Saand ki Aankh, or the Bulls Eye, has an unusual subject for a Bollywood film: it is about Prakashi and Chando Tomar, two octogenarian grandmothers who became sharp shooters in their 60s.
A Bollywood film with two female protagonists is a rarity a film about two elderly women is almost unthinkable. Instead of making a positive buzz about its unusual protagonists, the film is mired in controversy because of its mismatched casting. Taapsee Pannu, who is 32, and Bhumi Pednekar, who is 29, play the roles of the two octogenarian characters.
Older actresses, such as Neena Gupta, and Soni Razdan, have pointed out that instead of using make-up and prosthetics to age these young actresses on screen, the film producers could have cast older actresses who crave roles appropriate for their age.
Pannu, and Parineeti Chopra have defended the film producers casting choice on the grounds of creative freedom. Pannu claims, I can play a person of any age and gender, race or sexual orientation thats what acting is about.
Also read:When Will Bollywood Portray Widows as Complete Humans?
What is lost in the game of one-upmanship between two generations of actresses is the role of representation in perpetuating the injustices of ageism.
Pannus response to charges of ageism is similar to Scarlett Johanssons when she withdrew from playing a transgender character in Rub and Tug. Johansson responded to the public backlash with the same argument about the creative freedom of an actor: You know, as an actor I should be allowed to play any person, or any tree, or any animal because that is my job and the requirements of my job.
Claims of artistic freedom as a response to charges of ageism or trans-discrimination miss the fact that creative freedom for one set of actors denies the same freedom and opportunity to a marginalised group. It misses the fact that all art, including films, is representation. As such, a film is a response to and commentary on the world.A film that casts two young actresses in their twenties to present the story of two geriatric sharp shooters is commenting on the value of older woman.
Remarks about creative freedom of actors assume that art is separate from the real world. While art is not a passive reflection of reality, it is not disconnected from it either. Arts relation to the world is two-fold: symbolic and material. The symbolic aspect of art is that it is a representation of the real world filtered through media such as language, colours, and sound. Art is a response to reality, rather than its mirror.
In this regard, Edward Said observed that representation involves transpersonal, transhuman, and transcultural forces as class, the unconscious, gender, race, and structure among other things.
Since art operates according to its own logic, it is able to affirm or challenge these forces through aesthetic choices. Art, therefore, has the freedom to reaffirm or resist the real world. The material aspect of art refers to the tangible effect of representation on the world.For example, stereotyping of minorities or erasing them from stories, and history, perpetuates the discrimination of the real world through the use of language and symbols in art. Such representations are pernicious because they precede actual policies, acts of exclusion and violence.
Also read:A Great Year for Women-Centred Hindi Cinema
Bollywood cinema, as a form of narrative cinema, has two layers of representation: at the level of the story, and at the level of casting (corresponding with the symbolic and the material, respectively). At the symbolic level, Saand ki Aankh resists Bollywoods patriarchal, youth-obsessed values.
Bollywoods commitment to youth and patriarchy suggests that older women are neither interesting, nor marketable. On the surface, Saand Ki Ankh subverts the normative order associated with narratives about the elderly. Its story about two rural octogenarian grandmothers allows for portrayal of complex women characters that traditional Bollywood films do not allow.
However, by casting 20-year olds for 60-year olds, the film undermines the revolutionary potential of the story. The use of 20-year-olds made-up to resemble 60-year olds signals that old age is acceptable only if it is dressed up in youth. These casting decisions also have far-reaching consequences on the professional lives of veteran actresses. The absence of stories in which older women are representing the complexity of the lives of elderly women precludes older actresses from obtaining meaningful work and relegates them to one-dimensional stereotypical roles. Given the preference for younger actors, older actors are unable to audition for roles of younger women.
For many veteran actresses, Saand Ki Aankh would be a wonderful opportunity. For young talented actresses, such as Taapsee Pannu or Bhumi Pednekar, on the other hand, this is one among many interesting roles they will get to play during the early stage of their acting career.
The issue of age-appropriate casting is about inequality, not authenticity. There is an important difference between identity categories (such as race, gender, sexuality, ability, and age) and professional identities (e.g., a sportsmen, doctors). Professional identities are not minority identities. In contrast, identity categories, such as race, gender, sexuality, age and ability, are tied to discriminatory structures. Minorities in these identity categories often face discrimination and are excluded from narratives or are reduced to stereotypes. This limits opportunities for actors who belong to that category.
A classic example of this problem is manifest in the selection of Priyanka Chopra to play Mary Kom. No one disputes Chopras ability to portray Mary Kom. But Chopra gets to play both north and north-eastern Indian, characters. A north-eastern Indian actress does not have such flexibility. Because Kom is from the northeast, and Hindi cinema, reflecting the national imagination, rarely has any northeastern characters, the film would have been a rare opportunity for a talented northeastern actress.
Also read:Does the Bollywood Heroine Ever Sweat?
