Monthly Archives: March 2021

Police, Rioters Clash in West Coast Cities on Anniversary of Breonna Taylors Death – National Review

Posted: March 16, 2021 at 2:39 am

Federal law enforcement officers stand guard outside the Mark O. Hatfield U.S. Courthouse in Portland, Oregon, U.S., July 29, 2020. (Caitlin Ochs/Reuters)

Police clashed with rioters in Seattle and Los Angeles on Saturday night during demonstrations marking the one-year anniversary of the death of Breonna Taylor, an African-American resident of Louisville, Ky., in a police shooting.

Seattle police made a number of arrests during the clashes, as seen in footage captured by the Daily Caller. The police said 13 people were arrested on Saturday.

Rioters also vandalized businesses including a Starbucks, smashing the stores windows.

Rioters also clashed with police in Los Angeles. Two rioters jumped on to a police car, with one remaining on the hood as the car drove off, in footage shared by journalist Andy Ngo.

Los Angeles rioters also vandalized businesses overnight. The riot was backed in part by the Youth Liberation Front, a group that expressed support for riots in the summer of 2020 via its social media posts, Ngo claimed.

Meanwhile in Portland, Ore., some demonstrators attempted to tear down plywood boards erected outside the federal courthouse in the city. However, some protesters at the vigil for Taylor condemned violent conduct and called on rioters to go home, the local CBS affiliate reported.

Demonstrations marking the anniversary of Taylors death occurred in other cities without reports of violence. Taylor, an emergency-room technician, was shot by Louisville police officers at her apartment during a botched drug raid.

Police said that they identified themselves before entering the apartment, however Taylors boyfriend Kenneth Walker claimed that he didnt hear the police before they knocked down the apartment door. Believing there was an intruder, Walker, a licensed gun owner, opened fire on police, who returned fire and shot Taylor.

Taylors mother and other family members participated in a march in Louisville on Saturday commemorating her death. The march was peaceful.

Breonna Taylors death was a tragedy, a blow to her family, her community, and America, President Biden wrote on Twitter on Saturday. As we continue to mourn her, we must press ahead to pass meaningful police reform in Congress. I remain committed to signing a landmark reform bill into law.

Send a tip to the news team at NR.

Excerpt from:

Police, Rioters Clash in West Coast Cities on Anniversary of Breonna Taylors Death - National Review

Posted in Antifa | Comments Off on Police, Rioters Clash in West Coast Cities on Anniversary of Breonna Taylors Death – National Review

Rank and file officers claim Sarah Everard vigil infiltrated by members of XR and Antifa – Telegraph.co.uk

Posted: at 2:39 am

One of Britains most senior officers called for greater clarity about how police forces should deal with protests during the pandemic.

National Police Chiefs' Council chairman Martin Hewitt said balancing rights to protest with legal health regulations was complex and extremely challenging.

We want clarity so commanders on the ground can make those decisions in what are always very challenging circumstances," he said.

A senior police source said: There is a strong feeling in policing that the Government is throwing us under the bus. There was a strong view on Friday saying the vigil should not happen. Now they are stepping back and saying the scenes are awful.

We need a bit more clarity on what is okay and not okay. If you want us doing that at some protests but you don't want us doing it at other protests, are you looking for police to decide what is an acceptable protest and what is not? That's the mess we have been in.

However, a Government source countered that it was the ministers' role to set the laws, but it was for the police to determine how those rules should be applied.

Its not the Government's job to tell the police how to police protests. The exercise of police powers is a matter for the police force. Its up to the police to how they enforce the law, its not for Government to tell them, said the source.

Dame Cressida met members of the Reclaim these Streets campaign on Monday, who originally proposed the vigil, and refused their appeals to waive the fines of the women arrested on Saturday night.

I asked about waiving the fines for the women that were arrested on Saturday night, and her answer was 'absolutely not', said Jamie Klingler, one of the organisers.

"We feel that there's institutional misogyny and racism within the police and criminal justice system in the UK. Cressida Dick has lost our confidence and the confidence of women in the capital. There are no solutions forthcoming."

