Capitalism, Francis Fukuyama announced more than a decade ago, is the promised land at the End of History. The collapse of the Soviet Union confirmed that there was neither an alternative to the market, nor a possibility of transcending capitalism.
Not even the events of September 11, which have led many critics to mock the 'End of History' thesis, have given Fukuyama cause to change his mind. The end of history, Fukuyama argues, means not the termination of conflict, simply the recognition that nothing can improve upon capitalism. Why? Because, as he puts it in Our Posthuman Future, capitalist institutions 'are grounded in assumptions about human nature that are far more realistic than those of their competitors'.
Yet even Fukuyama has come to worry that the reports of History's death might have been a mite exaggerated. Capitalism, he fears, is undermining its own foundations. Not, as Marx thought, through the agency of the working class, but as a result of the unrestricted advance of science and technology. Science, and in particular biotechnology, has, Fukuyama believes, the potential to change the kinds of beings we are, and in so doing to 'recommence history', propelling us from a human to a posthuman world. From the end of history to the end of human nature as we know it.
Fukuyama's argument runs something like this. Human values are rooted in human nature. Human nature is rooted in our biological being, in particular in our genes. Messing around with human biology could alter human nature, transform our values and undermine capitalism. 'What is ultimately at stake with biotechnology', Fukuyama declares, 'is... the very grounding of the human moral sense.' We therefore need international regulation to obstruct any technological advance that might 'disrupt either the unity or the continuity of human nature, and thereby the human rights that are based upon it.'
While most worried about genetic engineering, other technologies also concern Fukuyama. Cloning is an 'unnatural form' of reproduction that might create 'unnatural urges' in a parent whose spouse has been cloned. Prozac is giving women 'more of the alpha-male feeling that comes with high serotonin levels', while Ritalin is making 'young boys... sit still' even though 'nature never designed them to behave that way.'
Even attempt to slow down the ageing process is 'unnatural' and fraught with danger. The world, Fukuyama believes, may soon be divided 'between a North whose political tone is set by elderly women' (since women tend to live longer than men) and 'a South driven by... super-empowered angry young men'. The consequence will not simply be more days like September 11, but also a disinclination on the part of the West to use force in response, since women are apparently naturally less aggressive than men.
Such fears may seem to carry all the scholarly weight of a Hollywood dystopian fantasy (Gataca meets The Invasion of the Body Snatchers, perhaps). If capitalism is as natural as Fukuyama claims, how is it that for virtually the whole of human history people abided by entirely different sets of values and beliefs? And what exactly worries Fukuyama about genetic engineering? That we will be turned into a race of beings who believe that the market may not be the best way to promote human flourishing? Or (God forbid) that we will lose our attachment to the sanctity of property?
As for the dangers of longevity, life expectancy has doubled in the past two centuries - without any evidence of social breakdown. Nor is there any evidence that the extension of the franchise to women at the beginning of the twentieth century made that century any less violent than the nineteenth.
Absurd though such arguments may seem to be, at the heart of Fukuyama's book is a discussion, not of biotechnology, but of what it is to be human. To understand his alarmism about biotechnology, we have to understand his confusions over human nature.
For Fukuyama, humans as a species possess an inner essence or nature, which he defines as 'the sum total of the behaviour and characteristics that are typical of the human species, arising from genetic rather than environmental factors.' From this perspective, humans seem little more than sophisticated animals. 'Many of the attributes that were once held to be unique to human beings - including language, culture, reason, consciousness, and the like - are', Fukuyama believes, 'characteristic of a wide variety of nonhuman animals'.
At the same time, though, Fukuyama presents humans as exceptional beings. While all animals have a nature, only humans possess 'dignity'. Dignity gives humans a 'superior... moral status that raises us all above the rest of animal creation and yet makes us equals of one another qua human beings.' Such dignity, Fukuyama believes, resides in a mysterious 'Factor X' which is the 'essential human quality' that remains after 'all of a person's contingent and accidental characteristics' have been stripped away. It is Factor X that Fukuyama wants to preserve from the clutches of biotechnologists.
And therein lies the problem. 'Factor X' appears to be both the same as human nature the 'essence' of our humanity - and also that which makes humans entirely distinct from the rest of nature. Indeed, Fukuyama suggests that somewhere along the human evolutionary journey there occurred 'a very important qualitative, if not ontological, leap', that came to separate Man and Beast.
Fukuyama is right, I think, to assert the 'dual character' of human existence, of humans as both animal and yet more-than-animal. But he seems not to recognise what this means for the concept of human nature. If humans are qualitatively distinct from the rest of the natural world, then the human 'essence' cannot be simply rooted in nature.
