One must empathise with Left-liberals who have to perform a high-wire balancing act just to acknowledge the obvious.
For the Left-liberal, Hinduism did not exist before the British came to rule over us; but caste rigidity, which was as much a colonial legacy as anything else, must be labelled as intrinsically Hindu and ancient.
And even when this backdoor nod to Hinduisms existence is accepted, it must be contrasted with vile Hindutva, so that only negative linkages remain to the term Hindu.
The latest liberal to do this kind of balancing act is Pratap Bhanu Mehta, who called out the tendency among some intellectuals to deny Hinduisms existence before colonial interventions made the term more widely usable to describe an Indic plurality.
But before he acknowledged the obvious, from the very first line of his article, he sought to differentiate Hindutva from Hinduism.
He wrote: In part as a reaction to the spiritual desecration, homogenisation and centralisation of Hinduism that Hindutva represents, there is a temptation to take recourse to the idea that Hinduism is a colonial invention and no such identity existed before the 19th century.
Really? Is it the votaries of Hindutva who are desecrating Hinduism or its mindless critics?
The context of Mehtas observation was a recent statement by actor Kamal Haasan, a covert Hinduphobe, who critiqued the film Ponniyin Selvan-I, based on a popular novel written by the late Kalki Krishnamurthy and serialised in the Tamil magazine Kalki in the sixties.
The novel has had, and continues to have, a cult following among some sections of Tamilians. It is a piece of historical fiction set in the Chola era, where some of the finest Hindu temples were built. Most major Tamil dynasties, whether Cholas or Pandyas or Pallavas, were great temple builders.
But Kamal Haasan would have none of it. There was no Hinduism in the Chola era, he said. There were Shaivites and Vaishnavites, no Hindus.
To debunk this nonsense, Mehta, in an article in The Indian Express, had to resort to the subterfuge of bringing in Hindutva to contrast with Hinduism.
He wrote: Recently, the actorKamal Haasanwas reported as referring to this idea in his historical critique ofPonniyin Selvan-I, to flag the dangers of homogenisation in modern representations of Hinduism.
"Kamal Haasans critique has a local context in Tamil Nadu politics. But increasingly, this idea of Hinduism as a British invention is seen as some kind of intellectual response to the claims of Hindutva.
"Many academics and self-proclaimed secularists spout this idea, as if this was common sense. But this idea is itself philosophically nave, culturally ignorant and even politically self-defeating.
Mehta is right to indirectly point out that the mainstream Dravidian political discourse in Tamil Nadu is anti-Hindu, but why does he need to bring in Hindutva, and give it a negative connotation, just to be able to say that denying the existence of Hinduism was philosophically nave, culturally ignorant and even politically self-defeating.
Clearly, liberals fear being cancelled by their own for merely accepting the reality of Hinduisms pre-colonial existence.
Mehta is bang on when he notes that a category can exist even though it may not have a name attached to it, especially when almost every foreign source assumed that Indias plurality existed within a field that made it distinctive.
As one TV debate participant noted, we dont say the human species did not exist before the term homo sapiens was invented. We dont say the American continent did not exist before Amerigo Vespucci and Columbus brought it to the notice of Europeans.
The real problem is why Mehta thinks Hindutva is about spiritual desecration, homogenisation and centralisation of Hinduism? Is the search for common elements (our collective Hinduness) a form of homogenisation and centralisation?
While religion can be vulgarised by (for example) the use of loud Bollywood music during festivals, but is this spiritual desecration when Hinduism does not hold spirituality to be something different from basic human desires?
Hinduism embeds both sublime spirituality and earthy physicality. The four purusharthas: Dharma, Artha, Kama and Moksha, embody this multiplicity of human aspirations. Sensory pleasures were never deemed to be antithetical to more spiritual pursuits.
Where is the attempt at homogeneity, when all that is being attempted under the banner of Hindutva is to find common elements of identity in order to protect the interests of the collective?
