People seldom eulogize the wisdom and virtues of their fathers, but to excuse some folly or wickedness of their own. ...America is false to the past, false to the present, and solemnly binds herself to be false to the future. There is not a nation on the earth guilty of practices, more shocking and bloody, than are the people of these United States. Frederick Douglass in "What To The Slave Is The Fourth Of July?"
During the most recent legislative session, Texas Republicans ostensibly theparty of small government usurped the role of the state's teachers and school boards in drafting social studies curricula. The bill they passed follows the lead of other state legislatures in targeting a bogeyman by the initials of CRT. If you haven't been following the debate, that stands forCritical Race Theory.
This allegedly pernicious ideology goes unmentioned in the text of the bill, which Gov. Greg Abbott signed into law on Wednesday. Even so, the legislation's author, State Rep. Steve Toth, R-The Woodlands, couldn't resist touting his handiwork as "a dagger shot right through the heart of Critical Race Theory."
Many of the conservative critics of this relatively obscure field of legal scholarship would no doubt flunk a remedial pop quiz on the subject. However, before we do some brushing up on what CRT actually is, let's survey the collateral damage wrought by House Bill 3979.
Decree #1: "A teacher may not make part of a course or award extra credit for efforts to persuade members of the legislative or executive branch at the federal, state, or local level to take specific actions by direct communication."
That means no more having students write a letter to the president or their congressperson about pressing issues of the day one of the standard assignments in basic civics courses. And no more extra credit for anything remotely resembling "political activism" or "participation in any internship or similar activity involving social or public policy advocacy." That means penning an op-ed for a local newspaper, volunteering to register voters, interning for an elected official, attending a town hall with Cornel Westor mustering up the courage to speak at a city council meeting can no longer earn a Texas student class credit. So much for fostering an engaged citizenry.
Decree #2: "A teacher may not make part of a course the concept that the advent of slavery constituted the true founding of the United States" or "that slavery and racism are anything other than deviations from, betrayals of, or failures to live up to, the authentic founding principles."
Not only does that seem to nix the famous speech quoted above from Frederick Douglass even though the bill specifically recommends his autobiography as essential reading it also effectively bans an important book by University of Houston history professor Gerald Horne titled The Counter-Revolution of 1776. In it, Horne shows that one of the catalysts for American independence was colonists' outrage and fear that Britain broached the possibility of forbidding chattel slavery outright something the country ultimately did three decades before us. The motivating power of slavery was even stronger in Texas' independence from Mexico, but that's another story.
Fact is, slavery was legal in all 13 colonies at the onset of the Revolutionary War. Whether you consider that a "deviation" or take it to be foundational to America's later prosperity,why is it the business of armchair historians in the state legislature, over objections from more than 70 civic groups and businesses across Texas, to censor the teaching of one side or the other in a partisan manner?
Similarly, the bill states: "The State Board of Education shall adopt essential knowledge and skills that develop each student's understanding of the fundamental moral, political, and intellectual foundations of the American experiment in self-government."
This leaves out historians who question whether we can best conceive of the founding as an "experiment in self-government" at all including Michael Klarman, a constitutional law professor at Harvard. In his book The Framers' Coup, Klarman debunks the romanticized image of our national user-agreement, contextualizing it as an elitist reaction to the burgeoning democractic zeitgeist of 1780s.
Indeed, many voices of the founders' generation may not even escape Texas' new curricular muzzle. Here's Rep. James Lincoln, speaking at the debate over whether South Carolina should ratify:"He had listened with eager attention to all the arguments in favor of the Constitution; but he solemnly declared that the more he heard, the more he was persuaded of its evil tendency. 'What does this proposed Constitution do? It changes, totally changes, the form of your present government. From a well-digested, well-formed democratic, you are at once rushing into an aristocratic government. What have you been contending for these 10 years past? Liberty! What is liberty? The power of governing yourselves. If you adopt this Constitution, have you this power? No: you give it into the hands of a set of men who live 1,000 miles distant from you. Let the people but once trust their liberties out of their own hands, and what will be the consequence? First, a haughty, imperious aristocracy; and ultimately, a tyrannical monarchy. ... It is said this Constitution is an experiment; but all physicians are cautious of experiments'."
Decree #3: "A teacher may not require an understanding of the 1619 Project."
Whatever one's opinion, the 1619 Project was a significant series of articles published in the New York Times Magazine, and the editor of the project won a Pulitzer Prize,both for her work in assembling a range of high-caliber authors as well as her own "distinguished commentary."
Agree or disagree with Nikole Hannah-Jones, as a journalist she's a role model for what students of any background should aspire to achieve through hard work, dedication and resolute character. But now this "groundbreaking look at the impact of slavery" can never be required reading in any of Texas' public or open-enrollment charter schools. To quote back the language of the bill, how does that "strive to explore the topic from diverse and contending perspectives without giving deference to any one perspective?"
