Under Donald J. Trump, the longstanding debate over the proper scope of the federal governments powers vis--vis the states has largely focused on whether there remain any meaningful constraints on the massive powers of the U.S. presidency. Now, with COVID-19 gripping the globe, Americans are looking to the government for protection from uncertainty, chaos, illness, and death. Millions of people are already heeding the advice of medical experts and voluntarily practicing social distancing. Soon, Americans could find themselves confined to their homes by order of the government. Its scary stuff that strikes at the very heart of individual liberty: the ability to move freely in public without being punished by the government.
What, then, is the scope of the governments power to confine people to their homes or, worse, to a government-run facility? What are the possible penalties for violating a government-ordered quarantine? And what does the U.S. Constitution have to say about all of this?
Lets address the last question first. In general, individual states have the power to make quarantine decisions affecting movements within their borders, pursuant to the Tenth Amendment to the Constitution, which leaves to the states the powers not delegated to the United States. Such residual powers include whats generically known as the police powerthat is, the power to establish laws protecting the health, safety, and welfare of the public. Every state has laws on the books permitting authoritiessometimes the governor, sometimes public health officials, sometimes bothto enact and enforce quarantine and isolation.
Meanwhile, the federal government derives its constitutional authority to quarantine people from the Commerce Clause, which gives Congress the power to regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States. Thus, the federal governments quarantine power applies most clearly at the U.S. border and for purposes of preventing the movement of infected people from state to state.
Under its Commerce Clause authority, Congress in 1944 passed the Public Health Service Act, which gave the executive branch power to enforce quarantines. The statute remains in effect today, although it has been amended several times, and although the relevant executive-branch agencies have been repeatedly reorganized and renamed. As it reads now, it gives the surgeon general, with the approval of the secretary of health and human services, the authority to take steps necessary to prevent the introduction, transmission, or spread of communicable diseases from foreign countries into the States or possessions, or from one State or possession into another State or possession. The statute also allows the president, via executive order and upon the recommendation of the HHS secretary, to issue regulations that provide for the apprehension, detention, or conditional release of individuals... for the purpose of preventing the spread of disease.
On January 31, 2020, HHS Secretary Alex Azar declared a United States public health emergency in connection with the coronavirus. His declaration unleashed massive regulatory powers to infringe on individual liberties in order to stem the crisis.
First, the declaration means that the fedsif they believe that the states arent doing enoughcan step in and impose a national quarantine. The relevant regulations allow the federal government to step in to manage disease whenever the director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) determines that the measures taken by health authorities of any State or possession... are insufficient to prevent the spread of any of the communicable diseases from such State or possession.
Second, if people want to travel across state lines anyway, the federal government can require permits. The regulations provide that requests for a travel permit must state the reasons why the travel is being requested, along with the mode of transportation, the places or individuals to be visited, the precautions, if any, to be taken to prevent the potential transmissionand whatever else the CDC believes it needs to know about people. Those who receive a permit must retain it in his/her possession throughout the course of travel, and can be required to present the permit to the operators of conveyances.
Third, the regulations state that the CDC director may, when acting under an executive order, authorize the apprehension, medical examination, quarantine, isolation, or conditional release of those who are reasonably believed to be infected and moving from state to state. The CDC can also require an individual to undergo a medical examination as part of a Federal order for quarantine. (The government is obliged to arrange for adequate food and water, appropriate accommodation, appropriate medical treatment, and means of necessary communication for detained individuals, although those terms are undefined.)
But what about the Due Process Clause, which forbids the government from depriving individuals of libertyhere, freedom of movementwithout some form of notice and process, i.e., the ability to be heard? (There are actually two Due Process clauses in the Constitutionone in the Fifth Amendment, which applies to the federal government, and one in the Fourteenth, which applies to the states.)
The regulations set forth the process that the federal government must follow in issuing a quarantine order, which includes that it provide an explanation of the factual basis for it, a promise to reassess the order within 72 hours, and an explanation of the criminal penalties for violating the order.
Yep, there are criminal penalties for violating a federal quarantine order. For individuals, they include a fine of up to $100,000 or a year in jail, or both. If the violation results in a death, the maximum fine climbs to $250,000.
The regulations disclaim that nothing in this section shall affect the constitutional or statutory rights of individuals to obtain judicial review of their Federal detention. All this means is that, if someone is detained, that person can go to court and ask a judge to order the government to release him or her, or, if the person is criminally prosecuted, it means that he or she can mount a defense based on the Due Process Clause or other provisions of the Constitution.
At the end of the day, however, a right under the Constitution is only so good as it is enforced. The Constitution does not prevent Congress from passing unconstitutional statutes or regulations in the first place. Nor does it prevent the executive branch from unconstitutionally enforcing quarantine laws. In the event of a mass quarantine in the United States, those battles would end up in the courts, which could decide not to intervene at all on the theory that the countervailing public-safety questions are too weighty for the judiciary.
