Major employers and universities across the U.S. have comfortably relied on legal precedent that supports mandating a COVID-19 vaccine for workers and students. However, when New York City becomes the first government in the country to ban unvaccinated people from indoor restaurants, gyms, and entertainment venues, it opens up a new legal debate.
On Tuesday, New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio announced the plan, which will go into effect on Aug. 16. Legal experts told Yahoo Finance that the rule will test the authority of a 1905 Supreme Court case that gave states a broad yet still limited right to uphold compulsory vaccination laws.
We should all keep in mind that the courts jurisprudence is still unsettled, Jim Oleske, professor at Lewis & Clark Law School, told Yahoo Finance. I think that no matter what [New York Citys] final rule looks like...it's going to get challenged.
While the New York City rule is scheduled to go into effect on Aug. 16, enforcement will begin Sept. 13 and will be up to the city's health department rather than the city's police force.
When announcing the rule, de Blasio said, This is going to be a requirement. The only way to patronize these establishments indoors, will be, if you're vaccinated at least one dose. The same for folks in terms of work they'll need at least one dose.
Mayor Bill de Blasio says NYC will mandate the COVID-19 vaccine to enter restaurants and fitness centers. (Photo by SBN/STAR MAX/IPx)
Legal scholars and practitioners say that while there's a strong foundation for states and local governments to adopt and enforce their own vaccination policies, the foundation isnt unshakable.
The coming challenges are expected to raise some of the arguments already brought against COVID-19 mandates in lawsuits across the country, and ultimately force courts to grapple with the 1905 Supreme Court decision, Jacobson v. Massachusetts. In Jacobson, the court said that states, under their police power, could require the smallpox vaccine.
Story continues
Jacobson is an old case, and how much force it will have, I think it depends, Oleske said.
Most ripe for debate, Oleske said, is whether state and local governments need to provide exceptions to mandatory vaccination policies either to protect the constitutional right to the free exercise of religion, or to protect the constitutional right under the Due Process clause to remain free from bodily interference.
University of California Hastings College of Law professor Dorit Rubinstein Reiss said another unsettled question is whether such government mandates are legal while inoculations remain under Emergency Use Authorization. Dr. Anthony Fauci told USA Today's editorial board on Friday that there will be a "flood" of vaccine mandates at schools and businesses after the vaccines receive full FDA approval.
She also expects debate over the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and whether it overrides a vaccine policy like New York City's, given that for places open to the public, like restaurants, fitness venues and entertainment spaces, it generally requires accommodations for people with disabilities.
"Those who cannot be vaccinated should not be punished for it," Reiss said. "I would be surprised if [New York City's] law did not include an exception."
While the CDC does not cite specific disabilities known to preclude people from getting a vaccine, the agency notes that some people may be allergic to ingredients in the COVID-19 vaccines. The agency also acknowledges it has limited or no vaccine safety data on individuals with certain underlying medical conditions, citing people with weakened immune systems, and more specifically, autoimmune conditions. Ultimately, the CDC says it recommends COVID-19 vaccination for "most people" with underlying medical conditions, especially those whose condition puts them at higher risk of severe infection.
Although the ADA does not name all impairments that qualify as disabilities, it does recognize HIV, specifically. The agency defines a person with a disability as "a person who has a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities, a person who has a history or record of such an impairment, or a person who is perceived by others as having such an impairment."
Several COVID-19 era cases have begun to establish rules amid the pandemic's uncharted legal waters.
In April, the Supreme Court rejected Californias restriction on private gatherings because it didnt exempt religious gatherings. The case exemplifies how much deference the court has been willing to give to those who challenge the validity of a state law aimed at protecting public health, based on religious grounds. In its decision, the court pointed out that the case marked the fifth time it had rejected the Ninth Circuits analysis of Californias COVID restrictions on religious exercise.
A federal district court decision in Texas that dealt with a private employer mandate, rather than one issued by the government, could also have bearing on how courts handle complaints that vaccines have yet to receive full FDA approval. The Texas court dismissed claims of hospital employees who argued that because of the attenuated approval of vaccines, their employers' mandate forced them to either lose their jobs or unwillingly participate in a medical experiment. The case is unique in that it upheld an employer's rule despite no accommodation for workers who raised objections based on disability.
