Pioneering life sciences journal eLife finds itself at the center of a white-hot furor after its governing board fired editor-in-chief Michael Eisen following his endorsement on social media of a satirical article expressing sympathy for Palestinians caught in the escalating violence in Gaza between Israel and Hamas. The decision, which was called for by some corners of the scientific community, and ignited a subsequent backlash in others, highlights disagreements among researchers about institutions restrictions on free speech when science and politics collide.
At least seven editors at eLife and advisers to the journal have resigned in protest of his dismissal, including Elisabeth Bik, the celebrated spotter of scientific data manipulation. Other researchers have pledged to boycott the publication until its leaders provide a transparent explanation for Eisens removal and demonstrate a commitment to academic freedom of expression. Many declined to speak to STAT due to how heated the discourse has become in recent days.
On Monday, Eisen, a biologist at the University of California, Berkeley who is Jewish, posted on X (formerly Twitter) that he was being replaced for retweeting a @TheOnion piece that calls out indifference to the lives of Palestinian civilians.
In a statement posted to its website and emailed to eLife editors Tuesday, the journal confirmed the firing by the board, which is made up of representatives of eLifes founding funders the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, the Max Planck Society in Germany, and the London-based Wellcome Trust. But it suggested that the tweet in question was not the sole reason for Eisens ouster.
Mike has been given clear feedback from the board that his approach to leadership, communication and social media has at key times been detrimental to the cohesion of the community we are trying to build and hence to eLifes mission, the statement said. It is against this background that a further incidence of this behaviour has contributed to the boards decision.
Eisen did not respond to STATs requests for comment.
A longtime critic of traditional publishing and outspoken advocate for open science, he has a history of being unafraid to take on powerful institutions in the name of bettering the research enterprise. While many scientists describe him as amiable in person, his online persona has a more caustic edge, especially on X, where he has amassed more than 73,000 followers and posted nearly as many tweets. More than a few of those have sparked controversy in the past, including 2016s #landergate and 2020s wormageddon.
The turmoil this time began on October 13 when Eisen, with his trademark playful yet provocative ire, applauded a story posted by the news parody website The Onion, headlined Dying Gazans Criticized for Not Using Last Words to Condemn Hamas. Eisen wrote on X: The Onion speaks with more courage, insight and moral clarity than the leaders of every academic institution put together. I wish there were a @TheOnion university.
But unlike in the past, most people did not take Eisens comments which were aimed at vague university statements regarding the conflict in stride. Instead, his post ignited a fusillade of criticism that his statements were offensive and lacked empathy for Israeli civilians killed and taken hostage by Hamas.
Is this a joke to you? tweetedMeital Oren-Suissa, a senior scientist at the Weizmann Institute in Israel. Your comment and this article are very hurtful.
Absolutely disgusted by these heartless & callous remark, tweeted Derya Unutmaz, a cell biologist at the Jackson Laboratory. This isnt just insensitivity, its a cruel mockery of one of the worst tragedies, which deepens the pain of those who lost loved ones. Its also shocking such a malevolent comment is from a scientist and @eLife editor
Alleging an anti-Israel bias that would compromise the integrity of the journal, some Israeli researchers called for Eisen to resign and urged colleagues to withhold manuscript submissions until the demand was met. Others called on HHMI to cut funding to Eisens lab, which has received support through its individual investigator program since 2008.
The outpouring of antagonism and Eisens subsequent dismissal have troubled many researchers who feel that the ability to freely express ones opinions in the public square, whether thats on a university campus or on social media, is foundational to the scientific enterprise.
No scientist should be fired over something like this because it really affects the freedom of speech within the scientific community, especially for early career and minority researchers, said Lara Urban, a biodiversity researcher at Helmholtz Munich who held several eLife positions before stepping down this week. People need to be able to voice controversial opinions.
For the past three years, Urban has been a member of eLifes early career advisory group, which met weekly with the journals leadership team to discuss how the journal could use its growing prestige to further its goals of transforming the traditional publishing system to increase access, equity, and inclusivity.
Bik told STAT she resigned from the eLife Ethics Committee because as a scientific journal that considers ethics and equity as core values, it shouldnt get involved in personal opinions, in particular those on geopolitical situations, provided those opinions are not denigrating or hurtful. Bik understands why some have interpreted Eisens comments as hurtful, but she saw them as emphasizing the loss of civilian lives on both sides of this conflict. Pointing attention to civilian death in a war situation should not result in someone losing their position at a scientific journal, she said.
