Strive Asset Management and Engine No. 1 are firms on opposite ends of the environmental, social, and governance spectrum that have attracted more attention than assets. Both firms offer index-tracking funds that focus on voting decisions to allow fund investors to express their preferences on governance and sustainability matters. Now that both have voting records sizable enough to bear examination, this is a good opportunity to look at the signals the two firms voting decisions are sending.
Both Engine No. 1 and Strive are in the middle of strategic changes. Engine No. 1 sold its ETF business to TCW and announced its renewed focus on private investments; Strive announced it would reduce its anti-woke rhetoric in light of its message being misunderstood by investors. All the same, the firms proxy voting records shine a light on the importance of manager due diligence, even when selecting an otherwise plain-vanilla index fund.
For resolutions filed at S&P 100 companies in the 2023 proxy year (that is, the 12 months to June 30), we analyzed how Strive and Engine No. 1 voted on:
We compared Strive and Engine No. 1s decisions with those of the Big Three index managers (Vanguard, BlackRock, and State Street) for context.
Both Engine No. 1 and Strive offer exchange-traded funds that track broad market indexes. These funds dont apply any ESG criteriafor or againstin their portfolio construction; rather, they advocate for investor values through proxy voting and engagement. Both firms have also made big names for themselves despite relatively small asset bases: As of August 2023, Engine No. 1s three funds claimed $681 million, and Strives nine equity funds totaled $921 million. The exhibit below shows assets in each firms largest U.S. equity index-tracking fund for comparison.
With just over $500 million in assets, Engine No. 1 Transform 500 ETF VOTE seeks to use voting decisions to strategically hold companies and leadership teams accountable while focusing on sustainability issues that create value, while actively [working] with companies to strengthen the investments they make in stakeholders to drive company performance.
The Strive 500 ETF STRV, launched only in September 2022, has $268 million in assets and takes the opposite view of Engine No. 1 when it comes to voting. The firms ethos is to always prioritize the shareholder over other stakeholders by rejecting what they perceive is a tendency for large asset managers to [incorporate] non-pecuniary factors under the guise of considering environmental, social, and governance risk factors.
Of course, those large asset managers assert that they have always prioritized shareholder value and continue to do so. And they certainly are large. As shown in the exhibit, the Big Threes U.S. equity market tracker ETFsBlackRocks iShares Core S&P 500 ETF IVV, State Streets SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust SPY, and the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF VOOare around 1000 times the size of those from the two activist firms, with $300 billion-$400 billion in assets each.
So how did each firm vote?
There were 222 pro-environmental and social shareholder proposals that went to a vote at S&P 100 companies during the 2023 proxy year. Just 67 of those resolutions received more than 30% support from independent shareholders. Calculating support from independent shareholders excludes votes cast by company insiders who are unlikely to support shareholder resolutions, such as founders, directors and executives, and strategic investors. We also call this adjusted support.
Average adjusted support for the 67 resolutions stood at 40%. Engine No. 1 supported all but one of these resolutions, abstaining on one proposal directed at abortion-related privacy measures at Meta Platforms META. Unsurprisingly, Strive voted against 100% of the pro-ESG resolutions on which it voted.
Support from the Big Three ranged from 4.5% from Vanguard at the low end, to 45% from State Street at the high end. In the case of both Vanguard and BlackRock, these levels of support represent notable drops from past years. Both firms insist that the resolutions coming to vote in 2023 were of lower quality compared with previous years. On the other hand, State Streets support for key ESG resolutions in 2023 is roughly in line with recent years.
In the proxy year ended June 2023, the best-supported ESG resolution (with 66% adjusted support) came from the New York State Common Retirement Fund, which requested a report describing Teslas TSLA efforts to prevent harassment and discrimination against protected classes of employees. This proposal followed a federal courts ruling against Tesla based on a culture of racism. BlackRock, State Street, and Engine No. 1 voted for this proposal; Strive and Vanguard voted against.
Shareholder resolutions by anti-ESG proponents have ramped up in recent years. Forty-seven such resolutions addressing environmental and social themes went to a vote at S&P 100 companies in 2023. Support for these resolutions remained quite low, averaging just 3% adjusted.
As expected, Engine No. 1, Vanguard, and BlackRock voted against all 47 of these resolutions. Strive, on the other hand, supported 30 of these proposals (64%), voted against 10 (21%), and abstained on seven (15%).
