As non-controversial as Thanksgiving is today, you might imagine the proclamation met with universal acceptance. It did not.
Reflecting the sharp polarization in national politics, many Democrats and peace proponents refused to acknowledge the presidents proclamation of the new holiday, and some even denounced it as an attempt to impose a particular brand of New England fanaticism on the whole country. Lincolns proclamation unleashed the social resentments of many voters who resisted the growing influence of evangelical churches and the concurrent growth of social reform movements from abolitionism and temperance to Sabbatarianism and womens rights.
To borrow from todays political lexicon, Lincolns opponents nursed an intense dislike of that eras wokeness. Back then, they called it ism referring to the set of religious social reform movements of the day that sought to refashion the nations social and political systems in line with evangelical Protestant sensibilities. These critics recoiled at the pace of social change that these movements represented and resented the suggestion that they think or pray a certain way. Conversely, many Republicans greeted the presidents proclamation as a sign that the government in Washington embraced their worldview. The controversy over the first annual national Thanksgiving is a useful reminder that Americans have long argued over religion and culture, and that topics seemingly disconnected from politics can take on unexpected meaning in moments of rancor and disunity.
We tend to misremember Thanksgiving as a holiday born in Plymouth Colony and celebrated faithfully every November hence. In fact, early colonists frequently declared fast and thanksgiving days, partly in keeping with Puritan practice and partly in appreciation of bountiful harvests or victories in war with local Native American tribes. Presidents George Washington, John Adams and James Madison all proclaimed days of thanksgiving sometimes, but not always, in November (Adams and Madison issued such proclamations in March) and by the late 1840s, some form of harvest thanksgiving celebration was observed in 21 states, though on different days in November. The holiday was generally meant to inspire prayerful reflection and gratitude for Gods beneficence toward us (Washingtons words), reflecting its origins in Puritan New England as a harvest season observance.
But as late as 1863, there was no fixed national holiday.
Throughout the Civil War, both Lincoln and Confederate President Jefferson Davis issued multiple calls for national days of thanksgiving and prayerful reflection. Lincolns first such proclamation, in August 1861, came on the heels of the Unions defeat at the First Battle of Bull Run and was intended to calm the peoples nerves and steel their resolve. It was hardly a moment that inspired celebration. The president called on citizens to bow in humble submission to [Gods] chastisements; to confess and deplore their sins and transgressions in the full conviction that the fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom. It was, for Lincoln, an uncharacteristic display of public religiosity. Referring to the battlefield defeat, he recognized the hand of God in this terrible visitation and pointed to our own faults and crimes as a nation and as individuals as a sure cause of the Unions loss.
Even before the war, Lincoln told an audience in Wisconsin that holiday celebrations had the potential to bring us together, and thereby make us better acquainted, and better friends than we otherwise would be. He was particularly influenced by Sarah Josepha Hale, the editor of the popular magazine Godeys Ladys Book, who had for many years spearheaded a campaign to create a national Thanksgiving holiday on the last Thursday in November. Taking his cue from Hale, who had approached him with a specific proposal, on Oct. 3, 1863, the president issued a proclamation setting aside Thursday, Nov. 26, as a day when Americans, as with one heart and one voice, would thank God for the blessings of fruitful fields and healthful skies and pray that God heal the wounds of the nation and restore it as soon as may be consistent with the Divine purposes to the full enjoyment of peace, harmony, tranquility and Union.
On the face of it, a unifying and uncontroversial gesture for the time. But in 1863, hardly anything in American life was beyond dispute.
By 1863, the state of Union politics was deeply fractious. On the Republican side, conservative, radical and moderate Republicans largely agreed on the imperative of crushing the Confederacy, but not on the urgency or even the wisdom of either emancipation or arming Black soldiers and sailors. The Democrats, the opposition party, were split down the middle between War Democrats who supported the Lincoln administrations military policy, though not necessarily the Emancipation Proclamation, and Peace Democrats (whom Republicans disparaged as Copperheads) who supported an immediate armistice which would effectively allow the Confederacy to leave the Union on its own terms, with slavery intact.
Particularly in the border states and throughout the Midwest, Republicans and Peace Democrats eyed each other with mounting suspicion and loathing. Republicans viewed Peace Democrats like Ohio Rep. Clement Vallandigham as traitors to the country, while Democrats bitterly opposed the Lincoln administrations high-handed violation of civil liberties. (Lincoln had suspended the writ of habeas corpus throughout vast parts of the country, jailed newspaper editors and pro-secession state and local officials and even banished Vallandigham, who had agitated against military conscription, to the Confederacy.)
