Among the four elements required to establish liability for the tort of negligence is causation. In addition to proving that the defendant was careless or otherwise breached the legal standard of care, the plaintiff must establish that the wrongful conduct caused the harm the plaintiff suffers. This 1941 New Hampshire Supreme Court decision explains:
Necessary elements of a cause of action based on negligence are the causal negligence of the defendant plus the resultant harm to the plaintiff. Putting it another way, there must be negligence and harm and they must have a causal connection.
At the height of asbestos litigation, mesothelioma, a cancer of the lining of the pleural (lung) cavity or the abdominal cavity (peritoneal mesothelioma) was believed to be pathognomonic of asbestos exposure, meaning that the disease was a signal cancer of asbestos exposure, and only asbestos exposure. A diagnosis of the disease was tantamount to legal recovery (and virtually certain and swift death). No longer.
Today, it is recognized that mesothelioma has other causes, including erionite, another naturally occurring mineral used in pet litter, soil conditioners, animal feed, wastewater treatment, and gas absorbents. Radiation is also a recognized cause of mesothelioma, either from employment-related exposures, or older therapeutic uses which are now known to cause disease. And then there are causes we dont even yet know about as well as those arising spontaneously. These are known as idiopathic causes.
Asbestos exposure significantly declined beginning in the 1970s when the first OSHA asbestos laws were enacted. However, the incidence of mesothelioma, even with its notoriously long latency or delay period, is increasing in women, and has remaining constant overall. This lends credence to the fact that mesotheliomas arises from causes other than asbestos or even arises spontaneously, meaning the body needs no help from asbestos or anything else in generating them.
Of course, spontaneously does not mean magically or out of the blue. Rather, of the estimates that perhaps twenty to fifty percent of mesotheliomas dont arise from asbestos, it appears some are attributable to genetic misfirings, or mutations, that arise over time, some occurring as we age, and our defenses or repair mechanisms are no longer functioning optimally. (Think how slow your older computer worked compared to the new one you bought when old-trusty melted down.)
These genetic mutations are not necessarily inherited (although some are), but rather occur in clusters - or more rarely, singly due to natural causes or DNA breakage. The mutations can cause mesothelioma, either alone or by increasing susceptibility to minute exposures. The difference in the causal mechanism, however, has a huge impact on legal liability. And so it is that attention to genetics is now finding its way into the courtroom.
Courts are becoming more attentive to the need to establish that a potential carcinogen is responsible for causing the disease in a particular person, rather than based on its statistical or historical significance for a general population. Recently, in toxic tort cases, some courts are requiring a two-stage level of proof:
Specific causation requires showing that the plaintiff was exposed to a sufficient dose which is capable of causing the disease in that person. The application of this requirement is derailing some talc-mesothelioma cases.
But attention to the plaintiffs burden of proving specific causation is not the only monkey-wrench appearing in toxic tort cases these days. And not all courts are requiring specific quantification of plaintiffs exposure to prove causal-negligence, i.e, that the defendants asbestos caused the particular plaintiffs disease.
This situation invites another option for defense lawyers to protect their clients: genetics. And so we find defense lawyers turning to genetics to establish the defense that it wasnt exposure to asbestos per se, that caused the plaintiffs mesothelioma. Rather it was something else notably, something in their genes.
The genetic defense has found itself into other types of cases as well. And as we learn more about the genetic components of disease, we can expect to find its use burgeoning. Take the case of Bowen v. EI Dupont, in which the plaintiff alleged her retarded fetal growth and birth defects were caused by exposure to the fungicide Benlate during her gestation, when her mother was spraying houseplants.
The defendant obtained a court order to genetically test the plaintiff for a specific genetic variation (CHD7) that causes a specific condition (the CHARGE syndrome, a rare condition that causes birth defects), that resembled the plaintiffs condition. The defense argued that the mutated CHD7 was the sole and proximate cause of the plaintiffs condition a CHARGE syndrome-driven birth defect, a theory with substantial support in the record and substantiated in peer-reviewed literature. After the testing and finding the mutation present, the court dismissed the case.
In a similar case, Naomi Guzman v. ExxonMobil Corp, the plaintiff claimed that she was exposed to radioactive material as a bystander to her fathers work as an oil pipe cleaner. The court granted the defendants request for genetic testing of plaintiffs preserved thyroid tissue.
Genetic tests revealed both that the plaintiff did not have the genetic signature for radiation-induced cancer. It also revealed that plaintiff had several hereditary gene mutations predisposing her to thyroid cancer, leading the defenses expert-toxicologist to conclude her thyroid cancer was caused by her genetic predisposition and not exposure to her fathers drilling pipe. The jury agreed and sided with the defense.
