An opinion piece published on Livemint by Sandipan Deb claimed that COVID-19 will not affect Indians as they have the genetics for a sturdier immune system.
When questioned on Twitter, the author, also a founder of Swarajya Magazine, cited a Nature Asia article titled, More immunity in Indian genes, as his source.
The Nature Asia article (2008), based on the research study by Du and colleagues (2008), published in the journal Genes & Immunity was conducted by a team of scientists from the University of California in Los Angeles (UCLA), USA, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, India (AIIMS), and National Marrow Donor Program (NMDP), USA.
More immunity in Indian genes The title of Nature Asia magazine article.
Our bodies have one of the toughest immune systems in the world. We have grown up surrounded by so much filth and pollution that our natural resilience is much stronger than people in the developed world. Sandipan Deb in Livemint.
False.
1. The Livemint article is based on a superficial understanding of the title of the Nature Asia, not its text.
The Nature Asia article is titled More immunity genes in Indians. However, the article itself does not make any such claims that, on the basis of the research study quoted, that Indians will be protected from the coronavirus pandemic or other infections due to their biologically inherited resilience. It simply states that Indians may have more genes linked with immunity as per the data. Also, one of the authors of the article and the research study Rajalingam Raja wrote, Whether having more activating KIR genes is an advantage or disadvantage for Indians remains to be elucidated.
This means that the genes tested through this study are not a piece of conclusive evidence that the contested tougher immunity will be an advantage for Indians in any way.
2. The Nature Asia article is based on a research study based on a single gene polymorphism in various ethnicities.
The Nature Asia article is based on a research study which relies upon a single gene KIR2DL5 polymorphism in many ethnicities including Indian, East Asian, white (Caucasian) and black (African Americans), suggesting that the gene is not unique to Indians only. Also, no evidence suggests that the presence of gene translates to gene expression or phenotypic change (e.g. higher immunity) in this case.
Nature Asia article based its claim on a gene polymorphism study by Du and colleagues (2008). Genetic polymorphism is the occurrence of multiple forms of a single gene which is expressed in the same population as a trait or a phenotype (Bull, 2004). It is similar, but not the same, as varying levels of pigmentation in eyes, hair or skin colour.
The study quoted showed the nature of polymorphism of one gene KIR2DL5 in four ethnic groups: Caucasians (European race, mostly white), Asian-Indians (South Asians), African-Americans and Asians (East Asians, i.e. Korean, Vietnamese, Japanese and Filipino).
KIR2DL5 (or CD158f) is the last identified KIR gene (the inhibitory receptor expressed on the surface of immune cells), with KIR2DL4, it makes up a structurally divergent lineage conserved in different primate species such as humans. The percentage frequency of this KIR2DL5 gene in Indians is used as an indicator of higher immunity.
The graph from the research study illustrates that the percentage frequency of KIR2DL5 (A and B, polymorphic forms of KIR2DL5 gene) is higher in Asian Indians than the other ethnic populations studied. However, the graph below from the same study suggests that the Individuals carrying the KIR2DL5 gene vary substantially among populations ranging in frequency from 35-85%. Thus, as per the authors conclusions, higher immunity can be found in every ethnicity ranging from 35-85% population, not just in Indians.
Hence, with such large variability in genes in each population, it is impossible to deduce that the researchers certainly found the KIR2DL5 gene more frequently in Indian ethnicities, as compared to other ethnicities.
Also, the research paper doesnt claim that this higher frequency in Asian-Indians population is linked to a better immune system or more natural killer cells in the body. In fact, there are no conclusions drawn on any ethnic group being genetically superior or inferior regarding immunity.
3. Is the occurrence of genes (KIR2DL5 gene) linked with immunity synonymous with its traits (tougher immunity)?
The occurrence of more genes in a population isnt always synonymous with better traits. This is mainly because a greater amount of genes doesnt always translate to a protein abundance, which consequently becomes a trait. That is, the presence of genes doesnt always lead to the presence of characteristic traits related to the expression of the gene.
Sometimes, polymorphic changes in natural killer cells can also be associated with a susceptibility towards certain diseases (Orange, 2002). Thus, more correlative studies should be conducted where a higher frequency of KIR2DL5 gene results in an increased immunity regardless of ethnicity.