In another decision, handed down in August, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit upheld Indiana Universitys right to require student vaccinations for those on campus, reasoning that students could choose to remain unvaccinated and not attend, or another school.
Bill Gordon, a lawyer for King & Spalding who advises companies and individuals on state and local government rules, speculates that New York City may not be legally required to offer exceptions, specifically if its vaccination mandate is limited to restaurants, gyms, and entertainment venues.
Like the Indiana case (which said students could choose not to attend the University), the argument will be that it's not necessary to go to a restaurant, and it's not necessary to go to a movie theater, he explained. That being said, it's possible that they will have had some limited exceptions.
Gordon added that if the legality of New York City's mandate were to be challenged in federal court, the analysis would probably look slightly different than the one in Jacobson.
Courts would likely use the rational basis test, Gordon said, referring to a minimum standard that requires governments to show that a law or ordinance is "rationally related" to a legitimate government interest. In 1905, the court required the ordinance to be "reasonable."
Rubinstein Reiss said at a minimum, under either standard, when a government seeks to make vaccination mandatory, she expects a medical exception to be a legal must.
"In terms of medical exemptions, Jacobson implied or strongly suggested that you may be required to give a medical exemption," Reiss said, emphasizing that the case left the door open for debate because it didn't deal directly with the question.
Beyond that, Oleske and Reiss say state and local vaccine mandates are likely going to need to include exceptions for those who decline vaccination on religious grounds.
If it does not include religious exemptions, there will almost certainly be constitutional claims brought under the Free Exercise Clause, Oleske said.
On more shaky ground, he said, will be any challenges claiming a general right to bodily integrity under the constitutions Due Process clause, which has been invoked in abortion and right to die cases.
"On that front, it's going to be very hard because the precedent from the Supreme Court has decided that issue, albeit in 1905," Oleske said.
Another issue that could open the door to legal challenges is how New York City goes about enforcing and penalizing its ban. City officials have yet to explain how they intend to enforce the rule or punish those who violate it. However, already settled in Jacobson was the state's right to impose a fine. The plaintiff who declined vaccination was fined $5, today's equivalent of approximately $150.
Alexis Keenan is a legal reporter for Yahoo Finance. Follow Alexis on Twitter @alexiskweed.
Follow Yahoo Finance on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Flipboard, SmartNews, LinkedIn, YouTube, and reddit.
Find live stock market quotes and the latest business and finance news
For tutorials and information on investing and trading stocks, check out Cashay
Read more:
NYC's vaccine mandate will test the authority of a 1905 Supreme Court case - Yahoo Finance
- 7 Social Security Shakeups You Need To Be Ready For Heading Into the New Year - Yahoo Finance - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Crypto had a surprisingly great year. It still faces threats in 2024. - Yahoo Finance - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- 'How the hell does that even happen?' McCarthy exits Congress amid confusion over who can run to replace him - Yahoo News - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Short sellers lost close to $178 billion in 2023 - Yahoo Finance - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Trump legal news brief: Giuliani files for bankruptcy after judge rules he must immediately pay $148 million for election ... - Yahoo News - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- No One Wants Used EVs, Making New Ones a Tougher Sell Too - Yahoo Finance - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Israel's military campaign in Gaza seen as among the most destructive in recent history, experts say - Yahoo News - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Barbara Corcoran Says Housing Prices 'Are Going To Go Through the Roof' But When? - Yahoo Finance - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Are You Wealthy? The Net Worth You Need To Be Considered Poor, Middle-Class And Wealthy In America - Yahoo Finance - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- German bishop Btzing criticizes pope over Ukraine and Israel stance - Yahoo News - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- 'Severe revenue decline': California faces a record $68 billion deficit here's what is eating away at the Golden State's ... - Yahoo Finance - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Poll: Trump is tied with Biden for now but criminal trials and unpopular plans pose risks for 2024 - Yahoo News - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Rudy Giuliani files for bankruptcy days after being ordered to pay $148 million in defamation case - Yahoo News - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- 