The Central governments recent tussle with West Bengal over the decision to place the services of the chief secretary of West Bengal with the Government of India, with immediate effect, has stirred a political hornets nest. Beyond the din, the Centres decision raises some very troubling legal questions that appear to strike at the foundations of cooperative federalism and the independence of civil servants.
With the chief minister of West Bengal, Mamata Banerjee, barely having assumed her third term, the state found itself ravaged by Indias second COVID-19 wave and the destructive Cyclone Yaas. The chief secretary of West Bengal, Alapan Bandhopadhyay, was slated to retire on the May 31, 2021. Given his experience in handling the COVID-19 crisis, the state of West Bengal had requested an extension of his term. This request, according to the chief minister, had been acceded to on the May 24, 2021 with a three-month extension being approved by the Centre.
However, in a complete renege, on May 28, 2021 an order was issued to the chief secretary, West Bengal, informing him that the Appointments Committee of the Cabinet has approved the placement of the officer with the Government of India in terms of Rule 6(1) of the Indian Administrative Service (Cadre) Rules, 1954 with immediate effect. The officer was asked to report to the Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT) by 10 am on May 31, 2021.
West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee and former chief secretary Alapan Bandyopadhyay in the states cyclone control room. Photo: Twitter
From several media reports, it appears that the decision to recall the officer closely followed a meeting held on May 28, 2021 between the prime minister and the state administration, for the purposes of reviewing the post-cyclone situation in West Bengal. In this meeting, the Bengal chief minister reportedly made the prime minister wait for 30 minutes and then curtailed her meeting with the prime minister due to prior commitments. The chief ministers response was that she took the prime ministers consent before leaving.
While the officer, as per the Centres order of 28 May was directed to report by May 31, 2021, the West Bengal government did not relieve the officer. The chief minister wrote a letter that explained these actions to the prime minister, protesting against what she termed as a unilateral decision which was also historically unprecedented and wholly unconstitutional. The next twist in the saga saw the officer opting to retire and being appointed an advisor to the chief minister. By late night of May 31, the Centre had predictably initiated action against the officer, now caught in the crossfire, by issuing a show cause notice.
Also read: Indefensible: Former Bureaucrats Slam Centres Unilateral Move to Transfer Bengal Chief Secy
Undermining federalism
In this backdrop, what are the legal implications of this whole episode? The order being passed without following the procedure prescribed by the very Rule it was passed under, is the first legal infirmity one observes. Rule 6 of the Indian Administrative Service (Cadre) 1954 Rules, under which the officer has been recalled, requires the concurrence of the state government in matters of deputation. It states that:
A cadre officer may, with the concurrence of the state governments concerned and the Central government, be deputed for service under the Central government or another state government.
Thus, seeking the concurrence of the state government before taking this step is a prerequisite under the Rule. The rule also has a proviso which states that in the event of a disagreement the matter shall be decided by the Central government. However, it is hard to foresee a disagreement if the concurrence of the state government was never even sought in the first place.
This means, that without following the procedure prescribed under the Rule, the Central government assumed a lack of concurrence, and proceeded to pass an order of deputation. This course of action makes the sub-section meaningless and puts the cart of the proviso before the horse of the sub-section. Placed with the course of events it almost seems that the order of deputation was retaliatory and motivated by extraneous considerations.
The whole exercise makes for extremely uncooperative federalism of the kind that has no place in our constitutional scheme. The officer was slated to retire on the May 31, 2021 and was given a brief extension after a consultative process. If the raison-dtre of the extension was the COVID-19 crisis in West Bengal and his experience in managing it, there was simply no material change in circumstances to warrant the deputation order. Even from the material available on record, there seems to be no particular need for the officer at the central level for a specific post. The order merely asks the officer to report to the DoPT in New Delhi by 10 am on May 31.
Also read: Modi Govts Move With Former Bengal Chief Secy Is in Sharp Contrast to History
Does this mean that any officer of the Indian Administrative Service can now be directed to proceed on central deputation with immediate effect, without even an attempt at obtaining the concurrence of the state government not to talk of the officers consent?
