This case, from the U.S. Federal Appeals Court, considers the applicability of the Fifth Amendments privilege against self-incrimination in relation to testimony compelled by a foreign government, on the present facts the UKs Financial Conduct Authority. It will therefore no doubt influence how the DOJ operates and interacts with UK investigatory authorities in the future.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, in a decision published on 19 July1, reversed the convictions of Anthony Allen and Anthony Conti. Allen and Conti (the Defendants) had previously been tried and convicted before the District Court (Southern District of New York) for wire fraud and related conspiracy offences, concerning the alleged manipulation of LIBOR. The appeal focused on the defendants claim that their privilege against self-incrimination under the Fifth Amendment had been violated. It was argued that the testimony of Paul Robson, a key witness in the case, had been tainted by statements the Defendants had made in compelled interviews with the UKs Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). The FCA had disclosed the transcripts of the Defendants interviews to Robson, pursuant to the regulatory proceedings against him. Robson had reviewed the transcripts prior to cooperating with the DOJ.
In reversing the District Courts decision, the Appeals Court held that the Government had failed to prove (as required under the Kastigar doctrine2) that Robsons evidence had been derived from a source wholly independent of the compelled testimony. In addition, the Appeals Court addressed a more fundamental issue which the District Court had previously declined to consider: whether the Fifth Amendment is even engaged by testimony compelled by a foreign government. Given the increasing prevalence of cross-border investigations this question was evidently important to resolve. The Appeals Court concluded that the protection offered by the Fifth Amendment applied to the use of all compelled testimony, irrespective of whether it had been obtained by a foreign Government. This blog piece summarises both elements of the Appeal Courts decision.
Application of the Fifth Amendment to foreign compelled testimony
In a previous blog post we analysed the competing arguments raised on behalf of the Government and the Defendants, before the District Court, on whether the Fifth Amendment applied to foreign compelled testimony. We concluded that it was difficult to reconcile the Governments position with Federal Appellate authority. The Appeals Court decision is not therefore overly surprising.
The decision emphasizes that the Self-Incrimination Clausewhich enshrines a right not to testify against oneselfprovides a personal trial right to an accused in any US criminal case. A violation of the Clause therefore occurs only when the statement is used at trial, not at the point of its compulsion. In short, compelled testimony cannot be used to secure a conviction in an American Court.3
The Appeals Court rejected a policy argument raised by the Government in support of adopting a restrictive scope of the Fifth Amendments application. The Government suggested that foreign authorities could frustrate US prosecutions by publicizing compelled testimony, thereby submitting the US Government to the burden raised by Kastigar. The Appeals Court dismissed these concerns. Negligent publication, the Court held, seemed increasingly unlikely given the trend towards closer and earlier coordination between U.S. and foreign agencies. The tide of international criminal enforcement, the Court reasoned, bolstered the argument for having the Fifth Amendment apply to foreign compelled testimony:
If as a consequence of joint investigations with foreign nations we are to hale foreign men and women in to the courts of the United States to fend for their liberty we should not do so while denying them the full protection of a trial right we regard as fundamental and absolute.4
The Appeal Courts decision appears to resolve this issue unequivocally and will presumably inhibit recent attempts made by the DOJ to rely on foreign compelled testimony. In June, the DOJ requested the District Court for Northern California grant a subpoena for the production of a transcript of testimony compelled by the UKs Financial Reporting Council (FRC).5 Following the Allen and Conti decision it is hard to see how the FRC evidence could be deemed admissible, and therefore satisfy the preconditions for being the object of a subpoena.
Application of the Kastigar doctrine
Under Kastigar, where an individual is compelled to testify he is protected by use and derivative use immunity: neither his testimony, nor any evidence derived (directly or indirectly) from it, can be used as evidence against him in criminal proceedings. The prohibition on use is total. The testimony cannot, for example, be used as a basis to commence an investigatory enquiry. Kastigar also espouses a test by which the protection is enforced: the Government bears the burden of proving that all the evidence it proposes to rely upon was derived from legitimate sources, wholly independent from the compelled testimony. The burden is significant and must be proved by a preponderance of the evidence (in UK terms on the balance of probability).