Creative casting choices have deepened the symbolic aspect of representation in recent years. For example, the runaway Broadway hit Hamilton, by Lin Manuel Miranda, traces the life of the youngest Founding Father of the US: Alexander Hamilton.
In its casting, the Broadway musical used African American, Latinx, and Asian actors to portray the white founders of the US. Non-white actors for the white Founding Fathers made visible the forgotten people who built the US through slavery, indentured servitude and inequitable labor relations. In other words, the casting decisions for Hamilton underscores the inherent racism of the countrys defining documents such as the constitution, Bill of Rights and the Federalist Papers.
Lin Manuel Miranda, actor and creator of the of the play Hamilton, addresses the audience after the plays opening night on Broadway in New York in this August 6, 2015 photo. Photo: Reuters/Lucas Jackson/Files
In addition to exposing the racism at the foundation of the US, Hamiltons unusual casting decision created opportunities for skilled non-white performers in Broadway, which is notoriously limited in its opportunities for people of colour. Hamilton shows how creative casting decisions can draw attention to forgotten aspects of history and provide opportunities for minority talent in an industry where the dominant groups determine who tells the stories, what they say and how they present it.
In the performance arts whether theatre or cinema casting choices are never innocuous in terms of their impact. Pannus right to creative freedom is possible if we live in a world that is free of inequality and discrimination. Until equal opportunities are available to people of minority identity categories, it is necessary for the allies of minority groups to be aware of the impact of their actions, including their exercise of artistic freedom.
Dr Sohinee Roy is an Associate Professor of English at North Central College. Her research interests are in postcolonial literature and culture.
Read this article:
'Saand ki Aankh' Casting Misses the Bulls Eye - The Wire
- Martine Rothblatt - Wikipedia - November 25th, 2022
- Red Pill University | Beyond the Matrix - November 25th, 2022
- China Runs Police Outpost In New York City - technocracy.news - November 23rd, 2022
- Trilateral Commission: The secret circle that controls governments - November 23rd, 2022
- Steve Jackson Games Forums - Powered by vBulletin - November 23rd, 2022
- Elon Musk: Here Comes 'Optimus' - technocracy.news - October 28th, 2022
- Biden Builds Transhuman Cyborg Army using Immigrants! - October 28th, 2022
- What Is Transhumanism? - Human Life International - October 23rd, 2022
- Ageing is a technical problem that can be reversed, Dubai Future Forum told - The National - October 15th, 2022
- Ai-Da the robot and the myth of AI - Spiked - October 15th, 2022
- Dwayne Johnson's Black Adam to release a day early in Indian theatres - Ottplay - October 15th, 2022
- WISeKey Strengthens its Technology Portfolio Across Cybersecurity, IoT, NFT and the Metaverse ... - Ottumwacourier - August 10th, 2022
- Madison writer Meghan O'Gieblyn explores the connection between technology and religion - Isthmus - August 10th, 2022
- What Happened to Royce White? Mother Jones - Mother Jones - August 10th, 2022
- The "resurrection" of the dead pigs, the promise of progress and the source of questions - - News84Media.com - August 10th, 2022
- Letter: Criticism of school district plan misleading | Letters To The Editor | newburyportnews.com - The Daily News of Newburyport - July 27th, 2022
- 12 Best Sci-Fi Games On PS4 And PS5 - Tech News Today - July 27th, 2022
- Mutants are Coming to the MCU, But Where Does Krakoa Fit In? - Gizmodo - July 27th, 2022
- Transhumanism to humankind's rescue? A new book claims we face a 'make or break' century, so let the technological remake begin - Genetic Literacy... - July 27th, 2022
- All Posts - Latest News - McAllisterTV - July 9th, 2022
- Chile Bans Discrimination Against Mutants and Genetically Altered ... - July 9th, 2022
- Biden Proves Soaring Gas Prices Are Intentional To Transition To ... - July 9th, 2022
- The Most Powerful Characters In The Boys Ranked - /Film - July 9th, 2022
- Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Just Showcased One Of Its Most Effective Metaphors Yet - /Film - June 20th, 2022
- Fear-extinction and the end of self-loathing in the metaverse - TNW - June 20th, 2022
- FDA Making COVID Vax Decision Based on a Study of 10 - Verve Times - June 20th, 2022
- 2022-05-16 | NDAQ:WKEY | Press Release | WISeKey International Holding AG - Stockhouse - May 21st, 2022
- Russian Colonel threatens Elon Musk, says you will be accountable - Euro Weekly News - May 11th, 2022