The best-supported resolution in this category was filed at Ford Motor Company F by the National Center for Public Policy Research. With 16% adjusted support, the proposal requested an audit of child labor risks in Fords electric vehicle supply chain. To clarify, many so-called anti-ESG shareholder proposals use various tactics to get on the ballot, many of which resemble pro-ESG proposals. However, they are usually submitted by groups that oppose the work of sustainability-minded investors. You can read more about it here. State Street abstained on this resolution and did not provide a rationale. Both Engine No. 1 and Strive voted against this proposal. According to Strive, Ford was already addressing the outlined issues.
Strive broke away from the crowd when it came to backing the CEOs of S&P 100 companies. Typically, investors support CEOs. In the 2023 proxy season, 94 CEOs were up for election or reelection at the largest companies. These proposals received more than 95% adjusted support on average. As expected, the Big Three voted in support of all S&P 100 CEOs up for reelection.
However, Strive withheld support from 60 of the 92 such proposals it voted on, backing only 32.
Voting against the CEOs would likely prompt a board to consider a change in leadership; it would also be an unconventional and somewhat unprecedented approach to address dissatisfaction with company management.
Engine No. 1 only voted against one CEO: Michael Sievert at T-Mobile TMUS. Sievert was the second-worst supported CEO on the list, only trailed by Safra Catz at Oracle ORCL. Here, Engine No. 1 and Strive agreed: Both voted in support of Catz.
By and large, the activists voted as one would expect given their stated objectives. Investors looking to support pro-environmental and social initiatives would likely be satisfied with Engine No. 1s voting decisions; likewise, investors seeking an anti-ESG voting strategy might find a fit with Strive. On the other hand, the Big Three matched up on anti-ESG proposals and CEO reelections, but broke ranks when it came to pro-ESG resolutions. For investors wishing to take a stance on environmental and social issues, these results underscore the importance of manager due diligence when choosing between otherwise similar index-tracking funds.
For more on the 2023 proxy season, see our preview here.
For more on anti-ESG funds, see our report here.
Continue reading here:
Strive Asset Management vs. Engine No. 1: How Did the Activists ... - Morningstar
- 7 Reasons to Retire and Relocate When Savings Fall Short ... - ThinkAdvisor - October 9th, 2023 [October 9th, 2023]
- New Taskforce to build UK nuclear skills - GOV.UK - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- National Bank of Canada FI Has $16.22 Million Position in ... - Defense World - June 26th, 2023 [June 26th, 2023]
- RIT part of National Science Foundation grant to help spur next ... - Rochester Institute of Technology - May 22nd, 2023 [May 22nd, 2023]
- 2023 NAIA Outdoor Track & Field Regional Awards - U.S. Track & Field and Cross Country Coaches Association - May 22nd, 2023 [May 22nd, 2023]
- P&I wins ASBPE national gold award for managers microsite - Pensions & Investments - May 22nd, 2023 [May 22nd, 2023]
- The National - January 30th, 2023 [January 30th, 2023]
- Dimon Highlights Need For More Oil And Gas Investment As Vanguard Bails On ESG Group - Forbes - December 16th, 2022 [December 16th, 2022]
- About Us | National Vanguard - November 19th, 2022 [November 19th, 2022]
- Vanguard News Network - October 11th, 2022 [October 11th, 2022]
- Retirement Clearinghouse Announces Auto-Portability Network with Fidelity, Vanguard and Alight | PLANSPONSOR - PLANSPONSOR - October 11th, 2022 [October 11th, 2022]
- Abenaa Jones named Ann Atherton Hertzler Early Career Professor - Pennsylvania State University - August 6th, 2022 [August 6th, 2022]
- City of Detroit, Charles H. Wright Museum of African American History, join the Black Theatre Network (BTN) to host Broadway Comes Home to Detroit, a... - July 25th, 2022 [July 25th, 2022]
- California Senate Votes to Keep Legalized Slavery in its Prisons - The Peoples Vanguard of Davis - June 29th, 2022 [June 29th, 2022]
- Schneider National (NYSE:SNDR) Now Covered by Analysts at Credit Suisse Group - Defense World - June 29th, 2022 [June 29th, 2022]