Genetic defenses, however, must be used with care. In some cases, exposure to a chemical overwhelms multiple natural genetic repair mechanisms, leading to the cancer or disease. In those cases, the genetic defense may not work.
Thus, the failure of a genetic-defense mechanism to activate (or activation of a susceptibility gene) may not absolve the defendant, since it was the impact of exposure (to their asbestos or whatever chemical) that caused these genes to malfunction, and which in turn began the chain-reaction leading to the disease.
Instead, focusing on point mutations, where cancers occur as the direct result of a consequential change in a particular genetic set of alleles (subparts of a gene responsible for expression of a particular trait), independent of exposure, present the genetic alterations generating the most success in legal cases.
So far, two genes have been implicated as causally-related to mesothelioma in the absence of asbestos exposure. One, is a mutation on the AKL gene. While the discovery may not help plaintiffs in a legal setting, such discoveries do bode well for enhanced therapeutics and treatment.
Other studies have identified mutations on the BAP1 gene, discoveries that again bode well for possible treatment, although not necessarily for success in the legal setting. The BAPI gene is also related to several other cancers, including melanoma, so the causal connection is not one-on-one. But the BAP1 gene also has an additional effect- not only has it been related to direct causation of mesothelioma, it is also known to enhance susceptibility to prior exposures to asbestos. And that poses a legal problem.
The published findings do not establish a synergistic gene/environment interaction as a causal factor for the development of mesothelioma [and Bap1].,,, At present, it is estimated that between 1 and 8 percent of all spontaneous mesothelioma cases involve BAP1 germline mutations.
Bernier et al.
In law, the defendant is said to take the plaintiff as one finds him/her. That means if a plaintiff, by virtue of his or her individual make-up, is unusually susceptible to a condition, the defendant is still liable for all incident harms of their negligence. These include even those that might not have happened if the same wrongdoing was inflicted on a hardier plaintiff. (The term got its name from a case about running over a plaintiff with a skull as thin as an eggshell).
That maxim makes finding a BAP1 gene problematic. In some cases, the gene will render the plaintiff unusually susceptible to a small amount of exposure; in others it can cause mesothelioma, outright. Where the gene acts as a susceptibility gene, the defendant is still liable. Where it causes the disease outright, the plaintiffs case fails.
At the end of the day, the answer becomes a matter of fact for the jury to decide after listening to a battle of experts. But recent research shows that up to one-third of all cancers are produced by the bodys own mutation errors, and not by environmental causes. The complete genetic-cause defense would likely work best in cases of teenagers or women who were unlikely to have been exposed to significant levels of exposure.
To maintain a genetic defense, the plaintiff would have to petition the court to compel genetic tests of the plaintiff and sometimes the family to show a hereditary defect. Courts usually direct the plaintiff to submit to genetic testing (via blood test or tissue swipe), if the requested tests are particularized enough, although they will often reject requests to compel family-testing.
Is this forced test legal? Yes. First because such tests are not usually invasive; and second, by bringing the lawsuit, the plaintiff has put his condition into controversy and hence waives some rights.
To date, a few dozen personal injury cases have involved court-ordered genetic testing. Most courts have allowed it, especially as the tests are not painful, protracted, or intrusive. (Although, when the genetic tests are to be used for prospective or predictive purposes, such as medical monitoring or gauging the likelihood of future disease severity or longevity, the courts may not agree. In these cases courts often conclude that DNA tests are more speculative in prediction than identifying causal genes in those already suffering a disease).
Most important, however, a defendant who wants to compel a test must seekprecise information or evidence. In other words, like in any litigation discovery procedure, neither party is given largesse to go on a fishing expedition, for example by seeking reems of data, hoping to uncover an unanticipated smoking gun.
This objection wouldnt be typical in the asbestos cases, since specific and responsible genetic culprits have been identified. But we can see the abuse in other cases, notably birth-related negligence cases which often result in a surfeit of issues, such as brain damage, developmental issues, and physical disabilities. To be sure, such conditions can be caused by environmental exposures, poor pre-natal care, or even the birth process itself, especially if negligently performed.
In one birth-related negligence case, Fisher for XSF v. Winding Waters Clinic, the defendant sought a court order compelling the plaintiff to submit to genetic testing to confirm whether their impairments are more likely than not the result of a genetic condition unrelated to prenatal care
The problem was that the defendants had no specific condition in mind. They sought a WES (Whole Exome Sequencing) array meaning they wanted to look through the plaintiffs entire genomic vocabulary in the hopes of finding one or more errors to explain the condition. The court rejected the request.
Recognizing that overbroad requests promote the possibilities for abuse, including privacy violations or the potential to uncover genetic predispositions to numerous unrelated conditions, the court noted that the defendants request was particularly troubling.