What sets humans apart is not some mysterious Factor X hidden somewhere in our biology but rather our ability to act as conscious agents. Uniquely among organisms, humans are both objects of nature and subjects that can, to some extent at least, shape our own fate. We are biological beings, and under the purview of biological and physical laws. But we are also conscious beings with purpose and agency, traits the possession of which allow us to design ways of breaking the constraints of biological and physical laws.
It is only because humans are conscious agents that we possess moral values. As Fukuyama himself observes, 'Only human beings can formulate, debate, and modify abstract rules of justice'. This is why we should not 'confuse human politics with the social behaviour of any other species'.
Human values, in other words, are not fixed in our nature, but emerge from our capacity to transcend that nature. To a certain degree, Fukuyama recognises this. Violence, he suggests, 'may be natural to human beings'. But so, too, is 'the propensity to control and channel violence'. Humans are capable of 'reasoning about their situation' and of 'understanding the need to create rules and institutions that constrain violence'. Humans, therefore, possess the capacity to rise above their natural inclinations and, through the use of reason, to shape their values.
But if this is so, then no amount of biotechnological intervention will transform our fundamental values. What may transform them, however, is the kind of pessimism that Fukuyama expresses in his End of Human Nature thesis.
Fukuyama rightly worries about the 'medicalisation of society' - the inclination tendency to view personal, social and political problems in biological or medical terms. In part, at least, this arises from the growing tendency of our age to view humans as weak-willed, sick or damaged, as victims lacking the capacity to transcend their situation, either individually or collectively. Biotechnology, Fukuyama believes, can only entrench such perceptions, making it easier for individuals who 'would like to absolve themselves of responsibility for their actions.'
But Fukuyama's own belief that values are embedded in our biology, and should be ring-fenced for protection, can only exacerbate this problem. If our values were simply evolved adaptations, then the notion of moral responsibility would indeed appear to be fragile. And what would then be wrong with popping a pill or performing a bit of genetic surgery to improve our moral condition?
The real debate is not about whether biotechnology will undermine our values, but about the kind of values to which we aspire. Do we want a human-centred morality rooted in concrete human needs (such as for solutions to brain disorders and genetic illnesses like Alzheimer's, Parkinson's and cystic fibrosis)? Or are we happy with a moral code that undermines the promise of medical advance in the name of a mythical human nature?
For Fukuyama 'There are good prudential reasons to defer to the natural order of things and not to think that human beings can easily improve upon it through casual intervention'. But why should the 'natural order of things' be better than human creation? After all, we only need medicine because nature has left us with jerry-built bodies that tend constantly to break down with headaches and backaches, cancers and coronaries, schizophrenia and depression.
'If the artificial is not better than that natural', John Stuart Mill once asked, 'to what end are all the arts of life?' 'It's unnatural' has always been the cry of those who seek to obstruct progress and restrain 'the arts of life'. It's an argument no more valid in response to biotechnology than it was in response to vaccination, heart transplants or IVF treatment. The 'duty of man', as Mill put it, 'is the same in respect to his own nature as in respect to the nature of other things, namely not to follow but to amend it.'
More here:
Kenan Malik's review of Our Posthuman Future by Francis ...
- The Surprisingly Long History of Auto-Tune, the Vocal-Processing ... - Open Culture - December 3rd, 2023 [December 3rd, 2023]
- Drowning in Potential The Guardsman - The Guardsman Online - December 3rd, 2023 [December 3rd, 2023]
- Portraits of the Posthuman: Jon Rafman and AI | Berlin Art Link - December 26th, 2022 [December 26th, 2022]
- 7 Bio-Artists Who Are Transforming the Fabric of Life Itself - Gizmodo - December 23rd, 2022 [December 23rd, 2022]