But there was more to it. For years, many Southerners and pro-slavery Northerners had pilloried the Republican Party as an organization of religious fanatics bound by a commitment to extreme and even (for the time) zany evangelical reform movements in the words of Sen. Stephen Douglas of Illinois, the black republican army is an allied army, composed of Know Nothings, Abolitionists, Free Soilers, Maine Liquor Law men, womans rights men, Anti-renters, Anti-Masons, and all the isms that have been sloughed off from all the honest parties in the country. While some of these movements strike the modern reader as incongruous, in the antebellum era, some of the strongest advocates of abolition and womens rights also wanted to restrict immigration and impose sobriety on a nation of heavy drinkers. Race the debate over slavery and abolition was always at the center of the political debate. But it intersected with a broader array of cultural concerns.
In the same way that some Americans today lump their cultural resentments under the banner of wokeness, many conservatives in Lincolns day decried the Republican Partys affinity for isms an abolition conglomerate of all the isms at war with the rights of the States, all the isms combined in the superlative ism, which I denounce as demonism, as Gov. Henry Wise of Virginia stated the case. George Fitzhugh, a leading Southern polemicist before the war, echoed Douglas when he denounced the Bloomers and Womens Rights men, the I vote myself a farm men, the Millerites, and Spiritual Rappers, and Shakers, and Widow Wakemanites, and Agrarians, and Grahamites, and a thousand other superstitious and infidel isms.
While most Americans in Lincolns time identified as evangelical Christians, and while the ranks of War Democrats included many evangelicals, the churches were closely associated with many of the reform movements including abolitionism that Democrats so sharply opposed. Particularly in the Midwest, many Democrats resented the increasingly partisan tone that political priests assumed in their Sunday sermons and, as one newspaper editor wrote, the fanatics [who] have assumed the cloak of religion to carry out schemes entirely at variance with the Almightys commandments.
It became increasingly popular for administration critics to lump the offending religious reform movements under the moniker of Puritanism, given the central role that New England played in organized abolitionism. It made little difference that Puritanism bore nothing in common with evangelical Christianity, either intellectually or theologically. By 1863, the term had become a political descriptor, devoid of its original meaning. The Republican Party, as one Confederate political cartoonist portrayed it, was built on the foundation of PURITANISM, supported by pillars that included WITCH BURNING, SOCIALISM, FREE LOVE, SPIRIT RAPPING, RATIONALISM and NEGRO WORSHIP.
Puritanism, said influential Peace Democrats like Clement Vallandigham and Samuel Cox, was the origin of all the isms that had propelled America to war. Shortly before his Thanksgiving proclamation, Lincoln received a letter from Indianas beleaguered Republican governor, who reported that every democratic newspaper is teeming with abuse of New England and it is the theme of every speech. They allege New England has brought upon us, the War, by a fanatical crusade against Slavery.
Little wonder, then, that many Democrats resented the spirit of Lincolns proclamation, to say nothing of their ministers Thanksgiving sermons the following Sunday morning. Many Democratic newspapers, like the York Gazette in Pennsylvania, scarcely mentioned the holiday, noting simply that shops would be closed, and instead devoted column space to fulminations against political preachers who stoked anti-Southern passions and promoted endless war against the South. Further west, the Indianapolis Star railed against the administrations Puritan abolition game to protract the war till the period of another Presidential election is passed, to be decided not by the people, but by the army.
Little wonder that the label Puritan so easily came to mind. Thanksgiving was, after all, steeped in Pilgrim lore. In response to such criticism of the presidents call, Harpers Weekly ran a satirical Copperhead Editorial that offered Lincolns union Thanksgiving as final damning proof of the utter subserviency of the present imbecile Administration to the rankest Puritan fanaticism. The joke was funny because people had grown quite used to hearing Democrats reduce the term Puritan to a catch-all phrase encompassing a broad swath of Christian reform causes foremost among them, abolition.
To be sure, it didnt help that New England abolitionists homed in on Thanksgivings Puritan roots and rejoiced, in the words of an abolitionist newspaper, in knowledge that it had now gone forth with her children to all the continent.
Lincoln would again declare the last Thursday of November a national day of Thanksgiving in 1864. And again, the Democratic opposition press ignored or disparaged the Puritan nature of the proclamation. Only in subsequent years would the holiday assume its more saccharine and secular character.
Much else has changed in the past 150 years, including the timing of the holiday (it now falls on the fourth Thursday of each November, rather than the last) and its meaning. Few people stop to remember its Civil War origins, or the controversy that surrounded it. Evangelical churches so core to radical reform in the 19th century are now more closely aligned with opponents of social change.