- Introducing the Truckstop.com Partner Marketplace: A Comprehensive Transportation and Logistics Ecosystem Empowering the Freight Community - Yahoo... - June 29th, 2022 [June 29th, 2022]
- A Pilgrimage to the Birthplace of the Modern Womens Rights Movement - AFAR Media - June 29th, 2022 [June 29th, 2022]
- White Child Adopted by Black Reality TV Star Beaten to Death - June 24th, 2022 [June 24th, 2022]
- National Car Rental - Wikipedia - June 24th, 2022 [June 24th, 2022]
- Down 15% in 2022, is it time to jump on Vanguard Australian Shares Index ETF? - The Motley Fool Australia - June 24th, 2022 [June 24th, 2022]
- LIVE BLOG: 2022 Corps at the Crest - San Diego - FloMarching - June 24th, 2022 [June 24th, 2022]
- Greater Sacramento Attends Bio International Convention in San Diego - The Peoples Vanguard of Davis - June 22nd, 2022 [June 22nd, 2022]
- Vanguard International Semiconductor : VIS and National Yang Ming Chiao Tung University Cofound Intelligent Manufacturing and Management Laboratory -... - June 22nd, 2022 [June 22nd, 2022]
- The Shadow Of June 12 - The Left and Nigeria's Democratic Revolution, By Baba Aye - SaharaReporters.com - June 22nd, 2022 [June 22nd, 2022]
- Yolo County Honors Juneteenth with Celebration - The Peoples Vanguard of Davis - June 22nd, 2022 [June 22nd, 2022]
- Commentary: Why San Francisco May Not Be the Best Test Case for Progressivism - The Peoples Vanguard of Davis - June 22nd, 2022 [June 22nd, 2022]
- As tennis fans gather Wimbledon worries expansion won't get over the line - The National - June 22nd, 2022 [June 22nd, 2022]
- Vanguard Charitable survey: More than 1 in 3 American donors gave half or more of their charitable contributions to disaster relief efforts in the... - May 20th, 2022 [May 20th, 2022]
- National Grid warns on cost-of-living challenges after strong profit (NYSE:NGG) - Seeking Alpha - May 20th, 2022 [May 20th, 2022]
- Is it a good time to buy the Vanguard Australian Shares Index ETF? - The Motley Fool Australia - May 20th, 2022 [May 20th, 2022]
- Student Opinion: The Biden Administration and Cable Companies Working Together to Bring Internet to Millions of Households - The Peoples Vanguard of... - May 20th, 2022 [May 20th, 2022]
- THE POWER OF LEADERSHIP - THISDAY Newspapers - May 20th, 2022 [May 20th, 2022]
- Vanguard may be shorting much vaunted 'owners' of its low-cost index funds as it upshifts to more Wall Street-style exec-comp tactics to thwart... - May 17th, 2022 [May 17th, 2022]
- Opinion | BlackRock, Vanguard and State Street Control a Piece of Nearly Everything - The New York Times - May 17th, 2022 [May 17th, 2022]
- Somalis receive explosive threat reduction training | Shephard - Shephard News - May 17th, 2022 [May 17th, 2022]
- JV Article: Platinum Group Metals is at the vanguard of next generation lithium-ion batteries - The Northern Miner - May 17th, 2022 [May 17th, 2022]
- Neo-Nazi Alex Davies guilty of belonging to banned terror group National Action - Tell MAMA - May 17th, 2022 [May 17th, 2022]
- Firearm-Related Homicides Reach an Unprecedented Level in the 21st Century - The Peoples Vanguard of Davis - May 17th, 2022 [May 17th, 2022]
- Satellites, the Space Race, and Supercomputing: How NASA Goddard's Beowulf Cluster Computer Became an Award-Winning Space Technology - NASA (.gov) - May 17th, 2022 [May 17th, 2022]
- Vanguard may be shorting much vaunted 'owners' of its low-cost index funds as it shifts to Wall Street-style exec-comp tactics to thwart competitors... - May 15th, 2022 [May 15th, 2022]
- Senate Democrats Fail to Codify Abortion Rights; Don't Have Votes to Overcome Filibuster Dem Manchin Votes with GOP - The Peoples Vanguard of Davis - May 15th, 2022 [May 15th, 2022]
- The School Buzz: Vanguard rocketry team competing for national title - KRDO - May 9th, 2022 [May 9th, 2022]
- The Anglo-Indian-Nigerian designer at the vanguard of British fashion - The National - May 9th, 2022 [May 9th, 2022]
- Candidate for Yolo County District Attorney Cynthia Rodriguez Announced Her Growing List of Endorsements in a Press Release on Thursday - The Peoples... - May 9th, 2022 [May 9th, 2022]
- Commentary: Trends Are Pushing Tech, Housing Toward Sacramento Region - The Peoples Vanguard of Davis - May 9th, 2022 [May 9th, 2022]