Decree #4: "A teacher may not make part of a course the concept that an individual bears responsibility for actions committed in the past by other members of the same race."Imagine if a right-wing government in South Africa or Germany passed a malleable restriction like this regarding education about racial apartheid or atrocities during Word War II. In 1946, philosopher Karl Jaspers published The Question of German Guilt, evocatively arguing that an acknowledgment of national guilt was a necessary condition for the moral and political rebirth of Germany." Can we ever truly heal from our wounds as a country without admitting that racism remains a problem the white majority must honestly confront?
Decree #5: "A teacher may not make part of a course the concept that an individual should feel discomfort, guilt, anguish, or any other form of psychological distress on account of the individual's race."How, pray tell, can one study the dispossession and slaughter of Native Americans, the kidnapping and enslavement of Africans, the legacy of lynching and segregation and housing discrimination with which we're still living, the racial wealth gap, mass incarceration or the murder of an unarmed Black suspect in custody without feeling some measure of distress?
These injustices should break our hearts, and when teachers are allowed to teach, they can walk the line between letting kids know that while racism was not their idea, many of us are its inheritors and beneficiaries and therefore have a moral obligation to face uncomfortable truths. Being "colorblind," sadly, is not enough.
Decree #6: "A teacher may not make part of a course the concept that an individual should be discriminated against or receive adverse treatment solely or partly because of the individual's race.""Reverse discrimination" and "special treatment" are how Fox News pundits have recently spun COVID-19 relief aid to Black farmers, despite the fact that over the past century the Agriculture Department stole tens of billions of dollars from them thanks to actual racial discrimination. This edict ostensibly declares off limits any teacher-led discussion of affirmative action to redress past wrongs and that in itself is a wrong.
Decree #7: "Any employee of a state agency may not be required to engage in training, orientation, or therapy that presents any form of race or sex stereotyping or blame on the basis of race or sex."That's unfortunate, since Texas lawmakers could really use a session with renowned diversity educator Jane Elliott.
Decree #8: "A teacher may not make part of a course the concept that meritocracy is racist or was created by members of a particular race to oppress members of another race."To quote pro football coach Barry Switzer, "Some people are born on third base and go through life thinking they hit a triple." The myth that every individual's share of success perfectly matches their talent can cover up unearned white privilege, recycling status into "merit." At the very least, it's worth considering as an idea, but it's now verboten.
Decree #9: "A teacher may not make part of a course the concept that an individual is inherently racist or oppressive, whether consciously or unconsciously."
This tosses the entire study of "unconscious racial bias" out the window along with this 1987 Stanford Law Review essayby professor Charles Lawrence III:Americans share a common historical and cultural heritage in which racism has played and still plays a dominant role. Because of this shared experience, we also inevitably share many ideas, attitudes, and beliefs that attach significance to an individuals race and induce negative feelings and opinions about nonwhites. At the same time, most of us are unaware of our racism. We do not recognize the ways in which our cultural experience has influenced our beliefs about race or the occasions on which those beliefs affect our actions. In other words, a large part of the behavior that produces racial discrimination is influenced by unconscious racial motivation."
And that brings us back to the bogeyman.
Spawned by Harvard Law professor Derrick Bell in the late 1970s, Critical Race Theory was an attempt to grapple with the exasperating persistence of racism in American law and life after the hard-won concessions of the Civil Rights era. Legal scholars such as Ricard Delgado, Patricia Williams, Cheryl Harris and Kimberl Crenshaw created an array of concepts the empathic fallacy, microaggression, intersectionality, whiteness to help explain how seemingly neutral institutions are implicated in the continuing subordination of people of color.
CRT is not "state-sanctioned racism," it's not "an excuse for giving up," it doesn't "pit our children against each other" or "teach hate." One of its vital contributions has been refreshing reinterpretations of American history through exhaustive archival work, as conducted by international relations theory expert Mary Dudziak in her must-read article "Desegregation as a Cold War Imperative". Though most of the recent scaremongering has had little to do with CRT as an academic discipline, it's fair to say CRT has inspired anti-racist activists from all walks of life, including many in the Black Lives Matter movement.
And perhaps that's where Texas lawmakers were really aiming their dagger. Like naming a high school after the commander of the Confederate Armyin response to integration, we had to expect blowback from the tens of millions of Americans who marched against police brutality and systemic racism last summer.
Ironic, though, that the Legislature's decrees were signed into law around the same time Juneteenth became a federal holiday. Apparently, in the culture war over symbolic gestures, substantive education got left behind.
Stay on top of San Antonio news and views. Sign up for our Weekly Headlines Newsletter.