4. Smaller sample size
The beneficial effects of higher frequency of a polymorphic gene in a population can only be established after detailed protein, genomics and evolutionary studies with large sample size. But in this study, only 96 Indian genomes were studied as opposed to 250 Caucasians. Hence, these higher percent frequencies of polymorphs KIR2DL5 gene could also be an artefact resulting from a smaller sample size.
Only 96 non-randomised samples for the Asian-Indian group were sourced from New Delhi, which is a minuscule representation for the Indian population. These sample sizes were further reduced after identification of KIR2DL5 positive individuals.
Also, the Nature Asia article further claims that Indians gained the activating KIR (killer cell immunoglobulin-like receptors) genes because of natural selection to survive the environmental challenges during their pre-historic coastal migrations from Africa. This conclusion is not based on any evidence.
Dr Mehra, former Dean of AIIMS, in his opinion piece in The Print mentions the results from the same study that includes SK Sharma of AIIMS, to make his claims about the genetic advantage of Indians over Caucasians with respect to immunity against the coronavirus. Additionally, Dr Mehra also included other factors that may give Indians advantage broad-based immunity due to overexposure to other pathogens, and epigenetic factors such as environment and consumption of Indian spices in cuisine. However, since the novelty of the virus and the increasing pathogenesis of SARS-CoV-2 in India, these claims remain without any research or evidence in Science.
The Nature Asia article published a misleading title on the basis of a genetics study which was termed inconclusive by the authors in their own research study. This title formed the basis of the Livemint article by Mr Deb.
The Nature Asia authors generalised their misleading article about Natural Killer cells (NK) to immunity genes. Natural killer cells are a small component of what makes up human immunity, not the expansive immune system.
Later, in the Livemint article, the Nature Asia article was used to claim a blanket superiority of the immune system of Indians. Mr Deb stated that Indians immune system is more robust than the people in the developed world to tackle the coronavirus pandemic.
Such dangerous opinion pieces with no understanding of the genetics of immunity have the potential to drive people to be careless with the protocols issued by the government on social distancing and other precautions or to encourage reckless behaviour during a critical situation.
Du, Z., Sharma, S. K., Spellman, S., Reed, E. F., & Rajalingam, R. (2008). KIR2DL5 alleles mark certain combination of activating KIR genes. Genes & Immunity, 9(5), 470-480.
Bull, L. (2004). Genetics, Mutations, and Polymorphisms. Molecular Pathogenesis of Cholestasis, 77-95.
Estefana, E., Flores, R., Gmez-Lozano, N., Aguilar, H., Lpez-Botet, M., & Vilches, C. (2007). Human KIR2DL5 is an inhibitory receptor expressed on the surface of NK and T lymphocyte subsets. The Journal of Immunology, 178(7), 4402-4410.
Orange, J. S. (2002). Human natural killer cell deficiencies and susceptibility to infection. Microbes and infection, 4(15), 1545-1558.
Donate Now
Related
- Copy number variation of the restorer Rf4 underlies human selection ... - Nature.com - November 15th, 2023 [November 15th, 2023]
- NYU Langone Health in the NewsThursday, November 9, 2023 - NYU Langone Health - November 15th, 2023 [November 15th, 2023]
- Eugenics: Plaguing scientific community with dark history | Opinion ... - The Arkansas Traveler - November 15th, 2023 [November 15th, 2023]
- Cranberries can bounce, float and pollinate themselves: The saucy ... - Japan Today - November 15th, 2023 [November 15th, 2023]
- Government Housing Assistance Linked to Increased Cancer ... - HealthDay - November 15th, 2023 [November 15th, 2023]
- Rate of New Lung Cancer Cases Has Decreased Over Last Five Years - HealthDay - November 15th, 2023 [November 15th, 2023]
- Clinically relevant antibiotic resistance genes are linked to a limited ... - Nature.com - November 15th, 2023 [November 15th, 2023]
- Disparities in Guideline-Concordant Care Found for Black CRC ... - HealthDay - November 15th, 2023 [November 15th, 2023]
- Mathematician Heather Harrington is new director at the Max Planck ... - EurekAlert - November 15th, 2023 [November 15th, 2023]
- New study finds genetic testing can effectively identify patients with ... - EurekAlert - November 15th, 2023 [November 15th, 2023]
- STK11 loss leads to YAP1-mediated transcriptional activation in ... - Nature.com - November 15th, 2023 [November 15th, 2023]