- UK Government announces 2 billion investment into nuclear submarines - The National - May 9th, 2022 [May 9th, 2022]
- Workers grapple with new stresses as they return to office - Tampa Bay Times - May 9th, 2022 [May 9th, 2022]
- Who is Ib Kamara, the new Off-White art director to fill Virgil Abloh's shoes? - The National - May 9th, 2022 [May 9th, 2022]
- Vanguard Lions Defeat Statesmen To End The Year - Victory Sports Network - April 15th, 2022 [April 15th, 2022]
- Other days - Arkansas Online - April 15th, 2022 [April 15th, 2022]
- Democrats are in danger of losing three congressional strongholds in South Texas - Standard-Times - April 15th, 2022 [April 15th, 2022]
- Remembering the WNBA's Portland Fire - Vanguard - Psuvanguard.com - April 13th, 2022 [April 13th, 2022]
- Honoring the life of Amara Marluke - Vanguard - Psuvanguard.com - April 13th, 2022 [April 13th, 2022]
- The grim outlook of owning and renting - Vanguard - Psuvanguard.com - April 13th, 2022 [April 13th, 2022]
- 2022 NAIA Women's Outdoor Track & Field Rating Index Week 3 - U.S. Track & Field and Cross Country Coaches Association - April 13th, 2022 [April 13th, 2022]
- ECOWAS and Nigeria Agree on a Roadmap to Institutionalise a Government and Society Wide Approach - African Business - March 17th, 2022 [March 17th, 2022]
- LA Treasurer joins other states in divesting Russian investments - KATC News - March 8th, 2022 [March 8th, 2022]
- How the US and Europe helped Ukraine prep for insurgency - ArmyTimes.com - March 8th, 2022 [March 8th, 2022]
- A Trailblazing Engineer Says Invention Is in Everything I Do - Tufts Now - March 8th, 2022 [March 8th, 2022]
- Russias Invasion of Ukraine and Implications for the Korean Peninsula - Council on Foreign Relations - March 8th, 2022 [March 8th, 2022]
- Vanguard University saying goodbye to the Pit - Los Angeles Times - January 14th, 2022 [January 14th, 2022]
- Energy Ended Up as a Good Bet Last Year. But Now What? - The New York Times - January 14th, 2022 [January 14th, 2022]
- Kensington Vanguard National Land Services - December 19th, 2021 [December 19th, 2021]
- Barry Harris, Pianist and Devoted Scholar of Bebop, Dies at 91 - The New York Times - December 10th, 2021 [December 10th, 2021]
- From Our Archives: a Profile of Bob Dole, Once the Senate's "Funniest Member" - Washingtonian - December 7th, 2021 [December 7th, 2021]
- National Auto Care on acquisition spree amid F&I consolidation - Automotive News - December 5th, 2021 [December 5th, 2021]
- A decade of marketisation has left lecturers with no choice but to strike - The Guardian - December 5th, 2021 [December 5th, 2021]
- A New Vanguard Is Reshaping the Art World - HarpersBAZAAR.com - December 5th, 2021 [December 5th, 2021]
- Opinion | The Trump Conspiracy Is Hiding in Plain Sight - The New York Times - December 5th, 2021 [December 5th, 2021]
- The forgotten importance of the War of Jenkins' Ear - The Economist - December 5th, 2021 [December 5th, 2021]
- What Conservative Critics of Higher Education Share - The Atlantic - December 5th, 2021 [December 5th, 2021]
- The Unite the Right trial is exposing the chasm between who plans White nationalism's battles and who does the fighting - ABC17News.com - November 19th, 2021 [November 19th, 2021]
- Tordue Salem: Journalists ask National Assembly to order independent inquiry into death of missing reporter - Premium Times - November 19th, 2021 [November 19th, 2021]
- Abu Dhabi to Welcome Two New Museums in Addition to Guggenheim and Zayed - Artforum - November 19th, 2021 [November 19th, 2021]
- Gauteng government at the vanguard of SAs green economy plans - Business Day - November 17th, 2021 [November 17th, 2021]
- 25 years of school and family connections | Hub - The Hub at Johns Hopkins - November 17th, 2021 [November 17th, 2021]
- Opinion: Organized crime is a top driver of global deforestation and climate change - Houston Chronicle - November 17th, 2021 [November 17th, 2021]
- Letters to the editor: Lend a hand to these family caregivers - Austin American-Statesman - November 15th, 2021 [November 15th, 2021]
- University of Chicago to award four honorary degrees at 2022 Convocation - UChicago News - November 9th, 2021 [November 9th, 2021]
- Review of Misfire by Tim Mak: How the Wheels Came Off at the NRA - The New Republic - November 9th, 2021 [November 9th, 2021]