Take a different example. When there is no caste called Dalit, why are so many different and unrelated jatis seeking to band themselves together under the term Dalit?
Why do we have a term called feminism, when we know that every woman is different from other women, and groups different from other groups? Is this an attempt at homogeneity?
If Hindutva is homogenisation, then Dalitism the search for an overarching identity in order to protect common interests and rights - is invalid too.
The real issue is not that Hindus are trying to find common linkages to one another, but why they need to do so.
Unlike religions which had clear founders and a set of defined fundamentals, where commonality is defined by these two factors, Hinduism is a ground-up religion that grew from this soil.
Soft unity was forged through interactions, contestations, debates and by borrowing ideas from one another.
Put simply, the three religions that originated from desert cults and three Indian ones Buddhism, Jainism and Sikhism started with a unified set of ideas and then developed diversity.
Hinduism started at the other end, with plurality as the norm, and then seeking spiritual and temporal unity. Given its origins and development over five millennia, it is easier to divide Hindus than unite them.
Which is why the predatory and expansionist religions find it easier to recruit new members by exploiting internal fault-lines. To guard against this, Hindus need to find common elements for unifying them and survive these assaults.
This is not the same as homogenisation and centralisation.
Pratap Bhanu Mehta should focus on the truth that he finds relevant, not try to create imaginary threats to plurality through homogenisation and spiritual desecration.
He could have merely said that Hinduism-deniers have no clothes, but he chose to clothe his statement by pointing in a different direction to balance the truth with some untruth. He probably fears being "cancelled".
Also Read: Hinduism v/s Hindutva: A False Dichotomy
Read the rest here:
Why 'Liberals' Tie Themselves Into Knots Over Hinduism And Hindutva - Swarajya
- Have the Liberal Arts Gone Conservative? - The New Yorker - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- Letters to the Editor: 'I see myself in Katie Britt' what liberal critics missed in the senator's response - Los Angeles Times - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- Even when it criticizes Israel, the liberal world is not against us - opinion - The Jerusalem Post - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- Former Trump Aide Alyssa Farah Griffin Becomes a Liberal Favorite - The New York Times - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- Renowned author, liberal arts proponent to deliver annual Lester Lectures - Mercer University - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- NYU to Host Zaheer Ali at the Annual Liberal Studies Student Research ColloquiumApril 5 - NYU - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- Power to the Neighborhoods!: New York City Growth Politics, Neighborhood Liberalism, and the Origins of the ... - Joint Center for Housing Studies - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- Canada's Conservatives back NDP-Liberal anti-scab legislation that undermines the right to strike - WSWS - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- The Surprising Left-Right Alliance That Wants More Apartments in Suburbs - The New York Times - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- PARKER: Clarence Thomas, liberal racism and the ongoing denigration of Black conservatives - Kankakee Daily Journal - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- Liberal Media Scream: Hollywoods freaks over Trump - Washington Examiner - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- Why liberals failed in the fight against antisemitism - JNS.org - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- Liberal Renew manifesto sneak peek and bits from Bucharest congress - EURACTIV - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- Katie Britt calls on liberal media 'to pay attention' to border - 1819 News - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- Liberal truck wash cited $171k for OSHA violations - KSN-TV - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- Over 30,000 Killed in Gaza, but Even Israel's 'Liberal Left' Says: That's