In the present case, the Appeal Court reversed the District Courts conclusion that the Government had met its Kastigar burden. It emphasized that the presence of evidence which corroborated Robsons account was insufficient to meet the applicable standard.6 Instead the Government was required to prove that Robsons exposure to the compelled testimony had not shaped, altered or affected the information he had provided and which the Government had used. Such an analysis could be conducted effectively where a witness testimony is memorialized (or canned) prior to their exposure to any compelled statements.7
Here, Robson had himself provided testimony to the FCA prior to exposure. Far from assisting the Government, a comparative analysis of Robsons accounts (his compelled statement to the FCA and his trial testimony) revealed marked discrepancies. Furthermore, the level of material exposure appeared substantial, the Government accepted that many of the topics discussed by Robson in his testimony also featured in the Defendants compelled statements. Notwithstanding this Robson had not claimed, at any stage during his testimony, that he could segregate the effects of his exposure.8 These findings, and other aspects of Robsons evidence, undermined any suggestion that Robsons exposure to the Defendants compelled statements had not shaped, altered or affected his own testimony. The Appeal Court held that generalized and self-serving denials of any taint was an inadequate basis on which the Government could satisfy its burden under Kastigar.9
It remains to be seen how often foreign compelled testimony will give rise to a Kastigar motion in US criminal proceedings. This decision of the Appeals Court makes it more incumbent on US Federal agencies to interact closely with foreign governments and to coordinate cross-border investigations at their outset. Where a Kastigar claim can be foreseen the US prosecuting authority will need to consider how it can protect against potential witnesses being exposed to the compelled testimony of a suspect / defendant. Where a risk of exposure still exists, for example through the imminent publication of compelled testimony, the authority will need to move quickly in order to memorialize a witness account.
1www.pbwt.com/content/uploads/2017/07/USA-v-Allen.pdf 2Kastigar v. United States, 406 U.S. 441 (1972) 3 See pages 35-38 of the decision. 4 See pages 54-5 of the decision. 5 See Global Investigations Review, 19 June 2017- DOJ pursues ex-Autonomy directors compelled testimony. 6 See pages 60-1 of the decision. 7 See pages 61-2 of the decision. 8 This formulation was taken from the case of Poindexter, 951 F.2d at 376. 9 See page 63 and 70 of the decision.
See more here:
Case Note: Allen and Conti - JD Supra (press release)
- VANDA Pharmaceuticals States a Fifth Amendment Claim against the Government for Taking a Trade Secret - Trade Secrets Trends - February 13th, 2024 [February 13th, 2024]
- Attorneys argue shooters Fifth Amendment rights on the 4th day of the Jennifer Crumbley trial - Detroit News - January 27th, 2024 [January 27th, 2024]
- Judge will not allow Michigan school shooter to testify in mother's trial if he invokes the Fifth Amendment - AppleValleyNewsNow.com - January 27th, 2024 [January 27th, 2024]
- Shamoon v. Resideo: Obviousness affirmed - Patently-O - August 12th, 2023 [August 12th, 2023]
- Billings County sued over eminent domain as bridge dispute rekindles - Bismarck Tribune - August 12th, 2023 [August 12th, 2023]
- 'Tyler' and a Call for Reform of the New Jersey Tax Foreclosure ... - Law.com - August 12th, 2023 [August 12th, 2023]
- "Like fatter Tony Soprano Attending the Arraignment and "Effect[ing ... - Emptywheel - August 12th, 2023 [August 12th, 2023]
- Call to faith-based leaders to help end violence; Parents need to pay ... - Capital Gazette - August 12th, 2023 [August 12th, 2023]
- "Stunning development": Experts say Trump target letter is surest ... - Salon - June 12th, 2023 [June 12th, 2023]
- LIV, PGA drop a bombshell on Washington - POLITICO - June 12th, 2023 [June 12th, 2023]
- Congressman Matt Gaetz Introduces Resolution to Hold Former ... - Congressman Matt Gaetz - June 12th, 2023 [June 12th, 2023]
- It's time to end home equity theft in Maine - Bangor Daily News - June 12th, 2023 [June 12th, 2023]
- Louisiana's Sabine River Authority Not Entitled To Sovereign Immunity - The Energy Law Blog - May 28th, 2023 [May 28th, 2023]