Where does that leave individual Americans? At the mercy of the people in power and a hope-against-hope that the quality of their judgment will strike the right balance between individual liberties and public safety.
The rest is here:
Quarantine and the Constitution - The Bulwark
- Fifth Amendment - The Text, Origins, and Meaning of the ... [Last Updated On: April 26th, 2014] [Originally Added On: April 26th, 2014]
- 5th Amendment - Revolutionary War and Beyond [Last Updated On: April 26th, 2014] [Originally Added On: April 26th, 2014]
- Fifth Amendment | Wex Legal Dictionary / Encyclopedia ... [Last Updated On: April 26th, 2014] [Originally Added On: April 26th, 2014]
- Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution ... [Last Updated On: April 26th, 2014] [Originally Added On: April 26th, 2014]
- In NH, Ted Cruz talks Senate race, personal past, 2016 [Last Updated On: April 28th, 2014] [Originally Added On: April 28th, 2014]
- Justices suggest public employees' testimony is protected [Last Updated On: April 28th, 2014] [Originally Added On: April 28th, 2014]
- Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution - Video [Last Updated On: May 1st, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 1st, 2014]
- HST 330 fifth amendment presentation - Video [Last Updated On: May 1st, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 1st, 2014]
- Police not sure if Sioux City murder suspect invoked 5th Amendment rights [Last Updated On: May 3rd, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 3rd, 2014]
- Christie Ally Samson Refuses to Give Documents to Lawmakers [Last Updated On: May 4th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 4th, 2014]
- House votes contempt for ex-IRS official [Last Updated On: May 7th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 7th, 2014]
- 231-187 vote fell almost entirely along party lines [Last Updated On: May 7th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 7th, 2014]
- House votes to hold ex-IRS official in contempt [Last Updated On: May 7th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 7th, 2014]
- House votes to hold ex-IRS official Lois Lerner in contempt of Congress [Last Updated On: May 7th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 7th, 2014]
- Ex-IRS official held in contempt [Last Updated On: May 7th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 7th, 2014]
- Judge: Bensalem officials didn't invoke the Fifth [Last Updated On: May 7th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 7th, 2014]
- House votes to hold Lois Lerner in contempt [Last Updated On: May 7th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 7th, 2014]
- House holds Lois Lerner in contempt [Last Updated On: May 8th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 8th, 2014]
- House votes to hold former IRS official in contempt [Last Updated On: May 8th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 8th, 2014]
- Articles about Fifth Amendment - Los Angeles Times [Last Updated On: May 8th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 8th, 2014]
- Former PA Chairman Samson Pleads Fifth - Video [Last Updated On: May 9th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 9th, 2014]
- No plans to arrest Lois Lerner, John Boehner says [Last Updated On: May 13th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 13th, 2014]
- Im not going to testify: Witness pleads Fifth Amendment during Bangor triple murder trial [Last Updated On: May 13th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 13th, 2014]
- GOP-led House votes to hold former IRS official in contempt [Last Updated On: May 13th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 13th, 2014]
- Attorney: Defense told Corso will take Fifth [Last Updated On: May 16th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 16th, 2014]
- Christie: I knew nothing about plot - Video [Last Updated On: May 21st, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 21st, 2014]
- 2 county workers take 5th - Thu, 22 May 2014 PST [Last Updated On: May 22nd, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 22nd, 2014]
- Shawn Vestal: County permit clerical mishap raises eyebrows - Fri, 23 May 2014 PST [Last Updated On: May 23rd, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 23rd, 2014]
- Spokane County workers use Fifth Amendment in back-dating case - Thu, 22 May 2014 PST [Last Updated On: May 23rd, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 23rd, 2014]
- Sexual abuse measure could lead to wrongful convictions, attorneys say [Last Updated On: September 1st, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 1st, 2014]
- 5th Amendment - Laws.com [Last Updated On: September 1st, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 1st, 2014]
- Wildstein takes the 5th - Video [Last Updated On: September 1st, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 1st, 2014]
- Teen charged with killing his mother appears in court [Last Updated On: September 1st, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 1st, 2014]
- New bill a powerful tool to imprison sex offenders [Last Updated On: September 2nd, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 2nd, 2014]
- Fifth Amendment (United States Constitution ... [Last Updated On: September 2nd, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 2nd, 2014]
- Cristin Milioti in The Good Wife - Julianna Margulies - Video [Last Updated On: September 4th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 4th, 2014]
- Kansas Supreme Court: Grand jury violated man's Fifth Amendment rights [Last Updated On: September 6th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 6th, 2014]
- GWB probe: Christie says he's not satisfied with unanswered questions [Last Updated On: September 9th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 9th, 2014]
- Texas man's conviction overturned because of Fifth Amendment violation [Last Updated On: September 9th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 9th, 2014]
- "Fifth Amendment" Defined & Explained - Law [Last Updated On: September 9th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 9th, 2014]
- Cop Says 'You Must Be Doing Something Wrong if You Invoke Your Rights' (Video) [Last Updated On: September 12th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 12th, 2014]
