The en banc opinion by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals could set up a new showdown on gun rights at the Supreme Court.
At issue was California's law on concealed weapons, which requires citizens to prove they have "good cause" to carry concealed firearms to get a license. Plaintiffs challenged guidelines in San Diego and Yolo counties that did not consider general self-defense to be enough to obtain a license.
"The historical materials bearing on the adoption of the Second and Fourteenth Amendments are remarkably consistent," wrote Judge William Fletcher, going back to 16th century English law to find instances of restrictions on concealed weapons. "We therefore conclude that the Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms does not include, in any degree, the right of a member of the general public to carry concealed firearms in public."
Fletcher also cited the most recent Supreme Court cases on gun rights, District of Columbia v. Heller and McDonald v. City of Chicago, which were major victories for gun rights activists, in making his case.
The Heller decision, authored by Justice Antonin Scalia, solidified a Second Amendment right of the public to keep guns, but it specifically noted the right was not absolute, and Fletcher pointed out that Scalia cited restrictions on concealed weapons as a historical example.
The court was careful to make the ruling narrow. The opinion does not say concealed weapons are unconstitutional, nor does it make any decisions about openly carrying weapons in public.
The case was a blow for gun rights advocates, and sets up the fight on gun rights for the Supreme Court to consider, says UCLA law professor and gun law expert Adam Winkler.
"This case raises the next great question for the Supreme Court: Does the Second Amendment guarantee a right to carry guns in public? And if so, what kind of licensing can states use to permit people to carry concealed weapons?" Winkler said.
The Supreme Court would not necessarily have to take up the case. The ruling does not create a substantive divide among different circuit courts in the U.S., one of the major factors the court considers in weighing which cases to take.
Four judges dissented from the ruling, with the main dissent by Judge Consuelo Callahan arguing that California's laws taken together amount to a substantial restriction on citizens' right to bear arms for self defense, as protected by the Second Amendment.
Whether the court does or does not take the case, the early 2016 death of Scalia looms large over it. Scalia authored Heller, the most substantial gun ruling in modern history of the court. And Republicans in the Senate have refused to consider President Barack Obama's nominee for replacing Scalia on the court, meaning the eight justice panel can split 4-4.
Without a ninth justice, Winkler said, it's unlikely the court would take up the case, even with Scalia's allies on the issue Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas still on the court.
Obama's nominee to replace Scalia, Judge Merrick Garland, was chosen in large part for his moderate record. But one of the most substantial conservative arguments against Garland has been that his record on guns is too liberal, though his written record on the issue is limited.
A partner for the law firm that helped argue on behalf of Peruta said that the plaintiffs were "disappointed" with the ruling but not surprised. He also said appealing to the Supreme Court is not a guarantee yet.
"An appeal to the Supreme Court is possible," said Chuck Michel, senior partner at Michel and Associates. "But significantly, the Peruta decision specifically avoided answering the critical legal question of whether, if concealed carry is prohibited, some form of open carry of firearms must be allowed. California law bans open carry, so the constitutionality of that ban will now have to be tested."
The case was primarily argued by Paul Clement, a former solicitor general under the George W. Bush administration and one of the top litigators for conservative causes at the Supreme Court in recent years.
Ever since the Supreme Court decided the Heller decision and a follow up case two years later, the Supreme Court has declined to take another major second amendment case, a frustration Clement cited in a 2013 filing with the court.
In the years since Heller had been decided many expected a "major consideration" or extant firearms laws, Clement wrote. "Instead, jurisdictions have engaged in massive resistance to the clear import of those landmark decisions, and the lower federal courts, long out of the habit of taking the Second Amendment seriously, have largely facilitated that resistance."
California state Attorney General Kamala Harris said the decision "is a victory for public safety and sensible gun safety laws. The ruling ensures that local law enforcement leaders have the tools they need to protect public safety by determining who can carry loaded, concealed weapons in our communities."
