By Paul Knoepfler By Paul Knoepfler February 2
Paul Knoepfler is a stem-cell biologist at the University of California at Davis and writes about innovative science at the Niche. His most recent book is GMO Sapiens: The Life-Changing Science of Designer Babies. You can watch his TED talk on that topic here and find him on Twitter: @pknoepfler.
A new study out of California unsettled a lot of people last week after revealing that scientists had, for the first time, made part-human, part-pig embryos referred to as chimeras. That should be expected: The debate over the technology is a mixed bag of difficult issues not unlike the fire-breathing hybrid Chimera from Greek mythology.
But on balance, the promise of this biotechnology should outweigh our fears and ethical questions. Chimeras could be a game-changer in terms of organ transplants in coming decades, and for that reason, scientists should carefully proceed with the research.
More than 100,000 people in the United States currently sit on organ waiting lists, struggling to stay alive long enough to get a new liver or kidney. With few realistic alternatives to the limited supply of cadaver-based transplants, about 22 Americans die each day. Hundreds more die daily at the global level.
[Eight questions to ask before human genetic engineering goes mainstream.]
Our recent renaissance of cutting-edge biotechnologies particularly based on the utilization of pluripotent stem cells gives real hope for these people in need of transplants. What exactly is a human chimera? Its a mixture of a small number of human cells within an otherwise predominantly animal embryo, such as a pig. The hope is that, if allowed to grow, a chimera embryo would develop entirely as animal except for one harvestable organ that is human. It might even be possible for that organ to be produced from the patients own stem cells, making it a perfect match.
In the past, other researchers have made similar chimeric embryos, mixing human stem cells with mouse cells. But a mouse-size kidney or liver even if made of human cells cannot help a human, because these organs would be about the size of a small kidney bean. Pigs, on the other hand, are relatively closer to humans on the evolutionary tree, perhaps bringing us a small step closer to actual clinical use.
Even so, theres a long road ahead. The California researchers found that many of the human-pig chimeric embryos did not grow properly. And even if organs in pig chimeras ended up 100 percent human at a cellular level, they are certain to contain other factors such as pig proteins that could spark a patient immune reaction leading to organ rejection. Still, every cutting-edge biomedical technology faces technical obstacles at first, and there is a good chance that researchers might overcome these hurdles in the future.
Its understandable if people imagined full-grown, human-pig creatures when reading about this new research. In reality, though, the chimeras produced were only embryos just tiny collections of cells. If the technology progresses further, chimeras would have to be taken to term or near-term before full-size organs could be harvested. Inevitably that means there may be large chimeras produced and photographed for the world to see; but remember, these animals wouldnt look any different from ordinary animals, because only a single organ would be human.
Animal rights advocates were quick to raise ethical questions: Should we allow chimeric pigs to be used as a biomedical incubator of sorts and then sacrificed to obtain a human organ? But this ignores the fact that people are eating billions of animals each year.
Tougher questions focus on the human side of chimeras and include the dilemma of what makes an animal a human in terms of cells. How many human cells within a chimera overall would make that chimera too close to a human being? How many human brain cells and in particular neurons in a human-pig chimera would be too many? What should we do if a human-pig chimera accidentally ended up with an abundance of human cells in its brain? What if a human-pig chimera made human sperm or eggs?
[Whats the difference between genetic engineering and eugenics?]
Fortunately, there are some simple technological answers to many of these questions. We could agree, for example, to prevent all chimeras from being born. We could also use animals that are sterile as the basis for making chimeras and closely monitor human cell numbers in chimeras (including in the brain) during early research studies. We could also ban organ production if human-cell levels consistently fall outside acceptable parameters.
Overall, though, the global shortage of organs for transplants is too urgent a problem to refuse to explore innovative solutions. We should pursue more human-chimera technology while from the start acknowledging and addressing the important bioethical considerations it faces. We should also carefully plan outreach efforts to the public as the technology advances.
Human chimeras not only have potential to address the organ shortage; they also could educate us about unexplored questions of human development. Groundbreaking biomedical technologies might be unnerving, but they have real potential to positively change our world.
Eight questions to ask before human genetic engineering goes mainstream
Whats the difference between genetic engineering and eugenics?