The Supreme Court in S.R. Bommai v. Union of India, (1994) 3 SCC 1 observed that states have an independent constitutional existence and they have as important a role to play in the political, social, educational and cultural life of the people as the Union. They are neither satellites nor agents of the Centre. In the same case the court observed the federal principle to be a part of the basic structure of the Constitution that is immune from even constitutional amendment. In Swaraj Abhiyan (V) v. Union of India, (2018) 12 SCC 170 the Supreme Court described cooperative federalism as a cherished constitutional goal.
In a country where cooperative federalism is ingrained in the constitutional scheme, a unilateral decision by the Central government to recall the chief secretary of a state during a pandemic seriously undermines federalism. There seems to have been no reason for such an order being passed, other than an alleged protocol violation by a chief minister in a review meeting with the prime minister. The manner, the haste, the infirmity and the timing of the order reeks of a colourable exercise of power by the Central government.
Lastly, it may be worth asking what message this sends to the officers of the civil services, whose job it is to serve the state administration while being politically neutral.
A punitive deputation order seems to have been issued in this case. This, followed up with threats of disciplinary action against the officer if he does not immediately report to New Delhi only paints a picture of an individual officer becoming collateral damage in a political dispute. How would this impact the morale of civil servants working across all states? More importantly how will this affect the independent functioning of the administrative service and the dispassionate and neutral discharge of duties by chief secretaries?
The issuance of unilateral deputation orders sets the stage for chief secretaries to pick sides between the state and the Centre. These are all very worrying signs for our republic already going through one of the most challenging times in its history.
Srishti Agnihotri is an advocate on record in the Supreme Court of India.
Read the rest here:
Centre's Tussle With Bengal Over Chief Secretary Reeks of Uncooperative Federalism - The Wire
- 2024 Lok Sabha Elections: Need to pitch for Federalism and Special Status for Goa - Herald Goa - April 6th, 2024 [April 6th, 2024]
- 1999 constitution and the quest for true federalism - Nigerian Observer - April 6th, 2024 [April 6th, 2024]
- Federalism is not Apartheid The Mail & Guardian - Mail and Guardian - April 6th, 2024 [April 6th, 2024]
- Modi has delivered confrontational federalism: Congress | Siddaramaiah highlights 'injustices to K'taka | Inshorts - Inshorts - April 6th, 2024 [April 6th, 2024]
- Lebanese Pro-Federalism Activist Alfred Riachi: Prior To October 7, The Standard Of Living In Gaza Was Pretty ... - Middle East Media Research... - February 22nd, 2024 [February 22nd, 2024]
- The Potential Impact of 'Disease X' on Federalism in the U.S. - Medriva - February 22nd, 2024 [February 22nd, 2024]
- 'People's Charter' Puts Federalism at The Heart of Myanmar's Democratic Future - The Irrawaddy - February 22nd, 2024 [February 22nd, 2024]
- Siddaramaiah vs Modi: The 'cess-y' mess in fiscal federalism - Deccan Herald - February 22nd, 2024 [February 22nd, 2024]
- Ideas Of India: Devendra Fadnavis To Take A Deep Dive Into Role Of Collaborative Federalism In Nation-Building - ABP Live - February 22nd, 2024 [February 22nd, 2024]
- Potential of federalism should be realized: PM Dahal - The Himalayan Times - February 22nd, 2024 [February 22nd, 2024]
- Sensible education policy needed - The Kathmandu Post - October 9th, 2023 [October 9th, 2023]
- Both cooperative federalism and competitive federalism have their ... - Insights IAS - August 18th, 2023 [August 18th, 2023]
- Federalism to poll promises: South India CMs bring up host of local ... - South First - August 18th, 2023 [August 18th, 2023]
- Justice Mitchell (Alabama): "The New Bar Exam Puts DEI Over ... - Reason - May 20th, 2023 [May 20th, 2023]
- Season of instability - The Kathmandu Post - May 20th, 2023 [May 20th, 2023]
