When the estates of nursing home residents who died from COVID-19 brought negligence and wrongful death lawsuits in New Jersey state court, defendant nursing homes removed the suits to federal court under the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act, 42 U.S.C. 247d-6d, 247d-6e (PREP Act), which protects certain covered entities, such as drug manufacturers, from lawsuits during a public health emergency. The federal District Court dismissed the cases for lack of subject matter jurisdiction and remanded them to state court, and an appeal to the Third Circuit ensued. Estate of Maglioli v. Alliance HC Holdings LLC, 2021 U.S. App. LEXIS 31526 (3d Cir. 2021).
The wrongful death actions arose from the treatment of residents at nursing homes where it was alleged that the residents' deaths were a direct result of the nursing homes failures to take measures to protect them at the facilities from the coronavirus and/or medical malpractice (including failure to provide personal protective equipment, to timely diagnose and treat the disease and permitting visitors and employees to enter the facilities without taking their temperatures or requiring masks.) The nursing home defendants premised their removal on the basis of a combination of federal officer removal, complete preemption and a substantial federal issue. The nursing homes urged the federal court to defer to PREP Act interpretations of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services; however, the Third Circuit ruled that deference is not owed to HHS interpretations for the simple reason that HHS is not delegated authority under the PREP Act to interpret the scope of federal courts' jurisdiction.
Additionally, while removal was also premised upon the federal officer removal statute (28 U.S.C. 1442)a)(1)) the Third Circuit found nursing homes were not "acting under" the United States, its agencies or its officers. The nursing homes did not assist or help carry out the duties of a federal superior and are not government contractors. Finally, the nursing homes argued complete federal preemption of the estates' claims as the PREP Act is so pervasive that the state law negligence claims are in fact federal claims under the Act, and thus removable to federal court. The Third Circuit disagreed, finding that simply making the preemption argument is insufficient to get the nursing homes into federal court. Nevertheless, a state court might find the PREP Act displaces one or more of the estates' state law claims when they adjudicate the issue. But simply raising a defense of federal preemption does not make the case removable.
Here, the estates alleged only negligence, not willful misconduct. The Act creates an exclusive cause of action for willful misconduct, and requires plaintiffs bringing willful misconduct claims to first exhaust administrative remedies and then to bring their claim only in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. In other words, "just because the PREP Act creates an exclusive federal cause of action does not mean it completely preempts the states' state law claims." The Third Circuit also rejected the argument that formation of a compensation fund creates preemption, inasmuch as the compensation fund is not a cause of action. Finally, Federal Question removal was also not appropriate since the estates did not assert a federal cause of action.
The Third Circuit stressed that they are not holding that all state law causes of action are invulnerable to complete preemption under the PREP Act, nor are they holding the PREP Act preempts the estates claims under ordinary preemption rulesthat is for the state court to decide. Importantly, while the pandemic has tested our federal system, there is no COVID-19 exception to Federalism.