In defense of transhumanism
- Designer Babies: The Ethics of Human Genetic Engineering - May 27th, 2022
- Human genetic enhancement - Wikipedia - October 19th, 2021
- 16 Advantages and Disadvantages of Human Genetic Engineering - June 23rd, 2021
- Engineering Illusions Part I: Religion and Technology III - Medium - April 9th, 2021
- Genetic Engineering in Humans - Curing Diseases and ... - March 9th, 2020
- Human Genetic Engineering - AllAboutPopularIssues.org - March 9th, 2020
- Human Genetic Engineering Probe Ministries - March 9th, 2020
- Human Genetic Engineering Facts - August 14th, 2017
- The ethics of creating GMO humans | The Spokesman-Review - The Spokesman-Review - August 6th, 2017
- Human Genetic Engineering Cons - July 26th, 2017
- China unveils technology to create SUPER-HUMANS via hyper-muscular test-tube dogs - Express.co.uk - July 19th, 2017
- The Scopes Monkey Trial and global warming: Same playbook, different football - Baptist News Global - July 14th, 2017
- Science and Scientists on the Vineyard: Genes at play with CRISPR - Martha's Vineyard Times - June 17th, 2017
- Two Representatives Offer A Look At How Congress Is Doing - WNIJ and WNIU - June 16th, 2017
- 'Knights of Sidonia' is the Pinnacle of Gritty Mecha Anime - Inverse - June 12th, 2017
- Technosplit: The bifurcation of humanity - Salon - June 5th, 2017
- Breakthrough Regenerative Therapeutics Company Establishes Scientific Advisory Board - PR Newswire (press release) - May 4th, 2017
- Ethical Implications of Human Genetic Engineering | SAGE - April 19th, 2017
- Human Genetic Engineering on the Doorstep - hgalert.org - April 15th, 2017
- The Threat of Human Genetic Engineering - hgalert.org - April 12th, 2017
- Gene Editing Could Make You Smarter - Futurism - Futurism - March 1st, 2017
- Immoral Uses of Biotechnology Even With Good Intentions Are Evil - National Catholic Register - February 7th, 2017
- 5 Key Pros and Cons of Human Genetic Engineering | NLCATP.org - November 21st, 2016
- Gene therapy - Wikipedia - October 25th, 2016
- Human Genetic Engineering: A Guide for Activists, Skeptics ... - September 20th, 2016
- Human Genetic Engineering - The Future of Human Evolution - March 25th, 2016
- Human Genetic Engineering : History - December 22nd, 2015
- 00.03.07: Human Cloning, Genetic Engineering and Privacy - October 16th, 2015
- Online Debate: Human genetic engineering is a good thing ... - October 16th, 2015
- Bioethics Of Human Genetic Engineering - Documentary Video ... - September 30th, 2015
- Pros and Cons of Genetic Engineering in Humans - Part 1 - August 29th, 2015
- Genetic Engineering - humans, body, used, process, plants ... - August 27th, 2015
- Genetic Engineering In Humans - August 27th, 2015
- Human Nature on Collision Course with Genetic Engineering ... - August 27th, 2015
- Human Genetic Engineering Cons: Why This Branch of Science ... - August 19th, 2015
- Human Genetics Alert - Human Genetic Engineering resources - August 19th, 2015
- Genetic engineering - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - August 4th, 2015
- Benefits of Human Genetic Engineering - Popular Issues - August 4th, 2015
- Human Genetics - July 31st, 2015
- Human Genetic Engineering Pros And Cons - July 31st, 2015
- Gene therapy - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - July 28th, 2015
- Human Genetic Engineering - Popular Issues - July 28th, 2015
- Human Genetics Alert - The Threat of Human Genetic Engineering - July 28th, 2015
- Human Genetic Engineering - Popular Issues ... - February 16th, 2015
- Human Genetic Engineering - Buzzle - February 12th, 2015
- Pros and Cons of Genetic Engineering in Humans - February 12th, 2015
- Human Genetic Engineering History - February 12th, 2015
- Benefits of Human Genetic Engineering - Popular Issues ... - February 12th, 2015