But some things stay the same.
As Americans sit down to their holiday meal this Thursday, we remain steeped in a debate over isms wokeness political correctness. Just as it was with Puritanism in 1863, in todays political landscape, the actual meaning of terms like critical race theory is less important than what such terms symbolize to many people who are unnerved by the pace of social change in American society, and, conversely, to those who welcome it.
Americans might celebrate Thanksgiving very differently than they did in 1863, but one tradition remains the same: We still argue about politics on the holiday.
Read the rest here:
- A Sci-Fi Visionary Thinks Greed Might Be the Thing That Saves Us - The New York Times - January 13th, 2022
- Why Bother? Australians are sick of politics and politicians - The Spectator Australia - January 13th, 2022
- Latest spy shots of what is expected to be the 2023 KTM 990 Duke - MCNews - January 9th, 2022
- Readers Write: Trump falsely compared to Hitler - Readers Write - The Island Now - January 3rd, 2022
- The Enlightenment: The pursuit of happiness 1680-1790 by Ritchie Robertson - Church Times - January 3rd, 2022
- The cold truth about India's income inequality - The Hindu - January 3rd, 2022
- Will the Real Santa Claus Please Stand Up? - Patheos - January 3rd, 2022
- Gandhis politics is hollow and noisy, full of treachery and deceit: Read what Dr Ambedkar said about the Mahatma - OpIndia - January 3rd, 2022
- From Balochistan to US, Armenia, Hindutva, threat of Big Tech and more: Here are the top 30 opinion pieces from 2021 handpicked by Editors - OpIndia - January 3rd, 2022
- Rationalism and mystification. On the formal pathetic of being against - DocWire News - December 25th, 2021
- From headless angels to boiled children: A brief history of macabre Christmas cards by the worlds greatest artists - The Indian Express - December 25th, 2021
- The Fiji Times Where are you this time? - Fiji Times - December 22nd, 2021
- This Year's Book Recommendations - Reason - December 15th, 2021
- If You Want to Play in the Sandbox, Just Wait for a Few Weeks - InvestorPlace - December 15th, 2021
- Some rationality called for amidst the drumbeat to restrictions - City A.M. - December 15th, 2021
- Silence in the Face of Intellectual Conflagration - JSTOR Daily - December 10th, 2021
- Technology will be soft-capped by the Era system in Victoria 3 - AltChar - December 10th, 2021
- The famous composer is dead. Steve Frances died at the age of 61 :: Magazine :: RMF FM - brytfmonline.com - December 10th, 2021
- Foucaults Political Spirituality, Punjab And TLP - The Friday Times - December 10th, 2021
- Press Misinformation on Critical Race Theory in Schools Fuels the Fight - The Roanoke Star - December 3rd, 2021
- On Brick - The American Conservative - December 3rd, 2021
- When Evangelicals Were Considered Too Progressive | Gene Veith - Patheos - December 3rd, 2021
- Terry McLaughlin: Why a Catholic school education? - The Union - December 3rd, 2021
- Professor George Paxinos' 21-year writing odyssey comes to an end with 'A River Divided' - Greek Herald - December 3rd, 2021
- Kirkwood Artist Works with Psychology Group to Find Link Between Art and Science with Creativity and Madness - Catholic University of America The... - December 3rd, 2021
- The Best Books I Read This Year (2021 Edition) - Patheos - December 3rd, 2021
- Nine Implications for Investors of the Longer-Term Coronavirus Legacy ShareCafe - ShareCafe - November 28th, 2021
- A decolonised approach to tackling community challenges - University World News - November 28th, 2021
- Brexit, an unresolved personal issue between London and Paris | International - Market Research Telecast - November 28th, 2021
- Ayanna Pressley And The (Un)Logic of Critical Theory - The Claremont Independent - November 28th, 2021
- What is the difference between Rationalism & Empiricism ... - November 25th, 2021
- Time for South Korea to abandon the middle power moniker - The Interpreter - November 25th, 2021
- JUST PLAIN TALK: Thanksgiving, time to remember things we are thankful for - Walton Sun - November 25th, 2021
- Thanksgiving and the Frailty of Scientific Atheism - Discovery Institute - November 25th, 2021
- Ecology and the arts: What does extinction mean for us now? - The National - November 25th, 2021
- How the RSS transformed India? - Global Village space - November 25th, 2021