See the original post here:
there is no Second Amendment protection for ... - cnn.com
- The Second Amendment was ratified to preserve slavery - July 12th, 2016 [July 12th, 2016]
- Minn. police shooting reignites debate over Second Amendment ... - July 12th, 2016 [July 12th, 2016]
- The Right to Bear Arms - July 12th, 2016 [July 12th, 2016]
- Second Amendment Basics | Law Center to Prevent Gun Violence - July 3rd, 2016 [July 3rd, 2016]
- The Second Amendment, the Bill of Rights, and the ... - June 25th, 2016 [June 25th, 2016]
- The Second Amendment Is About Revolution - June 25th, 2016 [June 25th, 2016]
- Don't Bank On The Supreme Court To Clarify The Second ... - June 16th, 2016 [June 16th, 2016]
- Why It's Time to Repeal the Second Amendment - June 14th, 2016 [June 14th, 2016]
- Hillary Clinton wavers on Second Amendment right to bear arms ... - June 7th, 2016 [June 7th, 2016]
- Politics & 2nd Amendment Archives - Guns.com - May 25th, 2016 [May 25th, 2016]
- Second Amendment - lawbrain.com - May 20th, 2016 [May 20th, 2016]
- Second Amendment Sports - Bakersfield, CA - Yelp - April 18th, 2016 [April 18th, 2016]
- Second Amendment - Conservapedia - October 20th, 2015 [October 20th, 2015]
- Second Amendment | Fox News - October 20th, 2015 [October 20th, 2015]
- The Second Amendment Is a Gun-Control Amendment - October 4th, 2015 [October 4th, 2015]
- Clinton at private fundraiser: SCOTUS is wrong about the ... - October 4th, 2015 [October 4th, 2015]
- Obama Mocks Second Amendment Supporters For Crack Pot ... - October 4th, 2015 [October 4th, 2015]
- Second Amendment - September 25th, 2015 [September 25th, 2015]
- 7th Circuit Court: Illegal Immigrants Have Second ... - August 29th, 2015 [August 29th, 2015]
- Court Rules Illegal Aliens Have Second Amendment Rights ... - August 27th, 2015 [August 27th, 2015]
- Second Amendment - Text, Origins, and Meaning - July 12th, 2015 [July 12th, 2015]
- Second Amendment : Pictures, Videos, Breaking News - July 9th, 2015 [July 9th, 2015]
- Twenty-second Amendment to the United States Constitution - May 30th, 2015 [May 30th, 2015]
- Second Amendment | Wex Legal Dictionary / Encyclopedia ... - May 28th, 2015 [May 28th, 2015]
- Brantley Gilbert Inks His Love For The Second Amendment ... - May 13th, 2015 [May 13th, 2015]
- 2nd Amendment advocates push to repeal switchblade, other ... - May 12th, 2015 [May 12th, 2015]
- 2015 NRA Convention Interview with Michigan 2nd Amendment Supporters - Video - April 14th, 2015 [April 14th, 2015]
- Second Amendment Youth Leadership Conference Wrap-Up - Video - April 14th, 2015 [April 14th, 2015]
- PASTOR SAYS BLACKS NEED TO GET GUNS AND FIGHT BACK - Video - April 14th, 2015 [April 14th, 2015]
- Second Amendment - Web Mashup for Second, Amendment ... - April 14th, 2015 [April 14th, 2015]
- Six takeaways from the NRA convention - April 13th, 2015 [April 13th, 2015]
- More than 70,000 people attended event - April 13th, 2015 [April 13th, 2015]
- RIGHT TO BEAR ARMS? Police grabs of legal guns on the rise across US - April 13th, 2015 [April 13th, 2015]
- The Death of the Second Amendment - Video - April 12th, 2015 [April 12th, 2015]
- Ben Carson Speaks on Second Amendment at NRA Leadership Forum - Video - April 12th, 2015 [April 12th, 2015]
- As Scott Walker addresses NRA, concealed carry vote criticized - April 12th, 2015 [April 12th, 2015]
- GUN RIGHTS UNDER FIRE Illegal police grabs of legal firearms rising nationwide - April 12th, 2015 [April 12th, 2015]
- Colt 1911 Gold Cup Pistol for Sale - Video - April 11th, 2015 [April 11th, 2015]
- Some Conservative Lawmakers Working To Roll Back Gun Restrictions - Second Amendment - Video - April 11th, 2015 [April 11th, 2015]
- Teaching the Bill of Rights: The Second Amendment - Part One - Video - April 11th, 2015 [April 11th, 2015]