- Venice Biennale 2022: Man's relationship with the planet gets surreal - Euronews - April 25th, 2022
- Venice Biennale 2022: the worst art on show in the city - Art Newspaper - April 25th, 2022
- Who is Kwan Ha in the Halo show? Here's the character's story - Win.gg - April 11th, 2022
- Top 20 Companies That Rule The Web - technocracy.news - March 29th, 2022
- The Brian Jonestown Massacre reveal new album is on the way | Gigwise - Gigwise - March 27th, 2022
- WEF Global Risks Report 2022 Imagines ... - technocracy.news - February 17th, 2022
- Major LGBTQ+ organisations spark international review of the EHRC - Stonewall - February 17th, 2022
- Government to set up Military Base in the Afram Plains - GhanaWeb - February 17th, 2022
- The platform for a transhuman future: LABORATORY ... - February 7th, 2022
- X22Reports: The Storm is Upon Us, Green ... - Before It's News - February 3rd, 2022
- When hateful words arrive at the door - TheRecord.com - February 3rd, 2022
- Alert over killings of human rights defenders and journalists in the Americas in first month of 2022 - Amnesty International - February 3rd, 2022
- The best of Manfred Thierry Mugler's theatrical, otherworldly fashion - i-D - January 28th, 2022
- CEO of Pfizer arrested, charged with fraud media ... - January 19th, 2022
- Noah Hawley outlines the big themes of his Alien TV show - Winter Is Coming - January 7th, 2022
- Matrix Online may have perished in 2009, but it still exists as a ghost - BollyInside - December 19th, 2021
- Will artificial intelligence achieve godlike power? Wallace B. Henry asks, Who Will Rule the Coming 'Gods'? - Denison Forum - December 19th, 2021
- Vatican Hosts Conference Touching on Transhumanism - December 10th, 2021
- WISekeys Founder and CEO Carlos Moreira was Interviewed by - November 28th, 2021
- Doctor Issues Dire Warning to the ... - Technocracy News - November 28th, 2021
- Vinegar Syndrome Celebrates Black Friday With Secret Title Reveals and 50% Off Most Releases! - Bloody Disgusting - November 27th, 2021
- The Horror Movies Coming to Netflix in December Include 'Tremors' and the 'Final Destination' Films - Bloody Disgusting - November 27th, 2021
- ECB survey shows euro zone inflation just below goal in 2022 - Yahoo Finance UK - October 30th, 2021
- Succession Returns, with no real people involved - WION - October 21st, 2021
- Proof That The Vaxxed Are No Longer Human - Luciferian ... - October 3rd, 2021
- RUBY 9100M x adidas Originals Ozrah Release Info | HYPEBEAST - October 3rd, 2021
- Ming-Na Wen & SNLs Keith Ian Raywood Reflect On 9/11 At Creative Arts Emmys: Twenty Years Ago Completely Changed Our Lives - Deadline - September 12th, 2021
- Jeff Bezos is reportedly funding Altos Labs, a new anti-ageing venture aiming to cheat death - Screen Shot - September 10th, 2021
- 13 Most Extreme Body Modifications - CBS News - July 27th, 2021
- Klaus Schwab: Great Reset Will Lead to Implantable ... - July 27th, 2021
- Technocrat Millionaire Unlocks Secrets Of The Mind - July 25th, 2021
- Crimson Circle > Library - July 25th, 2021
- Transhuman | Futurist Transhuman News Blog - June 23rd, 2021
- Transhuman 101: Moderna Declares COVID Vaccine To Be An ... - June 23rd, 2021
- Futurist Transhuman News Blog - euvolution.com - June 23rd, 2021
- Coronavirus and the transhuman future - European Academy ... - June 23rd, 2021
- Transhumanism Is The New Religion Of Technocracy - June 23rd, 2021
- Its A Sin Star Lydia West On Walking Her First Major Red Carpet At The TV BAFTAs - British Vogue - June 11th, 2021
- Mother Lands is a tabletop RPG free of slavery and colonialism - Polygon - June 11th, 2021
- Twenty years covering people, politics, and protests - rabble.ca - May 11th, 2021
- Will New COVID Vaccine Make You Transhuman? (You Need to ... - March 21st, 2021
- Will New COVID Vaccine Make You Transhuman? - The Vaccine ... - March 21st, 2021
- El-Rufai: Clerics can negotiate with bandits -- that's not our job - TheCable - March 21st, 2021
- Falana-led Coalition Urges FG to Ban Foreign Armed Herders - THISDAY Newspapers - February 27th, 2021
- Insecurity: Nigeria working towards amendment of ECOWAS Protocols - Guardian - February 25th, 2021
- Herder crisis: Not impossible that non-Nigerian elements are involved - Fayemi - Nairametrics - February 25th, 2021
- It's A Sin cast: meet the unknowns behind 2021's first TV hit - NME.com - February 4th, 2021
- Years and Years - News24 - October 22nd, 2020
- Transhumanism: Meet the cyborgs and biohackers redefining beauty - CNN - May 29th, 2020
- Kriya Therapeutics announces $80 million Series A financing to advance gene therapies for highly prevalent serious diseases - PRNewswire - May 17th, 2020
- Conscious Evolution | Futurist Transhuman News Blog - April 11th, 2020
- No death and an enhanced life: Is the future transhuman ... - April 11th, 2020