The Prime Minister confirmed his full confidence in Dame Cressida but described events at the vigil as "very distressing".

"The police do have a very, very difficult job. But there's no question the scenes that we saw were very distressing and so it is right that Tom Winsor, the inspector of constabulary, should do a full report into it. People have got to have confidence in the police and Tom's going to look at that."

See the original post here:

Rank and file officers claim Sarah Everard vigil infiltrated by members of XR and Antifa - Telegraph.co.uk

Posted in Antifa | Comments Off on Rank and file officers claim Sarah Everard vigil infiltrated by members of XR and Antifa – Telegraph.co.uk

This Week’s Comics: America’s Most Haunted Road, Therapy for the Dead, and Antifa Supersoldiers – The Portland Mercury

Posted: at 2:39 am

One of this weeks most intriguing new comic releases, Karmen, features at least one of those images, and its been long enough since I was numbed to the trope that I found myself unexpectedly affected by the sight of a gruesome, blood-spattered bathroom.

My eye was caught in general by some particularly dark titles this week. These are books that present tragedy and troubles in a way that feels far more genuine and mournful than 19-year-old Tarantino imitators whose greatest troubles in life are figuring out how to load celluloid into Bolex cameras.

Why does the sight of a body in a bathtub work in Karmen? Why do the dismemberments in Proctor Valley Road evoke real terror? Why did similar images fall so flat when repeated ad nauseam in film classes? I think its because these images are, fundamentally, troubling not gleeful or fun, as edgy indie projects from the late '90s presented them.

KARMEN

PROCTOR VALLEY ROAD

AND ALSO: SEX ED, NAUGHTY X-TEENS, AND COVID CHRONICLES

One of the most attractive new releases this week is Lets Talk About It, the latest invaluable sexy resource from Portlands Erika Moen and Matthew Nolan. If sex ed was actually good is how the book was described to me. Its a super-comprehensive sex-positive guide to questions likely on the minds of young adults and teens. Children of the Atom will be required reading for X-Men fans keeping up-to-date with that whole twisted family; and the anthology Batman Urban Legends will be required reading for fans of the growling billionaire who stalks the night. And if youre ready to reflect on the last year that weve lived through (Im personally still trying to avoid thinking about it), consider Covid Chronicles, an anthology of stories about people affected by the pandemic. (Not to be confused with another anthology with the same name; that one was more big-picture than this more intimate book.)

But wait, there's more! Thor and Loki: Double Trouble is a fabulous and fun story that positions the two characters where they work best, as bickering mismatched brothers. Also great is the second installment of the Aster series an action-adventure fantasy for young readers that is completely adorable on absolutely every page. And check out The Thud, an amazing and empathetic graphic novel based on a real-life town designed for people with developmental disabilities.

Visit link:

This Week's Comics: America's Most Haunted Road, Therapy for the Dead, and Antifa Supersoldiers - The Portland Mercury

Posted in Antifa | Comments Off on This Week’s Comics: America’s Most Haunted Road, Therapy for the Dead, and Antifa Supersoldiers – The Portland Mercury

NASA Hubble Space Telescope Reveals A Distant Planet May Be On Its Second Atmosphere – Mashable India

Posted: at 2:38 am

NASA revealed recently that scientists have found evidence with the help of NASA Hubble Space telescope that a planet orbiting a distant star may have lost its atmosphere and gained a second one through volcanic activity.

"It's super exciting because we believe the atmosphere that we see now was regenerated, so it could be a secondary atmosphere," said study co-author Raissa Estrela of NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) in Pasadena, California.

"We first thought that these highly irradiated planets could be pretty boring because we believed that they lost their atmospheres. But we looked at existing observations of this planet with Hubble and said, 'Oh no, there is an atmosphere there.'"

SEE ALSO: NASA Hubble Telescope Captures A Beautiful Evil Eye Galaxy In The Sky!

NASA states that the planet GJ 1132 b is hypothesized to have begun as a gaseous world with a thick hydrogen blanket of atmosphere. Starting out at several times the diameter of Earth, this so-called "sub-Neptune" is believed to have quickly lost its primordial hydrogen and helium atmosphere because of the intense radiation of the hot, young star it orbits.