Read this article:
- A Treasure Trove of Midcentury Modern Architecture - Hyperallergic - December 3rd, 2021
- Steely Dan, The CIA and the acid anthem of Kid Charlemagne - Far Out Magazine - December 3rd, 2021
- Liquid Reality at MoMA Explores the Intersections of Shigeko Kubota - Observer - December 3rd, 2021
- Is communal living the future of parenting? - The Guardian - December 3rd, 2021
- Will Twitter's CEO succession speed up a needed wave of innovation? - Marketing Dive - December 3rd, 2021
- The Making of IDMAN - vmagazine.com - December 3rd, 2021
- Does it Hold Up? Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex - Anime News Network - November 28th, 2021
- Dubai Watch Week 2021 - Of Watches and Men (and Women!) - Dubai Watch Week - WorldTempus - November 28th, 2021
- Must Read: How Von Dutch Spurred the Rise of Influencer Culture, Revolve Launches Ambassador Program - Yahoo Lifestyle - November 19th, 2021
- Meet the Costume Designers of 'Sing 2' - The New York Times - November 19th, 2021
- The Rise of Indias Cancel Culture - Gulf News - November 19th, 2021
- The Nutmegs Curse review: Listening to natures voice - The Hindu - October 24th, 2021
- CNBC Transcript: Robinhood Co-Founder and CEO Vlad Tenev Speaks with CNBCs Jim Cramer Live During the CNBC Disruptor 50 Summit Today - CNBC - October 24th, 2021
- International Artists Day 2021: Celebrate occasion ..earning about these legendary painters of 20th Century - Firstpost - October 24th, 2021
- The Art of No Longer Being Cool: How to Survive Your 30s - gearpatrol.com - October 24th, 2021
- Westman artists helping others craft their creative voice - Brandon Sun - October 24th, 2021
- Taliban-Controlled Afghanistan Will Further Radicalize Pakistan - Fair Observer - October 24th, 2021
- The Middle East is unfriending Facebook - The National - October 21st, 2021
- Writing Through the Moment - Vulture - October 21st, 2021
- TV Talk: '4400' is the latest in TV's remake/reboot trend - TribLIVE - October 21st, 2021
- Swedes Along the Mississippi - Lavender Magazine - October 21st, 2021
- Halloween Kills Star Judy Greer: People Love New Series Because of Its Zeitgeist-y Themes - IndieWire - October 17th, 2021
- Barr-Melej examines Chile's path amid violent upheavals of the 'Global 1968' - Ohio University - October 17th, 2021
- Lowe - Lakers? Warriors? Nets? Ranking the top 10 most fun NBA teams to watch this season - ESPN - October 17th, 2021
- 'Jesus Christ Superstar' In Its 50th Anniversary Tour Is a Brash and Unrelenting Take on the Rock Opera - SFist - October 17th, 2021
- A Jan. 6 blood flag and a Bond villain in the Senate its no time to go back to brunch | Will Bunch - The Philadelphia Inquirer - October 17th, 2021
- From Patti Smith to Blondie: The 10 greatest albums of the CBGB punk movement - Far Out Magazine - October 17th, 2021
- What's Next After the Supreme Court Reverses 'Roe'? Attack of the Egg People #ABLC - Rewire.News - October 17th, 2021
- Bernie On Missouri Football: Coach Eli Drinkwitz, Hype, Hope, Impatience, And Overreaction. - Scoopswithdannymac.com - Scoops with Danny Mac - October 17th, 2021
- How anti-BDS laws paved the way for the assault on critical race theory - +972 Magazine - October 17th, 2021
- Shirley Manson: At what point as a culture are we going to value things of depth? - HeraldScotland - October 17th, 2021
- Fall Guys have been inspired to revisit unused minigames thanks to the Squid game - Gaming News - BollyInside - October 17th, 2021
- We Need to Talk About Sally Rooney. Or Do We? - The University Times - October 17th, 2021
- ESG Investing what is it, and how does it impact your portfolio? - Proactive Investors UK - October 11th, 2021
- How The Cardigans ended up in two of the biggest movies of the 1990s - Far Out Magazine - October 9th, 2021
- A perilous week for the Government as the real war begins - Stuff.co.nz - October 9th, 2021
- VC INTERVIEW | Co-Artistic Directors Antje Weithass & Oliver Wille on the New Joseph Joachim Competition - The Violin Channel - October 9th, 2021
- ESG Investing what is it, and how does it impact your portfolio? - Proactive Investors Australia - October 9th, 2021
- Food trends 2021: where to find the globe's most-talked about dishes in Dubai - Time Out Dubai - October 9th, 2021
- Spring 2022 Accessories Market: The Greatest Hits WWD - WWD - October 7th, 2021