War - Opinion - Haaretz - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- Liberal Man Injured in Beaver County Accident - KSCB News.net - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- What is the Market's View on China Liberal Education Holdings Ltd (CLEU) Stock's Price and Volume Trends Monday? - InvestorsObserver - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- German liberals send defence expert into tripartite EU election leadership team - EURACTIV - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- Ramaswamy warns liberal justices 'buying political latitude' with 9-0 ruling as more Trump cases lie ahead - Fox News - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- How much of this is propelled by white liberal guilt from executives?: Gutfeld - Fox News - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- Liberals and the Libel of Christian Nationalism - The Imaginative Conservative - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- Liberal Arts & Science Academy - Austin extends home winning streak to seven - MaxPreps - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- Liberal Racism and the Denigration of Black Conservatives - Daily Signal - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- Watchdog group exposes radical, liberal ideology of school-based health centers - The Lion - March 12th, 2024 [March 12th, 2024]
- What happens when a liberal learns her family owned slaves? - Leader & Times - February 11th, 2024 [February 11th, 2024]
- Is it Liberal Arts, Without the Arts? - Xavier Newswire - February 11th, 2024 [February 11th, 2024]
- Quebec Liberal Party would be more popular with Denis Coderre at the helm: poll - Montreal Gazette - February 11th, 2024 [February 11th, 2024]
- Maine's Liberal Members of Congress Stand by Biden After Disastrous, Confused Press Conference - The Maine Wire - February 11th, 2024 [February 11th, 2024]
- Liberal Media Scream: Kristen Welker likes to lecture Republicans, too - Washington Examiner - February 11th, 2024 [February 11th, 2024]
- Australia's only Liberal government lives on - for now - Yahoo News Australia - February 11th, 2024 [February 11th, 2024]
- Liberal institutions are the threat to liberal institutions Claudine Gay is warning about - Washington Examiner - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- Elon Musk, the "free speech absolutist" kicks liberal journalists off Twitter - Daily Kos - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- Liberal Arts and studies in humanities under attack on college campuses - The Community Word - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- Liberal candidate for federal byelection planned to run for Conservatives last year - National Post - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- Bill Barton: 'The Liberal by the Bay' - Redheaded Blackbelt - December 7th, 2023 [December 7th, 2023]
- OPINION | Female-dominated liberal arts imperative in male-dominated tech world - Tulane Hullabaloo - December 7th, 2023 [December 7th, 2023]
- Dean of the College of Liberal and Fine Arts job with Tarleton State University | 37572379 - The Chronicle of Higher Education - December 7th, 2023 [December 7th, 2023]
- Laughing Stock: 'A liberal agenda' may not be what you think - Tucson Weekly - December 7th, 2023 [December 7th, 2023]
- Justin Trudeau plays the Trump card - POLITICO - POLITICO - December 7th, 2023 [December 7th, 2023]
- Norman Lear, Producer Of TV's 'All In The Family' And Influential Liberal Advocate, Dies At 101 - Newstalk 750 - 103.7 ... - KFQD - December 7th, 2023 [December 7th, 2023]
- Kremlin Taps Liberal Businessman to Oppose Putin in 2024 Election Report - The Moscow Times - December 7th, 2023 [December 7th, 2023]
- Norman Lear, producer of TV's 'All in the Family' and influential liberal advocate, has died at 101 - WV News - December 7th, 2023 [December 7th, 2023]
- MoveOn Carries Out Layoffs as Liberal Groups Struggle to Raise Money - The New York Times - December 7th, 2023 [December 7th, 2023]
- Norman Lear, producer of TV's 'All in the Family' and influential liberal advocate, has died at 101 - El Paso Inc. - December 7th, 2023 [December 7th, 2023]
- UW System President suggests universities with high numbers of low income students should shift away from liberal arts - Wisconsin Examiner - December 7th, 2023 [December 7th, 2023]