Astronomers were really surprised to find that Hubble observed an atmosphere which, according to their theory, is a "secondary atmosphere". Scientists used a combination of direct observational evidence and inference with the help of computer modeling and found out that the atmosphere comprises molecular hydrogen, hydrogen cyanide, methane and also contains an aerosol haze. Moreover, modeling suggests the aerosol haze is based on photochemically produced hydrocarbons thats similar to smog on Earth.

The team of scientists working on this new discovery will publish their findings in an upcoming issue of The Astronomical Journal.

Continue reading here:
NASA Hubble Space Telescope Reveals A Distant Planet May Be On Its Second Atmosphere - Mashable India

Posted in Hubble Telescope | Comments Off on NASA Hubble Space Telescope Reveals A Distant Planet May Be On Its Second Atmosphere – Mashable India

Hubble Eyes Planet Thats Had Multiple Atmospheres – Nerdist

Posted: at 2:38 am

Using NASAs Hubble telescope, astronomers have observed an exoplanet that may have had two completely separate atmospheres in its lifetime. The exoplanet (that is, a planet outside our solar system), currently has an atmosphere gassed into existence from volcanoes and a roiling surface. But astronomers think some of that same atmosphere had a previous life; long before it was sucked into the planets mantle in the first place.

CNN reported on the discovery, which NASA recently announced. The astronomers say they used Hubble to observe the planet indirectly, detecting its atmospheric fingerprints thanks to the way they distort the light coming from its parent star.

The planetwhich has the ever-showy moniker, GJ 1132 borbits inside a star system 41 light-years away. And basically sounds like Mustafar from Star Wars.

Thanks to the gravitational pull from its parent star, as well as a nearby planet, GJ 1132 b is constantly subjected to tidal forces. That is, the gravitational pulls of both its parent star and the nearby planet are simultaneously tugging on GJ 1132, causing its crust to crack, its mantle to churn, and all of the subsequent volcanic activity. Which includes the outgassing of hydrogen, hydrogen cyanide, methane, and an aerosol haze.

NASA Goddard

In the planets past, however, the hydrogen from that toxic mix had another life as a blanket around GJ 1132. Using computer modeling, the astronomers think its likely GJ 1132 was once a sub-Neptune planet; that is a planet with a smaller radius than Neptune, but a larger mass. During this period of its life, it had an atmosphere of hydrogen and helium. But, thanks to the heat from its parent star, the helium blew off into space. The hydrogen, on the other hand, likely made its way into the planets magma mantle.

NASA says this is the first time astronomers have detected a secondary atmosphere on a planet outside of our solar system. Although well have to wait for the upcoming launch of the James Webb Telescope to observe GJ1132 directly. Using Webbs infrared vision, the astronomers think theyll even be able to see down to the planets surface. Which probably looks like an endless landscape of volcanoes and lava rivers. I.e. a great place to have a lightsaber duel.

NASA Goddard

Feature image: NASA, ESA, and R. Hurt (IPAC/Caltech)

Excerpt from:
Hubble Eyes Planet Thats Had Multiple Atmospheres - Nerdist

Posted in Hubble Telescope | Comments Off on Hubble Eyes Planet Thats Had Multiple Atmospheres – Nerdist

NASA’s Hubble telescope ‘on its last legs’ as faulty gear found in IT glitch – Daily Star

Posted: at 2:38 am

NASA's Hubble Space Telescope is "on its last legs" after scientists discovered faulty gear while carrying out checks following a computer glitch.

Scientists uncovered a safety door that had failed to close and a camera had been taken offline after the IT error saw Hubble enter "safe mode" on Sunday.

The space telescope, which has helped find black holes and determine the age of the universe since going into Earth's orbit in 1990, returned to operational mode in the early hours of Friday.

Space expert Neel Patel has said the glitch showed the historic telescope was on its "last legs".

He wrote in MIT Technology Review: "Sundays announcement does once again remind us that Hubble is old! It's three decades of service are more than anyone expected, and the telescope is on its last legs from here. How much longer does the observatory really have, and what happens when its finally gone?"