Read more from the original source:
PREP Act Preemption: There is no COVID-19 Exception to Federalism - JD Supra
- Could overturning Roe end the abortion wars? Yes, thanks to federalism - Washington Examiner - May 21st, 2022
- Federalism and the failed pandemic response | Columnists | hampshirereview.com - Hampshire Review - May 21st, 2022
- Op-Ed: Leave abortion law to the states? Just look at the Fugitive Slave Act to see how that will go - Los Angeles Times - May 21st, 2022
- Panic-Driven Crypto & Stablecoin Regulation Would Create Further Instability - Forbes - May 21st, 2022
- UPSC CSE Key May 20, 2022: What you need to read today - The Indian Express - May 21st, 2022
- The Concurrent List is a hindrance to good federalism - Business Standard - April 29th, 2022
- Federalism in India - Federal Features & Unitary Features ... - April 27th, 2022
- Understanding Federalism | National Archives - April 27th, 2022
- First Five Years of Federalism in Nepal - Myrepublica - April 27th, 2022
- Reinstated Trump Water Rule Could Help Economy Grow - Heritage.org - April 22nd, 2022
- Technical support to teachers: Mentoring as an intervention - The Himalayan Times - April 22nd, 2022
- Rafael Nuez, the man who has been president of Colombia the most times - AL DIA News - April 22nd, 2022
- Chapter 3: Federalism and the Separation of Powers ... - April 13th, 2022
- Global federalism is necessary to solve world problems - The Cougar - The Daily Cougar - April 13th, 2022
- Opinion: In Quebec, the only thing deader than sovereignty is federalism - The Globe and Mail - April 13th, 2022
- Kejriwals meeting with Punjab officials in Manns absence draws flak, Oppn calls it breach of federalism - The Financial Express - April 13th, 2022
- 'Pro-choice' is not the same thing as 'pro-Roe' - Washington Examiner - April 9th, 2022
- Federalism And The Idea Of Regionalism - Outlook India - February 19th, 2022
- Constitutional Federalism: State Of Exception In The Paradise Of Kashmir - Outlook India - February 19th, 2022
- Size Matters: Why Tiny Goa Needs To Be Heard More Often - Outlook India - February 19th, 2022
- Centre-State Relations: Has The Concurrent List Outlived Its Utility? - Outlook India - February 19th, 2022
- How Regional Parties Are Becoming The Voice Of Small Communities - Outlook India - February 19th, 2022
- A federalism issue, a political necessity - Deccan Herald - February 17th, 2022
- CPI(M) against TMC's plan to forge alliance in fight against BJP's 'onslaught' on federalism - Deccan Herald - February 17th, 2022
- Education and Federalism in Myanmar - The Irrawaddy News Magazine - February 17th, 2022
- Tamil Nadu CM MK Stalin opposes one nation one registration, says BJP posing threat to federalism - The Indian Express - February 17th, 2022
- Federalism and the Nigeria of our dreams (III) - NIGERIAN TRIBUNE - February 17th, 2022
- Only BJP can save Punjab from the scourge of drugs, says Prime Minister Narendra Modi - The Tribune India - February 17th, 2022
- How Federalism Settled States vs Federal Rights - HISTORY - February 7th, 2022
- 15 Advantages and Disadvantages of Federalism ConnectUS - February 7th, 2022
- The India Fix: How big a force is federalism on the ground in Indian politics? - Scroll.in - February 7th, 2022
- The Victims of The So Called Federalism Battle-cry - Burma News International - February 7th, 2022
- All EAOs invited to Diamond Jubilee Union Day celebration, preliminary peace talks - Eleven Myanmar - February 7th, 2022
- Rebecca McQuillan: The real threat to independence that could save the Union - Yahoo News UK - February 7th, 2022
- The Extreme Difficulty of Diplomatically Resolving the Ethiopian War - The McGill International Review - February 7th, 2022
- Why federation reform should be an urgent priority - The Saturday Paper - February 7th, 2022
- The Republic Day is a reminder of the spirit of federalism and why it is under strain - The Indian Express - January 21st, 2022
- Should Democrats look to the states? - The Week Magazine - January 21st, 2022
- Peace talks will be held if the NCA and the constitution do not affect the building of a union based on democracy and federalism: SAC's Chair - Eleven... - January 21st, 2022
- PDP ready to shove APC out of power at the centre Agbaje - New Telegraph Newspaper - January 21st, 2022
- The Constitution's Basic Principles: Federalism ... - January 19th, 2022