- Advantages & Disadvantages of Rationalism & Empiricism ... - November 17th, 2021
- How 'WitchTok' Lets Kids Dabble In The Occult From Their Phones - The Federalist - November 17th, 2021
- Putting the white in witness since the 1940s Baptist News Global - Baptist News Global - November 15th, 2021
- The Allure of Satanic Conspiracy - Splice Today - November 15th, 2021
- Exhibition Review: The Joy of Sculpture at Bonington Gallery - LeftLion - November 15th, 2021
- Those who still question the enduring legacy of the Nehru-Gandhi family should read VS Naipaul - National Herald - November 15th, 2021
- Five new titles advocate for truth and rationalism - The Globe and Mail - November 13th, 2021
- Evening Update: Fears of military clash rise as migrant crisis on Poland-Belarus border continues - The Globe and Mail - November 13th, 2021
- Critical rationalism - Wikipedia - November 5th, 2021
- What philosophy has shaped your life? - The New Times - November 5th, 2021
- In the war with Covid, rebels who risk spread don't command respect - Stuff.co.nz - November 5th, 2021
- Euripides' The Trojan Women An Unflinching Look at Brutality of War - Greek Reporter - November 5th, 2021
- The Catholic Church in retreat - The Kingston Whig-Standard - November 5th, 2021
- Reason, Arguments, And Truth | Henry Karlson - Patheos - November 5th, 2021
- Rationalism (Liberalism) | tutor2u - October 30th, 2021
- Sentiments instead of rationalism taking over LGBTQI+ debate in Ghana Boadu-Ayeboafoh - Graphic Online - Graphic Online - October 30th, 2021
- The Right Way to Reject Critical Race Theory - The Dispatch - October 30th, 2021
- Tangents and Tirades The Cowl - PC The Cowl - October 30th, 2021
- When the mystical goes mainstream: how tarot became a self-care phenomenon - The Guardian - October 30th, 2021
- Democracy in India is in danger because the opposition at the national level is paralysed by - Free Press Journal - October 26th, 2021
- The Veer, Mercy Petitions and Contemporary Justifications - The Shillong Times - October 26th, 2021
- Police Abuse the Laws Because the Laws Are Designed to be Abused - The Wire - October 24th, 2021
- Guide to the classics: Euripides' The Trojan Women an unflinching look at the brutality of war - The Conversation AU - October 21st, 2021
- Love and Other Acts of Violence - Donmar Warehouse, London - The Reviews Hub - October 19th, 2021
- Probing the wounds of a scarred country - Green Left - October 19th, 2021
- Features | Low Culture | If I Quit Now, They Win: What The X-Files Taught Me About Love - The Quietus - October 11th, 2021
- Should scientists run the country? - The Guardian - October 1st, 2021
- The less you know going into 'Midnight Mass', the better - entertainment.ie - October 1st, 2021
- On the psychology and politics of wearing masks - The BMJ - The BMJ - October 1st, 2021
- Those were the days: Kalaivanar with a big heart, NS Krishnan used comedy as reform tool - DTNext - September 26th, 2021
- Act against elected representatives accused of land grabbing, HC tells bureaucrats and police - The Hindu - September 26th, 2021
- Como Is Northern Italys Most Refined City For Culture And Cuisine - Forbes - September 24th, 2021
- Deal land grabbing by elected representatives sternly, says Madras HC - Business Standard - September 24th, 2021
- Wigtown welcomes Mrs Death and hosts a Meeting of Spirits - Scottish Field - September 24th, 2021
- Periyar: A social justice champion and beyond - Hindustan Times - September 22nd, 2021
- The justice league: A campaign on cards - The New Indian Express - September 22nd, 2021
- The Patriot, The Picasso And The Reformer: Celebrating The Birth Anniversary Of PM Modi, MF Husain And Periyar - The Logical Indian - September 22nd, 2021
- Values and Interests in World Politics Valdai Club - Valdai Discussion Club - September 22nd, 2021
- Foundations David S. Goyer on the Vital Changes Needed to Be Made for the Adaptation - Gizmodo Australia - September 22nd, 2021
- Tarrant: 'Pray that we, the plaintiffs, continue to upset the enemy' Waterbury Roundabout - Waterbury Roundabout - September 10th, 2021
- From Horror to History - The Bulwark - September 10th, 2021
- Why I Am Probably Leaving United Methodism - Patheos - September 10th, 2021
- 'The North Water' review: a chilling adventure in Arctic conditions - NME - September 8th, 2021
- Sambavami yuge yuge: How DMK is the new guardian angel of Hindus - The Times of India Blog - September 8th, 2021