- Public be damned Litchfield latest example [Last Updated On: September 14th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 14th, 2014]
- Volokh Conspiracy: What the posse comitatus case might mean for the future of the exclusionary rule [Last Updated On: September 15th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 15th, 2014]
- Fifth Amendment - Video [Last Updated On: September 16th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 16th, 2014]
- Top 5 Constitution-Related Searches at FindLaw.com [Last Updated On: September 18th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 18th, 2014]
- The Fifth Amendment Eminent Domain - Video [Last Updated On: September 18th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 18th, 2014]
- Apple And Google Will Force A Legal Battle Over The Privacy Of Your Passcode [Last Updated On: September 20th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 20th, 2014]
- Civics- The Fifth Amendment (Sarah Hutchinson) - Video [Last Updated On: September 20th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 20th, 2014]
- GOP fumes over Lerner remarks [Last Updated On: September 22nd, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 22nd, 2014]
- Google and Apple Wont Unlock Your Phone, But a Court Can Make You Do It [Last Updated On: September 22nd, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 22nd, 2014]
- Assistant to DeKalb CEO Ellis invokes 5th Amendment 30 times [Last Updated On: September 22nd, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 22nd, 2014]
- GOP fumes as Lois Lerner talks to press but snubs Congress [Last Updated On: September 24th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 24th, 2014]
- Cry us a river, Lois Lerner [Last Updated On: September 24th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 24th, 2014]
- Can You Go to Jail for Refusing to Testify? [Last Updated On: September 25th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 25th, 2014]
- Fifth Amendment Projectb - Video [Last Updated On: September 25th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 25th, 2014]
- The Commander Cody Band - Take The Fifth Amendment - 8/5/1977 - Convention Hall (Official) - Video [Last Updated On: September 27th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 27th, 2014]
- Joey Gallo Takes The Fifth Amendment - Video [Last Updated On: September 30th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 30th, 2014]
- Batavia High School teacher John Dryden retires [Last Updated On: October 4th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 4th, 2014]
- Batavia High School teacher John Dryden retires from school district [Last Updated On: October 4th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 4th, 2014]
- The Fifth Amendment Please Don't Leave Me Now - Video [Last Updated On: October 5th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 5th, 2014]
- Man Denied Fifth Amendment While In Court Wearing Anti-Police Shirt, Still Won His Case (Video) [Last Updated On: October 6th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 6th, 2014]
- Batavia teacher previously involved in Fifth Amendment dispute retires [Last Updated On: October 7th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 7th, 2014]
- INFORMUCATE: THE FIFTH AMENDMENT - Video [Last Updated On: October 8th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 8th, 2014]
- Fairholme Funds Appeals Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Verdict [Last Updated On: October 11th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 11th, 2014]
- Fresno Police Officer violated fifth amendment at a dui checkpoint. part 2 - Video [Last Updated On: October 11th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 11th, 2014]
- Fresno Police Officer violated fifth amendment at a dui checkpoint. - Video [Last Updated On: October 11th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 11th, 2014]
- Code cases: Police want phone access, but some pass [Last Updated On: October 12th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 12th, 2014]
- All About - Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution - Video [Last Updated On: October 16th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 16th, 2014]
- Property Rights | Century Law Group - Video [Last Updated On: October 21st, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 21st, 2014]
- Scott and Crist have heated and personal final debate before November election [Last Updated On: October 22nd, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 22nd, 2014]
- Agents questioned, Askar takes the Fifth in Trombetta hearing [Last Updated On: October 22nd, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 22nd, 2014]
- Detective dodges questions about allegations made during rape investigation [Last Updated On: October 25th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 25th, 2014]
- Disciplinary hearing for SB officer moved to later date - Video [Last Updated On: October 26th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 26th, 2014]
- Court rules: Touch ID is not protected by the Fifth Amendment but Passcodes are [Last Updated On: October 31st, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 31st, 2014]
- Virginia Court: LEOs Can Force You To Provide Fingerprint To Unlock Your Phone [Last Updated On: November 1st, 2014] [Originally Added On: November 1st, 2014]
- Virginia judge: Police can demand a suspect unlock a phone with a fingerprint [Last Updated On: November 1st, 2014] [Originally Added On: November 1st, 2014]
- Judge Rules Suspect Can Be Required To Unlock Phone With Fingerprint [Last Updated On: November 1st, 2014] [Originally Added On: November 1st, 2014]
- Your Fingerprints Belong To Us: Iphone Users Forfeit 5th Amendment 1 - Video [Last Updated On: November 1st, 2014] [Originally Added On: November 1st, 2014]
- Civil Rights and Civil Liberties - Fifth Amendment - Shh! The Right to Remain Silent - Video [Last Updated On: November 1st, 2014] [Originally Added On: November 1st, 2014]
- All Your Fingerprints Are Belong To Us: iPhone Users Forfeit Fifth Amendment - Video [Last Updated On: November 2nd, 2014] [Originally Added On: November 2nd, 2014]