Legal experts who have followed the case said the journal was within its rights in firing Eisen, because eLife is a private nonprofit organization. Its a simple fact of employment law in the United States that people in the private sector have essentially no protection from their employers if the employers dont like their opinions, said Brian Leiter, a professor of law and philosophy at the University of Chicago.
But the role of academic journal editor is rarely a full-time job. Like Eisen, most people take on those positions in addition to their university work running research labs and teaching classes which come with constitutionally and contractually protected rights to academic freedom of expression. The eLife case highlights fears over how that freedom can get whittled away if other parts of the research ecosystem, like funders and publishers, dont support the same values.
Its always been the case that we have no guarantee that the people reviewing our grants, or reviewing our papers, or reviewing us for promotion arent influenced by other things they know about us, Leiter said. All social media does is to make it easier to advertise what your views are.
eLife was launched in 2012 with a commitment to open access and a collaborative system of peer review that attracted hundreds of top scientists, making it quickly rise to the ranks of big-name publications like Science, Nature, and Cell. In 2019, when eLife hired Eisen, it was seen widely as a doubling down on its mission of ensuring that everyone has access to the infrastructure needed to openly disseminate, review, and curate the scientific literature.
Eisen championed bold moves for the journal that were often divisive. In 2020, the journal announced a new policy requiring that all authors who wanted to publish in eLife first post their submissions online as preprints. In 2022, it introduced an even bigger change the decision to publish every paper it sent out for peer review, alongside reviewers assessments of the works significance and rigor a change that was effectively relinquishing the traditional journal role of gatekeeper, Eisen said in a press release at the time.
That particular experiment proved too much for a number of eLife editors, who worried about its impact on the prestige of the platform and threatened to resign if the policy was implemented. When Eisen pushed forward anyway, a few followed through, though not the mass resignation that was feared.
But for Urban, who became an editor at eLife a few months ago, it was precisely these kinds of policies that attracted her to the journal. Mikes eLife is the eLife I joined, she said. He elevated the early career advisory group and gave researchers like her a voice within the organization. When she and others in the group saw people organizing online against him, they reached out individually to eLife leadership with their concerns that censuring Eisen would set a dangerous precedent. When those concerns werent addressed, they submitted a formal letter to the board on October 19, to be considered at its meeting that day.
According to Urban, they never received a response. She learned of Eisens ouster on Twitter Monday. After seeing the journals statement Tuesday, she reluctantly resigned her positions at eLife.
The statement implies that because of tweets in the past he wasnt able to unite people behind him, Urban said. It was an explanation she found unsatisfactory, and out of alignment with eLifes mission. Its easy to unite people when youre playing to majority, entrenched interests, she said.
If you make those people mad, maybe thats a good thing for the future we imagine a scientific community that is more diverse and more equitable than it is now.
It was a difficult decision, she emphasized, because eLife is such a promising organization striving to change structural shortcomings of the scientific publishing system. Now she worries that the innovative policies Eisen pushed may disappear along with his name from the masthead.
At the same Oct. 19 meeting, the eLife board met with Eisen to discuss his tweets, and later that day it asked him to resign or face termination, Eisen told Science. The board doesnt want eLife embroiled in controversies and they look at me, I guess, as someone who makes things controversial, he said.
At the time of publication, eLife had not responded to STATs requests for an interview or emailed questions.
At least online, Eisen seems to be embracing this latest kerfuffle as the price to pay for speaking his mind, perhaps even a badge of honor. Mama always said Id be the first person to be cancelled, he tweeted late Tuesday night.