- Trump Indictment Tests Congress's Role in State Investigations - Bloomberg Law - May 20th, 2023 [May 20th, 2023]
- Big Business' New Plan Would Create Fifty New Immigration Policies - Federation for American Immigration Reform - May 20th, 2023 [May 20th, 2023]
- Senator decries move to block bill loosening Wisconsin abortion law - Milwaukee Journal Sentinel - May 20th, 2023 [May 20th, 2023]
- "Illegally buying time": Congress leader Abhishek Singhvi chastises ... - ANI News - May 20th, 2023 [May 20th, 2023]
- Baby Ninth Amendments Part IV: All the Rights but Not ALL the Rights - Reason - May 20th, 2023 [May 20th, 2023]
- Amid the Fight for Myanmar, Federalism Rises from the Grass Roots - United States Institute of Peace - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- Lesson from Karnataka respect states and India's federalism - Deccan Herald - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- Dr. Paul Nolette named director of Les Aspin Center for Government ... - Marquette Today - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- Sen. Cramer Welcomes ND Witnesses, Discusses Water ... - Kevin Cramer - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- Utilities, Transmission, and the Grid: An Interview with Ari Peskoe - Brown Political Review - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- Six months after elections, provincial governments are still incomplete - The Kathmandu Post - May 18th, 2023 [May 18th, 2023]
- NON-FICTION: WHY FEDERALISM ENDURES IN PAKISTAN ... - DAWN.com - May 6th, 2023 [May 6th, 2023]
- Justice Scalia's Unpublished Dissent in Kelo v. City of New London - Reason - May 6th, 2023 [May 6th, 2023]
- Citizens, civil society hold the ruling party, BJP to account ... - SabrangIndia - May 6th, 2023 [May 6th, 2023]
- ED Proposes Title IX Athletics Rule Requiring Participation Based ... - The Federalist Society - May 6th, 2023 [May 6th, 2023]
- The Mysterious Case of the Imposition of Article 355 in Manipur - The Wire - May 6th, 2023 [May 6th, 2023]
- Non-BJP State Governments Not Exercising Accountability, Allowing ... - Daily Excelsior - May 6th, 2023 [May 6th, 2023]
- Two years of Stalin government in Tamil Nadu: Two steps forward - Times of India - May 6th, 2023 [May 6th, 2023]
- What is the issue of gubernatorial inaction in the legislative process ... - Insights IAS - April 29th, 2023 [April 29th, 2023]
- World Bank Approves $100 Million to Strengthen Nepal's Healthcare ... - ReliefWeb - April 29th, 2023 [April 29th, 2023]
- Canada's federal transfer payment system badly needs a tune-up - The Conversation - April 29th, 2023 [April 29th, 2023]
- 50 years of basic structure doctrine | Only safeguard against majoritarian govt: Sr Advocate Ramachandran - The Indian Express - April 29th, 2023 [April 29th, 2023]
- Federalism - Definition, Examples, Cases, processes - Legal Dictionary - February 20th, 2023 [February 20th, 2023]
- What is federalism? | State Policy Network - February 5th, 2023 [February 5th, 2023]
- UPSC Key- January 19, 2023: Learn about Annual Status of Education Report, Federalism and State Legislatures - The Indian Express - January 19th, 2023 [January 19th, 2023]
- Advantages and Disadvantages of Federalism American Government - January 6th, 2023 [January 6th, 2023]
- fiscal federalism | public finance | Britannica - December 26th, 2022 [December 26th, 2022]
- About ALEC - American Legislative Exchange Council - December 12th, 2022 [December 12th, 2022]
- Canadian federalism - Wikipedia - November 23rd, 2022 [November 23rd, 2022]
- U.P. bags top honours at PMAY-U Awards 2021 - The Hindu - November 23rd, 2022 [November 23rd, 2022]
- Political Line sc views on conversions rajiv convicts and federalism and more - The Hindu - November 21st, 2022 [November 21st, 2022]
- Byron Williams: The court is poised to rewrite federalism - Winston-Salem Journal - October 17th, 2022 [October 17th, 2022]
- Why Hindi may set the tone for 2024 - Deccan Herald - October 17th, 2022 [October 17th, 2022]
- A Myanmar roadmap: Charting the path to federal democracy - International IDEA - October 17th, 2022 [October 17th, 2022]
- Next generation of reforms should focus on reducing cost of doing business - Economic Times - October 17th, 2022 [October 17th, 2022]