'It's just bragging rights': Once you achieve this credit score there's 'no benefit' to scoring higher, expert says here are ... - Yahoo Finance - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Records released by House Republicans show that Joe Biden repeatedly emailed Hunter Biden's business associate ... - Yahoo News - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Tesla Getting Trounced by S&P 500 Three Years After Joining - Yahoo Finance - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Ukrainian forces shoot down three Russian Su-34 fighter jets on southern front - Yahoo News - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- The only AI 'regulation' coming is from workers - Yahoo Finance - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Innocent Black Man Spent 50 Years in Prison, His Compensation Will Annoy The Hell out of You - Yahoo News - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Texas begins flying migrants from southern border to Chicago. The 1st plane carried over 120 people - Yahoo News - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Donald Trump Is Running Scared - Yahoo News - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- The biggest 2024 threat to Big Tech is coming from both sides of the Atlantic - Yahoo Finance - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- Apple halts online sales of its Apple Watch Series 9 and Apple Watch Ultra 2 - Yahoo Finance - December 22nd, 2023 [December 22nd, 2023]
- 2023 FIBA World Cup: Jaren Jackson Jr.'s elite rim protection and defensive presence come with a price - Yahoo Sports - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- Fantasy Football Rankings: These are the hardest players to ... - Yahoo Sports - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- Cowboys QB Dak Prescott feels for Will Grier after Trey Lance deal, not worried about future in Dallas - Yahoo Sports - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- Massive alligator captured in Mississippi is a new state record. Nightmare material - Yahoo! Voices - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- Virginia Gov. Youngkin eyes a 15-week abortion ban as a 'consensus' voters would back - Yahoo News - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- Poll: Trump could be in big trouble for 2024 if convicted of crimes - Yahoo News - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- 'She-Hulk' star Tatiana Maslany nearly brought to tears after overcoming fears of heights and cold with the help of Bear Grylls - Yahoo Entertainment - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- Don't feel guilty about being lazy. Experts say there are some health benefits. - Yahoo Life - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- Center Paolo Banchero helps Team USA power past physical New Zealand in FIBA World Cup - Yahoo Sports - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- Tyreek Hill says Tua's response to ESPN criticism 'fires me up,' shows Dolphins something they've never seen - Yahoo Sports - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- USA's Katie Moon, Australia's Nina Kennedy agree to share pole vault gold after tie atop World Athletics Championships - Yahoo Sports - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- Blue Jays' Bo Bichette, Matt Chapman leave game vs. Guardians with injuries - Yahoo Sports - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- Benches clear twice as Rays roll past Yankees 7-4: 'It's a last-place team' - Yahoo Sports - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- All-Pro Chris Jones says hes willing to extend Chiefs holdout through Week 8 - Yahoo Sports - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- Fyre Festival II: Andy King confirms he's working with Billy McFarland for 'redemption'; 1st drop sells out - Yahoo Entertainment - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- Pirates first overall pick Paul Skenes doesn't make it out of 1st inning in Double-A debut - Yahoo Sports - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- U.S. men and women sweep gold in 4x100m relay at World Championships - Yahoo Sports - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- Spain soccer president Luis Rubiales apologizes for kissing player, as calls for his resignation mount - Yahoo Sports - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- COVID cases are rising. What are schools doing about it? - Yahoo Life - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- Nicolas Batum ashamed and scared to go home after France is knocked out of FIBA World Cup - Yahoo Sports - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- Tour Championship: How much did Viktor Hovland, others earn at East Lake? - Yahoo Sports - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- The Daily Sweat: Cubs get chance to cut into streaking Brewers' NL Central lead - Yahoo Sports - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- NASCAR: Chris Buescher wins at Daytona after Ryan Preece's car flips at least 10 times in terrifying crash - Yahoo Sports - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- With college sports more in flux than ever before, new players association group emerges - Yahoo Sports - August 28th, 2023 [August 28th, 2023]