Follow this link:
Free speech concerns arise in wake of journal editor Eisen's firing - STAT
- Opinion | U.S. religious freedom effort gets an unwelcome message in Saudi Arabia - The Washington Post - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Freedom Caucus urges GOP to reject government funding deal without border reforms - The Hill - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- The Equal Justice Initiative's soon to open Freedom Monument Sculpture Park - Montgomery Advertiser - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Freedom school district to go to referendum April 2 for capital improvements totaling $62.5 million - Post-Crescent - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Press freedom in Kenya, Uganda and Rwanda: what journalists have to say about doing their jobs - The Conversation Indonesia - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- She bought an animal testing site and turned it into a rehab sanctuary - The Washington Post - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Young Americans for Freedom said UW-Madison's security fees were 'unprecedented.' Records show that's not the full ... - Daily Cardinal - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Responds to Outcome in Ohio GOP Senate Primary - Reproductive Freedom for All - Reproductive Freedom for All - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Biden Redefines Freedom and Democracy - AMAC Official Website - Join and Explore the Benefits - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Freedom snaps three-game streak of wins at home - MaxPreps - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- DePauw Faculty Talks Merit Pay, Academic Freedom, Donor Funds, and Event Planning at Monthly Meeting - The DePauw - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- SC governor: Proposed Medical Freedom Act could place innocent lives at risk - Live 5 News WCSC - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Li Yilei recaptures the freedom of childhood through sound - The FADER - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- The massive copper mine that could test the limits of religious freedom - Grist - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Netflix Is Rethinking Employee Freedom, a Core Tenet of Its Vaunted Culture - WSJ - The Wall Street Journal - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Freedom Caucus touts bill banning Ranked Choice Voting - Pelican Post - Online Newspaper - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Proposed TikTok ban is an affront to economic and personal freedom - The Hill - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Chase Freedom Encourages Cardmembers To Celebrate With Family, Given and Chosen, With Q2 2024 Quarterly ... - Yahoo Finance - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Baseball Game Recap: Freedom Patriots vs. East Bay Indians - MaxPreps - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- 'The veils and the women': Can we really advocate for freedom when we are banning them? - LSE Home - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Freedom wins going away against Brandon - MaxPreps - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Protect the founder of WikiLeaks for the future of press freedom - The Baylor Lariat - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Applauds Confirmation of Judge Nicole Berner to Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals - Reproductive Freedom for All - Reproductive Freedom for All - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Five Themes Discussed at Princeton's Workshop on Decentralized Social Media - Freedom to Tinker - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Meghan Markle Unveils New Brand on Poignant Date with Prince Harry - PEOPLE - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Freedom set to open the 2024 season against Torrey Pines (CA) - 69News WFMZ-TV - March 20th, 2024 [March 20th, 2024]
- Texas A&M Creating A Task Force To Work On Academic Freedom - Navasota News - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- H.S. BASKETBALL ROUNDUP: Freedom teams advance to Christmas tournament title games - Morganton News Herald - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Gow cites freedom of expression in defending porn videos which led to his firing as UWL chancellor - WIZM NEWS - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Sound Of Freedom: All Updates & Controversies Since It Released - Screen Rant - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Im ready for freedom, Gypsy Rose Blanchard says as she gets early release from jail after role in moms... - The US Sun - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Turkish Airlines Hasn't Applied For Permission to Operate Crucial Fifth-Freedom Flights From Singapore to Australia - paddleyourownkanoo.com - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- New ballot language submitted for proposed changes to Arkansas Freedom of Information Act - Mountain Home Observer - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- The SRFOE calls on States to guarantee freedom of expression as a fundamental right for gender equality and the ... - Organization of American States - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Irene Crcoles releases 'Closet', a single that screams freedom - WECB - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Sound of Freedom Is Now Streaming: Heres Where to Stream the Controversial Crime Thriller Online for Free - Hollywood Reporter - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- FIA consider more freedom in technical regulations - The