Space Telescope Science Institutes director Kenneth Sembach has predicted the Hubble could keep going until 2025.

Last April he wrote: "Being realistic, I think Hubbles got a good five years left. And were operating the observatory in a way meant to keep it scientifically productive out to 2025. Does this mean well get to 2025? No, something could go wrong tomorrow. This is the space business, after all. But, then again, maybe we could get to 2030."

A statement for the US space agency said: "Hubble entered safe mode on Sunday, March 7, shortly after 4 a.m. EST, following detection of a software error within the spacecrafts main computer.

"The mission operations team at NASAs Goddard Space Flight Center identified the software error in an enhancement recently uploaded to the spacecraft to help compensate for fluctuations from one of its gyroscopes.

"The team will update the software enhancement so the fix can be uploaded to the spacecraft in the future. In the meantime, the enhancement will be prohibited from being used.

Want all the latest shocking news and views from all over the world straight into your inbox?

We've got the best royal scoops, crime dramas and breaking stories - all delivered in that Daily Star style you love.

Our great newsletters will give you all you need to know, from hard news to that bit of glamour you need every day. They'll drop straight into your inbox and you can unsubscribe whenever you like.

You can sign up here - you won't regret it...

"In entering safe mode on Sunday, however, the team discovered that the aperture door located at the top of the telescope failed to automatically close."

See more here:
NASA's Hubble telescope 'on its last legs' as faulty gear found in IT glitch - Daily Star

Posted in Hubble Telescope | Comments Off on NASA’s Hubble telescope ‘on its last legs’ as faulty gear found in IT glitch – Daily Star

There might be many planets with water-rich atmospheres – UChicago News

Posted: at 2:38 am

An atmosphere is what makes life on Earths surface possible, regulating our climate and sheltering us from damaging cosmic rays. But although telescopes have counted a growing number of rocky planets, scientists had thought most of their atmospheres long lost.

However, a new study by University of Chicago and Stanford University researchers suggests a mechanism whereby these planets could not only develop atmospheres full of water vapor, but keep them for long stretches. Published March 15 in the Astrophysical Journal Letters, the research expands our picture of planetary formation and could help direct the search for habitable worlds in other star systems.

Our model is saying that these hot, rocky exoplanets should have a water-dominated atmosphere at some stage, and for some planets, it may be quite a long time, said Asst. Prof. Edwin Kite, an expert in how planetary atmospheres evolve over time.

As telescopes document more and more exoplanets, scientists are trying to figure out what they might look like. Generally, telescopes can tell you about an exoplanets physical size, its proximity to its star and if youre lucky, how much mass it has. To go much further, scientists have to extrapolate based on what we know about Earth and the other planets in our own solar system. But the most abundant planets dont seem to be similar to the ones we see around us.

What we already knew from the Kepler mission is that planets a little smaller than Neptune are really abundant, which was a surprise because there are none in our solar system, Kite said. We dont know for sure what they are made of, but theres strong evidence they are magma balls cloaked in a hydrogen atmosphere.

Theres also a healthy number of smaller rocky planets that are similar, but without the hydrogen cloaks. So scientists surmised that many planets probably start out like those larger planets that have atmospheres made out of hydrogen, but lose their atmospheres when the nearby star ignites and blows away the hydrogen.

But lots of details remain to be filled out in those models. Kite and co-author Laura Schaefer of Stanford University began to explore some of the potential consequences of having a planet covered in oceans of melted rock.

Liquid magma is actually quite runny, Kite said, so it also turns over vigorously, just like oceans on Earth do. Theres a good chance these magma oceans are sucking hydrogen out of the atmosphere and reacting to form water. Some of that water escapes to the atmosphere, but much more gets slurped up into the magma.

Then, after the nearby star strips away the hydrogen atmosphere, the water gets pulled out into the atmosphere instead in the form of water vapor. Eventually, the planet is left with a water-dominated atmosphere.

This stage could persist on some planets for billions of years, Kite said.