- Book giveaway for Posthuman by M.C. Hansen Nov 14-Nov 30, 2022 - December 14th, 2022 [December 14th, 2022]
- Metahuman - Wikipedia - November 23rd, 2022 [November 23rd, 2022]
- More Posthuman Glossary | BibSonomy - November 23rd, 2022 [November 23rd, 2022]
- Paul Shapera Continues The Story Of The Fictional City New Albion In His Latest Concept Album, 'Jill's Psychedelic Sunday' - Broadway World - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- Sacred Nature Review: Back to the Garden - The Wall Street Journal - September 20th, 2022 [September 20th, 2022]
- Harm's Way (band) - Wikipedia - August 23rd, 2022 [August 23rd, 2022]
- Timothy Alberino - Author, Explorer, Filmmaker - August 23rd, 2022 [August 23rd, 2022]
- The Writing Seminars | Princeton Writing Program - August 23rd, 2022 [August 23rd, 2022]
- Five Brilliant Books of Aussie Spec Fic - tor.com - August 23rd, 2022 [August 23rd, 2022]
- The Best Electronic Music on Bandcamp: July 2022 - bandcamp.com - July 27th, 2022 [July 27th, 2022]
- Post-Human NarrativesIn the Name of Scientific Witchery - Announcements - E-Flux - July 27th, 2022 [July 27th, 2022]
- Transhumanism: Savior of humanity or false prophecy? - Big Think - July 27th, 2022 [July 27th, 2022]
- Physicist: Why the Alien Simulation Hypothesis Is Bunk - Discovery Institute - July 13th, 2022 [July 13th, 2022]
- More than 120 titles are coming to Prime Video today (July 1) - Amazon Adviser - July 4th, 2022 [July 4th, 2022]
- Ad agency news you need to know July 1, 2022 - AdAge.com - July 4th, 2022 [July 4th, 2022]
- 'Proof' We're Living In A Computer Simulation, According To TikTok And Elon Musk - YourTango - May 23rd, 2022 [May 23rd, 2022]
- Stranger Things to Obi-Wan Kenobi: the seven best shows to stream this week - The Guardian - May 20th, 2022 [May 20th, 2022]
- 'Ghost in the Shell: SAC_2045 Sustainable War' Ending Explained: Is Togusa compromised? - MEAWW - May 15th, 2022 [May 15th, 2022]
- 'A Baby at Any Cost' on Lifetime: 5 things you didn't know about Sarah Fisher - MEAWW - May 15th, 2022 [May 15th, 2022]
- The Biggest Asian-wide Mobile Game Developer DINO GAME Released A New Version of the Sci-Fi Action-RPG Punishing: Gray Raven - Digital Journal - April 15th, 2022 [April 15th, 2022]
- Sorry Grimes, Your Ex-Boyfriend Won't Save Us - Jacobin magazine - April 11th, 2022 [April 11th, 2022]
- Mapping Memory in the Wake of the Posthuman: India and ... - March 17th, 2022 [March 17th, 2022]
- The rise of robot dogs - Domus - March 15th, 2022 [March 15th, 2022]
- Simulation hypothesis - Wikipedia - March 11th, 2022 [March 11th, 2022]
- Neocolonialism, a History of Death and Richterian Melancholia: the Best Arts and Culture this February - ArtReview - February 5th, 2022 [February 5th, 2022]
- Transcendent (novel) - Wikipedia - January 19th, 2022 [January 19th, 2022]
- A Biohacker Implanted 50 Chips in Their Body to Become ... - January 7th, 2022 [January 7th, 2022]
- Posthuman Ensemble - Announcements - e-flux - December 22nd, 2021 [December 22nd, 2021]
- Stream another new Arca album, KiCK iiii - Treble - Treble - December 3rd, 2021 [December 3rd, 2021]
- The Public Theology of Noreen Herzfeld | Public Theology and Technology - Patheos - December 3rd, 2021 [December 3rd, 2021]
- The War Over Life, Liberty And Privacy Rights: From Abortion To COVID-19 And Beyond OpEd - Eurasia Review - December 3rd, 2021 [December 3rd, 2021]
- The sci-fi thriller on Amazon Prime Video with a big twist at the end - CNET - November 28th, 2021 [November 28th, 2021]
- The Posthuman Dog | MetaFilter - November 23rd, 2021 [November 23rd, 2021]
- Who could dogs become without humans in their lives ... - November 21st, 2021 [November 21st, 2021]
- Into the Metaverse | Samuel D. James - First Things - November 19th, 2021 [November 19th, 2021]
- Why dogs might actually be better off without humans - New York Post - October 26th, 2021 [October 26th, 2021]
- Trees Speak fuse krautrock with post-punk on Vertigo of Flaws - The Vinyl Factory - October 26th, 2021 [October 26th, 2021]
- The vinyl straw: Why the vinyl industry is at breaking point - Mixmag - October 26th, 2021 [October 26th, 2021]
- Apocalypse Yesterday: The Graphic Novel in the Anthropocene (Wednesday, 3rd November 2021) City, University of London - City, University of London - October 21st, 2021 [October 21st, 2021]