- CRISPR-broad: combined design of multi-targeting gRNAs and ... - Nature.com - November 15th, 2023 [November 15th, 2023]
- Master regulator of the dark genome greatly improves cancer T-cell ... - Science Daily - November 15th, 2023 [November 15th, 2023]
- Omega Therapeutics Showcases Bidirectional and Multiplexed ... - BioSpace - November 15th, 2023 [November 15th, 2023]
- Today is International 15q Day - ASBMB Today - November 15th, 2023 [November 15th, 2023]
- Evolution of taste: Sharks were already able to perceive bitter ... - EurekAlert - November 15th, 2023 [November 15th, 2023]
- Stanford Scientists Uncover New Indicators of Health, Disease, and ... - SciTechDaily - October 16th, 2023 [October 16th, 2023]
- NHGRI Director Eric Green elected to the National Academy of ... - National Human Genome Research Institute - October 16th, 2023 [October 16th, 2023]
- Monkey survives for two years after gene-edited pig-kidney transplant - Nature.com - October 16th, 2023 [October 16th, 2023]
- Opinion: Interest in RNA Editing Accelerates as Therapies Approach ... - BioSpace - October 16th, 2023 [October 16th, 2023]
- Regulation of dermal fibroblasts by human neutrophil peptides ... - Nature.com - October 16th, 2023 [October 16th, 2023]
- Consistent effects of the genetics of happiness across the lifespan ... - Nature.com - October 16th, 2023 [October 16th, 2023]
- Storytelling through the looking glass of genetics The Stute - The Stute - October 16th, 2023 [October 16th, 2023]
- Pet dogs shed light on human health, researchers say - UPI News - October 16th, 2023 [October 16th, 2023]
- Native microbiome dominates over host factors in shaping the ... - Nature.com - October 16th, 2023 [October 16th, 2023]
- Illinois-led project to sequence soybean genomes, improve future ... - Herald-Whig - October 16th, 2023 [October 16th, 2023]
- Unrealized targets in the discovery of antibiotics for Gram-negative ... - Nature.com - October 16th, 2023 [October 16th, 2023]
- How Biotech And AI Are Transforming The Human - Noema Magazine - October 16th, 2023 [October 16th, 2023]
- The Many Lives of Alexandria Forbes - BioSpace - October 16th, 2023 [October 16th, 2023]
- CEP20 promotes invasion and metastasis of non-small cell lung ... - Nature.com - October 16th, 2023 [October 16th, 2023]
- Genotyping, sequencing and analysis of 140,000 adults from Mexico ... - Nature.com - October 16th, 2023 [October 16th, 2023]
- The role and impact of alternative polyadenylation and miRNA ... - Nature.com - October 16th, 2023 [October 16th, 2023]
- Human - Simple English Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - January 30th, 2023 [January 30th, 2023]
- Deep Dive Ties Together Dog Genetics, Brain Physiology and Behavior to Explain Why Collies Are Different from Terriers - Scientific American - December 12th, 2022 [December 12th, 2022]
- How oxytocin drives connections of newly integrated adult-born neurons: Research - Hindustan Times - December 12th, 2022 [December 12th, 2022]
- Alzheimer's Disease Genetics Fact Sheet - National Institute on Aging - December 2nd, 2022 [December 2nd, 2022]
- Human genetic clustering - Wikipedia - November 23rd, 2022 [November 23rd, 2022]
- Human Genome Project Fact Sheet - November 23rd, 2022 [November 23rd, 2022]
- Abstracts | International Congress of Human Genetics 2023 - November 23rd, 2022 [November 23rd, 2022]
- Ancient DNA and Neanderthals | The Smithsonian Institution's Human ... - November 16th, 2022 [November 16th, 2022]
- Biological Influences on Human Behavior: Genetics & Environment - November 16th, 2022 [November 16th, 2022]
- Fluent BioSciences showcasing breakthrough solutions to enable unprecedented scale, cost-efficiency and access for single-cell RNA sequencing at the... - October 28th, 2022 [October 28th, 2022]
- Human behaviour genetics - Wikipedia - October 23rd, 2022 [October 23rd, 2022]
- Nucleome Therapeutics raises oversubscribed 37.5 million Series A financing to decode the dark matter of the human genome and deliver first-in-class... - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- Gladstone data scientist elected to the National Academy of Medicine - EurekAlert - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- Ocugen to Host R&D Day in New York City on Tuesday, November 1, 2022 - Yahoo Finance - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- Pharmacy researcher earns $2.3 million NIH award to study opioid addiction - EurekAlert - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- Study shows age often plays a bigger role than genetics in gene expression and susceptibility to disease - Anti Aging News - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- CSRWire - Direct Relief, Amgen and C/Can Team Up To