There are several ways to test this hypothesis. The James Webb Space Telescope, the powerful successor to the Hubble Telescope, is scheduled to launch later this year; it will be able to conduct measurements of the composition of an exoplanets atmosphere. If it detects planets with water in their atmospheres, that would be one signal.

Another way to test is to look for indirect signs of atmospheres. Most of these planets are tidally locked; unlike Earth, they dont spin as they move around their sun, so one side is always hot and the other cold.

A pair of UChicago alumni have suggested a way to use this phenomenon to check for an atmosphere. Scientists Laura Kreidberg, PhD16, and Daniel Koll, PhD16now at the Max Planck Institute for Astronomy and MIT, respectivelypointed out that an atmosphere would moderate the temperature for the planet, so there wouldnt be a sharp difference between the day sides and night sides. If a telescope can measure how strongly the day side glows, it should be able to tell whether theres an atmosphere redistributing heat.

Citation: Water on hot rocky exoplanets. Kite and Schaefer, Astrophysical Journal Letters, March 11, 2021.

Funding: NASA.

Continued here:
There might be many planets with water-rich atmospheres - UChicago News

Posted in Hubble Telescope | Comments Off on There might be many planets with water-rich atmospheres – UChicago News

US stocks move higher with help from Big Tech companies – WBRZ

Posted: March 11, 2021 at 12:36 pm

Technology stocks were pushing the broader market solidly higher on Thursday, as investors welcomed another reprieve from the volatility in the bond market that has dominated the conversation on Wall Street for the last several weeks.

The S&P 500 index rose 1.2% as of 10:55 a.m. Eastern. The Dow Jones Industrial Average rose 1% and the technology-heavy Nasdaq Composite was up 2.1%.

Big Tech stocks, which have been hurt this year by rising bond rates, were among the biggest gainers. Apple was up 1.5%, Microsoft rose 1.7% and Googles parent company Alphabet was up more than 2%.

The recent return of stability to the bond market has been reassuring investors after a sudden spike in long-term interest rates over the past month prompted traders to dump tech shares, which started to look expensive after months of gigantic gains.

Up until this week, bond yields have been steadily climbing higher as investors made big bets that trillions of dollars of coming government stimulus will result in strong economic growth later this year and potentially some amount of inflation. As of Thursday morning, the yield on the 10-year Treasury note was 1.53%, roughly where it has been all week. That yield struck the psychologically important 1.60% mark late last week.

The House approved thesweeping pandemic relief packageover Republican opposition on Wednesday, sending it to President Joe Biden to be signed into law. The package would provide $1,400 checks for most Americans and direct billions of dollars to schools, state and local governments, and businesses.

General Electric fell 7%, after falling sharply the day before. The industrial titan announced it would wind down its GE Capital business and merge its jet leasing business with Irelands AerCap. GE is in the midst of a multi-year turnaround plan, but investors have been concerned GE has been selling off too many of its more profitable assets.

The biggest IPO in years is rolling out Thursday on the New York Stock Exchange where Coupang, the South Korean equivalent of Amazon in the U.S., or Alibaba in China, will begin trading under the ticker CPNG. Its actually the largest initial public offering from an Asian company since Alibaba went public about seven years ago. And its the biggest in the U.S. since Uber raised more than $8 billion in 2019.

Read more from the original source:

US stocks move higher with help from Big Tech companies - WBRZ

Posted in Big Tech | Comments Off on US stocks move higher with help from Big Tech companies – WBRZ

Why Big Tech is facing regulatory threats from Australia to Arizona – Ars Technica

Posted: at 12:36 pm

Jackie Niam | Getty Images

Last week, Arizona's House of Representatives approved legislation to prohibit platform owners like Apple and Google from locking app makers into their own payment systems. The bill passed only narrowly, and it must be approved by the Arizona Senate and Gov. Doug Ducey before it can become law. But regardless of the bill's ultimate fate, the vote is the latest sign of a dramatic shift in public attitudes toward Silicon Valley's most powerful companies.

For the first two decades of the Internet era, there was a broad consensus that politicians shouldn't tie Silicon Valley companies down with burdensome rules and regulations. Companies like Apple, Amazon, Google, and Uber were widely admired. In 2007, presidential candidates from both parties made pilgrimages to associate themselves with Google. In 2015, Jeb Bush, Ted Cruz, and other Republican hopefuls tripped over each other to position themselves as the most Uber-friendly candidate.