- Cory Henry Returns To Touring With 'Best Of Me' Celebration At Gold-Diggers In Los Angeles [Photos/Videos] - Live for Live Music - October 7th, 2021
- Features | Spool's Out | Spool's Out: Cassette Reviews For October By Daryl Worthington - The Quietus - October 7th, 2021
- 17 free books to download on Kindle and Apple Books right now - CNET - October 7th, 2021
- Cycle syncing your workouts could benefit your body and mood - harpersbazaar.com - October 3rd, 2021
- New moon-shaped casino announced for Vegas, but for space themed fun Disney is a better bet - Orlando Weekly - October 3rd, 2021
- All The Y2K Beauty Details From The Coperni Show In Paris - Grazia - October 3rd, 2021
- An Immersive Art And Entertainment Attraction Highlighting The Bizarre, Mysterious And Often Hilarious Nature Of Consumer Culture Thrives During Covid... - October 3rd, 2021
- NY Times cluelessness is wrecking journalism | Will Bunch Newsletter - The Philadelphia Inquirer - October 3rd, 2021
- On the trail of the CBGB: What remains of the New York punk scene? - Far Out Magazine - October 3rd, 2021
- The most successful companies infuse their business with design. Now they need to think bigger - Fast Company - September 17th, 2021
- 'Excess Ain't Rebellion': How Cake Has Made Moderation Sound Fun For the Past 30 Years - Billboard - September 17th, 2021
- The Impossibility of Equity - ArchDaily - September 17th, 2021
- Podcast: Unraveling the QAnon Conspiracy Theory - PsychCentral.com - September 17th, 2021
- To infect and serve: The cop vaccine crisis | Will Bunch Newsletter - The Philadelphia Inquirer - September 17th, 2021
- The Future Is Divergent: On Literary Afrofuturism in the Twenty-First Century - lareviewofbooks - September 17th, 2021
- The yumminess of paint - Spectator.co.uk - September 17th, 2021
- How the hell did we get here? - Bloody Elbow - September 17th, 2021
- Some early crypto enthusiasts have bailed on the sector, saying the movement has bought into hype without unde - Business Insider India - September 12th, 2021
- Today's World An Unhappy Replacement For The One Of Pre-9/11 OpEd Eurasia Review - Eurasia Review - September 12th, 2021
- ABBAs perky pop may be what the world needs - The Times of India Blog - September 12th, 2021
- The Meaning Of Kawaii - Kotaku - September 10th, 2021
- 20 Years After the September 11th Attacks, What Does Never Forget Mean? - Hyperallergic - September 10th, 2021
- Records That Changed Our Lives: Julianne Escobedo Shepherd On Salt-N-Pepa - NPR - September 10th, 2021
- Tank Must: When the Iconic Cartier Tank Gets a Revamp - Prestige Online - September 10th, 2021
- Legends of the fall: the 50 biggest books of autumn 2021 | Books - The Guardian - September 10th, 2021
- The Mercury Prize 2021 - From Arlo to Alice - The Louder Than War Guide - Louder Than War - September 10th, 2021
- The early song David Bowie thought was better than Space Oddity - Far Out Magazine - September 2nd, 2021
- Iron Maiden's Bruce Dickinson talks surviving cancer and COVID: 'Medical technology worked really well for me' - Yahoo Canada Sports - September 2nd, 2021
- The Imperfect Legacy of Romeo Must Die - Vulture - August 28th, 2021
- Voices of the future: Focalistic to Polo G - GQ South Africa - August 28th, 2021
- Lorde and Nicole Kidman Take on the Cult-ish Wellness Industry - The Daily Beast - August 28th, 2021
- Broadway in 2021 will 'have so many Black voices.' Theatergoers, pros say it's about time - NorthJersey.com - August 28th, 2021
- The Card Counter: Paul Schrader on the Ways Scorsese and Taxi Driver Informed New Gambling Drama - IndieWire - August 28th, 2021
- Kalyan Singh was a product of, and contributed to, change in the BJPs politics, with all its tumult and contradictions - The Indian Express - August 28th, 2021
- FKK: Is Germany falling out of love with nudism? - The Local Germany - August 14th, 2021
- The ever-growing crises that are displacing migrants from their homes - The European Sting - August 14th, 2021
- The long road to gender equality at the Olympics - Aviation Analysis Wing - August 14th, 2021
- Our Town: Five writers in search of a story - Opinions - The Island Now - June 28th, 2021
- Sport and entertainment talent "in conversation" with the IOC Refugee Olympic Team Tokyo 2020 - UNHCR - June 28th, 2021
- Recreation is good for business | BusinessNorth Exclusives | businessnorth.com - BusinessNorth.com - June 28th, 2021