- SUNSET ON THE SECOND AMENDMENT 1080p - Video - April 11th, 2015 [April 11th, 2015]
- Donald Rumsfeld, former Secretary of Defense - Video - April 11th, 2015 [April 11th, 2015]
- GOP hopefuls flock to NRA cattle call - April 11th, 2015 [April 11th, 2015]
- Nevada Panel OKs Bill to Create Pro-Second Amendment License Plates - April 11th, 2015 [April 11th, 2015]
- NRA wants more than 'Second Amendment' - April 11th, 2015 [April 11th, 2015]
- Is encryption the Second Amendment for the Internet? - April 11th, 2015 [April 11th, 2015]
- Rand Paul calls NRA snub 'petty' - April 11th, 2015 [April 11th, 2015]
- The truth about the NRA's snub of Rand Paul - April 11th, 2015 [April 11th, 2015]
- Backing Out Sun Trust Bank Terminates Gun Shop's Accounts Second Amendment Fox & Friends - Video - April 8th, 2015 [April 8th, 2015]
- 2nd Amendment Keychain - RTBA - Video - April 8th, 2015 [April 8th, 2015]
- Dr. Rand Paul on the Second Amendment - Video - April 8th, 2015 [April 8th, 2015]
- 4.7.15 | Second Scoop: Justice in Jersey, Detroit's Top Cop & CCW, Clear Channel Controversy - Video - April 8th, 2015 [April 8th, 2015]
- Second Amendment Foundation Takes Case Of Arizona Navy Vet ... - April 8th, 2015 [April 8th, 2015]
- State GOP lawmakers look to roll back gun restrictions after midterm wins - VIDEO: Pols work to roll back gun ... - April 8th, 2015 [April 8th, 2015]
- NRA Convention Coming To Nashville This Week - April 8th, 2015 [April 8th, 2015]
- Two Charter Amendments to Be Voted on During Dundee Election - April 7th, 2015 [April 7th, 2015]
- State GOP lawmakers working to roll back gun restrictions after midterm wins - April 7th, 2015 [April 7th, 2015]
- GUN RIGHTS BATTLES GOP state legislators seek to ease gun codes - April 7th, 2015 [April 7th, 2015]
- SAF Takes Case of Arizona Navy Vet Whose Guns Were Seized - April 7th, 2015 [April 7th, 2015]
- Second Amendment Hoodie | Spreadshirt | ID: 101726003 - April 5th, 2015 [April 5th, 2015]
- Colt Commander Pistol for Sale - Video - April 3rd, 2015 [April 3rd, 2015]
- SCLC calling on blacks to Exercise Second Amendment Rights - Video - April 3rd, 2015 [April 3rd, 2015]
- District Drops Appeal Of SAF Concealed Carry Victory - April 3rd, 2015 [April 3rd, 2015]
- SCLC president suspended after comments regarding 2nd Amendment - April 3rd, 2015 [April 3rd, 2015]
- BladeFit and 2A Rights. Second Amendment rules! - Video - April 2nd, 2015 [April 2nd, 2015]
- SCLC suspends Georgia Chapter President for call to bear arms - April 2nd, 2015 [April 2nd, 2015]
- SCLC calling on blacks to "Exercise Second Amendment Rights" - March 31st, 2015 [March 31st, 2015]
- House approves amended re-homing bill - March 31st, 2015 [March 31st, 2015]
- David Mierswa Second Amendment Part 2 - Video - March 29th, 2015 [March 29th, 2015]
- Second Amendment in the 21st Century / New York Ideas 2014 - Video - March 29th, 2015 [March 29th, 2015]
- Campus Carry Talk, How the Second Amendment Applies to Campus Carry - Video - March 29th, 2015 [March 29th, 2015]
- Bearing ArmsRubio, Jordan File "Second Amendment ... - March 29th, 2015 [March 29th, 2015]
- Sen. Rubio, Rep. Jordan propose repealing D.C. gun control laws - March 28th, 2015 [March 28th, 2015]
- SD Attorney General Urges ATF to Respect Second Amendment - Video - March 27th, 2015 [March 27th, 2015]
- The second amendment explained to #gunsense supporters - Video - March 27th, 2015 [March 27th, 2015]
- Who's Going After D.C.'s Gun Laws? Marco Rubio Edition. - March 27th, 2015 [March 27th, 2015]
- Giveaway Prizes for April 7 2015 - Video - March 26th, 2015 [March 26th, 2015]
- Rant on guns - Video - March 26th, 2015 [March 26th, 2015]
- Second Amendment Shirts - Video - March 25th, 2015 [March 25th, 2015]
- Ensuring the Second Amendment Protections - Video - March 25th, 2015 [March 25th, 2015]