- NFL Hall of Fame Game: How to watch the 2023 NFL preseason opener - Yahoo Sports - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- 2023 NFL preseason: How to watch, full schedule, streaming info and more - Yahoo Sports - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- Reports: Colts considering placing Jonathan Taylor on NFI list, which could negate his 2023 salary - Yahoo Sports - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- Sources: Michigan's Jim Harbaugh, NCAA working toward 4-game suspension over recruiting investigation - Yahoo Sports - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- Oregon coach Dan Lanning slams Colorado after move to Big 12: I dont remember them winning anything - Yahoo Sports - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- As Bethenny Frankel calls for reality show performers to strike, 'Below Deck' star Captain Lee is only partly on board - Yahoo Entertainment - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- Ken Riley, Bengals' all-time INT leader, finally gets his flowers ... - Yahoo Sports - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- Broncos WR K.J. Hamler shares pericarditis diagnosis, will reportedly be waived with eye for return - Yahoo Sports - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- Sexist remarks from radio host enable Commanders to set tone that things are different after Dan Snyder - Yahoo Sports - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- Fantasy Football: What is the correct way to draft from these muddy NFL RB committees? - Yahoo Sports - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- Yahoo boys on rampage: The youth and Internet scam - Guardian Nigeria - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- NFL training camp tracker: WR Tim Patrick carted off at practice, Broncos fear Achilles injury - Yahoo Sports - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- Is winning the lottery all it's cracked up to be? - Yahoo News - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- Fantasy Football: How to avoid the most common draft mistakes in 2023 - Yahoo Sports - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- 2023 Hall of Fame: Don Coryell's offense changed the NFL, even if it didn't win a Super Bowl - Yahoo Sports - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- Giants' pass-catchers are wielding uncertainty to their advantage - Yahoo Sports - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- The USWNT diagnosed their biggest flaw in Dutch draw. Can they fix it? - Yahoo Sports - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- Julius Erving's all-time top 10 includes Tiny Archibald, no active players - Yahoo Sports - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- How to watch the Women's World Cup 2023: Full broadcast schedule, streaming info and more - Yahoo Sports - July 31st, 2023 [July 31st, 2023]
- 'Love Is Blind' star Deepti Vempati didn't talk about her eating disorder with family growing up: 'I used to live this double life' - Yahoo Life - March 4th, 2023 [March 4th, 2023]
- Ja Morant reportedly accused of repeatedly punching teenage boy in head, threatening him with gun last summer - Yahoo Sports - March 4th, 2023 [March 4th, 2023]
- Kyrie Irving and Kevin Durant's trade requests were about seeking control, but also came at a cost for the NBA - Yahoo Sports - February 20th, 2023 [February 20th, 2023]
- 'Winnie-the-Pooh: Blood and Honey' director shares details from the 'unfilmable' first draft of his bonkers horror movie - Yahoo Entertainment - February 18th, 2023 [February 18th, 2023]
- My party of 2 spent $210 to decorate a Mickey Mouse cake at Disney World. It was worth it for the mimosas and desserts alone. - Yahoo Life - February 18th, 2023 [February 18th, 2023]
- Kevin Durant is lone man standing amid Nets mess, and it's time to hit reset before things get uglier - Yahoo Sports - February 7th, 2023 [February 7th, 2023]
- This golden retriever has 'cooked' more than 400 meals. Here's how the dog's human taught him patience in the kitchen. - Yahoo Life - February 7th, 2023 [February 7th, 2023]
- Eagles lineman Brandon Graham fined more than Trent Williams for unsportsmanlike conduct in NFC championship - Yahoo Sports - February 7th, 2023 [February 7th, 2023]
- NASCAR Clash at the Coliseum: Martin Truex Jr. wins chaotic main event ahead of Austin Dillon, Kyle Busch - Yahoo Sports - February 7th, 2023 [February 7th, 2023]
- Kyrie Irving's trade request is logical move to secure his basketball future. Now Nets need to protect theirs - Yahoo Sports - February 5th, 2023 [February 5th, 2023]
- A decade ago, Colin Kaepernick commanded the Super Bowl stage and helped change the QB prototype conversation - Yahoo Sports - February 5th, 2023 [February 5th, 2023]
- M. Night Shyamalan on the 'power' of Bruce Willis, the movie he bet his house on, and his one film people watch on their deathbeds - Yahoo... - February 5th, 2023 [February 5th, 2023]
- Debt limit: Social Security is a hot topic even as the GOP says its off the table - Yahoo Finance - February 5th, 2023 [February 5th, 2023]
- Pamela Anderson's financial woes detailed in new doc: 'On the most famous show in the world' but 'doesn't have a nest egg' - Yahoo Entertainment - February 5th, 2023 [February 5th, 2023]