- Ninth Circuit Finds that Criminal Reentry Provision Not Driven by ... - Immigration Blog - May 28th, 2023 [May 28th, 2023]
- Ken Paxton Impeached on 20 Charges Including Bribery ... - The Texan - May 28th, 2023 [May 28th, 2023]
- Simply losing it: Bitter fight brews over federal judges forced retirement effort - Yahoo News - May 28th, 2023 [May 28th, 2023]
- Worth County Board of Supervisors Meeting (LIVE) - KIOW.com - May 28th, 2023 [May 28th, 2023]
- Trump Organization finishes last in brand reputation survey for second straight year - The Hill - May 28th, 2023 [May 28th, 2023]
- They held down a Black teen who tried to shoplift. He died from ... - Wisconsin Examiner - May 28th, 2023 [May 28th, 2023]
- What is the Fifth Amendment, and how has it been used? : NPR - March 31st, 2023 [March 31st, 2023]
- Tmc the Metals Company Inc. Enters into Fifth Amendment to Pilot Mining Test Agreement and Third Amendment to Strategic Alliance Agreement, Which Is... - February 20th, 2023 [February 20th, 2023]
- Interpretation: The Fifth Amendment Due Process Clause | Constitution ... - January 31st, 2023 [January 31st, 2023]
- Fifth Amendment invoked to the point of 'unintentional hilarity' by Jan ... - December 26th, 2022 [December 26th, 2022]
- Why Did Trump Plead The Fifth Amendment?What We Do Know ... - Newsweek - October 25th, 2022 [October 25th, 2022]
- Understanding the Fifth Amendment Right to Remain Silent - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- US Government for Kids: Fifth Amendment - Ducksters - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- Donald Trump loves to plead the Fifth. It won't save him this time. - MSNBC - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- Everything You Ever Wanted to Know About Georgia Special Purpose Grand Juries But Were Afraid to Ask - Lawfare - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- Citing double jeopardy, Fargo man who killed 14-year-old Jupiter Paulsen wants murder conviction dropped - INFORUM - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- Nicki Clyne: What Happened to NXIVM Member and Where Is She Now? - Newsweek - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- New York AG Asks Judge to Prevent Trumps From Hiding Assets Mother Jones - Mother Jones - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- Trump Will Finally Have to Face Questions About Alleged Rape, Judge Rules - VICE - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- 'In the Heat of the Night' star Lee Grant on working with Sidney Poitier and being blacklisted by Hollywood - Yahoo Entertainment - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- THE OTHER SIDE: Orange Jesus took the Fifth - theberkshireedge.com - October 6th, 2022 [October 6th, 2022]
- BNP Paribas : 5th amendment to the 2021 Universal Registration Document - Marketscreener.com - September 29th, 2022 [September 29th, 2022]
- Tlingit tribal member shares his story of helping the Yakamas get Mount Adams back - Yakima Herald-Republic - September 29th, 2022 [September 29th, 2022]
- Trump Pleading the Fifth Might Have Doomed Him in Civil Case - Newsweek - September 27th, 2022 [September 27th, 2022]
- Why is Kevin McCarthy Promising to Remove Parents from the Terrorist Watch List? - Daily Kos - September 27th, 2022 [September 27th, 2022]
- Alex Jones said he may have to plead the Fifth as he's set to testify - Insider - September 27th, 2022 [September 27th, 2022]
- USS Fitzgerald and ACX Crystal collision: The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals delineates the reach of personal jurisdiction - GARD - September 9th, 2022 [September 9th, 2022]
- Trump investigation tracker: Keeping up with Trump's many legal issues - Grid - September 9th, 2022 [September 9th, 2022]
- Bo Dukes's conviction to stand following motion for new trial - Douglas Now - September 9th, 2022 [September 9th, 2022]
- VAIL RESORTS INC : Entry into a Material Definitive Agreement, Creation of a Direct Financial Obligation or an Obligation under an Off-Balance Sheet... - September 9th, 2022 [September 9th, 2022]
- It's brother vs. brother at trial over NYC slaying of mobbed-up dad, 'Sally Daz' Zottola - New York Post - September 9th, 2022 [September 9th, 2022]
- Letters: Boater offers different perspective on the Playpen - Chicago Tribune - September 9th, 2022 [September 9th, 2022]
- Michael Flynn: From Government Insider to Holy Warrior - PBS - September 9th, 2022 [September 9th, 2022]