But all that is changing. Products like YouTube, the iPhone, and ride-hailing apps have become banal parts of modern life. The companies behind them are widely considered entrenched incumbents. And so the public and their elected representatives increasingly treat them like other big, powerful companies. Politicians score points by railing against them. Proposals to rein them in sometimes poll well.

The next few years are going to be particularly challenging for companies like Apple, Google, Facebook, and Uber because they are global companies. They not only have to worry about antitrust lawsuits by the US federal government, they also face heavy scrutiny from US states and from foreign governments around the world. For the tech giants, there's a danger that a policy experiment in one jurisdiction could become a precedent that's copied around the world.

Back in 2016, the city of Austin, Texas, wanted Uber and Lyft to fingerprint driversa rule that already applied to regular taxi drivers in the city. The idea was approved by 56 percent of the city's voters. Uber and Lyft responded by going nuclearshutting down their Austin operations until the city changed its rules.

Austin officials argued they were simply requiring Uber and Lyft to play by the same rules as other taxi providers. But many members of the public, especially customers of the services, bought into a different narrative: that Austin officials were out of touch and hostile to modern technology. Having a significant part of the public behind them gave Uber and Lyft a lot of powerpower Uber and Lyft ultimately used to get the state legislature to override Austin's rules.

This wasn't a one-off victory. It's a playbook the companies used over and over again in their early years. Uber and Lyft would frequently swoop into a new metropolitan area without worrying too much about local taxi regulations. Spending millions in venture capital, they'd try to build up a customer base as quickly as possible. City officials feared a backlash from these customers, and they didn't want to be seen as standing in the way of progress. So they almost always relented.

This strategy has become less effective in recent years. Partly that's because activists have generated more negative press for these firms. Once the gusher of venture-funded subsidies dried up, driving for Uber or Lyft proved to be a low-paying and precarious gig. Critics have also highlighted the problem of sexual assaults occurring in Uber and Lyft vehiclesalthough it's not clear if Uber and Lyft have a bigger problem here than traditional taxis.

But perhaps the most important shift is that Uber and Lyft are no longer seen as underdogs. In the early 2010s, these companies' survival still seemed like an open question. Customers worried that incumbent taxi companies would use antiquated regulations to smother them in the cradle. So when Uber and Lyft argued that a particular regulation could force them to leave a city or state, customers believed them, and some lobbied their elected officials to back off.

As a result, the companies are finding it more and more difficult to beat back efforts to regulate their business practices. In 2019, California passed legislation requiring Uber and Lyft to treat their drivers as employees. As they've done in the past, Uber and Lyft threatened to shut down their services if voters didn't overturn the law. Voters ultimately approved a ballot measure sponsored by Uber and Lyft. But Uber and Lyft were forced to make some tactical concessions; the voter-approved measures offered gig-economy drivers some added protections.

And things are going even worse for Uber outside the United States. Last month the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom ruled that Uber can't treat its drivers like independent contractors. Courts in France and Spain have reached similar conclusionsthough Uber seems to still be resisting a switch to an employee model in France.

Last year, Massachusetts filed a lawsuit against Uber and Lyft arguing that their drivers are employees under state law. A class-action lawsuit in Ontario makes a similar claim.

In each of these jurisdictions, a key Uber argument is that enforcing traditional labor law will break Uber's on-demand business model. That argument is hard to evaluate, since Uber has mostly been successful in defeating these efforts. But Uber will very likely need to change how it does business in the UK, France, Spain, and probably other jurisdictions in the coming years.

If Uber manages to come up with a viable model that treats drivers as employees, it will face pressure to adopt the same model in other cities. Though, of course, the opposite is also possible: maybe a switch to an employee-based model will make Uber's service dramatically worse in places like France and Spain, strengthening Uber's case in future battles.