- Nigeria And The Intrigues Of Insecurity -By Kene Obiezu - Opinion Nigeria - October 17th, 2022 [October 17th, 2022]
- Trudeau's aggressive federalism may leave Ottawa weaker than before - The Globe and Mail - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- What is Federalism? | CSF - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- Kerala Against Hindi Imposition; Terms Recommendations Attack on Federalism and Diversity of Nation - NewsClick - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- 2023: Well Vote for Candidate Committed to Federalism, Diversity, Says UPU - THISDAY Newspapers - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- Attorney General Knudsen fights Biden administration rule requiring states to reach net-zero highway emissions - Montana Department of Justice - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- How Scotland can learn from Quebec's third way on constitution - HeraldScotland - October 15th, 2022 [October 15th, 2022]
- Federalism and Why Presidents Fail - THISDAY Newspapers - September 22nd, 2022 [September 22nd, 2022]
- Vedanta and the missing spirit of federalism - The New Indian Express - September 22nd, 2022 [September 22nd, 2022]
- Federalism Most Suited Idea For India In View Of Its Diversity, Centralising Whole Things Will Lead To... - Live Law - Indian Legal News - September 22nd, 2022 [September 22nd, 2022]
- Urging the Use of One Federal Decision Rule to Speed Up Bipartisan Infrastructure Law Projects - Kevin Cramer - September 22nd, 2022 [September 22nd, 2022]
- Constitution Day 2022: Celebrating the right to govern ourselves - Yellowhammer News - September 22nd, 2022 [September 22nd, 2022]
- From Augusta Constitution Day: What does it mean to you? - Press Herald - September 22nd, 2022 [September 22nd, 2022]
- Explained | The office of the Governor: its origins, powers, and controversies - The Hindu - September 22nd, 2022 [September 22nd, 2022]
- Geography Professional Speaker Series kicks off with alumnus from Ohio EPA on Sept. 23 - Ohio University - September 22nd, 2022 [September 22nd, 2022]
- Vector-borne diseases trouble Nepal every year as there is not a single entomologist - Online Khabar (English) - September 22nd, 2022 [September 22nd, 2022]
- The Gujarat factor in the development project - Hindustan Times - September 22nd, 2022 [September 22nd, 2022]
- The downslide in federal relations - The Indian Express - September 22nd, 2022 [September 22nd, 2022]
- Competition between states to attract investment will boost Indias economy - Moneycontrol - September 22nd, 2022 [September 22nd, 2022]
- For state of the nation, look at states of the nation: Niti Aayogs new chief says it will help states learn - Times of India - September 22nd, 2022 [September 22nd, 2022]
- Letters to the Editor: Queen injected vitality, vigour into lives of many - The Kingston Whig-Standard - September 22nd, 2022 [September 22nd, 2022]
- Climate action that runs on cooperative federalism - The Hindu - September 15th, 2022 [September 15th, 2022]
- The spirit of federalism - The News International - September 15th, 2022 [September 15th, 2022]
- Javier Perez Sandoval Receives the 2022 William Anderson Award - - Political Science Now - September 15th, 2022 [September 15th, 2022]
- A new Constitutional Convention is a very bad idea | Opinion - Knoxville News Sentinel - September 15th, 2022 [September 15th, 2022]
- Rodney Hero Receives the 2022 Barbara Sinclair Lecture Award - - Political Science Now - September 15th, 2022 [September 15th, 2022]
- Department of the Interior, Fish and Wildlife Service: Migratory Bird Hunting; 20222023 Seasons for Certain Migratory Game Birds - Government... - September 15th, 2022 [September 15th, 2022]
- Increasing Threat To Federalism From Centrally Sponsored Schemes- Need To Form A Federal Front - Countercurrents.org - September 3rd, 2022 [September 3rd, 2022]
- Breakenridge: Supporting federalism is the only way Alberta can be a partner in LNG exports - Calgary Herald - September 3rd, 2022 [September 3rd, 2022]
- Two tools for tracking the American Rescue Plans local and national impacts - Brookings Institution - September 3rd, 2022 [September 3rd, 2022]