Nevertheless, we can expect an onslaught of compelled genetic testing arising out of litigation to continue. As to where the results take us, thats an interesting and open- question. Perhaps the most curious case is the pending matter of Lohmann v. Aaon Inc. There, the defendants experts sought evidence of the BAP-1 disorder. Not only did they want to use it for the litigation, they wanted it for their own research purposes, as well.
Seems the value of these tests is greater than we might imagine. No word yet, on the legal resolution. But Id bet the judge denies the request.
Dr. Barbara Pfeffer Billauer, JD MA (Occ. Health) Ph.D. is Professor of Law and Bioethics in the International Program in Bioethics of the University of Porto and Research Professor of Scientific Statecraft at the Institute ofWorld Politics in Washington DC. Find Barbara on Twitter@BBillauer
- Joel Embiid finally discovers he has the DNA of a champion. Down 2-1, can he lead the Sixers past the Knicks? - The Philadelphia Inquirer - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- Unraveling DNA's role in pop culturefrom superheroes to crime scenes - The Daily | Case Western Reserve University - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- Elucidation of inhibitory effects of bioactive anthraquinones towards formation of DNA advanced glycation end products ... - ScienceDirect.com - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- DNA Testing Proved My Innocence of My Son's Murder - Innocence Project - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- Generative A.I. Arrives in the Gene Editing World of CRISPR - The New York Times - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- Persistent TFIIH binding to non-excised DNA damage causes cell and developmental failure - Nature.com - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- Enhanced CRISPR method enables stable insertion of large genes into the DNA of higher plants - Phys.org - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- Scientists inspired the right guardrails for nuclear energy, the internet, and DNA research. Let them do the same for AI - Fortune - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- Test your dog's DNA to learn about their heritage and health for only $120 - New York Post - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- Earth Life Biodiversity: Vast DNA Tree Of life For Flowering Plants Revealed - Astrobiology - Astrobiology News - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- Katie Holmes and Suri Cruise Share Some Very Stylish DNA - Vogue - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- DNA evidence leads to arrest of 75-year-old Auburn man - Opelika Auburn News - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- Putnam NY cold case: DNA test finds skeleton is not Robin Murphy's - The Journal News - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- Ancient nomads you've probably never heard of disappeared from Europe 1,000 years ago. Now, DNA analysis ... - The Conversation - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- Genetics Studies Have a Diversity Problem That Researchers Struggle To Fix - Kaiser Health News - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- Keeping Telomeres in Their Places - The Scientist - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- WWII veteran Ward Thomas identified through genealogy testing - 10TV - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- Vast DNA tree of life for plants revealed by global science team using 1.8 billion letters of genetic code - Phys.org - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- Here is a look at one of the labs that helped uncover new DNA evidence in Lake Oconee murder - WSB Atlanta - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- This Guardians prospect has baseball in his DNA - 1330 WFIN - April 27th, 2024 [April 27th, 2024]
- DNA identifies last known remains of victims of notorious Green River Killer, cops say - Miami Herald - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- UNE to study why rare lobsters have strange-colored shells - Spectrum News - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- DNA evidence identifies last known victim of Green River Killer almost 40 years later - NBC Right Now - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- New bill would give California parents more control over whether state can store their kid's DNA - CBS News - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- Lucas County Sheriff's Office doing advanced testing on DNA found at site of 2011 Clarke and Straub murders - WTOL - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- Last known remains connected to the Green River Killer identified through DNA | WTGS - Fox28 Savannah - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- 5 Best Ancestry DNA Tests 2024 To Help You Learn More About Your Health - GLAMOUR UK - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- 11 Investigates: Lucas County Sheriff's Office doing advanced testing on DNA found at site of 2011 Clarke and Straub murders - WTOL - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- Researchers improve blood tests' ability to detect and monitor cancer - MIT News - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- DNA test approved for Duxbury's Lindsay Clancy, who is accused of killing her 3 children - The Patriot Ledger - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- 1,650th victim of 9/11 identified through advanced DNA testing - FOX 17 West Michigan News - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- We Think Cavco Industries (NASDAQ:CVCO) Might Have The DNA Of A Multi-Bagger - Yahoo Finance - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- DNA From the Ocean's 'Twilight Zone' Could Lead to New Lifesaving Drugs, Scientists Say - Smithsonian Magazine - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- Last known remains connected to the Green River Killer identified through DNA - KOMO News - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- 9/11 victim identified as John Ballantine Niven of Oyster Bay with help of DNA technology - WABC-TV - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- Scott Peterson has every right to DNA test: Attorney from case - NewsNation Now - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- DNA from stone age chewing gum sheds light on diet and disease in Scandinavia's ancient hunter-gatherers - The Conversation - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- Barbara Lee responds to Nikki Haley: Racism is in the DNA of this country - The Hill - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- DB Cooper 'will finally be identified' after 53 years due to huge DNA breakthrough - LADbible - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- Dog Owners Who Abandon Poops To Be Found Using DNA Tests in Italy - Newsweek - January 23rd, 2024 [January 23rd, 2024]