Continued here:

Why Big Tech is facing regulatory threats from Australia to Arizona - Ars Technica

Posted in Big Tech | Comments Off on Why Big Tech is facing regulatory threats from Australia to Arizona – Ars Technica

The House Judiciary Committee Takes on Big Tech – JD Supra

Posted: at 12:36 pm

Mark my words: Change is coming. Laws are coming. That was the warning David Cicilline (D-RI) the House Judiciary Antitrust, Commercial, and Administrative Law Subcommittee Chairman gave on February 25th at the first in a series of hearings following the Subcommittees 16-month probe into Big Techs gatekeeping power. This one, titled Reviving Competition, Part 1: Proposals to Address Gatekeeper Power and Lower Barriers to Entry Online, focused on three proposed reforms: interoperability and data portability requirements, nondiscrimination rules, and structural separation. The majority of the hearing witnesses, ranging from the CEO of Mapbox to the Director the Competition Advocacy Program at the Global Antitrust Institute, were clear supporters for these proposed reforms. While none are new ideas, each, if passed, would be a significant sea change in competition law.

Interoperability and Data Portability

Imposing interoperability and data portability is not a new idea. It already permeates our technological world. For example, telecommunications would not be possible without one users carrier networks interconnecting with other carrier networks. The Subcommittees proposal is to impose interoperability and data portability requirements. Applied to Big Tech, interoperability and data portability would require dominant platforms to make their services compatible with other networks, and make content and information portable between them. Snap Inc.s 2019 Annual Report illustrates this concern: [T]he vast majority of our computing [runs] on Google Cloud and AWS, and our systems are not fully redundant on the two platforms. Any transition of the cloud services currently provided by either Google Cloud or AWS to the other platform or to another cloud provider would be difficult to implement and will cause us to incur significant time and expense. Witnesses testified that interoperability requirements should be tailored, requiring technical detail and frequent updates to address changing technology. There was also some support from witnesses for Congress to give an agency rulemaking authority to oversee interoperability for gatekeeping platforms. Congress may like the idea of interoperability, but implementation is another question. What will count as a gatekeeping platform? How much interoperability will be required? How will any such requirements balance a need for access without deflating the incentive to create market-changing platforms in the first place?

Nondiscrimination Requirements

The nondiscrimination requirements proposed by the Subcommittee are two-fold. First, dominant platforms would be prohibited from engaging in self-dealing. Second, dominant platforms would be required to offer equal terms for products and services that are equal. Apple, for example, can give preference to its owns apps in an app store that it also runs, to the detriment of third-party offerings. Nondiscrimination requirements is not a new idea either. They play important roles in facilitating transportation and communications. For example, the Federal Communications Commissions Open Internet Order implemented nondiscrimination principles in prohibiting internet service providers from blocking or discriminating between lawful content on the internet. Advocates of a nondiscrimination regime also support a tribunal to police discrimination, which could require a recidivist discriminator to sell off a content arm of its business, and a private right of action to victims discriminated against by dominate platforms.

Structural Separation

Structural separation would prohibit certain dominant platforms from operating in an adjacent line of business. In other words, one could not be both a platform and own the content on the platform. By mandating separation, the idea is to remove perceived conflicts of interest between platforms competing with those that depend on them for access to customers. The Subcommittee also discussed using structural separation to introduce competition where a dominate platforms could both lock in users and keep competition out by tying products and service. Structural separation has also been imposed to restore competition in the past, namely in the railroad industry, under the Bank Holding Company Act of 1956, and with the breakup of AT&Ts Bell System.

* * * *

As one witness pointed out, [t]his is not the first time that Americans have heard proposals to apply the existing antitrust laws or extend them to limit or reduce perceived excessive concentrations of economic power. Political realities are in play just as much as legal ones. Without harnessing some bipartisan support, antitrust reform is unlikely as long as the legislative filibuster remains. Interest in antitrust reform is undoubtedly on the rise, but only time will tell if we are at the dawn of a new era, or just at high noon in the constant cycle of antitrust enforcement.

[View source.]

Read more from the original source:

The House Judiciary Committee Takes on Big Tech - JD Supra

Posted in Big Tech | Comments Off on The House Judiciary Committee Takes on Big Tech – JD Supra