Judge 13 - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Texas A&M Academic Freedom Task Force Is Nearing Completion Of Its Recommendations - WTAW - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- 2023 was a dire year for freedom of speech on campus, says this organization. Will next year be any better? - Fox News - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- The Spellbinding Freedom of Baldur's Gate 3 - The New York Times - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Stream It Or Skip It: Sound of Freedom on Prime Video, the Child-Trafficking Movie That Became a Culture War Flashpoint And Box Office Sensation -... - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Rare Mammoth Specimen Unearthed at Freedom Mine near Beulah, North Dakota - Net Newsledger - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Frontlines of Freedom TV Ep. 1 | 2023 Year In Review | Gaza | Ukraine | Trump RDI - Renew Democracy Initiative - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- We need more freedom of speech on campus, but that can't include advocating for genocide - Minnesota Reformer - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Freedom, first and last Sonoma Sun | Sonoma, CA - Sonoma Valley Sun - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Home for the holidays, from wrongful imprisonment - Star Tribune - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- The Freedom to Dress Cannot Be Overstated - Highsnobiety - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Freedom Town Column: Selectmen's meetings have resumed at the town office - Conway Daily Sun - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Did Disney own the rights to Sound of Freedom? - Dexerto - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Freedom Fitness 615 is ready to take on new year's resolutions - Lebanon Democrat - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Expressing the freedom of self-expression for Holocaust Memorial Day - North Kesteven District Council - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Airdate: Jamie Lee Curtis: Hollywood Call of Freedom - TV Tonight - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Harry Belafonte Used Fame to Fight for Freedom - The New York Times - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Abducted Anambra truck driver regains freedom - Punch Newspapers - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- OP-ED: Kwanzaa, Freedom, Justice and Peace: Principles and Practices For A New World - Black Press USA - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Webinar to give overview of Arkansas Food Freedom Act - Searcy Daily Citizen - December 28th, 2023 [December 28th, 2023]
- Statement to Mark 25th Anniversary of International Religious ... - USCCB - October 25th, 2023 [October 25th, 2023]
- Freedom of Information Act - Health.mil - October 25th, 2023 [October 25th, 2023]
- 'Freedom' to be featured on GS merchandise - Statesboro Herald - October 25th, 2023 [October 25th, 2023]
- Freedom students say they feel safe on campus; social media ... - thepress.net - October 25th, 2023 [October 25th, 2023]
- What kind of freedom? | News, Sports, Jobs - Marshalltown Times Republican - October 25th, 2023 [October 25th, 2023]
- Woman has few hopes for freedom in shaken bay death conviction - Mississippi Today - October 25th, 2023 [October 25th, 2023]
- MFRR Monitoring Report 575 media freedom violations in the first ... - European Centre for Press and Media Freedom - October 25th, 2023 [October 25th, 2023]
- Michigan's Freedom of Information Act Must Be Significantly Reformed - Mackinac Center for Public Policy - October 25th, 2023 [October 25th, 2023]
- Freedom without justice - IPS Journal - October 25th, 2023 [October 25th, 2023]
- Salman Rushdie calls for defense of freedom of expression as he ... - Spectrum News 1 - October 25th, 2023 [October 25th, 2023]
- Governor Murphy Sounds the Alarm on Incoming GOP Assault on ... - InsiderNJ - October 25th, 2023 [October 25th, 2023]
- Soloviev Group Announces Affordable Housing Units in Freedom ... - New York YIMBY - October 25th, 2023 [October 25th, 2023]
- North Macedonia Curbed Roma Citizens' Freedom of Movement ... - Balkan Insight - October 25th, 2023 [October 25th, 2023]
- NCT 127: We are limitless but that freedom also has a lot of ... - NME - October 25th, 2023 [October 25th, 2023]
- Academic freedom or state control: Court hearing will consider blocking key higher ed law in FL - Florida Phoenix - October 23rd, 2023 [October 23rd, 2023]
- Salman Rushdie calls for defense of freedom of expression as he receives German prize - Euronews - October 23rd, 2023 [October 23rd, 2023]
- It's Cold War II, and the enemies of freedom are lining up to forge a new world order - The Telegraph - October 23rd, 2023 [October 23rd, 2023]
- Freedom Caucus Urges GOP Leaders To Remain in Washington ... - The Messenger - October 23rd, 2023 [October 23rd, 2023]
- Statesboro: 'Freedom' the Eagle now has his own merchandise - WJCL News Savannah - October 23rd, 2023 [October 23rd, 2023]
- Escaping North Korea: 'Beyond Utopia' documents one path to ... - The Christian Science Monitor - October 23rd, 2023 [October 23rd, 2023]
- PRH, WNDB Launch Freedom of Expression Award - Publishers Weekly - October 23rd, 2023 [October 23rd, 2023]
- Carbondale branch of NAACP hosts 46th Freedom Fund Banquet - The Southern - October 23rd, 2023 [October 23rd, 2023]
- 'Herald favored our freedom of speech' The Durango Herald - The Durango Herald - October 23rd, 2023 [October 23rd, 2023]
- Carnival Freedom Returns To Service With New Look - Cruise Industry News - October 23rd, 2023 [October 23rd, 2023]