th, 2015 [February 24th, 2015]
- Comment on Have an opinion? Stuff it! by boh-liao - February 24th, 2015 [February 24th, 2015]
- Sports Hotline: What happened to freedom of speech - have Rangers fans lost their right to offend? - February 24th, 2015 [February 24th, 2015]
- Freedom of Speech: Canadians support Charlie Hebdos choice to publish images of Prophet Muhammad - February 24th, 2015 [February 24th, 2015]
- Should there be limitations on freedom of speech? - Video - February 24th, 2015 [February 24th, 2015]
- Topic Tuesday #39 - Freedom of Speech? (Minecraft Survival Games Gameplay) - Video - February 24th, 2015 [February 24th, 2015]
- DW Freedom of Speech Award for Raif Badawi - February 25th, 2015 [February 25th, 2015]
- THROWDOWN THURSDAY: The Four Causes of Anti-Israelism - February 26th, 2015 [February 26th, 2015]
- FCC Reinstates Net Neutrality, Protecting Open Internet - February 27th, 2015 [February 27th, 2015]
- CPDP 2015: Online privacy versus freedom of speech. Balancing rights in the EU context. - Video - February 27th, 2015 [February 27th, 2015]
- Net neutrality lobby victorious after FCC ruling - February 27th, 2015 [February 27th, 2015]
- Freedom of speech means tolerating opposing viewpoints - March 2nd, 2015 [March 2nd, 2015]
- The Death of Freedom of Speech on the Internet - Video - March 2nd, 2015 [March 2nd, 2015]
- Dangerman - Freedom Of Speech - Video - March 2nd, 2015 [March 2nd, 2015]
- Rebel Ratepayer Raps 4 Freedom of Speech in City of Melton, Melbourne - Video - March 2nd, 2015 [March 2nd, 2015]
- Students stand up for free speech at UI - March 2nd, 2015 [March 2nd, 2015]
- John Kerry asked to act on murder of Avijit Roy - March 3rd, 2015 [March 3rd, 2015]
- Not so Charlie now? - March 4th, 2015 [March 4th, 2015]
- ISIS Supporters Threaten "Charlie Hedbo style" Attack Against Twitter Employees - March 4th, 2015 [March 4th, 2015]
- AIB trying hard about freedom of speech - Video - March 4th, 2015 [March 4th, 2015]
- Freedom of Speech situation in Bangladesh BBC World Service discussion - Video - March 4th, 2015 [March 4th, 2015]
- Noam Chomsky on Freedom of Speech and Anti-Fascism [full] - Video - March 4th, 2015 [March 4th, 2015]
- AND..Y we should stand up for freedom of speech | AIB Roast | Delhi Elections | AAP - Video - March 4th, 2015 [March 4th, 2015]
- Vclav Havel Fellowship programme helps young journalists from post-Soviet bloc states - March 5th, 2015 [March 5th, 2015]
- Murderers condemned as message of peace is North Herts conferences priority - March 5th, 2015 [March 5th, 2015]
- four freedoms speech - FDR - Video - March 5th, 2015 [March 5th, 2015]
- Watch what the youth feels about the AIB Roast Controversy & so called "freedom of speech" - Video - March 5th, 2015 [March 5th, 2015]
- freedom of speech eminem remix - Video - March 5th, 2015 [March 5th, 2015]
- Freedom of speech has no limits- - Video - March 5th, 2015 [March 5th, 2015]