Improve Access to Breast Cancer Diagnostics and Treatment in Paraguay - CSRwire.com - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- Maze Therapeutics Appoints Harold Bernstein, M.D., Ph.D., as President, Research and Development and Chief Medical Officer - Business Wire - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- New Rare Disease Therapy Effectively Lowers Plasma Phe in Patients with PKU - MD Magazine - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- GSK : announces expanded collaboration with Tempus in precision medicine to accelerate R&D - Marketscreener.com - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- Famous Scientific Discoveries That Changed the Course of History - 24/7 Wall St. - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- Construction workers seek fulfilment of their demands - Star of Mysore - October 19th, 2022 [October 19th, 2022]
- Genetics | The Smithsonian Institution's Human Origins Program - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Genetics - Wikipedia - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Study looking at human genetics and Covid vaccine immune responses - Science Media Centre - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- ASHG 2022 in Los Angeles brings together researchers from around the world to advance discoveries in genetics, genomics research - EurekAlert - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Maze Therapeutics Appoints Harold Bernstein, M.D., Ph.D., as President, Research and Development and Chief Medical Officer - Yahoo Finance - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- The Age of the Pangenome Dawns - DNA Science - PLOS - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Influence of the microbiome, diet and genetics on inter-individual variation in the human plasma metabolome - Nature.com - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Genome editing technologies: final conclusions of the re-examination of Article 13 of the Oviedo Convention - Council of Europe - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Global Biobank Meta-analysis Initiative making genome-wide association studies more diverse and representative - EurekAlert - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- New NHS genetic testing service could save thousands of children in England - The Guardian - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Covid protection may be boosted by genes, study shows - Yahoo News Australia - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Genomics in Cancer Care Market is estimated to be US$ 72.61 billion by 2032 with a CAGR of 16.3% during the forecast period 2032 - By PMI -... - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Identification of hub genes and candidate herbal treatment in obesity through integrated bioinformatic analysis and reverse network pharmacology |... - October 13th, 2022 [October 13th, 2022]
- Our *Homo sapiens* ancestors shared the world with Neanderthals, Denisovans and other types of humans whose DNA lives on in our genes -... - October 8th, 2022 [October 8th, 2022]
- Blue Eyed People Have a Single Ancestor | History of Yesterday - History of Yesterday - October 6th, 2022 [October 6th, 2022]
- Heart infection could be cause of death of Polish, US hero - ABC News - October 6th, 2022 [October 6th, 2022]
- 23andMe Announces Trials-in-Progress Poster Presentation on 23ME-00610, An Investigational Antibody Targeting CD200R1, at The Society for... - October 6th, 2022 [October 6th, 2022]
- The Genetic Drivers Of Longevity In Mice, Humans And Worms - Science 2.0 - October 6th, 2022 [October 6th, 2022]
- ANGPTL7, a therapeutic target for increased intraocular pressure and glaucoma | Communications Biology - Nature.com - October 6th, 2022 [October 6th, 2022]
- 'Neanderthal Man' Nobel Prize winner Svante Pbo revolutionized anthropology. Here is a look back at his groundbreaking 2014 memoir - Genetic Literacy... - October 6th, 2022 [October 6th, 2022]
- Understanding Human Genetic Variation - NCBI Bookshelf - September 14th, 2022 [September 14th, 2022]
- Genetics - National Institute of General Medical Sciences (NIGMS) - September 14th, 2022 [September 14th, 2022]
- People with ME invited to take part in major genetic study - The Independent - September 14th, 2022 [September 14th, 2022]
- Ketamine Promising for Rare Condition Linked to Autism - Medscape - September 14th, 2022 [September 14th, 2022]
- How a small, unassuming fish helps reveal gene adaptations - University of Wisconsin-Madison - September 14th, 2022 [September 14th, 2022]
- How Nutrigenomics Explores Links Between Nutrition And Genes - Health Digest - September 14th, 2022 [September 14th, 2022]