- Scientists gather bobcat DNA from paw prints - KJZZ - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- Discovering Fusions Requires More Than DNA Testing in GI Cancers - OncLive - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- Largest-ever ocean DNA study uncovers mysteries of marine life - Earth.com - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- 1st-ever ancient case of Turner syndrome, with just 1 X chromosome instead of 2, found in ancient DNA - Livescience.com - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- Minnesota Mother Calls on NYS to Allow DNA Testing Finger Lakes Daily News - Finger Lakes Daily News - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- DNA Didn't Match Marcellus Williams. Missouri May Fast-Track Execution Anyway. - The Intercept - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- Ancient DNA From Eurasian Herders Sheds Light on the Origins of Multiple Sclerosis - Smithsonian Magazine - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- DNA's hotel toh kuyabeh mirrors bird flight undulations in tulum - Designboom - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- Research into ancient DNA sheds new light on cause of Multiple Sclerosis and other neurodegenerative diseases - University of Oxford - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- Ancient DNA reveals reason for high MS and Alzheimer's rates in Europe - University of Cambridge news - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- TIME-seq reduces time and cost of DNA methylation measurement for epigenetic clock construction - Nature.com - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- Gilgo Serial Killer Suspect Rex Heuermann Tied to Slaying by DNA From Daughter's Can of Coffee: Prosecutors - The Messenger - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- DNA evidence leads to arrest of Denton sexual assault suspect - The Cross Timbers Gazette - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- Ancient DNA reveals reason for high multiple sclerosis and Alzheimer's rates in Europe - EurekAlert - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- New technique identifies earliest cases of genetic disorders from ancient DNA - University of Oxford - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- Ancient DNA could be hiding all kinds of health secrets - Deccan Herald - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- Ancient DNA reveals reason for high MS and Alzheimer's rates in Europe - ScienceBlog.com - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- Supreme Court seeks government's view on DNA profiling of unidentified bodies - IndiaTimes - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- Prosecution Ordered to Release Portion of DNA Evidence to Kohberger's Defense Team - bigcountrynewsconnection.com - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- Judge orders more DNA disclosure in University of Idaho murder case - KXLY Spokane - January 16th, 2024 [January 16th, 2024]
- Cas9-induced targeted integration of large DNA payloads in primary human T cells via homology-mediated end-joining ... - Nature.com - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- The DNA glycosylase NEIL2 is protective during SARS-CoV-2 infection - Nature.com - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- How an immune response is driven by one letter difference in DNA - Medical Xpress - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- Tracy Morgan Discovered He Was Related to Nas After DNA Test - PEOPLE - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- Scientists testify about DNA in third week of Aguirre trial - The Spokesman Review - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- DNA metabarcoding focusing on the plankton community: an effective approach to reconstruct the paleo-environment ... - Nature.com - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- Advancement in DNA Technology and Tenacity of Cold Case Detective Identifies Victim in 37-year-old Homicide - hellowoodlands.com - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- Integrating DNA methylation and gene expression data in a single gene network using the iNETgrate package ... - Nature.com - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- Forensic scientist testifies about evidence contamination at state lab in 1986, says knowledge of DNA has since ... - The Spokesman Review - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- Tracy Morgan Discovers He Is Related To Nas Through DNA Test - BET - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- DNA discovery opens door to tailored medicine for Indigenous Australians | Australian National University - ANU - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- Tracy Morgan Started Crying After Learning Hes Related To Nas Through A DNA Test - TODAY - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- Electric eel zaps do more than just stun they can alter the DNA of their victims, study suggests - Salon - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- Blueface Says He Took a DNA Test That Proves He's Not the Father of Chrisean Rock's Son: 'Thank You Jesus' - Complex - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- Altina Wildlife Park to use DNA tests to find mystery father of black-and-white ruffed lemur triplets - ABC News - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- In the Shadow of Rome: Ancient DNA Recasts Balkan History - SciTechDaily - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- Even microbes felt the impact of ancient climate transitions, McMaster DNA researchers find - Brighter World - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- Clarence 'Red' Wilson cold case murder: DNA helps Montgomery County detective break 37-year unsolved Texas homicide - KTRK-TV - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- How Construction Companies Can Make Diversity Part of Their DNA - For Construction Pros - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- DNA analysis of bat droppings shows astonishingly high number of insect species - Phys.org - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]