- Norman Lear, producer of TV's 'All in the Family' and influential liberal advocate, has died at 101 - The Caledonian-Record - December 7th, 2023 [December 7th, 2023]
- Israels representative in New York resigned to protest Netanyahu. Now hes got some tough words for liberal New York Jews. - Forward - December 7th, 2023 [December 7th, 2023]
- Neal Milner: Watch That Swinging Door, Liberals, Lest It Hit You On The Way Out - Honolulu Civil Beat - December 7th, 2023 [December 7th, 2023]
- The Liberal Answer to Cancel Culture - Manhattan Institute - November 8th, 2023 [November 8th, 2023]
- Study: Liberal US priests facing 'progressive' extinction - The Pillar - November 8th, 2023 [November 8th, 2023]
- Liberal Jewish U.S. Groups Are Walking an Oh-So-Thin Tightrope - The New Republic - November 8th, 2023 [November 8th, 2023]
- Why a liberal arts degree is often a ticket to career success - USC Dornsife College of Letters, Arts and Sciences - November 8th, 2023 [November 8th, 2023]
- Open Forum: In their time, founding fathers were liberal - The Winchester Star - November 8th, 2023 [November 8th, 2023]
- Liberals announce National Campaign Committee Co-Chairs - Liberal Party of Canada - November 8th, 2023 [November 8th, 2023]
- UT College of Liberal Arts hosts panel about Senate Bill 17 - The Daily Texan - November 8th, 2023 [November 8th, 2023]
- Liberal Arts student uses platform to educate others on the ... - Pennsylvania State University - November 8th, 2023 [November 8th, 2023]
- Stanford celebrates 50 years of Structured Liberal Education ... - Stanford University News - November 8th, 2023 [November 8th, 2023]
- Brookline homes: One wealthy liberal town reckons with its past - The Boston Globe - November 8th, 2023 [November 8th, 2023]
- The Value of a Liberal Arts Degree: Whats the Return on Investment? - The New York Times - November 8th, 2023 [November 8th, 2023]
- California Police Say Investigation Ongoing into Death of Liberal Pro ... - Crime Report - November 8th, 2023 [November 8th, 2023]
- Liberal Arts, IST student scores sports technology internship with ... - Pennsylvania State University - November 8th, 2023 [November 8th, 2023]
- And the award for the worst Liberal Party leader goes to... - The New Daily - November 8th, 2023 [November 8th, 2023]
- Street fights over prayer offer liberal Israelis a chance to define a Judaism they can believe in - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - September 29th, 2023 [September 29th, 2023]
- Unmasking Hinduphobic Cartoons: The Liberal Media's Double Standard - The Jaipur Dialogues - September 29th, 2023 [September 29th, 2023]
- UC presents lecture on liberal arts featuring Michael W. Twitty - University of Cincinnati - September 29th, 2023 [September 29th, 2023]
- ISU makes progress on liberal arts cuts through incentivized ... - The Gazette - September 29th, 2023 [September 29th, 2023]
- Investing in the future of the liberal arts | Binghamton News - Binghamton - September 29th, 2023 [September 29th, 2023]
- Challenges to Liberal Democracy on Global Scale Is Topic of 2023 ... - University of Idaho - September 29th, 2023 [September 29th, 2023]
- Liberal Democrats edge ahead of Labour on charging, with free ... - Disability News Service - September 29th, 2023 [September 29th, 2023]
- Kerry Washington Creates $1 Million Earl and Valerie Washington ... - GW Today - September 29th, 2023 [September 29th, 2023]
- LILLEY: Justice Rouleau may have old Liberal Party ties but he's not Justin Trudeau's uncle or related at all - Toronto Sun - February 20th, 2023 [February 20th, 2023]
- Brian Lilley: Justice Rouleau may have old Liberal Party ties but he's not Justin Trudeau's uncle or related at all - The Province - February 20th, 2023 [February 20th, 2023]
- force.com - November 27th, 2022 [November 27th, 2022]
- Liberal Party SA - November 25th, 2022 [November 25th, 2022]
- Liberal Fascism: The Secret History of the American Left, From ... - November 25th, 2022 [November 25th, 2022]
- Ex-VP Hamid Ansari's 'Challenges to a liberal polity' book review: The politics of being Indian - The New Indian Express - November 7th, 2022 [November 7th, 2022]
- English | Liberal Arts | UT - Austin - November 5th, 2022 [November 5th, 2022]
- Liberal values are absolute - The Tribune India - October 17th, 2022 [October 17th, 2022]
- Fixing another liberal tax burden - The Hill - October 17th, 2022 [October 17th, 2022]