- You can only appreciate art when you're not worried about putting food on your plate: Abhay Deol - Times of India - October 3rd, 2021 [October 3rd, 2021]
- Conceptions of God - Wikipedia - September 29th, 2021 [September 29th, 2021]
- Anthropogenic transitions from forested to human-dominated landscapes in southern Macaronesia - pnas.org - September 29th, 2021 [September 29th, 2021]
- AWAY: The Survival Series Glides Onto PC and Console Today - GLYFE Nation - September 29th, 2021 [September 29th, 2021]
- Physicist's Kickstarter To Test Whether We Are Living In A Simulation Raises $236000 - IFLScience - September 16th, 2021 [September 16th, 2021]
- Bring Me the Horizon Wins Grand Prize at Heavy Music Awards 2021 | Music - Pennsylvanianewstoday.com - September 10th, 2021 [September 10th, 2021]
- AI Art: Kolkata Exhibition to Showcase Artworks Created With Assistance of Artificial Intelligence - Gadgets 360 - September 10th, 2021 [September 10th, 2021]
- Mayuri, or The New Human Chelsea Theatre, London - The Reviews Hub - August 14th, 2021 [August 14th, 2021]
- Story-based sugar glider adventure AWAY: The Survival Series is coming to PlayStation 5 in late Summer - - Mygamer.com - July 16th, 2021 [July 16th, 2021]
- Beyond Integralism and Progressivism | Michael Hanby - First Things - July 14th, 2021 [July 14th, 2021]
- Are Clothes Made From Mushrooms, Bacteria And Yeast The Way Forward For Fashion? - ELLE India - July 12th, 2021 [July 12th, 2021]
- Ian Volner on the 17th Venice Architecture Biennale - Artforum - June 28th, 2021 [June 28th, 2021]
- Posthumanist Criticism Literary Theory and Criticism - June 20th, 2021 [June 20th, 2021]
- Citizen Sleeper is a dystopian slice-of-life RPG on a space station - Rock Paper Shotgun - June 15th, 2021 [June 15th, 2021]
- Trees Speak prep 'PostHuman' watch the trippy Elements of Matter video - Brooklyn Vegan - May 20th, 2021 [May 20th, 2021]
- Splatoon 3 release date, trailer, news, and what we want to see - Texasnewstoday.com - May 20th, 2021 [May 20th, 2021]
- Point of Contact Gallery Announces the Opening of 'Carrying the Thick Present: Fabulation,' Syracuse University's 2021 M.F.A. Thesis Exhibition -... - March 31st, 2021 [March 31st, 2021]
- Posthuman | Tardis | Fandom - March 21st, 2021 [March 21st, 2021]
- Are We or Arent We? - National Review - March 21st, 2021 [March 21st, 2021]
- Connections and inspirations between science fiction, tech, and games - VentureBeat - March 3rd, 2021 [March 3rd, 2021]
- Has 2020 really been real? Or are we all living in a computer simulation? - Daily Maverick - November 15th, 2020 [November 15th, 2020]
- Futureshock: Herbie Hancock and the Body Politics of Pop - PopMatters - November 15th, 2020 [November 15th, 2020]
- Bring Me The Horizons Oli Sykes: Yungblud is a new breed of rockstar - NME.com - September 7th, 2020 [September 7th, 2020]
- Caitlin Cherry on digital abstraction and Black femininity - Artforum - July 21st, 2020 [July 21st, 2020]
- Posthuman | Discography | Discogs - June 15th, 2020 [June 15th, 2020]
- Posthuman | Transhumanism Wiki | Fandom - June 15th, 2020 [June 15th, 2020]
- posthuman | The Chicago School of Media Theory - June 15th, 2020 [June 15th, 2020]
- Noourbanographies of the Information Age: Your Real Estate Interior - ArchDaily - May 4th, 2020 [May 4th, 2020]
- We Are Probably Living in a Simulation, Here's What You Need to Know About Simulation Theory - Interesting Engineering - April 21st, 2020 [April 21st, 2020]
- ICYMI: A wrap of the week's arts news - ArtsHub - February 28th, 2020 [February 28th, 2020]
- FAITH AND VALUES: Where does the buck stop? - Aiken Standard - January 26th, 2020 [January 26th, 2020]
- Architecture professor invents wearable garden - Daily Trojan Online - January 18th, 2020 [January 18th, 2020]
- Best of 2019: Harm's Way Pick 5 Favorite Albums of Year - Revolver Magazine - December 25th, 2019 [December 25th, 2019]
- Moscows Garage Museum Starts Pioneering Online Art Venueand Its More Than a Museum on the Internet - ARTnews - December 13th, 2019 [December 13th, 2019]
- 'The Expanse' Season 4 Review: Hard science, biological conflicts laced with emotions and action makes space d - MEAWW - December 13th, 2019 [December 13th, 2019]
- David Blandy and a Cadre of Essex Gamers Introduce us to a World After Homo Sapiens - frieze.com - November 30th, 2019 [November 30th, 2019]
- Ethics, Truth and Post-Truth: Political and social implications - Modern Diplomacy - November 30th, 2019 [November 30th, 2019]