‘Don’t Break my Prime?’ Actually, it’s time to move fast and break….Big Tech bobsullivan.net – Bob Sullivan.net

This, from the industry that loves to move fast and break things.

Amazon Prime is *incredibly* popular with Americans. How popular? There are more than 150 million members in the U.S, with many (most?) there to enjoy free* two-day shipping. Thats roughly equal to the number of Americans who VOTED in 2020. And Amazon is betting all 150 million will do almost anything to keep that free shipping including abandoning any pretense that they prefer to live in a free country that supports capitalism and free-market principles.

Dont Break Our Prime is a deeply cynical ad campaign thats being thrust onto your TVs and Internet space as pro-competition legislation makes its way through Congress. Amazons monopoly power has deeply hurt American small businesses for years and made Jeff Bezos so much money that his hobby is going to space but lately, the tech giants tactics at crushing competitors have kicked up a notch.

Amazons customer base is so large that many small companies *have* to sell products on their platform. Thats weird, because it makes Amazon both a fulfillment service *and* a retailer. There have long been accusations that Amazons data nerds study all these competitors on their platform, rip off their products, and then advantage Amazon brands when consumers search for items. More than accusations, actually. Congress recently made a criminal referral about this practice to the Department of Justice.

The kind, gentle term for this minus the sneaky data harvesting is self-preferencing. And yes, some supermarkets put their own brand of toilet paper on the best shelf, right there next to the Charmin. If there were a few dozen Amazon-like services out there, self-preferencing there wouldnt be so bad. But since Amazon has 150 MILLION U.S. MEMBERS on Prime, its deeply anti-competitive. Kind of like owning most of the gas refineries, and most of the gas trucks, and most of the gas stations.

So the U.S. Senate is considering legislation that would ban this practice of advantaging its own products over competitors. Both Democrats and Republicans support the idea.

Amazon has now come out swinging. As is tradition with such campaigns, it is not attacking the premise of the bill. Its hitting consumers in an emotional spot, with the message that given all these concerns about inflation, and supply chains, and the pandemic now would be a terrible time to lose Amazon Primes free shipping! Dont Break Our Prime!

What are the particulars of this argument? Please read up on it.Heres a position piece from Project Disco (?) which attempts to explain why Amazon NEEDS its anti-competitive behavior in order to provide two-day shipping. And heres a Wired piece that does a good job of debunking that press release.

It should be clear that this isnt about two-day shipping. Rather, Amazon is hoping the popularity of Prime gives it enough clout to beat back, or at least delay, reasonable efforts at reform.

This is just the tip of the spear, however. Tech industry lobbyists are using this Dont Break Our Tech model to defend the status quo in the face of various reform efforts. Google serves up the most self-serving links, rather than the best links, it has engaged in ad bid-rigging, its business has been called the biggest data breach of all time,but if Congress messes with that, maps wont work! Your privacy will be violated. Also, China will become more powerful!

These are emotionally compelling arguments; they just might work. But as you begin to see all these Dont Break Our messages, please keep something in mind. Silicon Valley invented the phrase move fast and break things. So its deeply ironic that Big Tech firms are suddenly afraid of trying new things that might break something.

The techlash is real. Human beings are realizing that for all the great gifts tech has given us, there are serious costs. The pendulum has swung too far. Big Tech companies arent the only source of trouble, but they are a good place to start. Tech companies are so large they dont really have to answer to anyone right now. Facebook paid a $5 billion fine for ignoring a consent decree with the Federal Trade Commission anddidnt really change anything. Its time to draw some boundaries around the monoliths. As Harvards Francella Ochillo said to me in my recent docu-podcast, Defending Democracy from Big Tech, while we keep arguing about the details, these firms are making billions of dollars. We want techland to be free for competition. To do that, were going to have to break (up) a few things. So what? Were on iPhone 13. The beta version of tech reform might not be perfect. Thats shouldnt stop us. The cost of inaction is far too high. Im here for v2.0, and 3.0 and 13 pro! You should be, too.

*Free shipping isnt free, of course. Prime costs money! The cost is built into the products you buy. As with Uber, the price is being (temporarily) subsidized by investment money, which is another way of saying its a Ponzi scheme. Also, Amazon drivers live awful lives because of Prime. Theres all that cardboard. Free is never free.

Like Loading...

Read the original post:

'Don't Break my Prime?' Actually, it's time to move fast and break....Big Tech bobsullivan.net - Bob Sullivan.net