- Hamel found guilty of Athol murder, sentenced to life in prison - The Recorder - September 9th, 2022 [September 9th, 2022]
- Biden Slowly Winning LBJ- and FDR-Like Praise As Legislative Victories Mount - Seattle Medium - September 9th, 2022 [September 9th, 2022]
- Vice Principals, the Fifth Amendment, and Negative Inferences - JD Supra - August 30th, 2022 [August 30th, 2022]
- PERMA FIX ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES INC : Entry into a Material Definitive Agreement, Creation of a Direct Financial Obligation or an Obligation under an... - August 30th, 2022 [August 30th, 2022]
- Letter: Invoking the Fifth Amendment is not an admission of guilt - INFORUM - August 29th, 2022 [August 29th, 2022]
- Taking the Fifth, FBI attacked: 5 takeaways of Gov. Whitmer kidnap trial - MLive.com - August 29th, 2022 [August 29th, 2022]
- How much money could Donald Trump have to pay in fines if his businesses are penalized? - AS USA - August 29th, 2022 [August 29th, 2022]
- A high stake debate and tension at the GOP convention: Your guide to Michigan politics - MLive.com - August 29th, 2022 [August 29th, 2022]
- We Can Be Framers Too - The Atlantic - August 29th, 2022 [August 29th, 2022]
- For 38 Years of American History, There Has Been No Vice President - History News Network - August 8th, 2022 [August 8th, 2022]
- Emmett Till is gone. The quest for justice lives on. - New York Daily News - August 8th, 2022 [August 8th, 2022]
- 'A bold-faced LIE': St. Louis mayor blasts Black police officer groups criticism of oversight bill - KSDK.com - August 8th, 2022 [August 8th, 2022]
- He has done more to further the cause of hate in the US than almost anyone: the rise and fall of Alex Jones - The Guardian - August 8th, 2022 [August 8th, 2022]
- Even the District Attorney Believed Joaquin Ciria Was Innocent. Why Did It Take So Long to Set Him Free? - POLITICO - August 8th, 2022 [August 8th, 2022]
- Understanding the Constitution: Why It Doesn't Protect the Unborn - The Epoch Times - August 6th, 2022 [August 6th, 2022]
- Former fugitive charged with rape in Deerfield case demands new lawyer - The Recorder - August 6th, 2022 [August 6th, 2022]
- Sources: Donald Trump Jr., Ivanka Testify Before NY AG's Office in Finance Probe, Neither Pleads the 5th - NBC New York - August 6th, 2022 [August 6th, 2022]
- Time running out to try Catherine Hoggle for the disappearance, suspected murder of her 2 kids - WUSA9.com - August 6th, 2022 [August 6th, 2022]
- Trump faces uphill fight on executive privilege in DOJ probe - POLITICO - August 6th, 2022 [August 6th, 2022]
- Charles Milliken: Defining what exactly is a 'right' - Monroe Evening News - July 31st, 2022 [July 31st, 2022]
- How grand juries work and why Jan. 6 prosecutors are relying on them - Salon - July 31st, 2022 [July 31st, 2022]
- Roe, Dobbs and women's rights New York Daily News - New York Daily News - July 31st, 2022 [July 31st, 2022]
- Partisan congressional hearings are a threat to all citizens - Monroe Evening News - July 31st, 2022 [July 31st, 2022]
- 9 years after a UIW police officer shot student Cameron Redus, the case is going to trial - San Antonio Express-News - July 31st, 2022 [July 31st, 2022]
- Outcome of first kidnapping trial can't be used as evidence in second trial, judge rules - Michigan Radio - July 31st, 2022 [July 31st, 2022]
- Washington County woman held in death of 5-year-old son - Herald-Mail Media - July 31st, 2022 [July 31st, 2022]
- What Did the Dissenting Justices Think About the Power of Military Authorities & More - The Soldiers Project - July 31st, 2022 [July 31st, 2022]
- Whipping the votes in Suffolk - Newsday - July 31st, 2022 [July 31st, 2022]
- If Trump Takes the Fifth, Is He Guilty? - Law & Crime - July 29th, 2022 [July 29th, 2022]
- Anambra House of Assembly Passes 5th Amendment Bills - TVC News - July 29th, 2022 [July 29th, 2022]
- How do grand juries work? Their major role in criminal justice, and why prosecutors are using them to investigate efforts to overturn the 2020... - July 29th, 2022 [July 29th, 2022]
- We need to hear the unbiased story - Villages-News - July 29th, 2022 [July 29th, 2022]
- Outcome of first kidnapping trial can't be used as evidence in second trial, judge rules - WKAR - July 29th, 2022 [July 29th, 2022]
- LOVERRO: The weight on Rivera's shoulders is inevitably about much more than football - Washington Times - July 29th, 2022 [July 29th, 2022]