- Proposed amendment to IAS cadre rule 1954 'against spirit of cooperative federalism': Mamata Banerjee writ - Economic Times - January 19th, 2022
- Nepal`s ruling coalition parties agree to hold local elections in April - WION - January 19th, 2022
- Beyond the Accord and beyond India's reach - NewsIn.Asia - January 19th, 2022
- What US Gets Wrong About Vaccines That Other Countries Get Right - UT News - UT News | The University of Texas at Austin - January 19th, 2022
- Letters: Let's lance the Indy boil with a fully informed vote - HeraldScotland - January 19th, 2022
- Uttar Pradesh Assembly polls | Mamatas campaign for SP will help BJP: Adhikari - The Hindu - January 19th, 2022
- More could be done to restore peace as invitation already extended for peace talks resumption: Snr Gen Min Aung Hlaing - Eleven Myanmar - January 19th, 2022
- Biden's Higher Education Agenda, One Year In - The Dispatch - January 19th, 2022
- Federal control of elections, and getting the filibuster out of the way - Bluefield Daily Telegraph - January 19th, 2022
- How Ghana lost its federalism -- and lessons for others - The Conversation CA - January 11th, 2022
- Opinion | Why the politics of blame avoidance shouldn't be working in Canadian federalism - NiagaraFallsReview.ca - January 11th, 2022
- Extending GST compensation as a reform catalyst - The Hindu - January 11th, 2022
- Administrative federalism - The News International - January 9th, 2022
- Federalism and the Value of Institutional Experience During a National Disaster: Identifying Determinants of Rapid Emergency Medicaid Waiver Adoption... - January 9th, 2022
- 'Local control' of government is a hallowed idea in Wisconsin. Here's what we can do to give it real meaning again. - Milwaukee Journal Sentinel - January 9th, 2022
- Lowry: The left supports the Constitution until it doesnt - Boston Herald - January 9th, 2022
- Governors are the last adults standing in American politics | TheHill - The Hill - January 9th, 2022
- Time to remove insincerity from resource control Opinion - Guardian - January 9th, 2022
- Sorry, Democrats: Civil War isn't likely even if you're trying to provoke one - New York Post - January 9th, 2022
- Opinion: It will be a dreary Christmas in Ethiopia this year, and here's why Americans should care - Iowa City Press-Citizen - January 9th, 2022
- Indian Origin Tamils and Muslims refused to ink Tamils' joint letter to Indian PM - NewsIn.Asia - January 9th, 2022
- What is Federalism? - Definition & Factors of U.S ... - December 29th, 2021
- Masari: Power rotation will strengthen our federalism - TheCable - December 29th, 2021
- Nagaland To Lakhimpur Kheri: Rights, Regimes And Restitutions in Times Of Turbulence - Outlook India - December 29th, 2021
- Poland accuses Germany of trying to form 'Fourth Reich' - DW (English) - December 29th, 2021
- Federalism is the answer, after all - Part 61 Opinion The Guardian Nigeria News Nigeria and World News - Guardian Nigeria - December 23rd, 2021
- What the Pandemic Has Taught Us About American Democracy - The Nation - December 23rd, 2021
- Combatting air pollution in Northern India: Cooperative federalism is the way forward - Observer Research Foundation - December 23rd, 2021
- Ethiopia: A regressive vision spells the end of the republic - The Africa Report - December 23rd, 2021
- New Federalism - Wikipedia - December 7th, 2021
- Federalism: Basic Structure of Government | United States ... - December 7th, 2021
- The country is moving towards a union based on democracy and federalism and it will not deviate at all: SAC's Chair - Eleven Myanmar - December 7th, 2021
- New law will be "end of Russian federalism," says North Russian MP - The Independent Barents Observer - December 7th, 2021
- Federalism is the answer, after all - Part 58 - Guardian Nigeria - December 7th, 2021
- After Roe, The Coming Fight to End All Abortions Everywhere - Justia Verdict - December 7th, 2021
- Irreconcilable aspirations: A regressive Ethiopian vision spells the end of the republic - Ethiopia Insight - December 7th, 2021
- Tourism minister says theres no advantage in politicising border closures - Australian Aviation - December 7th, 2021
- The Meaning Of The Constitution | The Heritage Foundation - November 28th, 2021
- Federalism | CONSTITUTION USA with Peter Sagal | PBS - November 28th, 2021